- 1 - ! " #$ !% &! $ ''()* +')) & ! "# $%!! & ' (( '' ' $&# ##! # )! (# *+ # # ## '' '' (( ((' ( *! " # $ (! & Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( !# ' + !#! $ + # ( # '!! , $& ' '' ' '' $&$& $& ' # # ( ' ' (- ))) % # % $ #& $(& #!!! ! ( # ' ( ( . . (/ % (%(( ! 001234 56 730589 823 :! 736456; <3=:>3?@3:1>?:=)))449!5?A5B598643225:62%14;3 864 730589 %14;3 $ #& 36;891>1 8>5256; :1? := '!:! , $& >3;52?3>34 <A ?@3 6?3995;3603 ==503> := 5>30?:>8?3 := 3B3613 6?3995;3603 36;891>1 :689 65? 36;891>1 =:> ?@3 :==36032 71652@8<93 1643> 30?5:62 $0& $0& 864 := 8>0:?50 >1;2 864 #2A0@:?>:750 1<2?86032 0? * $=:> 2@:>? C # 0?-& 52 <3=:>3?@52:1>?233D56;>3;198><859! ! (38>4?@3938>6340:16239=:>?@378>?532! - 3 - ! ?52?@30823:=?@37>:2301?5:6?@8?:6?@3<8252 :=?@30>345<9356?3995;3603;8?@3>34<A?@36?3995;3603==503> := 36;891>1 :689 65? ?@3 73?5?5:63> E@: 8>>5B34 56 ?@5:7586 5>E8A2 8? 36;891>1 6?3>68?5:689 5>7:>? :6 !! E82 56?3>>:;8?34 864 =>:F @3> 7:223225:6 D59:;>8F 864 ;>8F2 := 0:08563 E82 >30:B3>34 1643> 8 F8@8G8> 864 21<23H136?9A ?@3 73?5?5:63> E82 8>>32?34 864 7>:41034 <3=:>3 ?@3 I1>52450?5:689 :1>? 864 >3F86434 ?: I1450589012?:4A!@356B32?5;8?5:6:=?@30823520:F793?34864 8 0:F79856? 82 7>:B5434 1643> 30?5:6 := ?@3 # 0? E82 =5934 <3=:>3 ?@3 730589 :1>? =:> ?@3 8=:>32854 :==36032 8;8562? ?@3 73?5?5:63>! @3 <859 8779508?5:6 =5934 <A ?@3 73?5?5:63> <3=:>3 ?@3 ?>589 :1>? 56 >9! 520! :!+ + E82>3I30?34:6 !!!@3>3=:>3?@373?5?5:63>52<3=:>3 ?@52:1>?! +! 38>6340:16239=:>?@373?5?5:63>21<F5?2?@8??@3 73?5?5:63> 52 8 F8>>534 984A @8B56; ?E: 0@594>36! @3 @82 6: :?@3>0>5F568986?303436?2!@35256012?:4A=:>?@3982?638>9A ?E:A38>2!@3?>58956?@3082352A3??:0:FF3603!@3>3526: 0:F7958603:=30?5:6*:=?@3 #0?56?@37>3236?0823! 00:>456;9A@37>8A2?:899:E?@373?5?5:6! - 4 - *! #3>0:6?>8938>6340:16239=:>?@3>327:6436?E@: @82=59342?8?3F36?:=:<I30?5:62@82:77:234?@373?5?5:6!(3 21<F5?2 ?@8? ?@3 235G1>3 52 =>:F ?@3 ?>:993A <8; := ?@3 73?5?5:63>E@50@2@3E8208>>A56;!@3>3526:>3H15>3F36?:= 0:F7958603 := 30?5:6 * := ?@3 # 0?! (3 21<F5?2 ?@8? 0@8>;32 @8B3 89>384A <336 =>8F34 56 ?@3 7>3236? 0823 864 3B36?@348?3=:>?>589@82<336=5J348643==:>?22@899<3F843 ?:0:609143?@3?>5898??@338>9532?!(3892:21<F5?2?@8?25603 ?@30:6?>8<8648>?509352:=0:FF3>0589H186?5?A56B53E:=?@3 >5;:>1643>30?5:6:=?@3 #0??@373?5?5:63>-27>8A3> 0866:?<3;>86?34! ! @3 F8?3>589 :6 >30:>4 E:194 ;: ?: 2@:E ?@8? :6 ?@3 <8252 := ?@3 0>345<93 56=:>F8?5:6 >3035B34 :6 !! ?@3 73?5?5:63> 8>>5B34 8? 36;891>1 6?3>68?5:689 5>7:>? 56 8 ?@5:75865>E8A2=>:F4452<8<8864E8256?3>037?34<A?@3 ==503>2 := 864 E@36 ?@3 ?>:993A <8; E@50@ 2@3 E82 08>>A56; E82 238>0@34 0:6?>8<864 8>?5093 8993;349A 0:08563 ?:?899A E35;@56; D59:;>8F 864 ;>8F2 E82 =:164! @3>38=?3> ?@3 >30:B3>34 0:6?>8<864 8>?5093 E82 21<I30?34 ?: #860@868F8 864 ?@3 73?5?5:63> E82 8>>32?34 864 7>:41034 <3=:>3 ?@3 I1>52450?5:689 :1>? 864 >3F86434 =:> I1450589 - 5 - 012?:4A! @3 56B32?5;8?5:6 := ?@3 0823 52 0:F793?34 864 0:F79856?52=5934827>:B54341643>30?5:6:=?@30?!@3 235G34 0:6?>8<864 8>?5093 :6 0@3F5089 3J8F568?5:6 @82 ?32?34 7:25?5B3=:>?@34>1;0:085638645?526:?5645271?3?@8??@3 235G340:6?>8<8648>?509352:=80:FF3>0589H186?5?A! ! @3 21<F5225:6 := ?@3 938>634 0:16239 =:> ?@3 73?5?5:63>?@8??@3>3H15>3F36?:=30?5:6*:=?@3 #0? @82 6:? <336 0:F79534 56 ?@3 7>3236? 0823 63342 ?: <3 >3I30?34=:>?@3>382:6?@8??@3>3526:235G1>3:=0:6?>8<864 8>?5093=>:F?@373>2:6:=?@373?5?5:63>56?@37>3236?0823864 ?@3 235G1>3 := ?@3 0:6?>8<864 8>?5093 52 =>:F ?@3 ?>:993A <8; E@50@?@373?5?5:63>E8208>>A56;E5?@@3>=>:F4452<8<8?: 36;891>1! ! @3 73?5?5:63> 52 8 F8>>534 984A 8;34 8<:1? * A38>28645?52<>:1;@??:?@36:?503:=?@52:1>??@8?2@3@82 ?E: 2F899 0@594>36! @3 73?5?5:63> 52 56 012?:4A =:> ?@3 982? 638>9A ?E: A38>2! @3 56B32?5;8?5:6 := ?@3 0823 52 89>384A 0:F793?34!@:1;@0@8>;3@82<336=>8F34<A?@3?>589:1>? 1645271?349A?@3?>58956?@30823@826:?A3?0:FF36034! - 6 - ! 6 ?@3 0823 := >37:>?34 56 ?@3 (:6/<93 17>3F3 :1>? ?8D56; 56?: 0:62543>8?5:6 ?@8??@38001234E8256012?:4A=:>873>5:4:=:63A38>23B36 F:6?@2 864 ?@3>3 E82 6: 21==50536? 7>:;>322 56 ?>589 E5?@:1? 3J7>32256;86A:7565:6:6F3>5?286443F3>5?2:=?@30823@82 ;>86?34 >3;198> <859 ?: ?@3 8001234! 6 ?@3 0823 := !"#$>37:>?3456 %5680823E@3>30@8>;32@33?E82 =5934=:>?@3:==3603271652@8<931643>30?5:62$0&864:= ?@3 #0?8648001234E8256012?:4A=:>873>5:4:=:63 A38> 23B36 F:6?@2 ?@3 (:6/<93 17>3F3 :1>? @82 ;>86?34 >3;198> <859 :6 ?@3 ;>:164 ?@8? ?>589 52 2?599 56 ?@3 7>395F568>A 2?8;382:69A:63E5?6322E823J8F5634! ! 6?@37>3236?0823?@373?5?5:63>5256?@3012?:4A =:> ?@3 982? 638>9A ?E: A38>2! 6 B53E := ?@3 9:6; 73>5:4 := 5608>03>8?5:6 := ?@3 73?5?5:63> 864 892: @8B56; >3;8>4 ?: ?@3 7>:B52:?:30?5:6+$&:=?@3>!#!!?@373?5?5:63>-27>8A3> =:>;>86?:=>3;198><85963342?:<3862E3>348==5>F8?5B39A! - 7 - ! 643>?@305>01F2?860328F:=?@3:7565:6?@8? ?@3 73?5?5:63> 7>8A3> =:> ;>86? := >3;198> <859 63342 ?: <3 862E3>34 8==5>F8?5B39A 21<I30? ?: 5F7:256; 877>:7>58?3 0:645?5:62!00:>456;9A?@3=:99:E56;:>43>. @373?5?5:652899:E34! @373?5?5:63>5245>30?34?:<33698>;34:6<85956>5F3 :! ,$& := 6?3995;3603 ==503> 5>30?:>8?3 := 3B3613 6?3995;3603 $ & 36;891>1 :689 65? 36;891>1 >3;52?3>34 =:> ?@3 :==36032 71652@8<93 1643>30?5:62$0&$0&864 $0&:= #0?736456;56 730589823:! :6?@3=593:=?@3)))449!5?A 5B59 864 3225:62 %14;3 864 730589 %14;3 $ #& 8? 36;891>121<I30??:?@3=:99:E56;0:645?5:62. 8&@373?5?5:63>2@8993J301?373>2:689<:64=:>821F := 2! E5?@ ?E: 21>3?532 =:> ?@3 95D321F 864:1?:=?@328F3:6321>3?A2@899<39:08921>3?A ?:?@328?52=80?5:6:=?@3I1>52450?5:689:1>?K <&@373?5?5:63>2@89987738>>3;198>9A:6899?@348?32 := @38>56; <3=:>3 ?@3 >589 :1>? 169322 ?@3 >589 :1>?3J3F7?2@3>87738>8603=:>B8954>382:62K - 8 - 0& @373?5?5:63>2@8996:?45>30?9A:>5645>30?9A?@>38?36 :>?8F73>E5?@?@37>:2301?5:6E5?632232K 4& @373?5?5:63>2@8996:?56B:9B35625F598>:==3603256 =1?1>3K 3& @3 73?5?5:63> 2@899 6:? 938B3 ?@3 I1>52450?5:6 := ?@3 >589:1>?E5?@:1?73>F5225:6:=?@32854:1>?16?59 ?@30823>3;52?3>348;8562?@3>524527:234:==! ,-*. '% &! ) ! B@ 52?:!.9:!. .#