- 1 - !" !# $% " & '" ! %(()*+ ( ** ' !"# $ % & # ' !"# !" $ % & Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ( %' ( & ) **" ' '' "' # ' ' ' ' + ' ' ' , , - ../01234051637189403/78/:2171.843:(36 7 ;489 < =7<>17 83 ?/<09 891 1:8471 =73.1124:@0 4: 3**"=1:24:@51637189122A3/78 7/=<8/:@< 73<2 1:@<A/7/ <7404:@ 3/8 36 < .74B1 3 71@4081712 5> 093C <@<7 3A4.1 8<843: 1:@<A/7/ 48> 637 891 3661:.10 =/:409<5A1 /:217 1.843:0 "<:271<2;4891.843:36 - 3 - 1<72 891 A1<7:12 .3/:01A 637 891 =184843:17 <:2 891 A1<7:12 4@9 3/78 3D17:B1:8 A1<217 637 891 710=3:21:8 1<7:12 .3/:01A 637 891 =184843:17 9<D4:@ 714817<812 891 @73/:20 /7@12 4: 891 =184843: 0/5B480 89<8 8917140<503A/81A>:3B<8174<A83=7301./81891=184843:17637 891 .9<7@1!0911812 3661:.10 91 =184843:17 9<2 =A12@12 @1:/4:1@3A237:<B1:804:891 <:C<889184B136<D<4A4:@ 891A3<:<:2<.17846412<==7<401736891 <:C9<2<==73D12 8910<4237:<B1:80=A12@125>891=184843:17<889184B136 <D<4A4:@891A3<:<:248403:A>891:891A3<:;<00<:.843:12 83 917 91 =184843:17 9<0 =/7.9<012 891 =A12@12 @3A2 37:<B1:80 673B < 71=/812 E1;1A7> 093= ;93 9<0 @4D1: < .178464.<81 ;489 71@<72 83 891 </891:84.48> 36 891 0<42 37:<B1:80..3724:@A>91=7<>083<AA3;891=184843: 17 .3:87< A1<7:12 4@9 3/78 3D17:B1:8 A1<217<==1<74:@3:519<A636891710=3:21:89<03==3012 891=184843:<:20/5B48089<83:8915<04036891.3B=A<4:8 A32@125>891 <:C4:;94.9891=184843:179<2=A12@12891 @3A237:<B1:808914:D1084@<843:9<0511:.3:2/.8124:891 - 4 - =7101:8.<01 91@3A237:<B1:80=A12@125>891=184843:17 ;94A1 <D<4A4:@ 891 A3<: ;<0 0/501?/1:8A> 63/:2 83 51 6<C1 <:2891<==7<4017<==34:8125>891 <:C9<2.3AA/212;489 891=184843:17<:25<0123:9406<C1.178464.<81891A3<:;<0 0<:.843:12 83 891 =184843:17 1 0/5B480 89<8 891 0<42 <==7<401740<A03<77<>12<0<:<../0124:891=7101:8.<01 ..3724:@A>91=7<>083240B400891=184843: :891647084:637B<843:89<8;<00/5B488125>891 7<:.9 <:<@17 36 891 <:C 4B4812 74@<21 3<2 7<:.9 1:@<A/7/48>2<812#F484008<81289<8 891=184843:17<:2389170:<B124:891647084:637B<843:9<2 <D<4A12A3<:673B891 <:C5>=A12@4:@89147@3A237:<B1:80 <:20/501?/1:8A>48;<063/:289<88910<42@3A237:<B1:80 =A12@12 5> 891 53773;17+0 ;171 0=/743/0 <:2 891 1G817:<A <==7<4017 673B 891 1:87<A ==7<4017 @1:.> 9<2 @4D1: < 6<A01 21.A<7<843: 71@<724:@ 891 @1:/4:1:100 36 891 =A12@12 @3A2 37:<B1:80 91 =3A4.1 <6817 891 4:D1084@<843: 36 891 .<01 9<D1 64A12 .9<7@1!09118 <@<4:08 64D1 <../012 =1703:0 91 1G817:<A <==7<4017 ;93 9<2 <AA1@12A> @4D1: 6<A01 21.A<7<843: ;489 71@<72 83 891 @1:/4:1:100 36 891 @3A2 - 5 - 37:<B1:80 ;94.9 ;171 =A12@12 5> 891 53773;170 9<0 511: <77<>12 <0 <../012 3 4: 891 .9<7@1!09118 =17/0<A 36 891.9<7@1!09118B<8174<A;3/A2@383093;89<8<889184B1 36 </2484:@ 3: #(F 891 @3A2 37:<B1:80 ;94.9 ;171 =A12@125>89153773;170;17171<==7<4012<:248;<063/:2 89<8891@3A237:<B1:80;94.9;171=A12@125>891<../012 30#83;94A1<D<4A4:@891A3<:673B891 <:C;1716<C1 37:<B1:80<:2<../0123;93;<0<:1G817:<A<==7<4017 673B8911:87<A==7<4017@1:.>410935303A29<2 .3AA/212;489891<../01230#83<:29<2@4D1:<6<A01 .178464.<81 ;489 71@<72 83 891 @1:/4:1:100 36 891 @3A2 37:<B1:80 ;94.9 ;171 =A12@12 5> 891 <../012 30# 83 ;489891 <:C<:25<0123:;94.9891A3<:;<00<:.843:12 83891B " 91 3:+51A /=71B1 3/78 4: 891 .<01 36 # 9<0 35017D12 89<8 48 40 87481 A<; 89<8 891 4@9 3/78 .<::38 1B5<7C /=3: 891 <==71.4<843: 36 1D421:.1 ;94A1 .3:042174:@ 891 =184843: 64A12 /:217 1.843: ( 36 7 637 ?/<094:@ 891 .74B4:<A 1 (2020) 3 SCC 317 - 6 - =73.1124:@0840.A1<7673B891A<;A<4223;:5>89403/78 89<8 46 < =74B< 6<.41 .<01 40 B<21 3/8 240.A304:@ 891 4:@71241:80 36 891 3661:.1 <AA1@12 <@<4:08 891 <../012 891 3/78.<::38?/<09<.74B4:<A=73.1124:@0 F :891.<0136 8913:+5A1/=71B13/78 <8=<7<@7<=93#9<035017D12<063AA3;0, ! " # $ %&'( " ) ) ) " ) " ) ) ) 2 2023 SCC OnLine SC 379 - 7 - ) ! # $ %&' ( ) " ) " * ( <D4:@71@<7283891<63710<42B<8174<A<D<4A<5A1 3:71.3724:891.9<7@1!0911848.<::38510<4289<88917140 <503A/81A> :3 B<8174<A 83 =7301./81 891 =184843:17 637 891 .9<7@1!0911812 3661:.1 04:.1 48 40 :38 4: 240=/81 89<8 091 9<2 53773;12 891 A3<: 673B 891 .3B=A<4:<:8! <:C <6817 =A12@4:@.178<4:@3A237:<B1:80 9403/78<889108<@136 1G17.404:@=3;170/:2171.843:(367.<::3893A2 < B4:4 874<A <:2 0.7/84:4H1 <AA 891 .9<7@1!09118 B<8174<A0 4:.1<=17/0<A36891.9<7@1!09118;3/A2=74B<!6<.41@383 093; 89<8 89171 40 0/664.41:8 B<8174<A 83 =7301./81 891 =184843:17637891<AA1@123661:.10<B368913=4:43:89<8 4840:38<648.<01;91714:89403/784071?/4712831G17.401 480 =3;170 /:217 1.843: ( 36 7 637 ?/<094:@ 891 4B=/@:12 .74B4:<A =73.1124:@ ..3724:@A> 891 63AA3;4:@ 37217, - 8 - 9174B4:<A184843:40 ,+- ( & '" !* " D9! 4083,#*A3,# ,