- 1 - ! "# $ % # & &' () * &(( )% # *& &' () * &(( ) % !"# $ % & ' ( ) *** $ % & Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' %' # & !"*" ' '' *%"& ' "*" #"*" ' ( ( ' ' % & ' ( *) % (( !" % & ' ( !" *** % & ' %'# & #"*" ( ' '' *%"&' - 3 - "*"( ' ' % & ' ( ' ( + + , ( --./01 2/ 341 54 6570 2 #"*" 6085/90601 :; 27<36=09 2>5-0 939524 2138. ?26 9@0 2??04-0/ =.45/@3:>0 .4106 0-9524 *%"& 2? @36395;3 ;3;3 34@593 "*" %?26 /@269 A "*"B& 360 :0?260 9@5/ 2.69 /00C548 608.>36:35> .4106 0-9524 # 2? @36395;3 38365C3 .63C/@334@593"*"%?26/@269A "*"B " 03619@0>036401-2.4/0>?269@0=36950/ ' 54 6570 2 #"*" <3/ 6085/90601 :; 27<36=09 2>5-0 939524 2138. ?26 9@0 3?260/351 2??04-0/ 38354/9 /5D .4C42<4 =06/24/ 24 9@0 :3/5/ 2? 9@0 ?56/9 54?2673952413901" *! "*"60-05E01?62724065 07363F 2 >3903>>3==3 .65489@0-2.6/02?54E0/958395242? 9@0 -3/0 3--./01 2/ 341 <060 3660/901 24 * *# "*" 341 /.:/0G.049>; 60734101 92 F.15-53> -./921; @0 54E0/95839524 2? 9@0 -3/0 5/ -27=>0901 341 -@3680/@009 @3/ - 4 - :004 ?5>01 38354/9 904 3--./01 =06/24/ @0 =095952406/ 360 3663584013/3--./01 2/ 341549@0-@3680/@009 @0:35> 3==>5-39524 ?5>01 :; 9@0 =095952406/ :0?260 9@0 F.65/15-95243> 0//524/ 2.69 <3/ 60F0-901 @060?260 9@0; 360 :0?260 9@5/ 2.69 036401 -2.4/0> ?26 9@0 =095952406/ /.:759/ 9@39 .415/=.901>;9@0=095952406/<060429=60/049399@0/=292?9@0 -6570 341 9@0 24>; 3>>0839524 38354/9 9@07 5/ 9@39 9@0; @31 049060154923-24/=563-;<59@9@029@063--./01=06/24/<@2 3-9.3>>;-277599019@0-6570 @0=095952406/12429@3E034; -657543> 3490-01049/ @0 54E0/95839524 2? 9@0 -3/0 5/ -27=>0901 --261548>;@0=63;/923>>2<9@0=0959524 06-24963>03640158@2.692E0647049>03106 @3/2==2/019@0=0959524 0/.:759/9@399@0:35>3==>5-39524 ?5>01:;9@03--./01 2 <3/036>50660F0-901:;9@5/2.6954 657543>0959524 2 !"*" @0605/60-2E06;2?-3/@?627 9@0 =095952406/ @06054 3?906 9@056 3660/9 @0 E5-957/ <060 C42<4 92 9@0 =095952406/ 341 9@060?260 9@0 =095952406/ @3E0 93C04 9@0 @0>= 2? 29@06 3--./01 92 -27759 9@0 -6570 --261548>;@0=63;/9215/75//9@0=0959524 - 5 - ' 54 9@0 =60/049 -3/0 <3/ 6085/90601 38354/9 /5D .4C42<4 =06/24/ 24 9@0 :3/5/ 2? 9@0 ?56/9 54?26739524 13901 " *! "*" 60-05E01 ?627 65 07363F 4 9@0 ?56/9 54?26739524595/7049524019@39249@00E045482?" *! "*" 9@0 ?56/9 54?267349 3?906 ->2/548 @5/ /@2= @31 C0=9 3 /.7 2? / #***9@60072:5>0=@240/3413-60159-36154@5/:38 341 <@04 @0 <3/ 24 @5/ <3; 92 @5/ @2./0 39 5::0993 E5>>380 ?627273<36=093>248<59@@5/<5?079 /@3393:2.9# = 7 3-36<@5-@-370?6279@02==2/590/5103>>2?3/.1104 13/@01 38354/9 9@0 /-22906 2? 9@0 ?56/9 54?267349 :036548 6085/9639524 2 " ! * 341 9<2 =02=>0 <@2 -370 54 3 /-22906?627:0@5419@60<-@5>>;=2<106249@0?3-02?9@0?56/9 54?267349 341 @5/ <5?0 9 9@39 9570 9@600 =06/24/ <@2 829 12<4 ?627 9@0 -36 96501 92 93C0 3<3; 9@0 :38 <@5-@ 9@0 ?56/9 54?267349 @31 C0=9 54 @5/ /-22906 341 <@04 @5/ <5?0 60/5/901 9@0563-952424037248/99@073//3.>901@0624@06@031<59@ 9@0 /900> ?>3/C <@5-@ <3/ 54 9@0 /-22906 341 -3./01 54F.60/ @0603?906 9@0 3--./01 =06/24/ 922C 3<3; 9@0 :38 341 0/-3=01?6279@0/=29 .65489@0-2.6/02?54E0/958395249@0 =2>5-0@3E03660/9019@0=095952406/@0605424* *# "*" ?906 -27=>09548 9@0 54E0/95839524 -@3680/@009 @3/ :004 ?5>01 - 6 - 38354/9 * =06/24/ 341 =095952406/ 360 366358401 3/ 3--./01 2/ 341 54 9@0 -@3680/@009 4 9@0 -@3680/@009 59 5/ 3>>08019@39249@054/96.-9524/2?3--./01 2 9@03--./01 2/ "341!@3113/@019@0<5?9-36:0365486085/9639524 2 "!" 38354/9 9@0 9<2 <@00>06 54 <@5-@ 9@0 ?56/9 54?267349341@5/<5?0<060963E0>5483413--./01 2/ #341 <@2-370543/-22906?627:0@5419@60<-@5>>;=2<106249@0 ?56/954?267349341@5/<5?03419@0603?906<@049@0<5?02?9@0 ?56/9 54?267349 96501 92 60/5/9 9@0 3--./01 =06/24/ 3--./01 2 ! 3>>0801>; @31 3//3.>901 @06 <59@ 3 /900> <3906 :299>0 24 @06 @031 341 -3./01 /57=>0 54F.650/ --./01 2/ 341 3>>0801>; @31 85E04 9@0 54?26739524 3:2.9 9@0 <@0603:2.9/ 2? 9@0 ?56/9 54?267349 341 @5/ <5?0 92 9@0 3--./01 =06/24/ <@2 @3154906-0=9019@0?56/954?267349341@5/<5?0249@056<3;92 9@056@2./0?627273<36=090341@31-277599019@062::06; 415/=.901>; 3--./01 2/ 341 <060 429 =60/049 39 9@0 /=292?9@0-657034124>;3>>083952438354/99@075/9@399@0; @31-24/=5601<59@9@029@06/5D=06/24/<@2@3154906-0=901 9@0?56/954?267349341@5/<5?0249@0458@92?" *! "*"341 @31 -27759901 62::06; @0 :35> 3==>5-39524 ?5>01 :; 3--./01 2 54 657543> 0959524 2 !"*" 39 9@0 /9380 2? - 7 - 54E0/95839524<3/15/75//01:;9@5/2.69249@0862.419@39 9@0 54E0/95839524 2? 9@0 -3/0 5/ /95>> .4106 =62860// 341 9@060?260399@39/9380=63;067310:;9@03--./01 2 ?26 608.>36 :35> -34429 :0 04906935401 2<0E06 9@0603?906 9@0 54E0/958395242?9@0-3/05/-27=>09013419@0-@3680/@009@3/ :004 ?5>01 341 3/ =06 9@0 -@3680/@009 3>>0839524/ 3--./01 2/ 341@3124>;-24/=5601<59@9@029@063--./01=06/24/ 92-277599@0-65703419@0;<0603-9.3>>;429=60/049399@0 /=292?9@0-6570249@03>>080113902?54-51049 415/=.901>; 9@0 =095952406/ 12 429 @3E0 34; 29@06 -657543> 29@06 3490-01049/ 41069@0-56-.7/934-0/372?9@02=545249@39 9@0 =63;06 7310 :; 9@0 3--./01 2/ 341 ?26 86349 2? 608.>36 :35> 4001/ 92 :0 34/<0601 3??567395E0>; --261548>; 9@0?2>>2<54826106+ 29@9@0=0959524/3603>>2<01 @0 =095952406/3--./01 2/ 341 360 1560-901 92 :0 04>36801 24 :35> 54 6570 2 #"*" 2? 27<36=09 2>5-0 939524 2138. 6085/90601 ?26 9@0 2??04-0 =.45/@3:>0 .4106 0-9524*%"&2? "*"=04154854 2 !"*"24 - 8 - 9@0 ?5>0 2? >036401 6> 5E5> .180 %6 4 & 341 ' 2.69 27<36=09@/.:F0-9929@0?2>>2<548-24159524/+ 3&@0 =095952406/3--./01 2/ 341 /@3>> 0D0-.90 =06/243>:241?263/.72?/ *****03-@<59@ 9<2/.60950/?269@0>5C0/.7929@0/395/?3-95242?9@0 F.65/15-95243>2.69H :&@0 =095952406/3--./01 2/ 341 /@3>> 3==036 608.>36>;243>>9@01390/2?@036548:0?2609@0653> 2.69 .4>0// 9@0 653> 2.69 0D07=9/ 9@056 3==03634-0?26E3>51603/24/H -& @0 =095952406/3--./01 2/ 341 /@3>> 429 1560-9>; 26 541560-9>; 9@603904 26 937=06 <59@ 9@0 =62/0-.9524<5940//0/H 1& @0=095952406/3--./01 2/ 341/@3>>42954E2>E0 54/575>362??04-0/54?.9.60H 0& @0=095952406/3--./01 2/ 341/@3>>429>03E0 9@0F.65/15-95242?9@0653>2.69<59@2.9=0675//524 2? 9@0 /351 2.69 .495> 9@0 -3/0 6085/90601 38354/9 9@075/15/=2/012?? +), &$ % ( E@ 5/9 2 +> 2 + +