Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 33401 (PNJ)
GOBINDER SINGH v. STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
CWP/7900/2022 · 2025-01-09
Vinod S Bhardwaj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 33401 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 33401 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
CWP-7900-2022
! ""#
$ %&$ '( ' )
*****
! "#$%&'&(&)*+&
,"
!&&#$%&) )
&-&&
..... ( ' )+ , -./
%$((",$"%&/010%( &(," &$&2+% 3" +$%$2&* ,,+)"
"&&&+""4$
5&4$2&&(6"&2,,"+
"& " 37( & & & + - " &% , +$ & "& & " 2*& % " 3&
" ,,+ , + -) &+"7$2& " 3& * 3" & +"&( " * %% 8911901 1'':; & 1<0/01/3"6-",223(+"&(3+*-
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
! " # " $% &' (
"#"
) *%
"
$ $%%$$
+ *
*% , -" %. / + 0
* $
+*%*
"
'
/
+ *% *
1
0(
*%* $ %%
2
$"#"
$
#%
% % 3-. 4 *% "% -#%
5 *
. 6
( %
%
" # " -$
" 7
4 . 8
4 *% "% -
.6
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
=
=
+"&"&+"&(3&$&&62&(&" 2(","2$2&($2&&322&"++$2& $ 6- " *% & 3"+" " 3& >$ ,%"$&&$62++$(&$62++$)""& 6?%*,+&&01000=,%",$+ &"@(*%2&A+,$2B,CC&$2< ,CCC,"+"$2,4,4*2+$)180/ ,$"+"&"&3""%&3&26," &2 4*2 '$( : *;) &+"7$2&) " "& &+$&22-&&&+&,",&6"&2,,
" & ,
&-&& "$(" " + 422+ 6$ + " 3&
"&*(&-$+,%"%&*+&-," &% &&6"&2,,"5&+>$,,+)"+)"$$ & &&&+ " 6"&2, ,$" + "& " ,,+ , " 5(&2 %%6&+ & %&* +&- *% , &-&&) 5&3 D 5(2&* &% "& $ & 4+$2& 6&( !% 1/< 1B<E & 00B01< &6$ " +$ 6 ,223 , $&+ , $+ , ,+ &22 4$ & + 5*2)
(" 4$96$&2:;94%%:;96& & $% 4$"&%?&+&$
"9
&
$ +%4 *
: (-. *-.:
-. " * VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
B
)
2 %
0 #% %
%
$
4; * <
$4; *<
%
33&' =(
%
1
+% 4 *
: (-.: *-.:
-. $
"
*
% #4
>
2 +$ < $
(%$% #%
%
0
%
$ %
4;*<
?
B
$6%"&*3,"+&76-"4", !*&1B0B01<&++$2&6-"&6*&%% &00B01<)"$+,"+&&$62+?& 6$6-"%&* &%&"&"+&)
"%&* &%"&$&-$+"$+" VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
E
" ,,+ , " + -) &+"7$2& &&&+&,"+&6"&2,,5&+>$,,+ $6%"&3"&("&,&&"&*(6&76-"
"2-,2&322&$("+$,"&%&2 >$-) +,+ ,( 3" + &% 3& + 6- "
>$-,,+""&6,$">$-6 6&+" , &- $+ ($29+ $ 6- " %&* &%"+%&$"-
+"&
"&6+,&-+,+$+6-"+%&$"-" %&* +&- &&&+ , " ,,+ , " 5& +>$422+:%3",%",,+,"5& +>$422+"&+&+",,+," +-" 6, & &6$ " ,&+ *2* "$;) " +$2"&*&%&22-+&(&" 3" &+ & " + $ * %% & 00B01< ,+&2%&"+,+&*%2&6-"
"2-"+"&("*$"%$$2,"
&-&& 4*2*+:$"%&&2;)$2)01<"2*&?&+ ,"2-&<1001/)&"$
(
% 4 +$
< +6 0 #% %
*% *
#%
1 / $
$
@ VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
<
#%
% (
%+$< &'
6 !8 4 +$ +
%
<
+ 6 $
%
"
$
&' . -. + 64 -. A * 3 -3!. -. #% 0
+ 6 4 (
% + 6
% "
#% 4 +$ +
% / '3))
3 -* . 1 6'. > ( %
1
+% 4 *
: (-.:*-. -.$
" * %
# 4 > 2
$
$ 3! #%
4 1 #%
$
4
63BCCD226 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
B CCC222
A
" * *%
! ( %
+ 0 *
- /. + ( *
8
$
$
- /. 2
#%
$
$
+ 0
*
- /.$ $
3 (
%
,$ D " 4%" D"
4ED
"
4E" D"
4E
D "
4 < E D "
4 / D "
4 699 % D " 4D"
4"$D" 4 8F8
"%
E +
*% , -" %. G
+ 0 *
- /. + (*
%
%$%
+0
*
- /.
) (
+ *% *
+ 0 *
- /.1 %
8 8F8 %(*
$
$
*%*
%
3F
8 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
/
3F
8F83F)
8F8-16' 6'3.%$+0
*
$
1 G 1
8 %
-16')6'. 88F81
$%
"
4+*% *
$
88F8%$ /+ 0
*
$ 1
4
% $
#%
B+( *
1 % 8-16'86' . %
(
0 :
/+0
*
%
$
D :8:8 8'8
8 !!'!3 8 )F'
3 )3')) F 83'3
8 8 3' 8 )
FF'! )!')! F 88'88
8 !8'! 8 F8'F
) ')F F F'
8 !F'3F 8 F)'F
)!')!! F 883'88)
8 3)'3 8 F!'F3
)!3')!) F )'
83!'33 8 F'F
)!')!8 F 8 '8
8 !)'! VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
8
8 !F'!! )! ')!F F -16'F
6'.(% % G
$
0
" %
'
:+ 0
*
( BD2226'**% %! 4$%
$ :6 /' + 0
*
< %
5%
:+0
*
-
/. %$
0 8 (
50$+ 4
""EG " < /$
"
D G 4$0 9
%
0
&' +
8-. 8- *. -. F - . #%
+B -$ H 5
4. $
$
9
% 1
!
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
10
"
# " $%&
'()*%& E
,("&%)2&4$2+"&&$&2 ,"&,&>$++2&2-&62""&""&&7&22 &>$&3""+2F",&&%&6$
"((+(&&7&&+2$(,$&+ ,$+&,$6%,")"3*) +)"+&"22&62,"2&&2&?-"3
"&,"5&+>$,,+)&+"7$2&,2(,"3 &% & 2 " G$+ &2+&) " %& , +*-6(%6-"
A62
("4$&2$6%6-
"+$2,""&&,"&(,&,&$>$) &+*2%+22&$&&23&,6$"&%3&%& 2&+7( % &2 $6% "& *$&22- " & 4*2 $ 3& % * G$(% & + & =01101/ & * " $6>$ 4*2 &&2 &(& " &6* G$(% & + 3& &2 %)"3*)"&$"&,73" <
,$" + "& & " ,+& & 01000=)""&&2&-6?%,%,%&+, ,$++,$2B,CC&$2<,CCC , " +"$2 , " 4 , 4*2 +$) 180/) "+) " +&6"22&62,,&2$&&&+6"&2,,
"5&+>$,,+
"&*"%2-&($"&" >$- ,,+ &7 +& " +,+ ,+ &7 6- " VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
11
& "& $ " +"&( "&* 6 * 3"$ +(&- ,( & 3"& $+9(*%"&6 *2& 6- " + "& " &6+ , " &,&2( &62"+&&6$" 6( 62(& &&&+ 6"&2, , " 5& +>$ ,,+)*"&6+,&-$+"&*(6$6-" %&* &%)"+&6&,&$2,"&*(,&2 &&&+ 6"&2, , " 5& +>$ 422+ 2(" , " +,+ $+ $ 6- " & ++$2& * %% &00B01<"5&3&5(2&* &%
,+ ,$" %& " ,( + 6- "
>$-,,+"+"&("&%?&+&$ +&,& ( )
$ %
0
% %
I % 2
%
% 0
''
( 0 $
$ VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
1
0 9 29
%
0
( $ $
$
2 0 0
2 ' 1
$ 1
>2 4;+
4 A26
"/" 4 % % * F 8>
$
$
$2 0 0
2 '1
$ 1
>* % %
J>
$
$
$
4;+
4 A26
"/" 2 B9
0 $ $ > B
0
+ *
0 %$
* "
0 $
+*
0 % %
(
$
> 2 %
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
1=
0
% 4$% % $ $ 0
4 $
2
4
$ $
0 :
$ ( 0
0
$
+ 0 *
-
/.) 512:2 I : -
I .
/-*
. +$
" #%
4:
4
:
9
29 0
*%*
*% , -" % , %. %
: #%
2
#%
"
#% -$
0
$:. :
#%
"
4 $ 0
#%
% VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
1B
*%*
$ 0
1
% % 2
$1 0 #% % **%F
4 #%
B:B
"
4 *
% ,
%
$ +$
"
4 2 0
:
)
51: %
* " #% 4
,
:* "
#%
4 $
%
2 %
*% *
'
/ -+ 0
*
. $ $
* "
#% 4 $
* " #%
4
,
$
0
$ 2
0
' 1
" 9 69 #
0
$ 1
>
" 51:
51:J>
$ $ $:
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
1E
2 :
: $:
"
$%
*
+$
'
" #%
#% % %
$$ $ $$ %%
2
" G 2
D: G G 26 ) "* !8
" *
%
%%- % % *
E"6(* D: <# D
6 -.
6", !3 (
%
$$
'1 $
0
$: 2
%
0
%
0 $ $
:%2%
$ /3
5%
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
1<
$ A I %
%
0
% B
%
0
5%
%
$$ :9
%
% $
% 9 %
0
2
%
0
%
0
2
/
+ "& & $&2 , " &,& ,( +2&2-
"3 "& >$- ,,+ "& * ( " >$ , " 6( 62(& $ " &$ &- " *% $+9 $ 6- " +% &$"- &&&+ &+&$%"&"6(&*2&& (( " ,+& & 01000=
+ "& & +"&( +&6"2"&*6*&(&&2>$%2-22-
" 6& , &- 2&+$& " ,+ +"&( >$ 6 &62" 6- " +$( &% & " +&) " ( ,,+ ,&2 2& &- *+ &62" " +"&( 6- ,( &- $+9,,+ %&&( " VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
1
&&&+ 6"&2, , " 5& +>$ 422+ " &2 +$"$%$26-"%&(",,+ , " 5& +>$ 422+ $ $+ & ,2 3 &%"$&2-"&2+&,&%$2(+
" +"&( "& 6 "2 6 * +G+$ & $% & 3"$ * %&7( & ,+ " $+ $ 6- " *%"&6+,"%&-6$6(+"&(6-" &)"+"&(&(&"+$2"&*6& 6*
,$"+"&"&,&&+3$ &(& $( " &( , + "3 +&$ +) "3*) 3"$ +("&%)"%&G$"%,&(,"+% 3"+$%$2&*,,+"&6%" 8
5& 4$2&&( 6"&2,, " ,$" $6%"&+&,",$"(",%"!% :1;90191< & 110801 $ 6- " + , +$)
&-&& &22 + - ,, &%",,+"&"5&3,,+&>$&&*, $+ "&* 6 +* ,% " ++ &% , &&&+9,+,"&+&"&,,+&2+&(& ? &"&%%?&+&$ </-.:8:8 F8
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
1/
"9
& ' *
"
4
*%
=====
$ B: #%
-
.
: "'%
"
4 *%
"
4
%
" 4 *% "
: *%
: *% 6%:51
%
% %
:
1'
% ( +$ : #%
%
4" *
:
"
2
%
$
4
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
18
$
(
$
%%$'
$
4 1'
$ $
(
*6 10
$6%"&&$&2,"&%+2&2-"3"&"
"&&$"-&&&+6"&2,," $( " 2*& % & "& & +* + "& 6 $*,,+&110801&&$+ +)"+&6"266&+",&-$+"&
"&*6$6-"+%&$"- 11
5& $- *+& &2)
&-&&) "3*) +"&"&%"&,223"+$+6$
"
&-&&4*2*+:$"%&&2;$2)01<& $-,"&("&6(&"
"&&26 (&&$-2&"*+6,">$-,,+3" $6%&3"+""+"&(3*&(&" $6% "& * "&,) " +- , " +"&( " & " >$- 3 &2 $2- * $ " (& &%2 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
0
$-,"%2,4>$"+,"+"3 +&$ +) " ,2 "
3& &2 (& & $-,"&(6$"+"&&&+
+
"& " +$ & +%2& $ "
&-&& 4*2 *+ :$"%&&2;$2)01<"&6,$22-+%23"&"&
" +"&( &(& " &6$ "&*( &&&+ 6"&2,," 5&+>$422+&322&62") $2( & , +*- &(& " 2&,, 6( &- 3& &
)"3*)$",&+"&&(&"% ,?
&&%,&$>$(&,&*$,"2&,,)
" +*2 $) & %+22&$ +*2 &&2 3& &2 , 6- " &%&"&%3&%
)"3*)+"&" &3& & 3"" " 4*2 $ 3& *$&22- % 6- " G$(% & + & =01101/ 6- " 4$ , &2 4*2 '$(: *;)&+"7$2&&&2&6$"$6>$&$,
"&&26-"2&,, 1
+"&&&$2,"2&?-&(2(+"3 6- " ) " 2&,, $$2- +" "%2* & " + , &?+">$6-&("&%$&"&&2&++$,"
"& 6 $,, 6- " &
+ "& " $"%,&(,"+%"23&$(" 2+- "& 6 "3 " " & $"% *6,3" VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
1
1=
) "3*) $ " ,&+ "& * ,,+ & 110801) " +* + 3 $ &22 + -9&2 +-&&&22+&+*, +,+ $+ "&*( 6 +* 6- " %&* +& 1B
" &($% "& 6 & 6"&2, , &- , " &&-G$(%+ 1E
"&*"&2&4$2&&(6"&2,,"& & "&* ( "$(" " +$% & 3" " 3""&62&&+ 1<
$2-) & %% , +"&( "& 6 * $ " ," &&&+6"&2,,"5&+>$,,+ 1E 4*2 $ "& "& 6 , 6- " 5&392&,, &(& " +*- +:; 6- " ,,+ 6- " 5& +>$ ,,+&2$"&""&&&&+ 6"&2,,"&,
&-&&"$(""422+&3&" +* & , "&( 3" " &(& " 5& +>$ 422+3&"$&+&3"""&&6 ,%"+(
&&,"&6$&&&+ 6"&2, , " 5& +>$ ,,+ + $+ "& 6 +*6-"%&&,$+",,+*"$("%$222
"&66-""+%2$+ &,22-"&2&2,",&+"&&+"&6 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
&7 6- " 4", !
, " & ,
&-&& 1B0B01< :++$2&* %% &00B01<; %&&( "& " ,,+ , " +-"&22&&&+6"&2,,&-&%
" &6+ , $+ ,% " %&* &% " &2 "( &*&2&62 + $+ $( " +$ , +( 6, " >$- ,,+ "& &- +,+ $+ "& 6$6-",,+,"5&+>$,,+6-"
&,
" &%+(",,+, +-)&+"7$2& &&&+ 6"&2, , " 5& +>$ ,,+ 4&) " +,++&"&",,+,"422+"&&2,3&2
" ,,+ , " 5& +>$ ,,+ " ,,+ "& "- "$2 ,"%&,&6"&2,,"422+&322*+"& 6&$+6-"6,">$-,,+"&&-+,+ $+"&6$6-",,+,"5&+>$ ,,+&&&+"6"&2,&-&%"&6%&6-
" & ,,+ $+ " ,2 2- $") " &2&2"+,+&*%%&6-""2-"& 3&,2"+"&("&$%$236-"%",,+ ,"5&+>$,,+),22-2-"2&6$&2
"&2+&7(%2, 1
"(*$$,&+$&2++$%&+)3$2"&* 6G$,"&,"?+"& + - &*2 6- " + $ >$& +&$ & VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
=
,,+***"&*&2&-6&76-"%F" ,(&%+ 1/
"+&,",$"&$(%6-",&+"& 110801)" &%,5&3&'$+$+",,+,
" +-&&&+3"&(+,&- $+ ,% " &%&* &%
+) " + +%%$+&&2*%%&00B01<&* $2* & 110801 + 6- " % " &,& & 110801 "& 6 ++$2&) " , &$ >$ "& &2&- 6 &)"+)"3$26&%+$+"3"& , " && 3"$ $+ $+" +2&,+& 2- $"+&,""&$&+,$+"+2&,+&)
"3&$&$"-+%+&&&+"&6+ , &- $+"&*(6 $6- " %&* &%
"2&?-),&-)"$"&,"5&+>$,,+&
"&,"3""3$2(+&"&&& 6"&2,,"&,
&-&&"$(""422+ 18
32222&3"&"6$&62"" +"&(2"%&* &%&"&%6* 6- +62 & 6G+* *+ * ,% & $&2 , " +2,+"&(&%,&22(&"&",+, &-$+9"&"&6%&6-"(,,+6,
">$-,,+,3"+""3&6&+"" VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
B
&%+&&76,,32&&3&-&&2(- +G+$ & (&2F &$% &6$ " ,$+ 6 +"&( " %&- 6$ &%&2 +( 6 +"&(6-" &%&"&6+,&-$+9,,+ 6( *2&) " +& 6 "2 ($2- , "&*( +%%&-*2&,%&+,&-+,+$-3"+"" 3&&,% 0
&2 * ,% & $&2 , " >$- "& & ,( "& 6 $ 6- " >$- ,,+ 6- 6*( "& ?+ ,% " *% 2& && 6"&2, , " (*%)"3*""&+*2-,&2,",+& & 01000= ?%( "% ,% ,%( ,$+ & & * 2& & 322 & " %% & 00B01< 3"+""6 * " *%2&,%(&&&+?+,3"$+
"(&"&*$6-"%&* &%"$,"&
",(+&(&"6-">$-,,+$,, ,% &+&,"&%&*$+9$6-" +%&$"- 1
>$- ,,+ & & +"&( &+ %+"&+&22-
& 3" ?+ &2- & %&&2%",&+&*+6$("6,"%&"&, $6%"&3""&+"&(9&22(&&*,%& 6G+* +& , " %&&2 2&+ 6, "% 4+2$ VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
E
&36-">$-,,+"$2%,%&&&2+&,
" %&&2 & G$ $ + , & $- & $% , 6&+"",,& >$-,,++&6(&6-"4$ 3"",(&6&$ ?&2*&%&&2& 3" " ++2$ & 6& $ +& , %&&2 $+9 $ 6- " *% "& 6 "2 6- " A62$%4$"%&,-+ . /
0 1'*234/&$&*)33"&"*&-*&2$,"%&&2%$ 6$+""&3$2&%$($2,"%2-+,+"&( 3&,$""2"%&,-1 $ 5
" $ ! 6"
1'*244/$*72,"&"++2$&>$- %$ 6 6& ?
& 2*& %&&2 $&2 , "
"3"&,"%&&26,&+ &$%3"+"&6$,%"*%
$")""(++&+"+ &6-"&"&*$&22-"4*2$% &*"&&2&(&"&%"&6% =
,&&"+," &"&"& *%"&$,,&2,&++$," &&( 6, " &2 4*2 '$( : *;) &+"7$2& &&,&$>$"&*(6&),"&"&6*& &($%6,,%"2$,,6-" &), &-)&++$,&,&$>$(&6-"4$6$ VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
<
3&&++$,3(,$26$%,"?+&%$6-",,+ ,"5&+>$,,+",($62++$+&6
"22&62,"+>$&22,"&%&-"&*6$,,
" %&- 62- , $( 6$% , " +%&2",,+,"5&+>$,,+&,)&& +&+&($2,&-&+,%&+%%+%%6-" ,,+,"5&+>$95&+>$422+)&-2& ?+">$+&$)+*-,$+"2$6,,+,%
"(,,+&2&,%"+$(9,(&% B
2"$("&2-)"
("4$3$2&&4$, &&2&(&&&6-"$"(&$"-)"3*)3" $+",%($"%6&$ &+&," *+ & +& , " $+9,,+ $ 6-
"(*%)$+"&,$"%+&&23&-6,3" 6-"
("4$?+,3,G$+&2*3 E
"
A62$%4$"%&,8
1 & .&&/
&)99:%:/$$32;)"&"2"&*"$(""
(" 4$&+$,&&2&(&&%&2>$-&"$2 &2-,$2""$(+$&2%-)&
"+7"+++,"+$,2(+"&*&& &$ 3( $
; $
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
$ $
2 %$ $
K %
4+
%* -F3 . EG!&-F38.56 -*.L
$
( 9 %$ '
)(
:
A 1
2
$
<
" & + &6*) , "& " & /010 %( $"% , &( , " &$&2 +% 3"+$%$2&*,,+&6-"&24",+&-*, &-&& 6& $ 6G+* +& , 3 & $""& +-,,&$2)&,&7( &+&(&"&%&*,,+3"3&&2&&+" ,,&-?2&&"&26(6-"" %$("+6&&2&626& VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
010"""
/
"3..2
,( ' )/
+""#
D"
H""&7(9&
9
H""&62
9 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.27 18:32 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document