- 1 - ! " #$ # % & ! " #$ % # # # # & ! " '# $ #%( "$## ) % # # # ) )%# ## ) & # ) # * # % % ' # +)## Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ,-. /01-.-23 405-5-23 -. 6-708 9: 5,0405-5-230/ ;<<=.08 90-3>;>>/-01089:5,0?=8>@03526<231-<5-23;382/80/ 23 .03503<0 8;508 4;..08 -3 ## 2 23 5,0 6-70 26 5,0 #-1-7 )=8>0 A )%# 075,;3>;8: ;38 -5. <236-/@;5-23 ?=8>@035 ;38 2/80/8;508 &4;..08-3#/7 2*23 5,0 6-70 26 5,0 887 -.5/-<5 ;38 0..-23. )=8>0 ;3>;72/0 .00B-3> 52 .05 ;.-80 5,0 <23<=//035 6-38-3>. /0<2/808 9: 5,0 #2=/5. 9072C C,0/0-3 5,0 405-5-230/ ;<<=.08C;.<231-<50862/5,026603<0.4=3-.,;970=380/ 0<5-23.;38(*26# ,0 /;3B. 26 5,0 4;/5-0. -3 5,0 /-;7 #2=/5 C-77 90 <23.-80/08,03<062/5,62/<23103-03<0 '()*'+,')-./)01('21 ( 5 -. 5,0 <;.0 26 5,0 4/2.0<=5-23 5,;5 23 ;/2=38 ( -5 -. .5;508 5,;5 5,0 ;<<=.08 ,;8 /0@2108 5,0 /226 5-70. 26 5,0 ,2=.0 26 ' ;38 5/0.. 4;..08 -352 5,0 ,2=.0 ;38 <2@@-5508 5,065 26 >278 2/3;@035. B045 -3 5,0 ;7@-/;, ,0/062/0 ; <2@47;-35 - 3 - <;@0 52 90 /0>-.50/08 9: ' ;>;-3.5 5,0 ;<<=.08 ;.08235,0<2@47;-355,0/0.4238035D427-<0/0>-.50/08 ;<;.0-3#/ 2(;>;-3.55,0405-5-230/;38;650/ <238=<5-3>-310.5->;5-23.=9@-55085,0<,;/>0.,005 ,0 4/2.0<=5-23 -3 2/80/ 52 4/210 -5. <;.0 0E;@-308 C-530..0.;.'.52 ;38>25@;/B08((82<=@035. ;. E. 52 (( ;38 -8035-6-08 ( 29?0<5. ;. . 52 ( ,0 /-;7 #2=/5 ;650/ ;44/0<-;5-3> 5,0 2/;7 ;38 82<=@035;/: 01-803<0 23 /0<2/8 <231-<508 5,0 ;<<=.08 62/5,026603<0..5;508 3;440;790-3>6-7085,0 44077;50 #2=/5 8-.@-..08 5,0 ;440;7 9: <236-/@-3> 5,0 ?=8>@03526<231-<5-234;..089:5,0/-;7#2=/503<0 5,-./01-.-23405-5-23 0;/8 /- -.,-5 =@;/ ,055: 70;/308 <2=3.07 62/ 5,0 405-5-230/;38/- ;>0.,C;/;44;70;/308->,#2=/5 210/3@03570;80/62/5,0/0.42380355;50 & 5-.5,0.=9@-..-232670;/308<2=3.0762/5,0405-5-230/ 5,;55,06-38-3>.265,0#2=/5.9072C;/0<235/;/:525,0 01-803<023/0<2/88@-55087:0-5,0/'2/;3:25,0/ C-530..0.,;10325-8035-6-085,0;<<=.082C010/5,0: - 4 - -8035-6-085,0>2782/3;@035.;770>0852,;109003.52703 9:5,0;<<=.080/0/0<210/:26>2782/3;@035.C-5,2=5 62772C-3> 5,0 4/2<08=/0 =380/ 0<5-23 26 38-;3 1-803<0<5<;332590.;-85,;55,0/0<210/:,;.9003 4/2108 5-.6=/5,0/.=9@-55085,;5-32/80/524/2105,0/0<210/: 5,0 127=35;/: .5;50@035 26 5,0 ;<<=.08 ,;. 52 90 /0<2/808-35,04/0.03<0264;3<,C-530..0.,0/0;650/ 5,0/0<210/:,;.52900660<508',035,0<;.0-.9;.08 23<-/<=@.5;35-;701-803<0@0/0-8035-5:265,0@;50/-;7 <;3325 90 .;-8 52 90 .=66-<-035 52 /0380/ 5,0 <231-<5-23 ;B-3> .=<, .=9@-..-23. 70;/308 <2=3.07 62/ 5,0 405-5-230/ 4;:. 52 ;772C 5,0 /01-.-23 405-5-23 9: .055-3> ;.-805,0<23<=//0356-38-3>. * 70;/308 ->, #2=/5 210/3@035 70;80/ 10,0@0357: ?=.5-6-08 5,0 <23<=//035 6-38-3>. 4;..08 9: 5,0 #2=/5. 9072C 0 .=9@-5508 5,;5 ;8@-55087: 5,065 ,;85;B0347;<0-35,0,2=.026'25,'.;38 ,;10.=442/5085,0<;.0265,04/2.0<=5-23'(90-3> ; C-530.. 52 5,0 .0-F=/0 @;,;F;/DE ,;. .=442/508 - 5 - 5,0<;.0265,04/2.0<=5-23'.;38&;/05,040/.23. C,2.2785,0>2782/3;@035.52',;10;7.28042.08 5,;5',;84=/<,;.085,0.;-8>2782/3;@035.6/2@ 5,0@-35,0-/.,24 5 -. 6=/5,0/ .=9@-5508 5,;5 ;77 5,0 C-530..0. ;/0 <23.-.5035 -3 5,0-/ 01-803<0 5,;5 5,0 ;<<=.08 ,;8 <2@@-55085,06526>2782/3;@035.90723>.52';38 5,0 310.5->;5-3> 66-<0/ ,;. /0<210/08 5,0 .;@0 ;5 5,0 -3.5;3<0 26 ;<<=.08 -3 5,0 4/0.03<026 4;3<, C-530..0. ..=<,5,0/0-.32/0;.23.528-.907-0105,001-803<026 ;775,0C-530..0.03<05,06-38-3>.265,0#2=/5.9072C ;/0 4/240/ ;38 ;44/24/-;50 350/60/03<0 C-5, 5,0 .;-8 6-38-3>. @;: 325 90 4/240/ ;B-3> .=<, .=9@-..-23. 70;/308->,#2=/5 210/3@03570;80/4/;:.528-.@-.. 5,0/01-.-23405-5-23 ;1-3> ,0;/8 70;/308 <2=3.07 62/ 5,0 /0.40<5-10 4;/5-0. ;38 ;7.2 40/=.08 5,0 6-38-3>. 26 5,0 #2=/5. 9072C -3 /0<2/8-3> 5,0 <231-<5-23 -5 -. /0701;35 52 /060/ 5,0 01-803<0264;3<,C-530..0.C,2;/04/0.035;55,05-@0 26<238=<5-3>5,0.0;/<,;38.0-F=/026>2782/3;@035.;5 - 6 - 5,0-3.5;3<026;<<=.08'.(;38;/05,0C-530..0. 26 .0-F=/0 @;,;F;/ 8042.08 ;92=5 5,0 .0-F=/0 26 >278 2/3;@035. ;5 5,0 -3.5;3<0 26 5,0 ;<<=.08 25, 5,0 C-530..0. ,;10 .=442/508 5,0 <;.0 26 5,0 4/2.0<=5-23 2C010/5,0:8-83258042.05,;55,0;<<=.08,;8@;80 127=35;/: .5;50@035 -3 5,0-/ 4/0.03<0 ;5 5,0 427-<0 .5;5-23 5-..0557084/-3<-470267;C5,;5520660<55,0/0<210/:26 ;3: -3</-@-3;5-3> @;50/-;7. <2350@47;508 =380/ 0<5-23 26 5,0 38-;3 1-803<0 <5 -5 -. 30<0..;/: 52 /0<2/8 5,0 .5;50@035 26 5,0 ;<<=.08 -3 5,0 4/0.03<0 26 4;3<, C-530..0.35,04/0.035<;.0925,5,04;3<,C-530..0. ,;10.5;5085,;55,0;<<=.08,;8325@;80;3:127=35;/: .5;50@0359062/05,0@4/-2/52>2-3>525,047;<0C,0/0 -5 -. ;770>08 5,;5 5,0 >278 2/3;@035. ,;10 9003 /0<210/08 3 5,-. <2350E5 -5 -. /0701;35 52 /060/ 5,0 ?=8>@035 26 23+970=4/0@0#2=/5-35,0<;.026 -3 4;/;D ;38 * ;/0 ,078 ;. =380/ 1 - 7 - ! " ! # $ % &' ( ( ) ! ! ! ! ! ! ' ' ' ( ( ( ! ! ! ! ! ! * * ( ( ! ! ' + ! * ! ! ! " " ! ( ( ! ! ! # $ % ! ! ! ! "( !( ! ! ! ! ( ! ! ! ! ! & ( * ! ! - 8 - ! ! " ( ( ! # $ % & ! ( ( , ( 3 <;/06=7 /0;8-3> 26 5,0 ?=8>@035 26 5,0 23+970 =4/0@0 #2=/5 -5 <;3 90 -360//08 5,;5 5,0 127=35;/: .5;50@03526;<<=.08,;.5290/0<2/808-35,04/0.03<0 26-38040380354;3<,C-530..0.;385,0/0;650/5,0:,;10 524/2<008525,0.425;38<238=<508.0;/<,;38.0-F=/0 35,0;9.03<02662772C-3>5,0.;-84/2<08=/0-5<;390 ,0785,;55,0;770>08/0<210/:,;.52901-5-;508 ;1-3> /0>;/8 52 5,0 4/-3<-4;7 7;-8 82C3 9: 5,0 23+970 =4/0@0#2=/5-35,0?=8>@035.5;508.=4/;;@265,0 <23.-80/0824-3-235,;5925,5,0#2=/5.,;10<2@@-5508 0//2/-3;447:-3>5,04/240/4/-3<-47023/0<210/:265,0 >278 2/3;@035. 23 5,0 9;.-. 26 127=35;/: .5;50@035 03<0;@265,0<23.-80/0824-3-235,;55,06-38-3>.26 5,0#2=/5.9072C;/07-;9705290.05;.-80 35,07->,5265,029.0/1;5-23.@;80;92104/2<00852 4;..5,062772C-3>D - 9 - "-$ ,0#/-@-3;701-.-2305-5-23-.! "--$ ,0 ?=8>@035 26 <231-<5-23 ;38 2/80/ 23 .03503<04;..08-3## 2 23 5,0 6-70 26 5,0 #-1-7 )=8>0 A )%# 075,;3>;8:;385,0?=8>@035;382/80/ 8;508 & 4;..08 -3 #/7 2* 23 5,0 6-70 26 5,0 887 -.5/-<5 ;38 0..-23. )=8>0;3>;72/0;/0.05;.-80 "---$ ,0 405-5-230/ -. ;<G=-5508 62/ 5,0 26603<0. 4=3-.,;970=380/0<5-23.;38(*26# "-1$ ;-79238.0E0<=508-6;3:.5;38<;3<07708 345 6 7 $ )D -.5 27 2