- 1 - ! " #$ # % & ! "#$%%%& ! ' ! (%& &(%')%&$ *& )%&( &%%$)%&( #*& )%&) ! + Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ,-. /-0-123 45-.-61 47-7-61 -. 8-349 :; 7,4 <47-7-614/ :4-1= 2==/-4549 :; 7,4 >?9=0417 68 @615-@7-61 219 6/94/ 61 .41741@4 92749 &%%$)%&( -1 6#*& )%&) 61 7,4 8-34 68 342/149 -5-3 ?9=4 219 29?/ 219 -7. @618-/027-61 >?9=04172196/94/92749&(%')%&$-1/36*& )%&(61 7,48-3468342/14999-7-61234..-61.?9=4,-AA202=23?/? B,4/4-1 7,4 <47-7-614/ 2@@?.49 -. @615-@749 86/ 7,4 68841@4 <?1-.,2:34 ?194/ 4@7-61 $: 68 2/1272A2 63-@4 @7 86/ :/45-7;C @7D ) ,4 <47-7-614/ -. 7,4 2@@?.49 219 7,4 2<<433217 :486/4 7,4 /-23 6?/7 2. B433 2. 7,4 <<433274 6?/7 /4.<4@7-543; 6/ 7,4 .2A4 68 @61541-41@4 7,4 /21A. 68 7,4 <2/7-4.,41@486/7,B-33:4@61.-94/492.<4/7,4-//21A.:486/4 7,4/-236?/7 '()*+,-,.)+*-)*') 7 -. 7,4 @2.4 68 7,4 </6.4@?7-61 7,27 61 )(%()%&)272:6?7*%<0B,417,4/2-3B2;688-@-23.B4/4 61 9?7; 2 <4/.61 B2. ?.49 76 :62/9 219 23-=,7 ,-5206==2 E</4../2-18/60614@60<2/70417762167,4/@60<2/70417 - 3 - 219 76?@,-1= 7,4 3?==2=4 68 7,4 <2..41=4/. ?.<4@7-1= ,-. @619?@77,4@60<32-1217"<63-@42.A49,-076.,6B,-.7-@A47 ,4,2.167</69?@497-@A47219,2.167=-54121;.27-.82@76/; 4E<32127-61 86/ ,-. @619?@7 6B454/ ,4 -186/049 7,40 7,27 ,4B2.7,4/4.-941768,-5206==20049-2743;,4B2.72A41 76 @?.769; 219 7,4 @60<32-1217"<63-@4 /4=-.74/49 2 @2.4 -1 /6& )%&)86/7,468841@4<?1-.,2:34?194/4@7-61$: 687,4 @7874/@619?@7-1=-154.7-=27-617,4@,2/=4.,447 B2..?:0-77492=2-1.77,4<47-7-614/ ( 6</6547,4@2.47,4</6.4@?7-614E20-1497,/44 B-714..4. 2. !.& 76 219 =67 02/A49 7B6 96@?0417. 2. E.& 219 ) 1 7,4 67,4/ ,219 7,4 94841@4 ,2. 167 @,6.4176342921;45-941@4,4/-236?/72874/2<</4@-27-1= 7,4 6/23 219 96@?04172/; 45-941@4 61 /4@6/9 @615-@749 7,4 2@@?.49 <47-7-614/ 86/ 7,4 68841@4 .72749 4-1= 2==/-4549:;7,4.2047,4<47-7-614/,4/4-1,29</484//4921 2<<423 :486/4 7,4 <<433274 6?/7 ,4 <<433274 6?/7 2874/ ,25-1= ,42/9 7,4 2@@?.49 @618-/049 7,4 >?9=0417 68 @615-@7-61/4194/49:;7,4/-236?/74-1=2==/-4549:;7,4 .2047,4<47-7-614/,2.</484//497,-./45-.-61<47-7-61.44A-1= 76.472.-947,4@61@?//4178-19-1=. - 4 - # 42/9 /- 25-19/2/2.29 342/149 @6?1.4386/ 7,4 <47-7-614/ 219 /- 2=4.,B2/2<<2 342/149 -=, 6?/7 654/1041734294/86/7,4/4.<619417F7274 $ 7-. 7,4.?:0-..-61687,4342/149@6?1.4386/7,4 <47-7-614/ 7,27 7,4 @60<32-17 254/0417. B6?39 -19-@274 7,27 7,4 <47-7-614/ B2. :62/9-1= 219 23-=,7-1= 8/60 614 @60<2/70417 76 2167,4/ 219 23.6 7/;-1= 76 .42/@, 3?==2=4 68 7,4<2..41=4/.6B454/16-194<419417B-714..4.,254:441 4E20-14976.?:.7217-2747,4.2-9@617417-61 ' !.& 76 2/4 7,4 688-@-23 B-714..4. 219 7,4-/ 45-941@4 6?=,7 167 76 ,254 @61.-94/49 B-7,6?7 @6//6:6/27-61 ,46?/7.:436B@600-77494//6/-1@61.-94/-1=7,445-941@4 68 688-@-23 B-714..4. 219 /4@6/949 7,4 @615-@7-61 B,-@, -. 4//6146?.2197,4.204-.?1.?.72-12:34 * 7-.8?/7,4/.?:0-77497,27-17,4@/6.."4E20-127-61 68!&,4.?:0-7.7,27,4,2.167/4@6/94921;.7274041768 <2..41=4/. 76 .?:.7217-274 7,27 7,4 <47-7-614/ B2. .42/@,-1= 7,4 3?==2=4 68 67,4/ <2..41=4/. -0-32/3; 2167,4/ B-714.. B,6-.4E20-1492.!)B6/A-1=2.2<63-@4@61.72:34-17,4 2-3B2; 4<2/70417 290-7749 -1,-. @/6.."4E20-127-61 7,27 - 5 - ,4 ,29 167 .441 7,4 2<<433217 -1 7,4 /2-3B2; .727-61 </-6/ 76 *%%<0 . 7,4.4 B-714..4. 2/4 7,4 688-@-23 B-714..4. 219 7,4; ,254 167 /4@6/949 7,4 .72740417 68 -194<419417 B-714..4. @/49-:-3-7; 76 7,4 688-@-23 B-714..4. .,6?39 167 ,254 :441=-541:;7,46?/7.:436B17,42:.41@468-194<419417 B-714..4. /43;-1= 61 7,4 45-941@4 688-@-23 B-714..4. 219 /4194/-1= 7,4 @615-@7-61 -. 4//6146?. 219 167 </6<4/ ,4/486/4 7,4 .204 -. 3-2:34 76 :4 .47 2.-94 2A-1= .?@, .?:0-..-61 7,4 342/149 @6?1.43 86/ 7,4 <47-7-614/ </2;. 76 2336B7,4<47-7-61 &% 342/149-=,6?/7 654/1041734294/ 86/ .,6/7 C D 54,404173; >?.7-8-49 7,4 >?9=0417 68 @615-@7-61 219 -7. @618-/027-61 6/94/ <2..49 :; 7,4 6?/7. :436B 219 .?:0-7749 7,27 7,4 45-941@4 68 688-@-23 B-714..4. @21167:49-.@2/949617,4=/6?197,277,4;2/47,4688-@-23219 -174/4.749 B-714..4. ,4 61D:34 ?</404 6?/7 /4-74/2749 7,277,445-941@468688-@-23B-714..4. @21167:49-.@2/94961 7,4=/6?197,277,4;2/47,4688-@-23B-714..4.219-174/4.749-1 - 6 - /4194/-1=7,4@615-@7-61182@77,4-/45-941@4.,6?3923.6:4 @61.-94/492874/7,6/6?=,.@/?7-1; && 4 8?/7,4/ .?:0-7749 7,27 2. 7,4 <47-7-614/ B2. /620-1=8/60614@60<2/70417762167,4/B-7,6?7523-97-@A47 219 ,4 B2. 23.6 76?@,-1= 6/ .42/@,-1= 3?==2=4 68 7,4 @6" <2..41=4/.,41@4,4B2.2//4.7492197,46?/7.:436B,254 /-=,73;,4397,27,4,2.@600-774968841@4?194/7,4286/4.2-9 </65-.-61. ,4/486/4 -174/84/41@4 B-7, 7,4 .2-9 8-19-1=. B2. 167 14@4..2/; 2A-1= .?@, .?:0-..-61. 7,4 342/149 </2;.769-.0-..7,4<47-7-61 &) 25-1= ,42/9 7,4 /-523 @617417-61. ?/=49 :; 7,4 342/149 @6?1.43. 86/ 7,4 /4.<4@7-54 <2/7-4. 219 23.6 <4/?.49 7,4 8-19-1=. /4@6/949 :; 7,4 6?/7. :436B -1 /4194/-1= 7,4 @615-@7-61 -7 -. 2<</6</-274 76 .7274 7,4 4@7-61 $ 68 2/1272A263-@4@7&$B,-@,/429.2.?194/ - 7 - ! & 1 /429-1= 68 7,4 286/4.2-9 </65-.-61. -7 2<<42/. 7,27 -8 21; <4/.61 B,6 -. 86?19 :47B441 .?1.47 219 .?1/-.4 2/049 B-7, 21; 921=4/6?. -1.7/?0417 6/ ,25-1= ,-. 82@4 @654/496/-121; 9B433-1=,6?.4B-7,6?7:4-1=.27-.82@76/-3; 762@@6?1786/,-. </4.41@47,4/46/3;-1=6/36-74/-1=-121; .7/447;2/96/67,4/<32@4:43-2:3476:4</6.4@?749 &( 6B454/-17,4</4.417@2.461=6-1=7,/6?=,7,4 45-941@4 68 !. & 76 7,4 45-941@4 68 233 7,4.4 B-714..4. 9-9 167 9-.@36.4 7,4 286/4.2-9 -1=/49-417. 2. 2=2-1.7 7,4 <47-7-614/?/7,4/7,4/-236?/72.B4332.7,4<<4332746?/7 ,254 =/6..3; @600-7749 4//6/. -1 /4@6/9-1= 7,4 @615-@7-61 61 7,4 .7/41=7, 68 7,4 688-@-23 B-714..4. B-7,6?7 -194<419417 @6//6:6/27-61 ,4/486/4 -1 0; @61.-94/49 5-4B 7,4 .2-9 8-19-1=.2/4167</6<4/219/434521741@47,4.2-98-19-1=. 2/43-2:3476:4.472.-94 - 8 - &# 1 7,4 3-=,7 68 7,4 6:.4/527-61. 0294 2:654 </6@44976<2..7,486336B-1= - ,4/-0-12345-.-6147-7-61-. -- ,4 >?9=0417 68 @615-@7-61 219 6/94/ 61 .41741@4 92749 &%%$)%&( <2..49 -1 6#*& )%&):;7,4342/149-5-3?9=4219 29?/2197,4>?9=04172196/94/92749 &(%')%&$ <2..49 -1 /3 6*& )%&( :; 7,4 342/149 99-7-6123 4..-61. ?9=4 ,-AA202=23?/?2/4.472.-94 --- ,4 <47-7-614/ 2@@?.49 -. 2@G?-7749 86/ 7,4 68841@4 <?1-.,2:34 ?194/ 4@7-61 $ : 68 2/1272A263-@4@7&$ -5 2-3:619.4E4@?749-821;.7219@21@43349 /01 2 3 $ "-.76&36#