- 1 - ! " "# $% & % ' ( ! " # $ # % " %&&&' $ ! " ( $ # )(&' * # & & &' * *# '&&+ * &' '& &' * ')&'" ### &" $# ' & &# # #(, Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , -* ' ./0 1/2/345 67/0/83 69/9/83 /0 :/56; <= 9.6 >69/9/8361 <6/3?4??1/676;<=9.6@83@A11639:/3;/3?08:9.68A190<658B B.616/39.691/458A1916@81;6;9.6@837/@9/838:9.6>69/9/8361 :81 9.6 8::63@60 >A3/0.4<56 A3;61 6@9/830 ) &" $ 8: 3;/4363458;6":810.819$43;6@9/838:9.63;/43 8981 6./@56 @9 ":81 0.819 $ .6 4>>655496 8A19 ;/02/006; 9.6 4>>645 :/56; <= 9.6 >69/9/8361 <= 4::/12/3? 9.6 CA;?26398:9.61/458A19 .6 143D0 8: 9.6 >419/60 .63@6:819. B/55 <6 @830/;616; 40 >61 9.6/1 143D/3?0 <6:816 9.6 1/45 8A19 :81 @83763/63@6 )*+,-./.0+-,/+,)+ 9 /0 9.6 @406 8: 9.6 >1806@A9/83 9.49 83 & & &&+494<8A9'' &&4 2 9B8>6108307/E 1/0.34>>4 8B;443;4D0.24224B616?8/3?<=B45D<=9.60/;68:9.6 184; 3641 ./7414C4>A14 .6 4@@A06; <6/3? 4 1/;61 8: 9.6 28981 </D6 B40 @82/3? :182 ./19.4.455/ /3 4 140. 43; 36?5/?639 243361 43; ;40.6; 1/0.34>>4 8B;4 43; @4A06; - 3 - /3CA1/6098./2 .8A?.9.6/3CA16;B400./:96;989.6.80>/945 .6 0A@@A2<6; 98 9.6 /3CA1/60 .6 CA1/0;/@9/8345 >85/@6 .476 16?/09616;9.6@406/341 8 &&+4?4/3099.6>69/9/8361 :961@83;A@9/3?/37609/?49/839.6@.41?60.669B400A<2/996; 8 >1876 9.6 @406 8: 9.6 >1806@A9/83 9.6 >1806@A9/83 6F42/36; 3/36 B/9360060 40 (0 ' 98 ) 43; ?89 241D6;3/36;8@A2639040F0 '98) 39.689.61.43; F ' B40 241D6; 83 <6.45: 8: 9.6 4@@A06; .6 1/45 8A19 4:961 4>>16@/49/3? 9.6 8145 43; ;8@A263941= 67/;63@6 83 16@81;@837/@96;9.64@@A06;>69/9/8361:819.68::63@6009496; 6/3?4??1/676;<=9.604269.6>69/9/8361.616/3.4; >16:6116;434>>645<6:8169.6 >>6554968A19 .6 >>655496 8A194:961.47/3?.641;9.64@@A06;@83:/126;9.6CA;?2639 8:@837/@9/83163;616;<=9.61/458A19 6/3?4??1/676;<= 9.6 0426 9.6 >69/9/8361 .40 >16:6116; 9./0 167/0/83 >69/9/83 066D/3?9806940/;69.6@83@A11639:/3;/3?0 641; 1/ 260. 564136; @8A3065 :81 1/ 47/3;41460.>43;6564136;@8A3065:819.6>69/9/836143; 1/ 4?60.B414>>4564136;/?.8A19876132639564;61 :819.6160>83;639%9496 - 4 - 9/0 9.60A<2/00/838:9.6564136;@8A3065:819.6 >69/9/8361 9.49 9.6 67/;63@6 8: 6=6 B/9360060 8A?.9 389 98 .476<663@830/;616;<=9.61/458A19B/9.8A9>18>610@1A9/3= 40 9.6= 416 9.6 165496; 43; /39616096; B/9360060 3 :4@9 9.6 ;6@6406; B./56 ?8/3? 83 9.6 184; 43; 0A;;635= .6 91/6; 98 @1800 9.6 184; B/9.8A9 :8558B/3? 9.6 5436 ;/0@/>5/36 8306GA6395=9.61/;619.8A?.91/6;98478/;9.64@@/;639.6 @8A5; 389 478/; /9 40 4 160A59 8: B./@. .6 4508 0A094/36; ?1/678A0/3CA1/60 9 /0 :A19.61 0A<2/996; 9.49 9.6 >1806@A9/83 .40 :4/56; 98 >1876 4<8A9 9.6 @A5>4<56 140.3600 43; 36?5/?63@6 B./@.4169.6<40/@16GA/1626390366;98<66094<5/0.6;<=9.6 >1806@A9/83 39.64<063@68:140.360043;36?5/?63@64@98: 9.6 >69/9/8361 @837/@9/83 8A?.9 389 98 .476 <663 16@81;6; /3 160>6@9 8: 9.6 8::63@6 A3;61 6@9/83 ) 8: 6 :A19.61 0A<2/996; 9.49 40 9.6 >1806@A9/83 .40 :4/56; 98 >1876 9.6 36?5/?63@6839.6>4198:9.64@@A06;9.6@837/@9/83/3160>6@9 8: 8::63@6 A3;61 6@9/83 & 8: 0.8A5; 4508 <6 ?836 .A09.6564136;@8A3065:819.6>69/9/8361>14=0984558B9.6 >69/9/83 - 5 - + 564136;/?.8A19876132639564;61 ":81 <167/9= HI$ 76.626395= CA09/:/6; 9.6 CA;?2639 8: @837/@9/83 43; /90 @83:/1249/83 81;61 >4006; <= 9.6 >>655496 8A19 60A<2/996;9.499.667/;63@68: ( 'B.8/09.6B/:6 8:9.6;6@6406;B8A5;@56415=/3;/@4969.49<89..61065:43;9.6 ;6@6406; B616 B45D/3? <= 9.6 0/;6 8: 9.6 184; .6 4@@/;639 8@@A116; ;A6 98 9.6 140. 43; 36?5/?639 4@9 8: 9.6 >69/9/8361 .6 67/;63@6 8: (0 43; B.8 416 9.6 /3;6>63;639 B/9360060 98 9.6 4@@/;639 416 @830/09639 9.49 9.6 4@@/;639 8@@A116;;A6989.6140.43;36?5/?6394@98:9.6>69/9/8361 ) 6 :A19.61 0A<2/996; 9.49 9.6 0D69@. B./@. /0 241D6; 40 F B8A5; ;6283091496 40 98 .8B 9.6 4@@/;639 .4; 8@@A116; 43; B.8 /0 .65; 160>830/<56 6 :A19.61 094960 9.49 ;8@91/36 8: 4>>5/@4<56 98 9.6 @406 83 .43; .616:8169.6@837/@9/83366;389<6;/09A1<6; 4D/3? 0A@.0A<2/00/83.6>14=098;/02/009.6>69/9/83 '& 47/3? .641; 9.6 1/745 @839639/830 A1?6; <= 9.6 564136;@8A30650:819.6160>6@9/76>419/6043;4508>61A06;9.6 CA;?263908:9.68A190<658B/94>>64109.499.61/458A19 43;9.6 >>6554968A1924/35=165/6;839.667/;63@68: (0 ' - 6 - 9843;4508F .667/;63@68: ( 'B8A5;/3;/@4969.49 0.6B40?8/3?4583?B/9.9.6;6@6406;98.6116549/76I0.8A06 .6 >69/9/8361 .4; ;40.6; 9.6 ;6@6406; <= 1/;/3? ./0 28981 </D6/34140.43;36?5/?639243361 .8A?.9.6;6:630691/6; 9865/@/99.499.64@@/;6398@@A116;;A69836?5/?6394@98:.61 .A0<43; 0.6 B40 @830/09639 /3 .61 67/;63@6 9.49 /9 B40 9.6 36?5/?6394@98:9.61/;618:9.628981@=@569.499.64@@/;639 .4;8@@A116; '' ( /3./067/;63@6.4009496;9.49499.69/268: 4@@/;639.6B4036419.6<A0098> :961066/3?9.64@@/;639 .6 1A0.6; 98 9.6 0>89 43; 0./:96; 9.6 /3CA16; 98 9.6 876132639.80>/94543;54961.658;?6;4@82>54/39 .8A?. /9 B40 0A??6096; 9.49 9.6 4@@/;639 8@@A116; ;A6 98 9.6 36?5/?6394@98:9.6/3CA16;.6;63/6;9.60426 ' ( ;6>806; /3 ./0 67/;63@6 9.49 9.6 >69/9/8361 B40 1/;/3? ./0 28981 </D6 98B41;0 ?A2<6 :182 ./19.4.455/ 9.6 4@@/;639 8@@A116; 83 9.49 ;4= 40 4 160A59 8: B./@. <89. 9.61/;618:9.6</D643;9.6>40061<=.4760A094/36;/3CA1/60 8B6761.6;/;389;6>8064098B.8B40160>830/<56:819.6 04/;4@@/;639 - 7 - ' ( .40450809496;98<69.66=6B/93600989.6 /3@/;639.8B6761.6;/;389;6>8064098B.8B401/;/3?9.6 28981</D6499.69/268:4@@/;639 ' .8A?. 9.616 416 89.61 :8A1 B/9360060 .476 <663 6F42/36;<=9.6>1806@A9/839.6/167/;63@6/03891656743940 9.6=4163899.66=6B/9360060989.6/3@/;639 ' 38761455164;/3?8:9.667/;63@68:9.624961/45 B/9360060/9@43<6/3:6116;9.499.667/;63@68: (0 ' 43; .476 0A>>8196; 9.6 @406 8: 9.6 >1806@A9/83 55 9.606 B/9360060416@830/096399.499.6</D6B40<6/3?1/;;63<=9.6 1/;61 /3 4 140. 43; 36?5/?639 243361 43; ;40.6; 98 9.6 >6;6091/43 8B6761 9.6 0D69@. B./@. /0 241D6; 40 F /3;/@49609.499.64@@/;6398@@A116;/39.62/;;568:9.6184; 0 >61 9.6 0D69@. 9.6 184; B40 2640A1/3? '+ :669 43; 9.6 4@@/;6398@@A116;452809:/7698963:669:182/9056:90/;6 ' 0>619.64761263908:9.6@82>54/3943;45089.6 67/;63@6 8: ( ' /9 4>>6410 9.49 9.6 ;6@6406; 43; ( ' B616?8/3?839.6184;98B41;0./7414C4>A14 .64;2/996;/3 .61 @18006F42/349/83 9.49 0.6 ;/; 389 8<06176 9.6 /3CA1= 8: 9.64@@A06;40839.6;4968:9.64@@/;639 8B6761 ( .40 - 8 - 09496; 9.49 9.6 <588; B40 88E/3? :182 9.6 28A9. 8: 9.6 4@@A06; 43; .6 0A094/36; /3CA1/60 .616:816 9.6 67/;63@6 8: ( ' @43389 <6 <65/676; 40 6=6 B/93600 98 9.6 /3@/;639 8168761 0.6 B40 389 9.6 @82>54/3439 8: 9.6 @406 4; 0.6 <663 9.616 B/9. 9.6 ;6@6406; 49 9.6 9/26 8: 4@@/;639 0.6 B8A5;.476<6639.6@82>54/3439 ' .6 67/;63@6 8: 6=6 B/9360060 B8A5; /3;/@496 9.49 9.64@@A06;.4;1/;;63./028981@=@56/34./?.0>66;43;140. 43; 36?5/?639 243361 ;40.6; 9.6 >6;6091/43 .8B6761 9.6 >16063@68: ( 'B40;8A<9:A5:819.61640839.490.6;/;389 ;/0@58069.6/3CA1=0A094/36;989.6>69/9/83614@@A06;/39.6 04/; 4@@/;639 0 >61 9.6 0D69@. /9 @43 <6 ?49.616; 9.49 9.6 ;6@6406;B40389?8/3?839.60/;68:9.6184; .616:8169.6 4@@A06; B40 1/;/3? 9.6 28981</D6 /3 4 140. 43; 36?5/?639 243361 @43389 <6 4@@6>96; 3 9.6 4<063@6 8: 67/;63@6 /3 160>6@9 8: 140.3600 43; 36?5/?639 4@9 8: 9.6 ;1/761 8: 9.6 76./@56 @837/@9/83 @43389 <6 0A094/36; .616:816 /3961:6163@68:9.6:/3;/3?08:9.68A190<658B/0CA09/:/6; '+ 3 9.6 5/?.9 8: 9.6 8<061749/830 24;6 4<876 >18@66;98>4009.6:8558B/3?, - 9 - "/$ .61/2/34567/0/8369/9/83/0 "//$ .6 CA;?2639 8: @837/@9/83 43; 81;61 83 063963@6 ;496; & & &' >4006; /3 8 '&&+<=9.6564136;15 /7/5*A;?6 43; *# ./19.4455/ 43; 9.6 CA;?2639 43; 81;61 ;496; &' '& &' >4006; /3 15 8 ')&' <= 9.6 564136; ;;5 600/830 *A;?6./7428??441606940/;6 "///$ .6 >69/9/83614@@A06; /0 4@GA/996; :81 9.6 8::63@60A3;616@9/830)&" $8:43; 6@9/838: @9 "/7$ 4/5<83;06F6@A96;/:43=0943;@43@6556; 123 4 5 & * /098 ,'58 ,