Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 30649 (KAR)
NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AUTHORITY OF INDIA v. SRI. U. GANGADHARA
MFA/5128/2024 · 2025-01-13
S Rachaiah, V Kameswar Rao
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 30649 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 30649 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " # $!%&
$! ## '( &
!"!##! $% & $
'
( $ )) !"!#'"
!*
( $ )) !"!#'"
Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)) !"!##'
+
, ))
) ) !"!##'
& '+$
"'-
*#!#+ *(#
)
,
,'(#'# "'#
$
. . /
$)
012 /
- 3 -
! '# $! (
' 345 066708 305 094571 :9;< =37 >?2@<71= 012 ;9279 20=72*#!#+60557241;*(#;1=37:487 ;: 224=4;108 45=94-= 012 7554;15 ?2@7 0A53410 )01102001@08?9? )*+,-./.0+-,/+
= 45 =37 -057 ;: =37 06678801= 0=4;108 4@3B0C5 ?=3;94=C;:1240:;953;9=DE=30=4=0-F?4972=37 8012:;9=376?96;57;:B427141@=370=4;1084@3B0C 69784<4109C1;=4:4-0=4;1B05455?72;1#*##'#012 =37 :4108 1;=4:4-0=4;1 B05 455?72 ;1 #+##'' 37 06678801= 379741 302 41G4=72 -804<5 :9;< =37 8012 ;B1795(41=7975=726795;1541=79<5;:=3769;G454;15;:
=37 0=4;108 4@3B0C5 -= '! :;9 53;9= D -=E 375?H>7-=<0==79;:=345066708679=0415=;79<011?9 $4880@701@08?9?4197567-=;:!"!-71=5;:801237 -;<67150=4;1B05:4I720=5'!####(679-71=
37 9756;1271=5 ;' 012 H741@ 0@@947G72 HC =37 -;<67150=4;1 27=79<4172 HC =37 67-408 012
- 4 -
-F?454=4;1 ::4-79 // :;9 53;9= 302 697:79972 01 09H4=90=4;1 06684-0=4;1 H7:;97 =37 9H4=90=;9
9756;1271=;379756;1271=;71301-72=37 -;<67150=4;1 :9;< 5'!####( 679 -71= =;
5#####( 679 -71= G427 0B092 20=72 '#+#'! 741@0@@947G72HC=3750<7=379756;1271=5;'012 379741 302 697:79972 01 9H4=90=4;1 ?4= 41 ;(#'! ;1 =37 :487 ;: =37 224=4;108 45=94-= 012 7554;15 ?2@7 0A53410 )011020 01@08?9? 37 9408 ;?9= G427 4=5 >?2@<71= 012 ;9279 20=72 #'##'* 305 57= 05427 =37 09H4=908 0B092 012 97<01272H0-A=37<0==79=;9756;1271=;:;9:9753 -;1542790=4;1
+ 37 9756;1271= ; 0:=79 370941@ =37 <0==79 -;1:49<72 =37 71301-7<71= ;: -;<67150=4;1 0B09272 7098479HC41G;A41@=374@3==;049;<67150=4;1012 901560971-C 41 012 -F?454=4;1 730H484=0=4;1 012 757==87<71= -= #' :;9 53;9= D -= #'E
- 5 -
! 741@0@@947G72HC=370B092605572HC=379756;1271= ;=3706678801=012085;=379756;1271=5;'012 302 697:79972 09H4=90=4;1 5?4=5 41 9H4=90=4;1 7=4=4;15 ;*(# 012 (# ;1 =37 :487 ;: =37 224=4;108 45=94-= 012 7554;15 ?2@7 0A53410 )011020 01@08?9? :;9 57==41@ 05427 =37 09H4=908 0B092 ;B7G79 =37 9408 ;?9= 245<45572 H;=3 =37 5?4=5(67=4=4;15 :4872 HC =37 06678801= 012 9756;1271=5 ;'012HC5=0=41@05?1279. ! ! " #! # $$%&# ' &
()
! "
*+ ' &! , " & - . /!" #,
&0 $1$#,223#&#,&4- " 4
5)-
"
6 " *+ '
&
""
%
#
"
- 6 -
!"
*+'
&
" ! "
6!" " 7 ! " 6 8
"
" 47 & 9"
"
! !" . "
" 9
#(
#':$;:;:; &! &
"
! "" -
! "
9
"
! "
6
! " 9 7
" ! "
<
! &
" ! """
. """
"
"
"
! ="" %
" !
!"
"""
7
" " ! . /!"#,
" 9
"
!% :$;
- 7 -
$%& #' &! , "
&
> -
&! , "
: ;& $1? -
! ! 9
#' & ,
! " 6!""7 = " %$#':$;
6 ! "
" 4""
"
7 - " <
"
! "
"
!"
!"
" $1 @
" ! . /!" # , 4
! ! ! ," +" "
! # 'A:?;
" . &
- 8 -
! 4 & &
!"
""
" ! ! ! ! ! ! ,
" A -
! ".&
"
" ! $ -
! &2+$1$'
! "
"
- "
"
"
"
&! <
"
! ""
, &#'$+$1? $$
! ! - . /!" # ,
" .&
5#9 B ," C & ," &" 2 $1$$D
"
E 6
"
"
"!" & >>2
"
- 9 -
# '
&
" !<
""
"!"
! ! ! ! ! " / /
" !" F
! " " ! " "
9
! ! " !"
!"
! 9
"
"" !" 7 6
"!"
" " # 'A:;:; .&
" ! ! # $( 08,-4&00 &
$1'
! <
7 6D "
G &
" '11& '&
,
"" ! ! " ! "
! " # "
"
"
" " <
<
"-
- 10 -
! ! <
"
"
" ! &
" # $( 08,-4&00 & $1' "
"!" # 'H. &
"" ! "
&
" ,
! -# :#;
# 'H . &
"
" "
"
" ""
"
$(($1? "
! "!"
" 08,-4&00 &
! " "!"
"" " "
"
'
8 #" . & . ""
# $2 $( 08,-4&00 &
"" ! "!"
#
'H 'A:;:;.& 7 $' - . /!" # ,
:$1; > #,, $2 %
5 #
*
"
- 11 -
! " "
"
"
! <
"
" !
"""
""
"
""
"
!" ,
! "
- . /!" #,
"
,
""
""
" $ - . /!" # ,
""
"
! ! &! " 9
! "
"! " "
! $?F "
! " ! "
"
! "!"
08,-4&00 & $1'
" ! ""
"
"
"" ! "
"!"
" &
- 12 -
" ! #'
&! , " & &
<
"
$2
? " . &
" "
" !" ) ! "
" ! " ! " . &
" " ! ! D ! "
$ 8 # 'A:;
" . &
! "
!% :; !%
:?; "" <
<
"
"
!"
# '&"
! <
" ! "
" ! 9"
- 13 -
!"
"
""
" ! !"
"
! "" *+'A:; !"
$( F
"
! " ! "
#'A:;:!;C:;
". &
"
$?I
"
" <
"
*+'&
" . &
" "
" "
- ! "
<
9
" . 3 22:; 4 &! <
" -" ! <
"
"
" ! .&
"
- 14 -
" J< @ J
"
" "
" & " ? $>
! !"
"
-
"""
!" "
" ! ""
! #! # $ $%& # '
&! , " & ! ! '1
2
% 8
? "" F0J=0 - ! " ! " +" " &2+$1$' *+ '&C& ! - &! " ! +.& &(>+$1$' *+':$;
& C , & + #'A:2;
" .& ! - & ! &! J , K " J@
- 15 -
,J#&0):$;.4&L,02+$1>%$1
$$$1$$! !
F
" @
" 9
&2+$1$'
&(>+$1$' # !<
"
9
71-7=345066708
7092 9401?<01=30 722C 8709172 -;?1578 :;9 =37 06678801= 756;1271=5 ;' =; + =3;?@3 30G7 H771 579G72097?197697571=72=<0C085;H75=0=72=30= =37 9756;1271=5 ;' 012 30G7 1;= -308871@72 =37 4<6?@172;927920=72*#!#+;:=379408;?9=
" = 45 =37 5?H<4554;1 ;: =37 8709172 -;?1578 :;9 =37 06678801==30==3787091729H4=90=;9012=379408;?9= -;<<4==72@90G7799;9410668C41@=376941-46875;:=37 -= #' 7G71 =3;?@3 =37 50<7 097 1;= 06684-0H8785;=3706684-0=4;1;:=37>?2@<71=;:=37 ;1/H87?697<7;?9=41=37-057;:
- 16 -
B34-345 1;=06684-0H87=;=37-057;1:0-=5
* = 45 :?9=379 5?H<4==72 =30= 0B09241@ =37 5;80=4?< 012 41=7975=41=345-057=;=370-F?49728012HC-;15427941@ =37 0H;G7 5042 6941-46875 45 -;1=909C =; =37 7-=4;1
" ;: -= 0A41@ 5?-3 5?H<4554;15 =37 8709172-;?1578:;906678801=690C5=;088;B=37066708
= 45 085; 5=0=72 =30= =37 9408 ;?9= 305 79972 41 <7-3014-088C ?63;8241@ =37 71301-7<71= ;: =37 -;<67150=4;1 :9;< 5'!####( 679 -71= =;
5#####( 679 -71= B4=3;?= =3797 H741@ <0=79408 =30= =37 <09A7= G08?7 ;: =37 8012 B05 =30= <?-3 --;9241@ =; 34< =37 B05 94@3= 41 @901=41@ -;<67150=4;1 0= 5'!####( 679 -71= H0572 ;1 =37 5087 5=0=45=4-5 ;: =37 0G790@7 =3977 C7095 ;9 @?4201-7 G08?7;:=375?99;?1241@8012505;1=3720=7;:=37 1;=4:4-0=4;1 ?= =37 8709172 9H4=90=;9 41 345 0B092 20=72 "'# B4=3;?= =3797 H741@ 01C 7G4271-7 41-8?241@ =37 5087 5=0=45=4-5 B4=3 01 ?19705;172 ;9279
1 (2019) 9 SCC 304
- 17 -
305?63782=37-;<67150=4;1;:5#####(679-71= 05 @901=72 G427 0B092 20=72 '#+#'! 1 ;=379 B;925 =37 8709172 9H4=90=;9 B4=3;?= 4127671271= 71F?49C012B4=3;?=27=79<4141@=37<09A7=G08?7305 ?63782 =37 697G4;?5 -;<67150=4;1 @901=72 B34-3 45 ?1=710H87
'# 0G41@ 37092 =37 8709172 -;?1578 :;9 06678801= 4= 45 9787G01==;97:797-=4;1 ";:-=B34-397025 05:;88;B5. 6 !"#$%!%&
:; :$;
:'; :; :?; :2; :; -
! "
!% :;!% :?;
!"" <
M :; <
"
"
!"
'&E :!;
! <
- 18 -
" ! "
" E :;
! <
" ! 9"
!"
E :;
"
""
"
!
!"
"
7
'' 1-097:?8970241@;:=370H;G7504269;G454;14=45-8709 =30==37<09A7=G08?7;:=378012B;?82H727=79<4172 05;1=3720=7;:6?H84-0=4;1;:1;=4-7?12797-=4;1 ;:-= ' 2<4==728C41=345-057=371;=4:4-0=4;1B05455?72:;9 =37 6?96;57 ;: 0-F?454=4;1 ;: 8012 ;1 #*##'# 012 :41081;=4:4-0=4;1B05455?72;1#+##''3767-408 012 -F?454=4;1 ::4-79 0:=79 -;15427941@ =37 9787G01= 5087 5=0=45=4-5 012 085; ;=379 <0=794085 0G0480H87 ;1 97-;920994G720=0-;1-8?54;1=30==37<09A7=G08?7;:
- 19 -
=37 5042 8012 B;?82 H7 ;: 5'!####( 679 -71= ;B7G79 ;1 =37 09H4=90=4;1 06684-0=4;1 :4872 HC =37 9756;1271= ;5' 012 =37 8709172 9H4=90=;9 9756;1271= ; 0994G72 0= 0 -;1-8?54;1 =30= =37 -;<67150=4;1 17725 =; H7 71301-72 --;9241@8C 37 71301-72 =37 -;<67150=4;1 B4=3;?= 01C H0545 7@97==0H8C =37 9408 ;?9= 305 1;= 06697-40=72 =37 0:;975042 5=012 ;: =37 06678801= B3487 245<45541@ =37 67=4=4;1?12797-=4;1+;:=37-=;:'=:;88;B5 =37 8709172 9H4=90=;9 012 =37 9408 ;?9=/5 -;1-8?54;1 ?63;8241@ =37 -;<67150=4;1 ;: 5#####( 679 -71= 3051;H0545<;975;B371=37H0545:;9=;0B092 5'!####(679-71=B05=3797-;92050G0480H87B4=3 =37 ?H7@45=909 012 =37 @?4201-7 G08?7 05 697G0871= ;1=3720=7;:69784<4109C1;=4:4-0=4;1
' 15;:09 05 =37 5?H<4554;1 ;: 8709172 -;?1578 :;9 =37 06678801= =30= =37 8709172 9H4=90=;9 45 1;= >?5=4:472 41 @901=41@ H717:4= ;: =37 69;G454;15 ;: -= #' <;975; =; 01 0-F?454=4;1 :;9 B34-3 69784<4109C 1;=4:4-0=4;1 B05 455?72 ;1 #*##'# =37 :4108 27-8090=4;1 B05 455?72 ;1 #+##'' 012 =37 0B092
- 20 -
B05 605572 ;1 +#*#'' 45 -;1-79172 =37 50<7 45 06670841@ 1 =345 97@092 B7 97:79 =; 6090@90635 ;+*!'012!;:=37>?2@<71=;:=37?697<7;?9= 41=37-057;: 5?690;1B34-3978401-7 B05680-72. (
"
F
""
"
"
- N
- 5
" 0 :>'; #,, ?11O ,
" A
! "!"
"
"" $1' &
""
"" "
'
8 #"
" . &
! - ! "
A
"
"
- N
- 5
"0:>';#,,?11O"
"
< "
" . &
"
"!!" $1' &
"
". "" "
"
- 21 -
" ! !"
$1' & - ! "
A
!"
! " ! $1'&
" ! " .&
! "
- 9
"
>?$&
"" J & > %
"<
"
" N - J & >
"
"
M# :'; & &
&
"
8 #" $1'& O
! !,99 0N*
,990:$11';?#,,?2(O ! ")
9! .
., N* -# $1(#,,F 4 C.
21'2ONH )* $1( #,, F 4 C. 21'ON*
- 22 -
&! ,
4
$12 #,, F 4 C. >'>O
09 . , N) "" #* $11? #,, F 4 09 ?$
$11?%12 # 04D ??>O
?1F ! " " !"
! ,
*
- ,< N* - ,< ," &" $>%?> $1
$%%$12 :#,;O M J ) 9
K . ,
! , -
! "" 6
! # 0 9
@
" #" A "
"
"
. ,
" ! " . & >?2 ! ""
"
"
- " "
"
"
" " -
- 23 -
M
!"
:;"
7 ?D "
#
K*
N#
K* :$1>;#,,2$ $12 #,, F 4 #, $(O
,
"
:#,,?%; 6? -
"
! ! " #"
A "
$'
9 N048
4 .& $1 #,, F 4 C.
2(
:$1;,,(?O . ,
! "
" " 6 7 ! "
"
! # $' $( 4 & & (>
"
9
! ""
" . &
>?2 "
"
#
$':$; $( 4 &
& (>"" ! 2 - " #" A "
9
! "
" ! ! ! " #" A "
.,
"! "
"
"
! "" ! - 24 -
- " #" A "
"" ! . ,
"
" " ! !" ! " "
"<
"
" :;
,
"
"
D
! A
# *
NA
# * :$112;(#,, ?O ,
9
,
# *
N# *
:$11; #,, $O
! "
"
D
""! "& "
"
"
" ! "
.,
A"
#
" 8 *
NA" #
" 8 * $11( #,, F 4 C. >( :$1; 0,0 :,"; '?O $(%'% $11(, "" ! &
"!! 0
8 , - 4 & 0!"
- 25 -
0
" & $1' :
%%$1; &
! "!"
" . &
>?2 !
+
$1'& 7 :="; 970241@;:>?2@<71=;:=37?697<7;?9=41=37-057 ;:
5?690 2;75 1;= 97G708 =30= 7G71 B3797 =37 0-F?454=4;1(0B092 =0A71680-7(605572H7:;97 #'#'#'+ 5?-3 0-F?454=4;1(0B092 53088 085; H7 @;G79172 HC -= #' 30= 0609= ;1 97:7971-7 =; 1;=4:4-0=4;1 20=72 *'#'" 455?72 HC 4145=9C ;: ;02 90156;9= 012 4@3B0C5 ;: B34-3 6090@9063;+454197567-=;:20=7;:27=79<410=4;1 ;: <09A7= G08?7 ;: 8012 97025 05 ?1279 -87098C -;1=7<680=7 G427 -80?57 +444- B3797 01 0-F?454=4;1(0B092 012 -;<671505=4;1 305 H771 605572(6042 H7:;97 ''#'+ =37 -= #'451;=06684-0H87(97;67172. 2J
<
"
" :;&
" ! <
" " ! - 26 -
" ! .& >?2
'$$1D"
! "
11$1? " "
11$1? :; # $2 08,-4&00 &
"
<
" "" ! ! #
: # '& .& ; #
(> &
-
# 2>:$; 08,-4&00 & &
"
"
<
""
#
' &
" . & >?2 !" :;)
"
"
8 # - #"
08,-4&00& $1'""!"!"
.& >?2
11$1? &
"" "
- 27 -
:; &"" 4
&
! # 'A . &
""'$$1 ! ! ! 9
" "
'$$1
" ! !"
8
#" 08,-4&00& $1' :!;
"
# 'A
" ! ! 11$1?! "" &
! ! ,&4&
"!"!" ! 8 #" 11$1?E :;
"
" : & # 'A ! ,&4&
! ,&4&
"
9
" ; ! '$$1
" ! ! "
"#"
!%
'+ 37-057;:=3706678801=05416090@9063;'';:=37 066708 B34-3 97025 05 ?1279 B488 085; =39;B 84@3= ;1 =37 :0-= =30= =37 -;<67150=4;1 305 H771 245H?9572 =;
9756;1271=5;'01241=37C709#''4=578:. - 28 -
- ,
&
""
# 'A :; . &
<
"
"
'& :; . &
5"" "
"
"
! .4&L#0?+$1%$
$1($1 &
?? " # 2+?& 5"" !"
0 C $
- ,
&
" 0?1111+%
"
! 0 C$ ; 4= :;88;B5 =37 0-F?454=4;1(0B092 30G41@ H7-;<7 :4108 05 679 - H7:;97 ''#'+ =37 0B092 ;:
=37 8709172 9H4=90=;9 =; =37 7I=71= ;: -08-?80=41@ =37 -;<67150=4;1 05 679 =37 69;G454;1 ;:
-= #' 45 085; ?1=710H87 012 45 840H87 =; H7 57= 05427 41 =37 :0-=5 = 45 ;927972 0--;9241@8C
- 29 -
'!
1G47B;:;?90H;G7245-?554;1B76055=37:;88;B41@. 4 3706670845088;B72 44 37 >?2@<71= 012 ;9279 20=72 *#!#+ 605572 41 ;*(# HC =37 224=4;108 45=94-= 012 7554;15 ?2@7 0A53410 )011020 01@08?9? 012 9H4=908 B092 H70941@;,'(#' # 20=72 "'# 605572 HC 9756;1271= ;4557=05427
71241@ 2;75 1;= 5?9G4G7 :;9 -;1542790=4;1 012=3750<745085;2456;572;:0--;9241@8C
12 '%&( ! 12 ' ( ! 45=;.'8;.