Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 29962 (PNJ)
SUKHVEER v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
CWP/7022/2019 · 2025-01-13
Vinod S Bhardwaj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 29962 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 29962 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"#$$% &'(
)
&$
*"+,*
$ &(&$
$ ----
Sr. Panel Counsel for respondents No.!" #### (&$
. $/ ,0
$%% "&!""'!()* +,-. / 0 0 . 1 $
2 . $/345"'!""'!"
0) 6
7- (' 89:
;.5 00 0 ;"3&!3!"3
)
-3)45-3 +<<3==>"!+==>"&
"?!!"'!"@%/. % A$
. )1- . B /0 6 0 07 A 0 . /0 / 0 !>'&"'!& % ;!" 6 0 07 % 0 / 0 % RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
. B . / ./0. C;D% . 8<;>'">'""'!" %
&"& &", . &= <$
% 00A . /01 . /.1 . 1 %
&", <$. /+0 0/ /. / / 5E % '!'?"'!& A 0 . . 0 / 0 . 0 1 30 0 A B % 0%09. . . % 0 .A .%/% 0 B 0. .. 0*. / 0 A /0 / $0 '=!!"'!& 0%
A .%/ $F;"G,! "'!= 1%0""'G"'!(. .. 0'=!!"'!&.A . 0 % . !"
#$ % . RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
# 0 / % &')=- 1%0 / 0 . / $0 .% 0
5 0 % / 0 . . $@$;?(="'!?5 %
0. / $0 0%
"&!""'!( . 0 % 9 . /
2 $0 0 % / 0 0 / 0 / . % 6 0 07 / B 0 / 3 0
/% 0/%% % . 0./ 0$8A 0 / 5 < 4 ) -
* +
!" # $ #% & % $'
()#% # "$ &*$ $+ ' +
$ $ # ## "$', RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
% $ $ +"+ #- #
& ' '"'
& # "$. $ $ / $'
" $ # $ 0+ 0' + 1 %2 ##' 3 . #
4
' ,$'')..( +
% # # !" "$ +
# # #. 5 1!2 6" '
' , $ "'
$ '' (.(.( $
+ ,$% ' ''(.7.($8
# $ +
"
' + # ' &% -&
. 5
&#'&%#,5#'&%##'3 . $
% ' '
' &# % *&
'$# $$ $$
+ $ #
# ' #'
% # #
"$#,...9.((.("' ' .(:3 ::;<4 =:>>:(4?
'' 9.((.( &% 5 $+ , $ ' # '
4() 1"2
+
#&% #
#',
$$
#$
'$'' #
$ . ) '')..( + '+ ;
$
0' + 1 %2' $?'9>;"' *'+#''(.7.(&'
$#"'&% $$' ' $#
$#'+ $ $# # ' $$ '+
% , $8'. $ $8
+ ' &
" #$'$ ' '
# & $ #
$$#
'+#$
,& #',
%$$
'$.> RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
& # ',$& '$% $ #
$ "@. % ,
+ $ #
:< # ' $'
% ,
+ A $
,$$&$$'
'$& + ' $''. "+&++ "'&% ' # # "$ '
'' ?.3.(9>! B@ ,$, *$'&+'"' # '#& ' '5#"' ' . >>: : B4C;::3:(9:47?(94(7''(.).(9 % '
' $ # # "$, ''&%##'3."' ' '' 9.((.(. D <D $#
$ ' -& $
# & 45#'$
% , $ $:
"+'' , 8 ' $ $ # + %#
#,
+ $ #
:< # ' A $ 8 # $ &'D #' & '$&$ #
.) ( + '+ #: ? / 9 >; ,$ &$#+ ##& < $, + %' + $ '
. > , ' '$
'; 437/)D #% '"
$#
$ + $ '# :
$ "$ ,
' & #' , ++ % . # ,&*$
#$ # / $' $ &' # ,$
'' .< $$##'&% :?>; $'; 41>>>21A2 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
0 +'
'' (..(
'' +,#$ +$ #
$&
' ' $ +
$+ % $ #
'+
$8'&%5'+& '& $8' , " ' '
. &% $$' 12 : +
%&$' '&
#;<. $$
# $" '' ' $'$ *$'&+'"'# . , "
$ ! .E
2 . /01 %/.1 / /% 1 .% 0+ 1 . . &= <$ 00 9 .% . 0 0/ ./0% 0 0 . 0 . +0 0 .
% % % % 0 0 % . *0/ $0
9 /0 0 . /
%$ . / ./ 97/
0$ E%0
' / / $0 < .0 % % / 0 0 0% RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
%/ 9/0 0 0 00 % . ."" A0. % . / 9/0 . 1%0
' . / 97/
0$ 0 ( )* $
$$
%
+, -. # $ <. / 97/
0$ /+ 0 0 % 0 0 . / 0 % 0 0% 0 1%0B B 3 0 +0 %. 0% . 1 1%%/ 0% / A 1%0 / 97/$ % 0 .1%0
' / * + (). $ "
'#'
% (..9 , ' &
,$ # $ + ' '+. <" '% &#+ $'&,#&
'$ #
$,$ $
' $8
&%
$ "' ' ''(..9'
,
'+#. ''
$ #$ '' .(.9 , 8 ' '" RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
0 # +" &% $ ##. >
$$
% #'
' $ " & $$
''"
$$''
& $$
.,
& # 9?3'7 '" #1+#, "2,+.> ''&
+$'''$
%$ #
$,$, + '+#F% #'' $ ,$, '+ ' # #
% ' $8
,
$
' .>
''$ 'GH$8 . H 5
$,$8'&'&
"' ,
% &
+' +" '
% '+ $'+. (. ' 6 $ #$'8 '", 8 $
' &+ $$
, $
%*'. . ,
'&% 4I'+$
" +1 2.; 9?3/),$ $$
5 $' &
,J4
9. '& & " $ $ $ ' $' # $ &
%'#
% '*'+$' $#&&
#$
'&&' &*$" $ ' $'
" $. ?.
#
E # , ' # E " % $$
"
# .#
% $'$' : $%5 $, ' $$
$'' #+ "$ #
%.+ , '# RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
# $ $
# ' + # $% "$ & + & ' , &
% ' 5 $ , & &
# , &*$"% "+ ' + ' $$. 3. % '$6 &
' '' + ,
'"
"# + $
"$
% #' "$.< , ,$ " '#$ &
% & $' ' &%
$$ ' $' + :
': "$ ' , & 5 $' ' $' " $. ). " $' " '$ ' ' 5
' $$
# &
.>", ''$,## $$
J ).(.> #+"#
% &%$'' $"$$8
'$%$ # $, & + "$#& '
'&
# 8 ' #. ).. + ' # "$ $$
$'' +"+
# #
% #% 6 $ $
$ $#$ $%,
+"+$ #. ).. #
%
6 $' +" # ' : $:
$& #
%#6+'$. ).9. > $
#
"
"#$ #
$, $"$ $8 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
' '% & $ '' & +
$:" $ # ' $ $
$# 6,
'+ #
% %
,+ $ $#%&''J ).9.(.>$ "
,$$"$' & $ ''$+
+%++ %$,$'$
',
'" ' ' $#& 8#
% #% '$ + $ $ #&%$'+
. ).9.. $"$& $ ''$,$
"
#
% #% $$
$'' # "$#
%. ).9.. > $8
'
'% & $ '' $
"
"+ #
' $ : $$
+ ' ' $ $ $8
& &
'&&+" #
% #% $'
" $ "
& $' ' #% 6 '$ $$#
%. ).?. > $ , #
% #' '$ % $$
'' $ #
$ #
% + $' $' ' $ & $#
'$''. ).3.
> $ , $ &
% '$
' $ $ " $ # + '+ '$% $ #
$ "
#
% $ ' $ $#$$'$ #% $''&*$'$$$. RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
).7.>$'
& $, $ #
'+ $ $
# &% ,
# +$$ ' #
% #% ' $$
+ $'' #+
"$# +,## $ #
$, '+#%& . ).).> $ #
$ , '+ & 6, $'' #
+ #
#% " '" #$ ' + % ,
' 6 '$ $' + $ #. )..>$#
%$ #' "$
'+ ' #
8 % ,
' & $ % & + ' #: #"
'#
+ ' &#+
# " $ #. ).(. < ' #+
#:" $ #&$$
"+.D
%$ #,$, 8 '& $$
%#'&'$
'.> # 6' &
" $# 6,
'+ #
% # $ & $' ' &*$" # ,
'' +8.," $$$$&6& &#+
#$,$,
"6' . ).((. '+
% " ++
6,
'+$#& && #. 1#
'2.E KKK KKK KKK RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
). $#+' $ # $F"
$' *'+#$8
F 8 %
$:" $ #F $$ $ " $ F$$#$ '"'
%+F $' $''F $' ' $ $$
: # ' # $ $
$ ,$
' *'$
" '$'*'++&
%' ' #+
& ' '. 9/ A E% 97/
0$ 0
' % %H 0 0 / 1% 0/. 0// /1 <. % . 0 00 % 0 / %/. / * . /0 ./1 % % A / F% .0 % . 3. B 0 A 0%% 00 // 0 %. RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
# .
B/ 0 0 %
9/0 0 ./ 97/
0 $ 0
'
0 % +0 /% %% 0 % % &"& <$ 0 / / ./%. % . /0 0 + %0 09 /0 /10 / 0 % / 0 %% /% + 9 /0 0 / /0 . 0/
$ / . 08<;>'">'""'!" % &"&&", . &=<$
% 0 .%/
5E % . 0 0 0. /0/ A /0 0 / RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
% . . . 0 0 %
"&
"''G$0 0 0 % % 0 0 0A* !" # $#%& % $'
()#% # "$ &*$ $+ ' +
$ $ # ## "$', $ $ +"+ #H #
& ' '"'
& # "$.E
< 0 0 %B $0;!"8 0 0 % / * % . "&
"''G 0 %1%097/
0$ 0
' 0 /
.0 . / % / % 0 1%097/
0$ 0
1. $ 2
. )* ! # & +( %$ <1%0 % 0 ./ 97/
0$ . % 0 . .0 0 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
& . B //. .0 B % /0 0 /0/
; %0/ 1%0/
B . +
/ $ %%%"&
"''G 0 . / . % % 0 . / * 0 %% 0/ .% 0 %%
9% % % %0/ 0 % 0/ % % 0. 0 0. 0./ 0< . . 0 0/ % / 0 A 0 % % . B % 0%0
8 / /0 0/ . / % 0 1 /. 1 . 1 %
&",<$. /+A 0 / 0 % % RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
%/ < % % /
&"&<$0
&",<$
A $ % /0% /% % B 0 % % 0 /0 % / . B / .1%0
' $
/ % 0 0 +0 /% / 0 .
.% 0
.%
0
% +0 0 . 0% 00 0 / . / * 1/ 00 % // /
< 0 . B 3 % < / 0 / 0 B 0 0 0 / $0 0 0
/ 0 * 0 / 0 /% 0%+0 0 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
8 "&
"''G. . . / 0 0 9 *0 / +% 0 0 /0 0 0 . 4 0< 90 % % 0$88;<+=,'"'3(3"'!'+ <<'!'""'!" . 0../ 0/ /$")<<-)<<<-A %A* /.+ . $$ '+
%# &$' '0 % $
,;<'&'$''
,J KKK KKK KKK 1>>2 >$''''$
: "
"#': $ #
$12 $#
$12 "" $'+$.' >; % $
!" #
$ # & '$ # ' + #'$
5#:; ': :" $ #, +$'' , &$$
'+ '
. >>>2 $'',
&$' ' $ #J 2
$ "
"#:$: $$ ' , $ #'5 4 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
0 &2
$ :'#'' %$,$ $$ ' , $ % ' + % $ % ' ' " $" $ + +$%$. $2 $'' & '' '
$ %$: #
$:%#
+
' #$ #'&% ",+ %. '2
$"
"#:$ $$ ',$
"
"+#
'J 2 : &$"$'&%$ %$, '++$$"$. ; "''$''
&& '&"$ %<> & + ':$' "+ ' $ + " & #' <> $#
% L,. ; "'' $''
&'& ': &
% $8':'$ +' &% , '+ +$$8
. ; "'' $''
& '& ' $'+ ,' ,&%
: !" #. ; "'' $''
&'& ': & "
"':$"$':$$ ' , # $ #5 4 #' A>>>/K #
; $' (7.D
< / / /% 0 /B %/ $ .% %BA 0B3 %0* .
0 0/0 0H 0 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
%/% %B3 %</ % /% / / 0 ) - /
% %. '!'""'!". 0. % . 0 / %/ %
% 0 % / . / 97/
0$ 0
'
1%0( )*
$$
3 %
+, -. # / <0
"&!""'!()* +,-/ 5 < 4 ) -
0 0% /%* 0
B + /1 % 0 // + A / + 1%/. /B/ *0/* . 0
< %. "'!G. / $@ <5+!G0 0 / 1 * 9 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
1 /%.. B/ /%
A . 0
/(&$
0
#.%$
4
6+: ' JM:
&
JM:
RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.01.26 23:23 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document