- 1 - ! " #$ # % & !" # $$%& $ $ ' %" ' ! " # " %& "( ) "" ' " ** ' ( " * % '(((" ( +" % " % % (" ( ( , Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , - % ./0 1/2/345 67/0/83 "69/9/83 /0 :/56; <= 9.6 >69/9/8361 <6/3?4??1/676;<=9.6@A;?26398:B837/B9/8343;81;61 8: 063963B6 ;496; ' /3 8 ' 83 9.6 :/56 8: ** ;;/9/8345 ./6: 6918>85/943 4?/091496 63?45A1A43;/90B83:/1249/83@A;?263943;81;61;496; /3 158 ' 83 9.6 :/56 8: * ;;/9/8345 /9= /7/5 43; 600/830 A;?6 63?45A1A C.616/3 9.6 >69/9/8361 4BBA06; C40 B837/B96; :81 9.6 8::63B6 >A3/0.4<56 A3;61 6B9/83 8: 9.6 6?89/4<56 3091A26390B9#:810.819DB9E& .6143F08:9.6>419/60C8A5;<6B830/;616;.63B6:819. 40>619.6/1143F/3?0/39.61/458A19:81B83763/63B6 '()*+,-,.)+*-) .6 B82>54/3439 09496; 98 .476 4;743B6; 9.6 5843 8: 0 G989.64BBA06;83 :81C./B.9.6 4BBA06;4?166;9816>4=9.65843C/9./30/H2839.0499.6 14968:I>612839..64BBA06;6H6BA96;83;6243; >182/0081= 3896 83 >182/0/3? ./2 9.49 .6 - 3 - C8A5; 16>4= 9.6 428A39 C/9./3 0/H 2839.0 4583? C/9. /39616098C6761.6;/;38916>4=9.604/;428A3943; /396160940C655.616:816C.63.6/30/096;9.64BBA06; 9816>4=9.6428A394B.6JA6C40/00A6;<=9.64BBA06; 83 :81 4 0A2 8: 0 G .63 9.6 04/; B.6JA6 C40 >1606396; :81 63B40.2639 83 9.6 04/; ;496 /9 C40 169A136; 40 D:A3;0 /30A::/B/639E 56?45 389/B6C40/00A6;989.64BBA06;43;<18A?.9./0389/B6 4<8A9 9.6 ;/0.838A1 8: 9.6 B.6JA6 BB81;/3? 98 9.6 B82>54/3439 389/B60 C616 0639 9.18A?. 6?/09616; "809 BF38C56;?2639 A6 43; >66; "809 3 0>/96 8: 9.6 0617/B68:389/B69.64BBA06;;/;38916>4=9.6428A39 .616:816 4 B406 B426 98 <6 16?/09616; <= 9.6 B82>54/3439<6:8169.64?/09149643;08A?.9:814B9/83 98<6/3/9/496;4?4/3099.64BBA06; .61/458A1943;9.6>>6554968A19B83BA116395=.65; 9.49 9.6 4BBA06; C40 :8A3; ?A/59= 8: 9.6 8::63B6 A3;61 6B9/83 8:B9.616:8169.6>69/9/8361.40:/56; 9./0167/0/83>69/9/83 8 >1876 9.6 B406 8: 9.6 B82>54/3439 9.6 B82>54/3439 6H42/36; ./2065: 40 " 43; 4508 ?89 6H42/36; " - 4 - 83 ./0 <6.45: 43;?89 241F6; ;8BA26390 40 H./</90 "98"39.689.61.43;9.6>69/9/8361 4BBA06; 6H42/36;./2065:4043;.4038956;43=67/;63B6 .6 1/45 8A19 4:961 4>>16B/49/3? 9.6 8145 43; ;8BA263941=67/;63B68316B81;B837/B96;9.6>69/9/8361 :81 9.6 8::63B6 09496; 6/3? 4??1/676; <= 9.6 0426 9.6 >69/9/8361 >16:6116; 43 4>>645 <6:816 9.6 >>655496 8A19 43; 9.6 >>655496 8A19 B83:/126; 9.6 @A;?2639 8: B837/B9/83 163;616; <= 9.6 1/45 8A19 6/3?4??1/676;<=9.604269.6>69/9/8361.40>16:6116; 9./0167/0/83>69/9/83066F/3?9806940/;69.6B83BA11639 :/3;/3?0 ' 641; 1/ .43;14 .6F414 $ 564136; B8A3065 :81 9.6 >69/9/8361 43; 1/ " 49./0.4 564136; B8A3065 :81 9.6 160>83;639 9 /0 9.6 0A<2/00/83 8: 9.6 564136; B8A3065 :81 9.6 >69/9/83619.499.6;6:63B68:9.64BBA06;<6:8169.61/45 8A19 C409.49 9.616 C40 38 56?455=63:81B64<56;6<9 81 5/4</5/9=839.604/;B.6JA63:4B9H"36243; "182/0081= 896 C40 ?/763 98 9.6 B82>54/3439 83 9.6 >1696H9 9.49 9.6 B82>54/3439 C8A5; ?69 9.6 5843 - 5 - 043B9/836;/3:478A18:9.64BBA06;8C6761.6;/;389 ?699.65843043B9/836; 9/0:A19.610A<2/996;9.49.6.4;38916B6/76;43=389/B6 40 /0 243;4981/5= 16JA/16; 98 <6 06176; 98 ./2 A3;61 6B9/83 #<&8:9.6B9 ) 9 /0 :A19.61 0A<2/996; 9.49 6763 9.8A?. 9.616 C40 38 914304B9/83 <69C663 ./2065: 43; 9.6 B82>54/3439 9.6 8A190 <658C .476 B822/996; 43 61181 /3 411/7/3? 49 4 B83B5A0/839.499.64BBA06;/05/4<5698>4=9.6428A3940 09496; /3 9.6 B.6JA6 4F/3? 0AB. 0A<2/00/830 9.6 564136; B8A3065 :81 9.6 >69/9/8361 >14=0 98 4558C 9.6 >69/9/83 "61 B83914 9.6 564136; B8A3065 :81 9.6 160>83;639 76.626395= @A09/:/6; 9.6 @A;?2639 8: 9.6 8A190 <658C 43;.6:A19.610A<2/996;9.499.6/00A43B68:9.6B.6JA6 43; 0/?349A16 :8A3; 83 9.6 B.6JA6 .40 389 <663 ;/0>A96;3B69.6/00A43B68:9.6B.6JA643;0/?349A16 416 4;2/996; 9.6 >160A2>9/83 C8A5; >1896B9 9.6 B82>54/3439 :182 >187/3? ./0 :/343B/45 B4>4B/9= 43; 4508 5/4</5/9= 9 /0 9.6 4BBA06; C.8 .40 98 16<A9 9.6 >160A2>9/83 <= 564;/3? B8?639 67/;63B6 0 0AB. 9.6 - 6 - 4BBA06;:4/56;98>1876./0B4069816<A99.6>160A2>9/83 9.6 1/45 8A19 43; 9.6 >>655496 8A19 1/?.95= 16B81;6; 9.6 B837/B9/83 C./B. /0 >18>61 43; 16567439 9.616:816 /3961:6163B6 C/9. 9.6 04/; :/3;/3?0 C8A5; 389 41/06 4F/3? 0AB. 0A<2/00/830 9.6 564136; B8A3065 :81 9.6 160>83;639>14=098;/02/009.6>69/9/83 47/3? .641; 9.6 564136; B8A3065 :81 9.6 160>6B9/76 >419/6043;4508>61A06;9.6:/3;/3?08:9.68A190<658C /9 /0 16567439 98 16:61 9.6 56?45 16JA/1626390 8: 6B9/83 8:B9.604/;>187/0/83164;040A3;61, - 7 - ! " # $ %& ' ( %& ! " ( %& - 8 - ) * + "+ 3B82>5/43B68: 6B9/83 8:B943;/34B406/: 9.6 4BBA06; 4;2/996; 9.6 0/?349A16 43; /00A43B6 8: 9.6 B.6JA6 9.6 >160A2>9/83 C8A5; 41/06 /3 :478A1 8: 9.6 B82>54/3439 .616:816 49 9.6 /3/9/45 094?6 9.6 B82>54/3439366;389>1876./0B4068C676183B69.6 4BBA06;.4016<A996;9.6>160A2>9/839.6<A1;63C8A5; <60./:96;989.6B82>54/343998>1876./0B406 3 9.6 >160639 B406 9.6 4BBA06; .40 <663 6H42/36; ./2065: 40 3 ./0 67/;63B6.6 .40;6>806; 9.49 9.616 C40 38 914304B9/83 <69C663 ./2065: 43; 9.6 B82>54/3439 49 43= >8/39 8: 9/26 6 :A19.61 ;6>806; 9.49 9.6 B82>54/3439 .4; 8<94/36; 4 <543F B.6JA6 43; >183896 83 9.6 >1696H9 9.49 .6 C8A5; ?69 9.6 5843 043B9/836; 98 9.6 4BBA06; 8C6761 .6 .40 389 94F63 43= 4B9/83 4?4/309 9.6 B82>54/3439 :81 .47/3? 2/0A06; 9.6B.6JA643;83;6243;>1838963896 - 9 - .64BBA06;6HB6>914/0/3?9.6:4506;6:63B6.40:4/56;98 >18;AB643=;8BA26390980.8C9.499.6B82>54/3439.4; >182/06; ./2 9.49 .6 C8A5; 41143?6 9.6 5843 :81 ./0 36B600/9/60 3 9.6 89.61 .43; .6 4;2/996; 9.6 6H6BA9/838:83;6243;>182/0081=3896B.6JA669B .683E<56 A>16268A19/39.6B4068: !" ! # .65; 9.49 2616 ;63/45 8: 9.6 914304B9/83 /0 389 0A::/B/639 98 16<A9 9.6 >160A2>9/83 A35600/9/0:8558C6;<=9.6B8?63967/;63B6 ' 3164;/3?8:9.6639/16B40643;45089.667/;63B68:9.6 4BBA06;428:9.6B830/;616;8>/3/839.49.6.40389 16<A996;9.6>160A2>9/83?A4143966;A3;61 6B9/83 ) 8:B9.616:8169.6:/3;/3?08:9.68A190<658C/3 163;61/3? 9.6 B837/B9/83 416 16567439 43; >18>61 8C6761 /308:41 40 9.6 063963B6 8: 9.6 1/45 8A19 /0 B83B6136;9.61/458A19389835=/2>806;4:/3698<6 >4/; <A9 4508 ;/16B96; 9.6 4BBA06; 98 A3;61?8 0/2>56 /2>1/0832639 :81 0/H 2839.0 .6 04/; >819/83 8: 9.6 063963B6 /0 B83B6136; C.63 9.616 /0 4 ;6:4A59 >A3/0.2639 /0 /2>806; 98 9.6 4BBA06; /: .6 :4/50 98 1 (2019) 4 SCC 197 - 10 - ;6>80/9 9.6 :/36 428A39 40 4C41;6; 4;;/9/83455= 40F/3? ./2 98 A3;61?8 0/2>56 /2>1/0832639 :81 0/H 2839.0 C8A5; <6 988 .410. 43; A31640834<56 .616:816 9.6 063963B68:0/H2839.0366;098<606940/;6 39.65/?.98:9.68<061749/83024;64<876>18B66;98 >4009.6:8558C/3?, .6 1/2/345 67/0/83 "69/9/83 /0 4558C6;G/3G >419 .6 @A;?2639 8: B837/B9/83 43; 81;61 83 063963B6 ;496; ' >4006; /3 8 ' <=9.6**;;/9/8345./6: 6918>85/943 4?/091496 49 63?45A1A /0 28;/:/6; .6 @A;?2639 43; 81;61 ;496; >4006; /3 1/2/345 >>645 8 ' <= 9.6 * ;;/9/8345 /9= /7/5 43; 600/830 A;?663?45A1A/9=/0450828;/:/6;835=/3 160>6B98:063963B6 .6 >69/9/8361 4BBA06; /0 B837/B96; :81 9.6 8::63B6A3;61 6B9/83 8:B943;.6/0 - 11 - 063963B6; 98 >4= :/36 8: 0' G #A>660 63 54F.0 0/H9= 836 9.8A043; 836 .A3;16;43;:/:9=835=&3;6:4A598:>4=2639 8::/36.60.455A3;61?80/2>56/2>1/0832639 :810/H2839.0 A9 8: :/36 428A39 8: 0' G 4 0A2 8: 0 G 98 <6 >4/; 98 9.6 B82>54/3439 <= C4= 8: B82>63049/83 A3;61 6B9/83 8: 1" 43; 9.6 <4543B6 428A390.455<6>4/;989.6 9496HB.6JA61 ' .6 6?/091= /0 ;/16B96; 98 063; 9.6 16B81;0 :819.C/9. 98 9.6 1/45 8A19 :81 36B60041= B82>5/43B6 /01 2 3 $ /098, 58,