- 1 - ! "# $ # % & !" # $ % & & && !! '!!!" # $ % & (!" "( !" !"!' !"' & !! !" ) !!) & $ % * & Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ! & & &+ + , % " -./ 0.1.234 56./.72 58.8.72 ./ 9.45: ;< 8-5 =58.8.7250 ;5.2>3>>0.565:;<8-5?@:>152879A726.A8.7232:70:50 79 /52852A5 :385: !! !" .2 7 ) !!) 72 8-59.45798-5&$7@08%32>3470532: .8/A729.0138.72?@:>152832:70:50:385:!"!' !"'.2 047"( !" 728-59.45798-5::.8.7234./80.A8 32:5//.72/@:>532>34705B-505.28-57@08/ ;547B-365A72A@005284<-54:8-388-5=58.8.7250./>@.48< 79 8-5 79952A5/ =@2./-3;45@2:50 5A8.72/ ( 32: !$%798-52:.3252347:5$970/-708CD% -5032E/798-5=308.5/B7@4:;5A72/.:505:-52A59708- 3/=508-5.0032E.2>/.28-50.347@08970A72652.52A5 '()*+,-,.)+*-)+ 8 ./ 8-5 A3/5 79 8-5 =07/5A@8.72 8-38 72 "!! !!) 307@2:" !=18-53AA@/5:;5.2>8-5:0.650798-5;@/ ;530.2> 05>./8038.72 7"( !( -3/ :0.652 8-5 /315 72 8-5 13.2 073: 2530 .8< @/ 87= /.8@385: 38 - 3 - 8385 32E .2 3 03/- 32: 25>4.>528 132250 32: :3/-5: 8-5 =5:5/80.32/ 23154< " 36.8-3 32: .E3/ B-7 B505B3.8.2>9708-5;@/-50539850-5:3/-5:3>3.2/83 =30E5: 1;3//3:70 30 ;530.2> 05>./8038.72 7"( ( (32:34/7:3/-5:32545A80.A=74532:/87==5:3/3 05/@4879B-.A-36.8-3/@AA@1;5:878-5.2?@0.5/388-5 /=78 32: .E3/ 5F=.05: .2 8-5 -7/=.834 -7B5650 " /@/83.25:/.1=45.2?@0.5/ 28-5;3/./798-5A71=43.2879"8-5?@0./:.A8.7234 =74.A5 -365 05>./8505: 3 A3/5 9850 A72:@A8.2> 8-5 .265/8.>38.72/@;1.885:8-5A-30>5/-558 7 =0765 8-5 A3/5 79 8-5 =07/5A@8.72 8-5 =07/5A@8.72 5F31.25:.23448-.08552B.825//5/23154</"87" 32:>78130E5: !:7A@1528/3/=50 F-.;.8/"87 ! -5 0.34 7@08 054.5: 72 8-5 56.:52A5 79 ) B-7 ./ 8-57B250798-5;@/32:(G72:@A870798-5;@/ 32: 34/7 8-5 56.:52A5 79 " 05A70:5: 8-5 A726.A8.72 5.2>3>>0.565:;<8-5/315323==534B3/=0595005:;< 8-5=58.8.7250-505.2-5==5443857@08:./1.//5:8-5 3==53432:A729.015:8-5?@:>1528798-50.347@08 - 4 - ' 530: 0. 55632 453025: A7@2/54 970 8-5 =58.8.7250 32: 0. 3>5/-B303==3 453025: .>- 7@08 765021528453:509708-505/=72:528G8385 8./8-5/@;1.//.7279453025:A7@2/549708-5=58.8.7250 8-38 8-5 ?@:>1528 79 A726.A8.72 32: 70:50 79 /52852A5 =3//5: ;< 8-5 0.34 7@08 32: .8/ A729.0138.72 70:50 =3//5:;<8-5==5443857@0830505H@.05:87;5/583/.:5 3/ 8-5 A72A@00528 9.2:.2>/ 305 =50650/5 .445>34 32: 34/7 3>3.2/88-556.:52A57205A70: ) 8./9@08-50/@;1.885:8-387@879)B.825 "87 -3652300385:8-5.2A.:528-7B5650 32: 305 .28505/85: B.825//5/ -7@>- 8-5< -365 .:528.9.5: 8-5 =58.8.72503/8-5:0.650798-5;@/8-593A80513.2/8-38 8-5 A453250 79 8-5 ;@/ B3/ :0.6.2> 8-5 ;@/ 32: A3@/5: :313>5 32: .2?@0.5/ 87 8-5 05/=5A8.65 =308.5/ 32: 65-.A45/ -52 8-5 /3.: 93A8 B3/ /@>>5/85: 87 / 32: 8-5<:.:278A7280765088-5/315 ( 8 ./ 9@08-50 /@;1.885: 8-38 2725 79 8-5 B.825//5/ -365 /@==7085:8-5A3/5798-5=07/5A@8.728-388-5=58.8.7250 B3/8-5:0.650798-565-.A45-5059705.28-53;/52A5 79.:528.8<798-5:0.650798-5;@/8-59.2:.2>/05A70:5: - 5 - ;<8-57@08/;547B8-388-5=58.8.7250B3/8-5:0.65079 8-5/3.:65-.A45./3>3.2/8878-556.:52A57205A70:32: 8-5059705 8-5 A726.A8.72 A32278 ;5 /@/83.25: 3E.2> /@A-/@;1.//.72/453025:A7@2/549708-5=58.8.7250/55E/ 873447B8-5056./.72=58.8.72 "! 453025: .>- 7@08 765021528 453:50 970 8-5 05/=72:528 G 8385 65-515284< ?@/8.9.5: 8-5 A72A@005289.2:.2>/32:/@;1.885:8-388-59.2:.2>/798-5 7@08/ ;547B 305 3==07=0.385 32: -5 /@;1.885: 8-38 " ;5.2> 8-5 .2?@05: -3/ /@==7085: 8-5 A3/5 79 8-5 =07/5A@8.72 32: .:528.9.5: 8-5 3AA@/5: B-7 B3/ :0.6.2> 8-5 /3.: 65-.A45 3/ 72 8-5 :385 79 8-5 3AA.:528 -5 13-3I30B7@4:.2:.A3858-388-5=58.8.7250-3/A3@/5:278 724< :313>5 87 8-5 =@;4.A =07=508< 3/ B544 3/ A30 ;@8 34/7 E.445: 8B7 =50/72/ -5059705 8-5 A726.A8.72 052:505: ;< 8-5 0.34 7@08 -3/ 87 ;5 A729.015: 32: .285095052A5 B.8- 8-5 9.2:.2>/ 79 8-5 7@08/ ;547B 13< 278 ;5 =07=50 3E.2> /@A- /@;1.//.72/ 453025: .>- 7@08 765021528 453:50 =03</ 87 :./1.// 8-5 056./.72 =58.8.72 - 6 - "" 36.2>-530:8-50.634A728528.72/@0>5:;<8-5453025: A7@2/54/ 970 8-5 05/=5A8.65 =308.5/ 32: 34/7=50@/5: 8-5 9.2:.2>/ 79 8-5 7@08/ ;547B .8 3==530/ 8-38 72 "!! !!)"B3//832:.2>25308-5838532E.8< @/ 87= 87 >7 87 -./ 90.52:D/ -7@/5 -52 -5 B3/ B3.8.2> 970 8-5 ;@/ 8-5 ;@/ ;530.2> 05>./8038.72 7 "( !( A315 .2 3 03/- 32: 25>4.>528 132250 32: :3/-5: 8-5 =50/72/ B-7 B505 B3.8.2> 970 8-5 ;@/ 3472> B.8- -.1 32: A3@/5: .2?@0.5/ 32: 8-50539850 .8 A3@/5: :313>5878-5A3032:34/732545A80.A=745-50539850 .8 /87==5: 8-505 -5 2315 79 8-5 :0.650 79 8-5 ;@/ E27B2 87 -.1 39850-36.2> -530: 8-52315 ;< 8-5 8-.0: =308< 7B5650-5-3/278/5528-5:0.650=50/72344< " ./ 8-5 /./850 79 8-5 :5A53/5: 36.8-3 B-7 :.5: .2 8-5/3.:3AA.:528-5:.:278/3<8-38/-5-3:/5528-5 :0.650 79 8-5 ;@/ 3/ 72 8-5 :385 79 3AA.:528 7B5650 /-5 :5=7/5: 8-38 8-5 =50/72 B-7 B3/ /832:.2> .2 8-5 7@08 B3/ :0.6.2> 8-5 /3.: ;@/ 3/ 72 8-5 :385 79 8-5 3AA.:528@A-.:528.8<A32278;5/@/83.25:-5059705 -5056.:52A5.205/=5A879.:528.8<798-5:0.650A32278;5 - 7 - 3AA5=85:-57@08/;547B-36593.45:873==05A.385.2 8-./132250 " ;5.2> 8-5 7B250 79 8-5 1;3//3:70 30 ;530.2> 05>./8038.727"(( (-3/:5=7/5:8-388-5=50/72 B-7B3//832:.2>.28-57@08 344B3/:0.6.2>8-5/3.: 65-.A453/728-5:385798-53AA.:528 7B5650-5:.: 278/558-53AA.:528=50/72344<32:34/7-5B3/2788-505 388-5/=78@A-;5.2>8-593A8.:528.9<.2>8-53AA@/5: 9708-59.0/88.15.28-57@08A32278;53AA5=85:8-38-5 B3/8-5:0.650798-5/3.:65-.A45 " B3/B70E.2>3/32>528798-5;@/ 5:5=7/5:.2 -./56.:52A58-38-5:.:278/55B-7B3/:0.6.2>8-5;@/ 3/728-5:385798-53AA.:528 " .1.4304< -3/ 34/7 278 /@==7085: 8-5 A3/5 79 8-5 =07/5A@8.72 "' ' B3/ B70E.2> 3/ 3 52.70 7870 5-.A45 2/=5A870 5/8385:87-365.2/=5A85:8-565-.A4532:/@;1.885:-./ 05=7083/=50 F !AA70:.2>87-.18-565-.A45B3/ .2>77:A72:.8.7232:.8-3:2715A-32.A34:595A8/ " )B3/8-57B250798-5;@/ 5-3/:5=7/5:8-38-5 B3/ 278 3B305 3;7@8 8-5 3AA.:528 &@08-50 -5 /8385/ - 8 - 8-388-53AA@/5:B3/2783==7.285:3/:0.65079-./;@/ -5265/8.>38.2>99.A50-3/278A7445A85:32<:7A@1528/ 87/-7B8-388-53AA@/5:B3/B70E.2>3/3:0.650798-5 ;@/ -5 =07/5A@8.72 805385: -.1 3/ 3 -7/8.45 B.825// 32: /@>>5/85: 87 -.1 8-38 3/ =50 F 8-5 3AA@/5: B3/:0.6.2>8-5/3.:65-.A453/728-5:385798-53445>5: .2A.:528 7B5650-5:52.5:8-5/3.:/@>>5/8.7232:-5 9@08-50 /8385: 8-38 .8 B3/ 278 B0.8852 ;< -.1 32: 8-5 A728528/79 F B505278053:765087-.1 ") 2A3059@4053:.2>798-556.:52A5793448-5/5B.825//5/ .8 3==530/ 9071 8-5 05A70: 8-38 " ;5.2> 8-5 .2?@05: B3/ 278 3B305 3;7@8 8-5 :0.650 70 -5 -3/ 278 /552 8-5 3AA@/5: 38 8-5 /=78 B3/ 34/7 /832:.2> 72 8-5 /3159778=38-B3.8.2>9708-5;@/32:/-5-3:47/8-50 <7@2>50/./850.28-5/3.:3AA.:528-7B5650/-5:.:278 278.A5 8-5 3AA@/5: 38 8-5 /=78 -7@>- 8-5< 305 8-5 5<5B.825//5/ 87 8-5 .2A.:528 344 8-5 B.825//5/ -365 278 /552 8-5 3AA@/5: 38 8-5 /=78 -7B5650 8-5< -365 /552 8-53AA@/5:.28-57@08 3449708-59.0/88.15 "( );5.2>8-57B250798-5;@/-3/278/8385:32<8-.2> 3;7@8 8-5 3AA@/5: 32: 8-5 265/8.>38.2> 99.A50 -3/ 278 - 9 - A7445A85: 32< :7A@1528/ 87 /-7B 8-38 8-5 3AA@/5: B3/ B70E.2> 3/ :0.650 79 8-5 ;@/ @A- ;5.2> 8-5 93A8 8-5 0.347@0832:8-5==5443857@08/-7@4:-3653 5: 8-556.:52A5=07=504<32:300.65:383A72A4@/.728-38344 8-5 B.825//5/ -365 /@==7085: 8-5 A3/5 .2 05/=5A8 79 .:528.8<798-53AA@/5:28-53;/52A5798-5.:528.8<79 8-5 3AA@/5: 052:50.2> 8-5 A726.A8.72 .2 1< A72/.:505: 6.5B3==53087;55007257@/32:278=07=50-5059705 .285095052A5B.8-8-5/3.:9.2:.2>/./?@/8.9.5: ! 28-54.>-8798-57;/50638.72/13:53;765=07A55:87 =3//8-597447B.2>+ $.% -50.1.23456./.7258.8.72./ $..% -5 ?@:>1528 79 A726.A8.72 32: 70:50 79 /52852A5 :385: !! !" .2 7 ) !!) 72 8-5 9.45 79 8-5 & $ 7@08% 32>34705 32: .8/ A729.0138.72 ?@:>152832:70:50:385:!"!' !"'.204 7"( !" 72 8-5 9.45 79 8-5 ::.8.7234 ./80.A8 32: 5//.72/ @:>5 32>34705 305/583/.:5 - 10 - $...% -5 =58.8.7250 ./ 3AH@.885: 970 8-5 79952A5/ @2:505A8.72/ ( 32: !$%792:.32 52347:5 $.6% 3.4;72:/5F5A@85:.932</832:A32A5445: /01 2 3 $ ./87+"47+