- 1 - ! " # $!$ ! %!&'"" & ! ! " " !#$ ! % &#' (')$' (' #$* %& " ($ ! ! ! ! '(''% ! ! ! "+ , Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( , ( -./01/2344.04-./5-067358-497/:1-;-:2:275-/ .50 <: 2/2=. 2/-<.:1 4-./5-0 2>1 73/: 7?-/5<-5: 4-.0-/97/:1-/-8;750-5:+:.:- 1-;-:2:275-/@1728.//.2>5-0.8.6638-07%25/2<- 7&#' 79 :1- /-8;750-5: A 7426- 28 B-97/- :128 73/: 8--C25>/->34./B.2497/:1-799-56-8;35281.B4-350-/-6:2758 (' #$* %& /@ ($ 79 502.5 -5.4 70- 97/ 817/: DE ;-5025> B-97/- :1- /2562;.4 -527/ 2?24 30>- .50 !.5-B-553/257(')$' !)*+,-./.0+-,/+,)+,/123+) # :28:1-6.8-79:1-;/78-63:275:1.:.67<;4.25:6.<-:7 B-/->28:-/-0BF1/201./8730/.;;.@1728:1-875+25+4.@ 79:1-0-6-.8-0667/025>:712<1-1.06758:/36:-0.>7.: 9./<25:1-4.5079:1-0-6-.8-01-0-6-.8-038-0:784--; 25 :1- 8.20 9./< BF :.C25> 6./- 79 :1- %' >7.:8 @1261 @-/- B-25> /-./-0 25 :1- 8.20 9./< 5 '%'' .8 383.4 128 3564-@-5::7:1-9./<.9:-/1.?25>0255-//7350(''6476C -./4F25:1-<7/525>1-8:.:-0:71.?-/-6-2?-0.;175-6.44 - 3 - 9/7<128/-4.:2?-5.<-4F5=.5.;;.8:.:25>:1.:1-817340:.C- 6./-79:1->7.:8.8.4-7;./0@.8@.50-/25>./7350128>7.: 9./< 5 '*'' ./7350 *#' .< 1- @-5: :7 :1- 9./< .508.@:1.::1-077/@.87;-5-0-@-5:25820-:1-9./< .5097350:1.:1283564-@.84F25>75:1-9477/350-/:1-67: 128B7:11.508@-/-:2-0@2:1./7;-.50128<73:1@.8>.3G-0 @2:1 :1- 435>2 9:-/ B-25> ;.526C-0 75 8--25> :1- 8.20 25620-5:1-/.28-0.5.4./<.506.44-0:1-5-2>1B73/89:-/ :1-F 6.<- :7 :1- 8;7: :1-F /-<7?-0 :1- 647:1 @1261 @.8 258-/:-025:7:1-<73:179:1-0-6-.8-0.5067592/<-0:1.:1- @.80-.067<;4.25:6.<-:7B-/->28:-/-025:1.:/->./0 1- =3/28026:275.4 ;7426- 1.?- /->28:-/-0 . 6.8- .>.258: 35C57@5 ;-/8758 9:-/ 675036:25> :1- 25?-8:2>.:275 83B<2::-0:1-61./>-81--: % : 28 :1- 83B<288275 79 :1- 4-./5-0 67358-4 97/ :1- ;-:2:275-/:1.::1-;-:2:275-/2825576-5:79:1-.44->-0799-56-8 .501-1.8B--59.48-4F2<;426.:-025:1286.8-1-/-97/-1- <.FB--54./>-075B.24BF2<;7825>832:.B4-67502:2758 * - 93/:1-/ 83B<2::-0 :1.: :1- 67<;4.25: @.8 /->28:-/-0 .>.258: 35C57@5 ;-/8758 1- =3/28026:275.4 ;7426- 1.?- - 4 - 8-63/-0 87<- 35C57@5 ;-/8758 .50 2<;426.:-0 :1-< 25 :1- 9.48-6.8- & : 28 93/:1-/ 83B<2::-0 :1.: :173>1 :1- 67<;4.25: @7340 0286478-8 :1.: :1- .6638-0 ;-/8758 1.?- 8:74-5 #% >7.:8 57 >7.:8 1.?- B--5 8-2G-0 .: :1-2/ 258:.56- -/-4F B-6.38- 53<B-/ 79 6.8-8 1.?- B--5 /->28:-/-0 .>.258: :1- ;-:2:275-/ <.F 57: B- . >/7350 :7 /-=-6: :1- B.24 .8 :1- 7:1-/ .6638-0 @17@-/-82<24./4F;4.6-025:1-61./>-81--:@-/->/.5:-0B.24 BF:12873/: ) : 28 93/:1-/ 83B<2::-0 :1.: :1- ;-:2:275-/ 28 :1- -./525> <-<B-/79:1-9.<24F.50128;./-5:8./-.>-0.5035.B4-:7 <.25:.25 :1-<8-4?-8 1- ;-:2:275-/ 38-0 :7 :.C- 6./- 79 128 ;./-5:8BF0725>67742-7@-?-/1-1.8B--5.//-8:-025. 9.48- 6.8- :173>1 1- 1.8 57: 67<<2::-0 .5F 799-56- 1-/-97/- 1- <.F B- -54./>-0 75 B.24 BF 2<;7825> 832:.B4- 67502:2758 .C25> 8361 83B<28827584-./5-0 67358-4 97/ :1- ;-:2:275-/;/.F8:7.447@:1-;-:2:275 $ 4-./5-0 2>1 73/: 7?-/5<-5: 4-.0-/ 97/ 817/:HI 97/:1-/-8;750-5:+:.:-?-1-<-5:4F83B<2::-0 :1.::1-;-:2:275-/28.//.2>5-0.8.6638-07%25:1286.8-.50 1-1.825?74?-025<.5F6.8-87983615.:3/-1-;-:2:275-/28 - 5 - . 1.B2:3.4 799-50-/ 9 1- 28 /-4-.8-0 75 B.24 :1-/- <.F B- 61.56-8 79 67<<2::25> 82<24./ 799-56-8 .50 <7/-7?-/ :1- 799-56-@12611-1.867<<2::-028>/.?-.501-25738255.:3/- 1-0.672:F@126128.88762.:-0@2:1<3/0-/1.8:7B-?2-@-0 8-/27384F .50 2: 28 5-6-88./F :7 >2?- . 8:/75> <-88.>- :7 :1- 762-:F:1.::1-F./-8.9-.::1-1.50879;7426-.5073/:8 (' : 28 93/:1-/ 83B<2::-0 :1.: 92425> :1- .9920.?2: BF :1- ;./-5:8:7 :.C- 6./- 79 :1-;-:2:275-/1-56-97/:1 <.F 57: B- :1->/7350:7>/.5:B.241-/-97/-128B.24.;;426.:2751.8:7 B-/-=-6:-0.C25>836183B<2882758:1-4-./5-02>173/: 7?-/5<-5:4-.0-/;/.F8:7028<288:1-;-:2:275 (( .?25> 675820-/-0 :1- /2?.4 83B<2882758 <.0- BF :1- 4-./5-067358-497/:1-/-8;-6:2?-;./:2-8.5075;-/38.479:1- .?-/<-5:8 79 :1- 61./>- 81--: 2: @7340 25026.:- :1.: :1- .6638-0 7% 8:.:-0 :7 B- 75- 79 :1- .88762.:-8 79 :1- 7:1-/ .6638-0 1- -5:2/- 6.8- 28 B.8-0 75 :1- 62/63<8:.5:2.4 -?20-56-1-.?-/<-5:8<.0-25:1-61./>-81--:./-B.8-0 75 :1- ?7435:./F 8:.:-<-5: 79 :1- .6638-0 1- <.55-/ 25 @1261 :1- 25620-5: 1.0 :.C-5 ;4.6- @7340 25026.:- :1.: :1- ;-:2:275-/ 1.0 57 25:-5:275 :7 67<<2: :1- <3/0-/ 79 :1- 0-6-.8-0 - 6 - ( 173>1 :1- 61./>- 81--: .?-/<-5:8 @7340 25026.:- :1.: :1-.6638-0.507:1-/81.067<<2::-0:1-9:79#%>7.:89/7< :1-9./<575-79:1-<./-B-25>/-67?-/-0173>1:1-/-./- 8-?-/.4 6.8-8 /->28:-/-0 .>.258: :1- ;-:2:275-/ :1- ;./-5:8 79 :1- ;-:2:275-/ .;;-./-0 B-97/- :128 73/: .50 924-0 :1-2/ .9920.?2: 8:.:25> :1.: :1-F @7340 :.C- 6./- 79 :1- ;-:2:275-/ 1-56-97/:1 .50 .487 /-J3-8:-0 :1- 73/: :7 >/.5: 12< B.24 BF 2<;7825> 832:.B4- 67502:2758 75 :1- ;/-:-K: 79 /-97/<.:2?- :1-7/F (# .?25>675820-/-0:1-.?-/<-5:879:1-61./>-81--:.50 .487:1-/-J3-8:79:1-;./-5:82:28.;;/7;/2.:-:7>/.5:12< B.24 BF 2<;7825> 832:.B4- 67502:2758 @1261 @7340 :.C- 6./- 79 :1-.;;/-1-5827579:1-;/78-63:275 ( -56-;/76--0:7;.88:1-97447@25> 2 1-/2<25.4-:2:27528 22 1-;-:2:275-/ .6638-0 7% 287/0-/-0 :7 B- -54./>-0 75 B.24 25 /2<- 7&#' 79 :1- /-8;750-5: A 7426- ;-5025>75:1-924-79:1-/2562;.4-527/2?2430>-.50! .5-B-553/ 25 7(')$' 75 -K-63:25> . ;-/875.4 - 7 - B75097/.83<798'''''+3;--8@7.C18754F @2:1 :@7 83/-:2-8 97/ :1- 42C-83< :7 :1- 8.:289.6:275 79 :1- /2.4 73/:83B=-6::7:1-97447@25>67502:2758 . 1- ;-:2:275-/ 81.44 .;;-./ B-97/- :1- /2.4 73/:75.440.:-8791-./25>@2:173:9.24 B 1- ;-:2:275-/ 81.44 57: :1/-.:-5 57/ :.<;-/ :1- ;/78-63:275 @2:5-88-8 .50 81.44 67+7;-/.:-@2:1:1-25?-8:2>.:275 6 1-;-:2:275-/81.4457:67<<2:.5F799-56-8 7/ 82<24./ 799-56-8 79 :1- 5.:3/- :244 028;78.4 79:1-6.8-7/2593:3/- 5 6.8- 29 :1- ;-:2:275-/ ?274.:-8 .5F 79 :1- B.24 67502:2758.88:.:-0.B7?-:1-;/78-63:275@244B-.:42B-/:F:7 8--C97/6.56-44.:27579B.24 "34 5" 6 ' 88 28:7($47