Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2025 DAILYLAW 2804 (PNJ)

UNION BANK OF INDIA v. DEBTS RECOVERY TRIBUNAL II AND OTHERS

CWP/30496/2025 · 2026-03-20

Parmod Goyal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

1               ! CWP-30496-2025           !   "#  CWP-35397-2025 $%&'        !  """" "#            !  """" "#  #$#%&#'() * "" %()(+),#'() * "" -.(/'#'() * "" '( ( )**+#,- ". #  " /0 "/(  ) 1    * 01 " 221 3  2  01 " 2   1   1 $ , (  *#0./ 2/,,. *3/# $ (/*$/*#0./ )( "  /4' 56789:6:;/#58<:5:6:; )(  "# /4' 5;58=:6:;  $ "(/>*/#0./   "#  :7' 56789:6:; ) "#  :/#5' 58<:5:6:;/# )( "  ' 5;58=:6:; ???? CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.03.21 13:20 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document       6 <3 '( (  (/#,/(.-"  / . -" ". #,) E .)# #/ #69 69 :6:;H :3 '( (  #  #/ # := <6 :6:; 0# >(.(@/4 (/ @  # . #    /**>  " /  )  ./(  . #  *-  "  5666666%"/. )# #/ #69 69 :6:;./@ "/ #  /#  >( (   /-    @ A#  ."  )  #   #/ # 69 69 :6:;/#H 53 '( (  @ .0 A@/*+) #"/,#  #/ #:6 <: :6:;H 73 '( ( /A# ./  F #@  #@A( )-"* - /)# #/ #69 69 :6:; <:  .  -", #  #   #/ #  67 <6 :6:;  := <6 :6:;  /# :6 <: :6:;/**(/0 / #  E .)# #/ #69 69 :6:; "/ # :5):6::/# 0  "# @A>/A)> "   (/  ,(  -"* - /  )  #   #/ #  69 69 :6:;  ( " /0 "/)# #/ #69 69 :6:;2 E  :' 56789 :6:;3@ , "#. #) /#A )  . 1                                                  !"#    $! # ! %   &'(&  "#            "#                 # !   )          !   "     #        *+       !  " ,  "# $ ! $ - '      "# %   &'(&   "#    # &   "#   .  #    "          CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.03.21 13:20 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document       15 *@ A    "    (      04  +#.  )  @   .0 A @/*/..#/. >(*/>    1! 21 !     2 :6 65 :6:9  (0/%.(/+ 0    '( (  / #%" /4,  % '( (  "/@*   % CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.03.21 13:20 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document