Research › Search › Judgment

Gauhati High Court · body

2025 DAILYLAW 27672 (GAU)

ASHATON BIBI AND ORS v. THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS

WP(C)/6174/2025 · 2025-11-02

Arun Dev Choudhury

Writ Petition (Civil)body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

Page No.# 1/20 GAHC010225122025 2025:GAU-AS:14824 THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) Case No. : WP(C)/6174/2025 ASHATON BIBI AND ORS W/O- LATE MAKBUL HUSSAIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 2: AJAHAR ALI S/O LT SAIBALI SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 3: MAYMUNA BIBI S/O LT MAFIZ SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 4: SOMESH ALI S/O LT ASARUDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 5: JAYTON NESSA W/O LTY JASHEM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 6: HAZARAT ALI S/O LT KURPAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 7: AYSHA KHATUN W/O LT MANU SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 8: AJMAR ULLAH S/O A KARIM R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 9: ISMAIL SHEIKH S/O LT MOKAM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS Page No.# 2/20 CHAPOR PIN 783348 10: MAHAMMAD ALI S/O LT SIKIM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 11: AMINA BEGUM W/O LT SAFAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 12: SAFAR ALI S/O LT MAFIZ SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 13: FAKRI CHAN S/O SANDULLA SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 14: SAMSUL HOUE S/O SAIBALI SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 15: ASHRAB ALI S/O LT BAHEZ ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 16: SALIMUDDIN SHEIKH S/O LT BAHEZ ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 17: JELHOK UDDIN S/O LT MOSLEMODDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 18: MAJEDA BEWA W/O LT IMAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 19: ABUSAMA SHEIKH S/O LT AJGAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 20: TAHAJ UDDIN S/O LT PANU SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 21: JAMIRAN NESSA W/O LT JAMER ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR Page No.# 3/20 PIN 783348 22: MAHERA KHATUN W/O LT SAMER ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 23: JAYNAB BIBI W/O LTY UJJAL SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 24: MALBAR ALI S/O LT HARMUJ ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 25: KANSER ALI S/O LT JUBBAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 26: SAHEJ ALI S/O LT SONAUULLAH SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 27: MALEK UDDIN S/O LT MAFIZ BEPARI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 28: JAYNAB BIBI W/O LT SAYEDALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 29: MANTAJ ALI S/O LT BABUR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 30: HAOWA BEGUM W/O LT ABDUL KADE R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 31: MAJER ALI S/O LT MAFIJ BEPARI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 32: RAHAM ALI S/O LT MAFIZ BEPARI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 33: BASHA SHEIKH S/O LT MAFIJ BEPARI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS Page No.# 4/20 CHAPOR PIN 783348 34: AHER ALI S/O LT MAJIJ BEPARI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 35: SAHAR ALI S/O LT MAFIJ BEPARI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 36: EJATAN NESSA W/O LT SALIMUDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 37: DALIMON BEWA W/O LTY KURMAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 38: MANTAJ ALI S/O LTY INSAB ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 39: SHEIKH ABDULLAH S/O LT AJGAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 40: JAYNUDDIN S/O LT MANTAJ AII R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 41: ANOWARA KHATUNI W/O LT RAHMAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 42: HAIDAR ALI S/O LT IMAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 43: JAHAN UDDIN S/O LT MAYJUDDIN SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 44: MANOWAR HUSSAIN S/O LT A MAZID R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 45: JAHAN UDDIN S/O LT AKBARI ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR Page No.# 5/20 PIN 783348 46: NOIMUDDIN SHEIKH S/O LT SOMED ALI MISTRI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 47: SAH ALOM S/O AMIR JOTDAR R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 48: JAMELA KHATUN W/O SUKUR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 49: ANSEN ALI S/O LT JAFAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 50: ABDUS SAMAD S/O LT TAYANUDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 51: SULTANUR RAHMAN S/O LT JAMSER ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 52: JALAL UDDIN TULUKDAR S/O LT ABDUR RAHMAN TALUKDR R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 53: MAHAMMAD ALI S/O LT MAJIBOR RAHMAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 54: ANSEN ALI S/O LT LAKU SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 55: SAMAD ALI S/O LT SABDER ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 56: NASKAR ALI S/O LT BILU SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 57: SUKKUR ALI S/O LT TARU SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS Page No.# 6/20 CHAPOR PIN 783348 58: ANOWARA KHATUN W/O LT RAHAM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 59: JAHIR UDDIN S/O LT HOSSEN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 60: AFSAR ALI S/O LT RAMJAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 61: NOWSHAD ALI S/O SATTAM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 62: SAMSUL HOQUE S/O LT MOIJUDDIN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 63: MANOWAR HUSSEN S/OP SAMSUL HOQUE R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 64: MAFIJ UDDIN S/O SANDULLAH SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 65: DELMAD ALI AHMED S/O LT JASMAT ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 66: ABDUS SAMAD S/O LT MOIJUDDIN SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 67: ABDUL BARI S/O LT MOIJUDDIN SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 68: KULSUM BEWA D/O MONTAJ ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 69: RAHIM UDDIN S/O LT SADULLAH SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS Page No.# 7/20 CHAPOR PIN 783348 70: SAIDALI S/O LT SUMAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 71: JAHIRAN BEWA W/O LT SAMED ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 72: BADSHA SHEIKH S/O SAHID ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 73: JAYMANA BIBI W/O LT MOICHAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 74: SHAMINA BIBI W/O MOICHAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 75: ANOWAR HUSSAIN S/O ISMAIL HOSS R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 76: ISMAIL HOSSEN S/O LT KABIR SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 77: SAMAD ALI S/O LT HABIBOR RAHMAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 78: JAMELA KHATUN W/O LT SAHAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 79: MOIDAN ALI S/O LT SABDER ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 80: ABDUR RAHMAN S/O LT AJGAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 81: AYNAL HOQUE S/O LT JAHER LAI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR Page No.# 8/20 PIN 783348 82: AJGAR ALI S/O LT HAJARAT ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 83: JAHIRUL ISLAM S/O LT ABDUL KADER R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 84: ABU BAKKAR SIDDIQUE S/O LT AJGAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 85: ASAN ALI S/O LT HAZARAT ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 86: AHAMMAD ALI S/O JAMAL UDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 87: SAIJUDDIN SHEIKH S/O RUSTAM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 88: MEHER ALI S/O LT AFSAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 89: SAHAR ALI S/O LT AFSAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 90: ABDUL MAJID S/O LT ISMAIL SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 91: MATLEB ALI S/O RAHAM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 92: SAIJUDDIN SHEIKH S/O DULAL SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 93: ABDUS SALAM S/O MAHIBUDDIN MUNCHI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS Page No.# 9/20 CHAPOR PIN 783348 94: MAIDAN ALI PARAMANI S/O RAHIMUDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 95: MOKBUL HOSSEN S/O AKABBAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 96: ABDUL REZZAK S/O MAHIBUDDIN MUNCHI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 97: SAFIQUL ISLAM MOLLAH S/O ASMAT ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 98: PASHAN ALI S/O KUDRAT ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 99: SAFIRO RAHMAN S/O NURUDDIN SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 100: MANIRUJ RAHMAN S/O MATIOR RAHMAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 101: SAJAHAN ALI S/O KUDRAT ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 102: ISMAIL SHEIKH S/O ENNAS ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 103: SATTAR ALI S/O JAYED ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 104: SATTAR ALI S/O JAYED ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 105: SAHAR BHANU BIBI W/O ISAP ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN Page No.# 10/20 783348 106: MAJIRAN NESSA W/O KAJIMUDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 107: KASHEM ALI S/O KUDRAT ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 108: MAHIR UDDIN S/O SAKMAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 109: MESER ALI S/O SAKMAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 110: SAMSUL HOQUE S/O NAJAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 111: BAHAR ALI S/O JAMERUDDDIN SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 112: SWAHID ALI S/O MESER ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 113: SAMSUL HOQUE S/O HAREJ ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 114: RABIQUL ISLAM S/O MESER ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 115: DELSAD ALI AHMED S/O RAJIJ UDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 116: SWAHID ALI S/O KUDRAT ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 117: SANOWAR HOSSAIN S/O JALIL R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN Page No.# 11/20 783348 118: ANOWAR HUSSAIN S/O SOHRAB ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 119: ANOWAR HUSSAIN S/O A JALIL R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 120: SORHAB ALI S/O KUDRAT ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 121: KHOWSHED ALOM S/O ABDUL KUDDUS R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 122: ABUL HOSSAIN S/O HABIBOR RAHMAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 123: MUKTAL ALI S/O JAFAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 124: MENDI BEWA W/O SAKMAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 125: MANOWAR HOSSEN S/O ABDUL JALIL R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 126: BUJUR ALI S/O KALIMUDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 127: ABU SAMA S/O BASER ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 128: SAYED ALI S/O BASER ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 129: SAHAR ALI S/O INNAS ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN Page No.# 12/20 783348 130: AHIMA KHATUN W/O RAKMAT ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 131: GOLAM HUSSAIN S/O ABDUL GANI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 132: RAJAB ALI S/O DELBAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 133: SAHAR ALI S/O SAMSUL HOQUE R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 134: FARMAN ALI S/O MAMUD ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 135: SAIJUDDIN S/O RUSTOM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 136: SOBAHAN ALI S/O FANSHU SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 137: AHAMMAD ALI S/O MUSA SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 138: ABDUL MONNAF S/O HAMED MUNSHI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 139: SAMSUL HOQUE S/O ABDUL HUSSIAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 140: SURHAB ALI S/O ABDUL HUSSAIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 141: FAJIUR RAHMAN S/O ABDUL GANI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR Page No.# 13/20 PIN 783348 142: SAMARTAN BHANU W/O ABDUL HUSSIAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 143: SANOWAR HUSSAIN S/O ABDUL HUSSIAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 144: AMINUL ISLAM S/O MAHAMMAD ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 145: NAGAR ALI S/O KUMUR UDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 146: JAYEDA KHATUN W/O MAJIBOR RAHMAN BHUYAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 147: MAJIBOR RAHMAN S/O ABDUL GANI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 148: KUNSUN NESSA W/OP BADSHA MONDAL R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 149: RAFIQUL ISLAM S/O HABIBOR RAHMAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 150: KHAIJOR ALI S/O RUSTOM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 151: MAHIR ALI S/O MOKSHED ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 152: BAKKAR ALI S/O ABDUL GANI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 153: JOYNAL ABEDIN S/O SAHA ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN Page No.# 14/20 783348 154: NAYEB ALI S/O ABDUL GANI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 155: KAMAR ALI S/O ALTAP ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 156: RAFIQUL ISLAM S/O MUSA SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 157: JAHER ALI S/O MUSA SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 158: AJIMUDDIN MANDAL S/O JAYNAL MONDAL R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 159: SAHA ALI S/O AJGAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 160: SWAHID ALI S/O ATOR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 161: SUKKUR ALI S/O KANSU SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 162: JAMAL BADSHA S/O HAMES ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 163: AHAJUL SHEIKH S/O MUSA SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 164: MOJIBOR BHUYAN S/O SUKUR ALI BHUYAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 165: MONOWAR HUSSAIN S/O AJON ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN Page No.# 15/20 783348 166: KHEIFUL NESSA W/O RAMJAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 167: SWBATON BIBI W/O ANOWAR HUSSIAN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 168: KHALEK ALI S/O MUSLIM UDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 169: KAMAL HUSSEN S/O HASHEM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 170: MAHIM UDDIN S/O HASHEM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 171: JURAN ALI S/O ABDUL KADER R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 172: AMJAT ALI S/O SUMAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 173: TARABHANU BEWA W/O RUSTOM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 174: SIDDIK ALI S/O JILIMUDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 175: HAREJ ALI S/O RUSTOM ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 176: SAFIQUL ISLAM S/O MUSA SHEIKH R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 177: SAIFUL ISLAM S/O RAMJAN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR Page No.# 16/20 PIN 783348 178: AYNAL HOQUE S/O HASHEN ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 179: BELLAL ALI S/O HAMED ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 180: JAYAN ALI S/O MAHAMMAD ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 181: KAMELA KHATUN W/O FAJAR ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 182: ALFFAJ S/O JAMAL UDDIN R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 183: ALI AKABBAR S/O AKUL HOQUE R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 783348 184: RABIAL ISLAM S/O AMJAD ALI R/O VILL SRIGAM 6TH PART PO HATIPOTA PS CHAPOR PIN 78334 VERSUS THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS REP BY THE COMM AND SECY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM, REVENUE AND DM, DISPUR, GUWAHATI- 06 2:DISTRICT COMMISSIONER DHUBRI P.O.- DHUBRI HEAD OFFICE DIST- DHUBRI ASSAM PIN- 783301 3:THE COMMISSIONER OF CO DISTRICT BILASIPARA P.O.- BILASIPARA DIST- DHUBRI ASSAM PIN- 783301 Page No.# 17/20 4:THE SETTLEMENT OFFICER DHUBRI DHUBRI P.O. DHUBRI DIST. DHUBRI ASSAM PIN-783301. 5:THE CIRCLE OFFICER OF CHAPOR REVENUE CIRCLE P.O.- DHUBRI DIST- DHUBRI ASSAM PIN- 783371 6:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM DEPT OF ENV AND FOREST DISPUR GHY 6 7:PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS ASSAM REHABARI GHY- 8 8:THE DIVISIONAL FOREST OFFICER DHUBRI P.O.- DHUBRI HEAD OFFICE P.O. DIST DHUBRI PIN- 783301 9:REGIONAL FOREST OFFICER/FOREST RANGER SALKOCHA FOREST RANGE P.O.- HATIPOTA DIST- DHUBRI ASSAM PIN- 78334 Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. M A SHEIKH, MS F INTAZ,MR. W A SHEIKH Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, SC, FOREST,SC. REVENUE BEFORE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN DEV CHOUDHURY ORDER 03-11-2025 1. Heard Mr. M. A. Sheikh, learned counsel for the petitioners and Mr. P.N. Page No.# 18/20 Goswami, learned Additional Advocate General, Assam assisted by Mr. I. Kalita, learned counsel representing the respondent Forest Department. 2. The petitioners claim that they are landless people who settled on Government Land and have continuously possessed the land in question for 40-50 years. It is their further claim that they are also paying land revenues on the lands reflected in the revenue records as Eksonia/Myadi. They are aggrieved by eviction notices issued by the authorities. 3. On the other hand, it is the case of the State of Assam in the Forest Department that the land under the possession of the petitioners is reserved for Srigram Reserved Forest and therefore, neither under the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886 nor under the settlement rules, such land can be settled with the petitioners. Accordingly, they have been issued notices. 4. Mr. Goswami, learned Additional Advocate General, Assam, however, in his usual fairness, submits that though the notices of eviction are issued, they are not in total conformity with the order dated 18.08.2025 passed by the learned Division Bench in WA No. 251/2025, more particularly, paragraph No. 21 of the said order. 5. Mr. Goswami, learned Additional Advocate General, Assam further submits that as the petitioners have raised bonafide claims of their right, the Forest Department along with the revenue authorities of the District concerned shall make a joint verification of the land in question and thereafter, if they find that the petitioners are in possessing the land under reserved forest, they will issue fresh notice of eviction to the petitioners by specifying the land. 6. In view of such submission of the learned Additional Advocate General, Mr. Sheikh, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the present writ petition may be disposed of by interfering with the impugned eviction notices. 7. Forest lands are outside the purview of settlement, however, there may be Page No.# 19/20 various situations, such as question of disputes pertaining to the boundary of such forest or there may be disputes related to reservation or de-reservation of the land for forest or for that matter, there may be a dispute that the persons who have been granted the settlement in respect of a land even before being declared as reserved forest etc. such may involve a bona-fide claim of right to claim. 8. Thus, when forest land cannot be settled, however, when a bona fide claim is raised, the affected persons should be given a proper opportunity to be heard. 9. In the opinion of this Court, when the bonafide claim of right is raised, the authority cannot be permitted to unilaterally decide as to whether an occupier/possessor has a bonafide claim of the right involved, inasmuch as, it would require adjudication of both law and facts and without providing any opportunity to the occupier/ possessor, it would be in violation of principle of natural justice, 10. Under such circumstances, issuance of a notice shall be necessary to form a subjective satisfaction, which is in consonance with the principles of natural justice inasmuch as the same will facilitate a just, fair and transparent procedure, which are facets of Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India. 11. In the case at hand, in the backdrop of the claim made by the petitioners and the stand taken by the learned Additional Advocate General, Assam, the impugned notices are set aside, and the forest authority is permitted to issue fresh notices, by giving an opportunity of hearing to the petitioners, in terms of paragraph 21 of the Division Bench Decision order dated 18.08.2025 passed in WA No.251/2025. For arriving at the decision, as proposed by Mr. Goswami, a joint verification should be made with the revenue authorities to ascertain the claim. A speaking order be passed in this regard. JUDGE Page No.# 20/20 Comparing Assistant