- 1 - !"" #$ % %$ & $ '(!')*+( !' ** !! !! "# $!# % & $ !!% #% !# ! ! ! "# $!! ##% #& '( $% & # $)' & !% ! # !!# Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ') & &&# ! $*%$++%! & #! ## !& ## # # & , # & & -! . $#-! .% #/0+0+12/3451+67337+82/9767::;6/91576<+=/9 05+6 >/0+0+12 ;29/3 /:0+12 )' 1< !57370+?7 7873+@ ;37@657725+07$<1365130A05/!:0B%01837205+C 3/8;=73 *7+= +2 3+C/ 1) 1< =9 ;**7==+ #1=+:/ 6070+12 <13 05/ 1<</2:/ >;2+657*=/ ;29/3 /:0+126 $*%$++%$!% 1< 05/ 73:10+: 3;86 729 #6?:51031>+: ;*6072:/6:0()$<1365130A05/ #:0B% 2 6;>>130 1< 05/ >/0+0+12 >/0+0+12/3 576 :120/29/905705/+6+221:/20729=747*+9+28:+0+D/2/ - 3 - 576 *//2 <7=6/=? +C>=+:70/9 5/3/ +6 21 >3+C7E<7:+/ :76/ C79/1;0787+26005/>/0+0+12/35/3/73/213/76127*=/ 831;29613C70/3+7=01*/=+/F/0570>/0+0+12/3+6+2F1=F/9+2 05/ 67+9 :76/ / +6 733/60/9 12 ') =3/79? +2F/60+870+12 +6 :1C>=/0/9 729 :5738/ 65//0 +6 <+=/9 729 05/3/<13/21=128/35+6:;6019+7=>3/6/2:/+62/:/6673? ' ::139+280105/>316/:;0+12'8C61<872G7 +63/:1F/3/9<31C05/>/0+0+12/345+:5:1C/6;29/36C7== H;720+0?72905/3/<13/05/3/+621+C>/9+C/20013/=/76/ 5+C12*7+=5/1<</2:/67==/8/973/210>;2+657*=/4+05 9/705 13 +C>3+612C/20 <13 =+</ #/0+0+12/3 +6 7 >/3C72/20 3/6+9/20 1< 7993/66 8+F/2 +2 05/ :7;6/ 0+0=/ / +6 3/79? 729 4+==+28 01 7*+9/ *? 72? :129+0+126 0570 C7? */ +C>16/97291<</36;*60720+7=6;3/0?0105/670+6<7:0+121< 05/03+7=1;307295/2:/05/>/0+0+12 /732/9 +85 1;30 1F/32C/20 #=/79/3 6;*C+00/9 137= 1*G/:0+126 6070+28 0570 12 ') #1=+:/ 26>/:013 1< =9 ;**7==+ #1=+:/ 070+12 87F/ 7 3/>130 6070+28 0570 45+=/ 12 >7031==+28 9;0? 5/ 3/:/+F/9 - 4 - :3/9+*=/ +2<13C70+12 3/8739+28 67=/ 273:10+: 93;86 2/73 607<< H;730/36 1< />316? 16>+07= !76/9 12 05/ 67+9 +2<13C70+12 05/ 2F/60+870+28 <<+:/3 3/8+60/3/9 :76/ +2 3+C/ 1) 729 7=128 4+05 >72:576 729 105/3 607<<6 >31://9/9 01 05/ 6>10 729 7>>3/5/29/9 +2 7== 2+2/ >/36126+/7::;6/91601(729<31C05/+3>166/66+12 F73+1;6H;720+0+/61<872G7+66/+D/9/I:/>07::;6/916 01( &31C 05/ >166/66+12 1< >/0+0+12/3 ' 8C6 1< 872G7 +6 3/:1F/3/9 5/ 7::;6/9 >/36126 4/3/07@/2+201 :;6019? 729>319;:/9*/<13/ 05/1;30 7293/C729/901 G;9+:+7= :;6019? 5/ 7==/870+126 C79/ 787+260 05/ >/0+0+12/3 +6 837F/ < 3/=/76/9 12 *7+= >/0+0+12/3 C7? 053/70/2 13 07C>/3 4+05 05/ 4+02/66/6 5/? C7? 7=61 7*6:129 729 05/3/*? 9/=7? 729 9/</70 05/ +2F/60+870+12 729 03+7= F/2 051;85 05/ H;720+0? 1< 872G7 3/:1F/3/9 <31C 05/ >166/66+12 1< >/0+0+12/3 :1C/6 ;29/3 6C7== H;720+0?5/+6+2F1=F/9+26/F/37=105/31<</2:/61<6+C+=73 270;3/729+205//F/201<8370+28*7+=5/C7?12:/787+2 - 5 - +29;=8/+267=/1<273:10+:93;86729>37?013/G/:005/*7+= >/0+0+12 J /73905/738;C/206729>/3;6/905/3/:139 5;6 12 3/:/+>0 1< :3/9+*=/ +2<13C70+12 05/ 2F/60+870+28<<+:/33/8+60/3/905/:76/7297=1284+055+6 607<< 729 +29/>/29/20 >72:576 >31://9/9 01 05/ 6>10 5/?<1;297::;6/91601(+27831;>729<31C05/+3 >166/66+12 F73+1;6 H;720+0+/6 1< 872G7 +6 6/+D/9 /I:/>0 7::;6/91601( ) 1 <73 76 >/0+0+12/3 +6 :12:/32/9 <31C 5+6 >166/66+12 ' 8C6 1< 872G7 +6 6/+D/9 < :1;36/ +0 +6 6C7== H;720+0? 5/ C7I+C;C >;2+65C/20 >3/6:3+*/9 +6 +C>3+612C/2045+:5C7?/I0/290112/?/7313<+2/45+:5 C7?/I0/2901<+2/1<6E134+05*10514/F/3 05/C/C1<+=/9*?=/732/9+851;301F/32C/20#=/79/3 6070/ 0570 05/ >/0+0+12/3 +6 +2F1=F/9 +2 :76/6 1< 1=9 ;**7==+#1=+:/070+12':76/61<!/29+8/3/#12/:76/ 1<;**7==+E 573479#>/307+2+2801273:10+:93;86 - 6 - / +6 7=61 +2F1=F/9 +2 12/ :76/ /7:5 1< # 1<</2:/6 +2 767*7>/0/ #1=+:/ 070+12 729 12/ /657F7>;3 #1=+:/ 070+12;**7==+/+67=6173149?65//0/3F/2051;85 5/ 576 210 *//2 :12F+:0/9 <7:0 3/C7+26 0570 5/ +6 57*+0;7==?+2F1=F/9+2273:10+:93;86729105/3:76/6729 45+=/ 83720+28 *7+= +2 >3/F+1;6 :76/6 9/6>+0/ +C>16+28 :129+0+1205705/657==210+2F1=F/5+C6/=<+272?:3+C+27= 7:0+F+0+/65/+6+29;=8/9+26/F/37=:76/6 ( 7@+28+201:126+9/370+127==05/6/76>/:0605+6 1;30+61<05/:126+9/3/91>+2+12057005/>/0+0+12/3+6210 /20+0=/9<13*7+=7297::139+28=?05/<1==14+28 5/ >/0+0+12 <+=/9 *? 05/ >/0+0+12/37::;6/9 1 ;29/3/:0+12)'1<!+65/3/*?3/G/:0/9 ,+ '%$ &* % ! ( 'K