Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 27504 (PNJ)
BHAGAL v. BULLA AND OTHERS
RSA/556/1993 · 2025-02-17
Vikram Aggarwal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 27504 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 27504 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
"
%()((**+$
$$ %%)0(** / / ,
%
2
+
, $ ## # $ # (
! 4
' /
! !# !#$
#$
"%
555 %
$ ##&$$
,-.#
$$# ,-#
**% $ ,- . # 1 ! 1# ! $
$ ## #
,
#' # ## (3+ # ' 0
&''(&)**+ !",,-),-,' !"!#"$ !").-,,-,'
7$$
7$
$$
$
"( '
/ 1
'
,8 # ,-$ ## $ ,#$
. ' - / -' ##
06 )% #-
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&,&
, $
4 / 1 ##9 $$-&! ' / 1 # ## '
%+):(*;<$
9
! ,
#$ ## '#$ ## ! $$
-. - # -
'
', '$ #$ ##!#
-
'
',- '$ = ' ' , ,
# #
2
#! "((0(,
(:(((*;<
,
$ #$ ## #
"( >! #
"% . $ $$
-$
>! $$
?8: ! # #
=
' # ,-#
"( !'
! # ! , ! -$ :
2' $ # $ #
#'8
! " ! #
$"%&%' ("'))!""
*+,,
-! -- .!-! %& /!! ! *+,0
-! % %& -!- ) *+,0
$ -!! .!!%! -! .*+,0 PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&+&
1 -! ! ! -!*+,0
2 ! ! ! -
! !134, *+,0
56
0
$ !! 6
. '
%+):(*;<>! $$# ,-#
# ,-$ ## ' # # $
$$ <
#$ ;
= ,' ,-
$
$ ##2 $$. $$
' =,' '
$,- . $ $$$$ ##
' - ,-2 $$. ;(
= ,' $# # ! # $ ## $! # $! ',- $$ ' ,# . = # ,' , $
' #'
# $
;%
# ,'
# ##
-$$ . - -$#
;+
,' ' ,-
##
$
$ , $
,'
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&/&
$ @ ##' -' ! , ! ;:
# ' #
$ #8A'
#
##
;0
## # !,
'
#
' @ =
$$#
$ $ ' $,- $' . # =
# 97 ! + 0-& 0
! ! ! +"
2 4(5 89 # ' $,- . #9/!. :08 9 ;5! +"#8955892#
#9!7 ;5'-!!
+ 854
#$" !###9 *
# #
,'
- '
$ ,- 2 $$.=,' $$-!!$
$ #' '
,. # ' ,- - # #' - '
- $! , # -,- . *(
# $ BA8(
' BA8% '
BA8+ ,' ,-
, #' '-
1 # $ ## = ,' $ # PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&'&
$
'
#! ,
#' -'
#
#
$
'
##, *%
,' #' -'
, @
,@
$! - ,
##
#,'
@ #' - '
#
! $ '
#' - '
*+
@ '
# #''
' - ' #
$$ #
' '
,' ! $! ''
$!1$A' -
'' ,
' '
,$ *:
$- ' , $
'
# $
,' $ -#
-
' , # $ ## $ !'
$
,' $8A #' $ # , @ ' #
*0
= ,' $-
# , -
# # ,$ $! $ #' #8! ' # $ ##
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&(&
#' -'',' #'4 $ $$#$ ## *6
,' . ## ,
'
# $$
,A
?8: -,! , $ *<
,' ! ! C $$
?8% ', '$ # , ## A
'
! 8A' ,- $ ## # ! A'
8 8 #!$ *;
# ,' $ ## '' !# , A' '# ,! = $$#
$ $
' $,-$'.#=
#9 /:
<!-
.-!&=! (! (!! ; ! +"##$ 89 55 89 $" >:? @! <A ; :? , . B8,9; "##$895589#">4;.!,; ! ! 4,4!"."4(5"> )4!! ! + , 5) 4!! ! +" ## 89 55 89 2" >C! ! ! + 4!) 7 ! 4! " >7 5.! + /!! + ' $,- . #9;0! +'!! +" # 819 55 89 #2" >;. 0 ! + - ! +"#81955892">:'5.! +"# 81955891
$' $,-
> .
#97C7
.- ; =,&
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&.&
()
=! ,' ',-
# $ !$ -''
((
@ #
# .,'
, , ,- # # @
(%
$ # $$
$$ #
,D>-
$$$# ,$$
:(# ,. (*(;
()) .. #
, ' ' #$'. #9,!D)D80 9
5! ! D! "8#298291
# ,-' #$'. #97 8!0 9
;5.,DE+"#8955892
>&! ! +" ) ! +" # 89 - $
# '
,
@ # @ , #' . $
@ #
(+
2 # , $ #
$! 9 ! 4! BA8(2'$ # $$ $ #(3+# ' 06
)% - # ,-
. %3+= $$%#$
'
% E - $ # # #' - ' , !, $ %3+# #
'#$ ## $ ,
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&0&
!= - #
## # '
BA8%
' # $ ## ' = , ', '$ # , . BA8+ ' #
. $$ ! BA8+
' # F- 4 ! $
$ ##
'-= ' #
. ,
''#' ' # - # ' # =-
#$
'
! ' , ! C $$
?8% $ , ! $$ # #
> - '
, #
##
-## A ', '$ # $
# ' , >' ##
,
$$
'
" , 1 #
$ -,
#
- , ! $$1
$ ",- 8A'
#
,-$ ## $ '
,-! ,$ (:
.' A$ A$ ?8( '
A' ,- $ ##
A$ '- '
A' ?8+,-#
! PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&*&
$ A$ ? ' ', '$
# '
- ', '$ #BA$1
!$
#!#
'2 . A'
3', '$
1-A'
, ', '$ . ! ! A'
', '$
$
# . . '$
G##
A$G
- 2 $$.A'
!
#
#
! ,-'
,'! # $ $= #
# 2 $$ . (0
" - #
"%. $$
,A
?8: ,! , $= ,1$ ' . ##
! (3+
' (6
-,''
'
###
,'' # .8
# . #9';! ! +"##$8$95589
1" ! 1
1'23456"73485" $!#"82!3495365" 7!6"734!#7434$! !234$5 !"!326" 5":;636" 3457#;"356 <:3485" $!#"82!34599885"33 6 $!$3 3453 #;;!" = "!3 6# 5 34 $ =5 95 !"34:">3 53!2342686"7!234#63<#363$!#8
"!3 < 69#3 3453 34 $ =5 95 !" 34 <56 !2 =633"353;"3268 <:;35;5#5 ;6336"734$856; !2 34 9856"3622 5" =4! 58! 5995 <2! 34 $!#3 PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&)-&
5 ;6336"734$856;!2349856"362242!%;8:<$5# #;;!"="!36# =688"!3;5?34 $#22 <: ;35;5#5688758!!"#226"72!;25# @
# # >;. 0 ! + - ! + $
,
,@
##,
# $
'
,-#' -'
,
@
,@
10
45 $52#88: $!"6 34 52!56 $!"3"36!"% <#3 26" ;:82 #"5<8 3! 5$$93 34 5;
5" $!#"82!34599885"336 3!96$?#934=! 86"A#64;"3 6" 6!8536!" " 34 !34 45" % $!""3 $=5#22 !"34<56!225;68:338;"3%=4<:
45 !2 5335 =5 86"A#64 6"25!# !2 2" 5"3 "!) 5" , 46" 4#% 25;68: 338;"3 =5 34 <56 !2 34 $!""3 $ 6" A#36!" !#3 6" " 65 45 58=5: $!7"6 34$!"$933425;68:338;"35;!"76" #" 346"35"3$5%3425;68:338;"3=5<3="53355" 4658"94=6 2" 5"3"!)5" ,46"56 25;68:
338;"3 6 "!3 A#6 $!;9#8!: 763536!" " 34 #<A#"3 #63% 56 25;68: 338;"3 6 "!3 A#6 3! < 9! 5756"!""3 $$5"<$4588"7 6"#<A#"3 #63 !" 34 7!#" !2 25# 3$% <#3 "!3 !" 34 7!#" 3453 25$3 985 6" 34 #63 85 6"7 3! 34 $!""3 $ = 6"$!$3 !#3 6" #<A#"3 #63 $5""!3 7! <46" 34 586 $B<$5#3453 $3386743!29536C5" 26" !#353!=43434586$!""3 $=595 !" 6743!=!"725$3#<A#"3$!#36"!3"3638 3!7!6"3! 25$33!26" =434!"3453<56%586$!""3 $$!#8 < 95 !
"!3 46 6= 26" #99!3 2!; D# 7;"3 !2 346!#36"34$5!259585" !34;35;
656 5" !34 9!3 5 )*0)
/*, #$4 $4588"7 6" #<A#"3#63658!<5 <:96"$698!23!9985" D# 6$535# 7;"3!2346!#3"5;8:;354565" !34;36$44;5"5" !349!3 5)*.0 PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&))&
+.* 5" ;3 5 5# ;3 45995" B 6 C 5" !34 9!3 5)*0(
*/#99!33466=@
'
$ #
#' -' !, ! # #
B! , #$ #' -'
, !, $ ", 1
! ,>! '1 #' - '
, -
- #' - '
, @
,@
,! ,
-
# # # # 9; 0 ! + ' !! +" $ .8
##' , '
. $! ,
- , # ' ## $$##= ' ' . - #
$ ,
# -=
-, $ #. -'#'
# $ =
''
## ! -
$ ##
'
' ##
=
-# , ,-
,,
,
1*
856"362245;65<8:2568 3!9!345887 25# 6" 956"7 !2 $!""3 D# 7;"3 5" $ 53 )'-/)**(456 $!""3D# 7;"35" $=95
"!3!"8:!"34<56!25 ;66!";5 6"=633"353;"3 PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&),&
268 <: 2" 5"3 !2 #63 ! ,0) !2 )**( <#3 58! !" 34 5 ;66!";5 <:3456 2" 5"3<:;5?6"7353;"36" !#36382
85!2349856"3622!2349"3#633453346 34#;< 6;96!"E67"53# 45 <" !<356" !" <85"? 959 !" !" 93>3 ! 34 !34% 62 #<35"3653 % $!#8 9!6<8: < 5$$93 62 34 45 <" 5 ;66!" 6" =633" 353;"3 !"8: !=% 5 ;66!" <: ;5?6"7 353;"3 6" !#335" !"583!734 622"32!!36"7353;"3;5 6" !#3$56 5#34"36$63: 3 $5""!3 < 56 3453 34 56 353;"3=5$! !"<85"?959585 :<56"734#;< 6;96!"E67"53#!2;5?!23456 353;"3#$45 $!"3"36!" $5""!3 < "3356" 53 588 2 #$4 $!"3"36!" 6 5$$93 %34"34=688<"!" 3!86367536!"!86=!#8 53356" 26"5863: ! 5"$363: =!#8 < 5335$4 3! 34 9!$ 6"7!234!#34=4!8:3;!25 ;6"63536!" !2D#36$=!#8 $!885936"!3#"$!;;!"3453#$4$!""3 $5#22 !8#"3568:5" 853!"%349!"=4! #22 #$4 $% $45"7 346 ;6" 5" $4588"7 34 5;!" 622"37!#" 36!"8:=425# 635<864 <:!" 5!"5<8 !#<33453#$4$!""3 $$5"<3 56 5# =4"985 6"$668$5658!A#6 3!< 9!
<:!" 5!"5<8 !#<3D#386?$6;6"58$457" 346"35"3$5%:3!"76 "$!2>$936!"58A#5863:6 A#6 3!9!345887 25# <$5# 2" 5"3!2#63 !,0)!2)**(45 ";5 353;"36"!#35 ;6336"7 34 $856; !2 9856"3622 !2 3453 #63 5" % 342!% 25# 6 5!"5<8:#8 !#3
856"362245;65<8:2568 3!9! 345887 25# @
(<
'
#'
#
# @ ! #' $ -'
,#' -' ! , ! # $8A
'
! $ # , ' #$A. #9
-!5.! :)
"8191
#
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&)+&
<-
!F89
! 89 !" !%
!"%.. % /G3
89 .- . % ! "!! .- . ! % -&.! .- ! / ! !" / ! F
! (! ! !" / F
! 89( .- . /
." !!.. %- -&
5##?3-/ ! !&-&
"
/ F ! 89( /! !&
%3 !89
! "/-
!! ,& ! ! H " --! / ! F ! 8$9 ( / ! .% & . .- ."/-
!!;
"%! . . .- .!! % "!/ % -
%
.- .!F ! 819 ( - -& / %& % ! I%) . - !I" 89 %3
!89/ ! -"% .! .! %&4
"/ !! ! ,& !" ! / ! / %! "!/ ! .- - -&! I
(;
# , ,
#
$8A = $
$ #$8A
#
@ B! $-
'
# '
# 9 /! . : 0 8 9 ;5 ! +$ , ,-
#$ ##
,$$ ,, , # ,-. #' -' 1 $
'
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&)/&
###
'
# @
= # 95))
'/!"##
8955892 .8
$-##
'
#
8
' -
# # ' $
1)) 4 !"8: A#36!" 3453 "!= #6 6 5 3! =434 5 953:% =4! 45 #22 5 $!""3 $% $5" $4588"763!"347!#" !2"!"&763536!"";:!96"6!"% 34953:%=4!45#22 34 $%$5"$4588"763!"34 7!#" !225# 5" ;69"3536!"58!"5" "!3!"34 7!#" !2"!"&763536!"63434$!"$" 953: "6 34:7"6!234 $<:5:6"7345363=534#83!2 25# % ;69"3536!" 5" 3453 34 =5 "! 6"3"36!" 3!
#2234 $%<#33!5:3453523#226"734 $3453 345;=5"!3763 6"!39;66<8345<"48 <:346!#36"34D# 7;"39!3 5,---B)CB668C ),,,---B)C668!#35)00B
FC%
5"#;5 465;58654!5;3453349!"%=4!45#22 34 $%$5""!3$4588"763!"347!#" !2"!"&763536!" 4 $ $5" < $4588"7 !"8: !" 34 7!#" !2 25# % ;69"3536!" ! 62 63 45 <" 95 <: 34 !#3 !2 6"$!;93"3 D#6 6$36!" 4 953: =4! #22 34 $!""3 $63!99 <: 46!="$!" #$33!$4588"7 345; >$93 !" 34 7!#" ;"36!" 5<! 4 45 3! < 5"$363:5$$! 3!34353;"3;5 <2!34!#33 =5!48 <:34#9;!#36"34D# 7;"39!3 5 ,--)B/CB668C)-(BC,--)#9;!#3,.*-% 58?65 #6";" !$6536!" 5" !34 !=54 #"6$6958!9!536!"5" !34%=46"63=5!< 5 #" I< .. ! . ! . .- . ! %.-
@ /!/ - ! / !& -
! . .- . %/! - ! /! ! / ! %. -
! . ! " %& ! !H .-! ! /!&
! . .- . %!/ %& . PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&)'&
. ! %/! - ! ! -A %
- !%& ! "A-%& ! ! . ! ! - ( ! ! ! .-.! /! " ! ! -& !3%&-%
" !!. /! ! 3%&
% ! ! %! %&.! 3
/ / !& % . &" ! - 3 &
!F! % ) & %& ! !& %&
!! !&I
(*
'
#' - $ , ' ! #' -@ '
#' -' ',
", ,-
8A'
, ! A $ ## >! ! , #' - '
, @
,@ =# ,
! ,
# %)
' $
' ' ! # ' , $ $$ ' ' #-!1 $ B! # - '
A$ - ' =
- ! # ' ! ,-
?8+ '
?8: . 1$
! ' -! # - #
# # = #
- - '
%()((**+$,-. #
/ 1,-
#
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
&''(&)**+
&)(&
- '
$ $$# ,- $ ## '
BC
!"!#"$ !").-,,-,'
?$1 3
H3" ?$, H3"
PRINCE CHAWLA 2025.02.17 18:35 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document