- 1 - ! " # # $ %!&!&% ' % (")(*+," ( !!++ ! " ##$ % ! ! !! % &&& ! " !!$ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! % '( %!" '(% &($! ! ' ( &'"! & &'$% %% ! &) &* (&')%!!%## ++% % ' ! % + ! % % , + +- "!, + +-$ !./0/012.3451067337082.9767::;6.91'576<0=.9 /506 >./0/012 ;29.3 .:/012 '( 1< 5737/0?7 78730@7 ;37@657 7250/7 " $ /1 8372/ 50A B70= 02 :30A. 1& &' <13 /5. 1<<.2:. >;20657B=. ;29.3 .:/012 &)&*(&3 4')1<! 2 6;>>13/ 1< /5. >./0/012 >./0/012.3 576 :12/.29.9/57//5.3.73.213.76127B=.831;296/1B.=0.C. - 3 - /57/5.576:1AA0//.9/5.7==.8.91<<.2:.6!./0/012.3067 :11=0.5.3.0621.C09.2:./1:122.:/50A/1/5.7==.8.9 :30A. 729 /5. :12:.32.9 >1=0:. 57C. 0==.87==? 0A>=0:7/.9 50A 1A>=70272/06/5.<7/5.31<9.:.76.9::;6.9 1& 06 /5. 40<. 1< 9.:.76.9 ::;6.9 1 06 /5. B31/5.37::;6.9106/5.A1/5.37297::;6.91 06/5.<7/5.31<7::;6.91&::;6.91/1)729( 73./5.<30.2961<7::;6.91 .:.76.9 @765 476 7990:/.9 /1 9302@028 5.03 ;6.9 /1 B. <3.D;.2/ D;733.= B./4..2 50A 729 7::;6.9 1& 729 6.C.37= /0A.6 :1A>31A06.9 476 .<<.:/.9 B./4..2 /5.A 7/ /5. >1=0:. 6/7/012 / 476 7 <7A0=? A7//.3 B./4..2 :1A>=70272/ 9.:.76.9 @765 7::;6.91&/114.C.39;302802C.6/087/012/5. 02C.6/087/0281<<0:.35760A>=0:7/.9/5.>./0/012.32=?02 139.3 /1 <0E /5. >./0/012.3 7==.87/0126 06 02/319;:.9 /57/ >./0/012.36=7>>.9/5.9.:.76.9 - 4 - ( !./0/012.3 06 7 >.3A72.2/ 3.609.2/ 1< 7993.66 80C.2 02 /5. :7;6. /0/=. . 06 21/ 02C1=C.9 02 72? 1/5.3 :76.6=3.79?7::;6.91/1)729(73.8372/.9 B70=B?/5./307=1;3/::;6.91&/173.8372/.9 B70=B?/5061;3/!./0/012.3063.79?72940==0287B09.B? 72?:1290/0126/57/A7?B.0A>16.97291<<.36;B6/72/07= 6;3./?/1/5.67/06<7:/0121</5./307=1;3/7295.2:./5. >./0/012 ( .732.9!6;BA0//.9137=1BF.:/01266/7/028 /57/7::;6.91&/173./5.40<.A1/5.3*02*=74729 <7/5.3*02*=74 1< /5. 9.:.76.9 5. A733078. 1< 7::;6.9 1& 729 9.:.76.9 /11@ >=7:. 12 &(&(&) 729 /5.? 73. 57C028 7 97;85/.3 451 06 214 78.9 ( ?.736 5.? 4.3. 6/7?028 /18./5.3 7/ ;3;9.65473 .:.76.9 476 413@0287672.=.:/30:072 02:.GA12/5/5.3.476906* :13907=0/?B./4..27::;6.91&7299.:.76.9729602:. /5.2 5. 476 6/7?028 7/ ;B=0 40/5 506 <7/5.3 451 06 /5. :1A>=70272/ B1;/ '* A12/56 >3013 /1 /5. 97/. 1< /5. 02:09.2/7<085//11@>=7:.B./4..29.:.76.97297::;6.9 - 5 - 1*5737/ 70@ /5. B31/5.3 1< 7::;6.9 1& 729 /5. A7//.3476>7:0<0.97//5.>1=0:.6/7/01272921:1A>=702/ 476<0=.940/53.8739/1/5.670902:09.2/ ' 2 /506 B7:@831;29 12 &&' 7::;6.9 16/1)450:502:=;9.65737/70@7667;=/.99.:.76.9 3.6;=/028025069.7/55.2/5.6709<7:/476B31;85//1 /5.21/0:.1</5.:1A>=70272/5.4.2//1/5.6>1/729674 /5. 9.79 B19? 76.9 12 /5. 02<13A7/012 3.:.0C.9 :1A>=70272/ <0=.9/5.:1A>=702/ ;3028/5. 02C.6/087/012 /5.2C.6/087/028<<0:.3576733.6/.961A.1</5.7::;6.9 02:=;9028 /5. >./0/012.3 / 06 7==.8.9 /57/ /5. 1<<.2:. 02 D;.6/012 06 :1AA0//.9 7/ /5. 026/087/012 1< /5. 7::;6.9 1&/15738.65../3.C.7=/57/0/06>./0/012.3451 6=7>>.9/5.9.:.76.97673.6;=/1<5.<.==914272990.9 12/5.6>1/7C0283.8739/1/5.27/;3.1</5.7==.87/0126 A79. 02 /5. .C.2/ 1< 8372/028 B70= /5.3. 06 .C.3? =0@.=05119 1< /5. >./0/012.3 7B6:129028 /53.7/.2028 729 /7A>.3028 40/5 /5. 40/2.66.6 729 >37? /1 3.F.:/ /5. >./0/012 - 6 - .739/5.738;A.2/6729>.3;6.9/5.3.:1396 ::;6.91&/173./5.40<.729>73.2/6* 02*=74 1< /5. 9.:.76.9 5. A733078. 1< 9.:.76.9 729 7::;6.9 1& 476 61=.A20H.9 12 &(&(&) 729 /5.? 73. 57C028 7 97;85/.3 451 06 214 6/7/.9 /1 B. 78.9 ( ?.7366.C09.2/<31A/5.:1A>=702/7C.3A.2/67</.3/5. A733078. 9.:.76.9 729 7::;6.9 1& =0C.9 /18./5.3 7/ ;3;9.65473 / 7>>.736 1< =7/. /5.03 3.=7/012650> B.:7A. 6/3702.9 729 602:. G A12/56 >3013 /1 /5. 02:09.2/9.:.76.94766/7?02840/5506>73.2/6B1;/'* A12/56 >3013 /1 /5. 02:09.2/ 7 <085/ /11@ >=7:. B./4..2 7::;6.9 1*5737/ 70@ 729 9.:.76.9 51;85 /5.? 4.2//1/5.>1=0:.6/7/01212/5.79C0:.61</5..=9.36/5. :1A>=702/47621/<0=.9 5. 7==.87/012 787026/ 7::;6.9 16 /1 ) 06 /57/ /5.? 7667;=/.9 /5. 9.:.76.9 729 9;. /1 /5. 02F;30.6 3.:.0C.9 B? 50A 5. 90.9 12 /5. 6>1/ 2 3.:.0>/ 1< /5. 6709 02<13A7/012 :1A>=70272/ 451 06 21 1/5.3 /572 /5. <7/5.3 1< 9.:.76.9 576 <0=.9 :1A>=702/ 5. 7==.87/0126 - 7 - 787026/ /5. 7::;6.9 1& /1 73. /57/ /5.? 026/087/.9 7::;6.916/1)/1:1AA0//5.A;39.31</5.9.:.76.9 / 06 /5. 6>.:0<0: :76. 1< /5. >316.:;/012 /57/ 9.:.76.94767990:/.9/19302@0282/5.97/.1<02:09.2/ 7::;6.9 1 /1 /11@ 9.:.76.9 B.5029 !7472 :511= 60/;7/.9 7/ 150?7 7873 729 5. 476 A79. /1 9302@ .E:.660C.=?729>0:@.9;>D;733.=40/550A/067==.8.9 /57/>./0/012.306/5.12.4516=7>>.9/5.9.:.76.9767 3.6;=/ 1< 450:5 5. <.== 9142 729 90.9 !./0/012.3 06 733.6/.912(&&'</.3:1A>=./028/5.02C.6/087/012 :5738.65../06<0=.9126.D;.2/=?21=128.3/5.:;6/1907= >3.6.2:. 1< >./0/012.3 06 3.D;03.9 <13 /5. >;3>16. 1< 02C.6/087/012 =3.79? 7::;6.9 1 /1 ( 73. 8372/.9B70=<:1;36./5.3.067>>3.5.2601212/5.>73/ 1<>316.:;/012/57/>./0/012.3A7?/53.7/.213/7A>.340/5 /5.40/2.66.67297=617B6:12914.C.3/5.67A.A7? B. 1C.3:1A. B? 0A>16028 6/3028.2/ :1290/0126 %13 /5. 7B1C.3.76126/506:1;3/061</5.:12609.3.91>02012/57/ - 8 - >./0/012.3 06 .2/0/=.9 <13 B70= 6;BF.:/ /1 :1290/0126 729 7::139028=?/5.<1==14028 !./0/012067==14.9!./0/012.3 7::;6.91' 06 3.=.76.9 12 B70= 02 30A. 1& &' 1< =9*;BB7==0 !1=0:. /7/012 <13 /5. 1<<.2:. >;20657B=. ;29.3 .:/0126 &) &* (& 3 4 .:/012')1<!6;BF.://1<1==14028 7$ 5.>./0/012.3 7::;6.91'657==.E.:;/.7 >.36127= B129 02 7 6;A 1< 6&&&&& * 40/5/416;3./0.6<13/5.=0@.*6;A B$ . 657== <;32065 506 3.609.2/07= 7993.66 >311< 729 657== 02<13A /5. 02C.6/087/028 1<<0:.3 1;3/ 0< /5.3. 06 72? :5728. 02 /5. 7993.66 :$ . 657== 21/ /7A>.3 40/5 /5. >316.:;/012 40/2.66.6.0/5.3903.:/=?1302903.:/=? - 9 - 9$ . 657== 21/ 029;=8. 02 72? :30A027= 7:/0C0/0.6 .$ . 657== B. 3.8;=73 02 7//.29028 /5. 1;3/ >31:..90286 !-, (&% '+ & ! 06/1) =1