Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 26263 (KAR)

A R SRINIVASA v. STATE BY PETE POLICE STATION

CRL.RP/647/2017 · 2025-02-27

S Rachaiah

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$ # % & ! "! # $! " % " " ! !!" # $! "% "!& !'( "!!" ) *!! " ) "!! ! * + " & " " ) )! !&!"! (! ! " " " "!"! ! (, , & & " " & " ( &" &" " ! " !!" & " & " & Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " - )" " % ! ./0 123/0/45 627/7/45 /0 8/92: ;< 7.2 627/7/4521 ;2/5= >==1/232:;<7.2?45?@112578/5:/5=0487.2"4@17;294A /512?41:/5=7.2?453/?7/458417.248825?2@5:212?/745 $% >5: 48 " A.212 7.2 627/7/4521 .>: ;225 ?453/?72:8417.2>;4320>/:48825?20! ! .21>5B0487.26>17/20A4@9:;2?450/:212:.25?28417. >06217.2/11>5B/5=0/57.21/>9"4@17841?45325/25?2! '()*+,-,.)+*-) '! 61/3>72?4C69>/57?>C274;28/92:;<!!>:>0./3> ;28412 7.2 >=/071>72 07>7/5= 7.>7 .2 ;2945=0 74 7.2 >3<>B>?4CC@5/7<>5:.2/0452487.2:/0?/6920481/ >C>?.>5:1>6@1> @77!7/007>72:7.>7C>5<:2347220 >12 84994A/5= 7.2 ?@074C0 48 7.2 0>/: @77! 2 8@17.21 07>7207.>77.2>??@02:;2/5=>6@;9/0.21487.2A22B9< C>=>D/52 5>C29< E >55/5> >0>52F .>: 6@;9/0.2: > :28>C>741< >17/?92 >=>/507 7.2 =@1@ 48 1/ >C>?.>5:1>6@1> @77 >992=/5= ?217>/5 8>?70 A./?. >12 - 3 - 8>1 >A>< 814C 7.2 71@7.! < 6@;9/0./5= 7.2 0>/: 07>72C2570 .2 71/2: 74 :232946 25C/7< >C45=07 7.2 ?4CC@5/7<7.2128412>0@/7>;92>?7/45C><;2/5/7/>72: >=>/507 7.2 627/7/4521 >??@02:! &@17.21 /7 /0 07>72: 7.>7 45 *! !( .2 547 459< 6@;9/0.2: 7.2 0>/: >17/?92 /5 7.2 A22B9< C>=>D/52 ;@7 >904 :/071/;@72: 6>C6.9270747.26@;9/?>79>1=2! ! >02: 45 7.2 0>/: ?4C69>/57 7.2 92>152: >=/071>72 1282112: 7.2 ?4C69>/57 74 7.2 G@1/0:/?7/45>9 >=/071>72! @10@>57 74 7.2 41:21 48 7.2 "4@17 & ?>C2 74 ;2 12=/07212: ;< 7.2 G@1/0:/?7/45>9 649/?2 /5 "1/C2 4!(8417.2>;4320>/:48825?20! ! 4 61432 7.2 ?>02 48 7.2 61402?@7/45 7.2 61402?@7/45 2H>C/52: A/7520020>00! 74 >5:=47C>1B2: :4?@C2570>0 H0! 74 ! 57.247.21.>5:0/H :4?@C2570 A212 C>1B2: 45 ;2.>98 48 7.2 >??@02: >0 H0! 74'!.21/>9"4@17>8721>6612?/>7/5=7.241>9 >5: :4?@C257>1< 23/:25?2 45 12?41: 12?41:2: 7.2 ?453/?7/45 841 7.2 48825?20 07>72: 0@61>! 5 >662>9 - 4 - ;2/5= 8/92: 7.2 0>C2 A>0 ?458/1C2: ;< 7.2 66299>72 "4@17! ! 2>1: 1/!C20. 449/C>5/ 92>152: ?4@5029 841 627/7/4521>5:1/!!>=20.A>1>66>92>152:/=."4@17 43215C25792>:218417.2120645:2577>72! ! 7 /0 7.2 0@;C/00/45 48 7.2 92>152: ?4@5029 841 7.2 627/7/4521 7.>7 7.2 41:21 48 12C>5:/5= 7.2 C>7721 841 ?4C69/>5?2 @5:21 2?7/45 ( 48 7.2 "4:2 48 "1/C/5>9 14?2:@12 $841 0.417 E"1!!"F% >5: 74 614?22: A/7. 7.2 ?>02>8120.>5::/06402487.2C>7721/5>??41:>5?2A/7. 7.29>A747.21/>9"4@17/0?4571>1<747.20>/:6143/0/45 >5:7.20>C2/09/>;9274;2027>0/:2! *! 7/08@17.210@;C/772:7.>77.241:21485474;7>/5/5=7.2 0>5?7/45 ;28412 7>B/5= ?4=5/D>5?2 /0 547 > 614?2:@12 .4A2321 /7 /0 > C>5:>741< 12I@/12C257! >3/5= 547 84994A2:7.20>/:614?2:@12/0547/112=@9>1/7<;@7/7/0 /992=>9! .2128412 7>B/5= ?4=5/D>5?2 .>0 74 ;2 =452! 4A23217.266299>72"4@17?450/:21/5=/7>012=@9>1/7< >5:1282112:7.2C>7721747.21/>9"4@17/0@5G@07>5: 2114524@0! .2128412 7.2 41:21 48 7.2 66299>72 "4@17 - 5 - 12I@/12:74;2027>0/:2! >B/5=0@?.0@;C/00/4507.2 92>152: ?4@5029 841 7.2 627/7/4521 61><0 74 >994A 7.2 627/7/45! (! 21?4571>7.292>152:"8417.2120645:2577>72 ?4571432172:7.20>C2>5:.28@17.210@;C/772:7.>77.2 0>/:0>5?7/45814C7.243215C257?>5>904;24;7>/52: 2325 >7 7.2 ;29>72: 07>=2! .2128412 7.2 41:21 48 12C>5:/5= 74 022B 0>5?7/45 A4@9: ;2 >661461/>72 >5: 12923>57 >5: 7.212 /0 54 /58/1C/7< /5 7.2 0>/: 41:21! >3/5=0>/:7.@07.292>152:"61><074:/0C/007.2 627/7/45! ! >3/5= .2>1: 7.2 92>152: ?4@5029 841 7.2 12062?7/32 6>17/20 >5: >904 621@02: 7.2 8/5:/5=0 48 7.2 66299>72 "4@17/512C>5:/5=7.2C>7721/7/052?200>1<742H71>?7 2?7/45 ($ %48"1!!"A./?.12>:0>0@5:21 - 6 - !" !# $%&'(#) * ** ) + , -, * . -, * / 0 12 ! 512>:/5=487.2>;4320>/:6143/0/45/7C>B20/7?92>1 7.>7747>B2?4=5/D>5?24848825?2@5:212?7/45$% 48"0>5?7/452/7.21814C7.2"2571>943215C25741 7>72 43215C257 41 /071/?7 >=/071>72 48 ?4@102 /0 C>5:>741<>5:52?200>1<! ! 5 7./0 ?>02 /7 /0 522:9200 74 0>< 7.>7 0@?. 0>5?7/45 814C7.2?4C627257>@7.41/7<.>0547;2254;7>/52:;< 7.2 53207/=>7/5= 88/?21! .2 1/>9 "4@17 744B ?4=5/D>5?2 48 7.2 0>/: 48825?20 A/7.4@7 4;7>/5/5= 7.2 0>5?7/45>5:12?41:2:7.2?453/?7/45!.27.210@?.>5 >?7487.21/>9"4@17/0G@07/8/2:41547/07.2I@207/45 12I@/12:74;2:2>97A/7./5>??41:>5?2A/7.9>A! '! 07.26143/0/45/70298A4@9:/5:/?>72 7.>7;284127>B/5= ?4=5/D>5?2/7/0C>5:>741<7.>77.20>5?7/45.>074;2 - 7 - 4;7>/52:814C7.2?4C627257>@7.41/7<7461402?@727.2 6210458417.248825?2@5:212?7/45$%48"!.2 53207/=>7/5= 88/?21.>05474;7>/52:7.20>5?7/45814C 7.2 ?4C627257 >@7.41/7< 7.2 1/>9 "4@17 4@=.7 547 74 .>32 7>B25 ?4=5/D>5?2 841 7.2 48825?2 @5:21 2?7/45 $%48"!.21284127.241:21487>B/5=?4=5/D>5?2 /512062?7482?7/45$%48":4205470@13/32841 ?450/:21>7/45>5:C41243217.241:214812C>5:747>B2 ?4=5/D>5?2A4@9:547>1/02>87216>00/5=7.2G@:=C257! .21284127.241:214812C>5:6>002:;<7.266299>72 "4@17:4205470@13/32>5:/7522:074;2027>0/:2! ! .2 ?4C69>/5>57 .>0 8/92: > ?4C69>/57 /5 12062?7 48 2?7/45 $% >5: 2?7/45 48 "! 0 12=>1:0 2?7/45 $% 48 " .>0 ;225 >50A212: >0 07>72: >;432/7/052?200>1<742?7/4548"! ! 0 12=>1:0 2?7/45 48 " /0 ?45?2152: 7.2 0>C2 12>:0>0@5:21 ! 3 , ** ** * ** ) , - 8 - * * + * *) + * * * + * + ) * , 12 ! 512>:/5=487.2>;4320>/:6143/0/45/7C>B20/7?92>1 7.>7?1/C/5>9/57/C/:>7/45;<>545<C4@0?4CC@5/?>7/45 41 .>3/5= 7>B25 7.2 612?>@7/45 74 ?45?2>9 7.2 5>C2 41 >;4:2487.2621045814CA.4C7.27.12>7?4C20! ! :C/772:9< /5 7.2 6120257 ?>02 7.2 >992=>7/45 C>:2 >=>/507 7.2 6120257 627/7/4521 /0 7.>7 .2 .>: 6@;9/0.2: :28>C>741<12C>1B04107>72C2570>=>/5077.20.22148 @77 >5: >904 :/071/;@72: 7.2 6>C6.9270 ;< 6@;9/0./5= 7.2:28>C>741<07>72C2570! *! .27.21 7.2 61402?@7/45 .>0 61432: 7.>7 7.2 >??@02: .>0 :/071/;@72: 7.2 6>C6.9270 41 6@;9/0.2: 7.2 :28>C>741< >17/?920 /5 ./0 A22B9< C>=>D/52 .>0 74 ;2 ?450/:212:;<7.223/:25?248>997.2A/7520020! - 9 - (! ! ;2/5=7.2?4C69>/5>57.>::26402:/5./023/:25?2 7.>7 7.212 A212 04C2 :28>C>741< 07>72C2570 /5 7.2 A22B9<C>=>D/526@;9/0.2:;<7.2>??@02:!2>:C/772: /5./023/:25?27.>70/C/9>1>17/?920A2126@;9/0.2:/57.2 A22B9< C>=>D/52 ?>992: E/ 25=>9@1@F >5: >904 /5 7.2 E/C20 48 5:/>F :>/9< 52A06>621! 2 8@17.21 >:C/772: 7.>7 .2 .>: 547 7>B25 >5< >?7/45 2/7.21 >=>/507 7.2 52A06>621 41 C>=>D/52! 2 8@17.21 >:C/772: 7.>7 .2 .>: 547 0225 A.212 7.2 6>C6.9270 A212 61/572: >5: 6@;9/0.2:! 4A2321 .2 0712002: 7.>7 6>C6.9270 A212 ;2/5=:/071/;@72:;<7.2>??@02:! ! /C/9>19< 0! >5: >12 7.2 /5:2625:257 A/75200207.2<.>3207>72:7.>77.2>??@02:.>:=/325 C>=>D/520>5:6>C6.9270>5:>0B2:7.2C74=/327.2/1 46/5/45! 4A2321 /5 7.2 ?1400,2H>C/5>7/45 7.2< >:C/772:7.>77.2<?4@9:547614:@?2>5<:4?@C257074 0.4A 7.>7 7.2< A212 6120257 >7 7.2 69>?2 A.212 /7 /0 >992=2:7.>77.26>C6.9270>5:C>=>D/520A212=/32574 7.2C! - 10 - ! /C/9>19< ! 7.2 53207/=>7/5= 88/?21 7.4@=. .2 07>72:7.>7.202/D2:7.2C>=>D/52>77.2.4@02487.2 >??@02:.2:/:54702?@127.2/5841C>7/4512=>1:/5=7.2 69>?2A.2127.26>C6.9270A21261/572:>5:6@;9/0.2:! ! 5 ?>128@9 12>:/5= 48 7.2 23/:25?2 48 >;432 A/7520020 7.2/5=12:/2570482?7/4548"?>5547;2>771>?72: >=>/507 7.2 >??@02:! 4A2321 7.2 "4@170 ;294A .>32 ?45?@112579<.29:7.>77.2>??@02:.>0;22584@5:=@/97< /5 12062?7 48 7.2 48825?20 07>72: 0@61> >12 ?4571>1< 74 7.223/:25?24512?41:!.21284127.20>C2/09/>;9274 ;2027>0/:2! '! 57.29/=.7487.24;0213>7/450C>:2>;432614?22:74 6>007.284994A/5= $/% .2"1/C/5>923/0/4527/7/45/0+1 $//% .2 G@:=C257 48 ?453/?7/45 >5: 41:21 48 025725?2 :>72: (! ! 6>002: /5 "!"!4! ;< 7.2 "4@17 48 1/5?/6>9 "/3/9 )@:=2 >5: ) &" >=>1 >5: 7.2 G@:=C257 >5: 41:21 :>72: *!! 6>002: /5 "19!! - 11 - 4! * ;< 7.2 "4@17 48 ::/7/45>9 /071/?7>5:200/450)@:=2./3>C4==>/77/5= >7>=>1>12027>0/:2! $///% .2627/7/4521/0>?I@/772:8417.248825?20@5:21 2?7/450$%>5:48"! $/3% >/9;45:02H2?@72:/8>5<07>5:?>5?2992:! /01 2 3 $ /074! 94!'