Page No.# 1/29 GAHC010060872024 undefined THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) Case No. : Review.Pet./46/2024 THE DIRECTOR GENERAL AND ORS. BORDER ROADS ORGANIZATION (BRO) SEEMA SADAK BHAWAN, RING ROAD, DELHI CANTT. , NEW DELHI-110010 2: THE SECRETARY BORDER ROADS DEVELOPMENT BOARD NO. 418 B WING 4TH FLOOR SENA BHAWAN DHQ PO NEW DELHI-110011. 3: THE PRINCIPAL CONTROLLER OF DEFENCE ACCOUNTS (BORDER ROADS) SEEMA SADAK BHAWAN DELHI CANTT. NEW DELHI-110010 VERSUS GS-162973N SRI BRIJ BHUWAN RAM AND 150 ORS S/O LATE RAMDEO RAM, R/O VILLAGE BAIJ NATH PUR, P.O. KHANJURA PHULAICH, DIST. AZAMGARH, UTTAR PRADESH-276126. 2:GS-164445H- BISHAN SINGH PINGAL S/O LATE SHRI KISHAN SINGH PINGAL R/O VILLAGE JOSHIKHET P.O. KALIKA THE-DHARCHULA DIST. PITHORAGARH UTTARAKHAND 262576. Page No.# 2/29 3:GS-168795M- RAMESH CHANDRA S/O SHRI BHARAT SINGH R/O VILLAGE SUSAIN P.O. NASIRPUR DIST. MATHURA UTTAR PRADESH-281001. 4:GS-170944N- DEVICHARAN SHARMA S/O LATE GAJRAJ SHARMA R/O NAI BASTI ANAJ MANDI VILL. AND P.O. PAHASU DIST. BULANDSHAHAR UTTAR PRADESH-203396. 5:GS-172577L- SUNIL KUMAR MISHRA S/O LATE SHRI DHARAM DEO MISHRA R/O VILLAGE AND P.O. SHEORIWARAYAN DIST JANJGIR-CHAMPA CHATTISGARH-495557. 6:GS-176044A-ASHOK KUMAR S/O SRI RAM KISHOR VISHWAKARMA R/O VILL. NARAYANPUR P.O. BASKHARI DIST. LAKHANPUR AMBEDKARNAGAR UTTAR PRADESH-224129. 7:GS-176114N-RAMA SHANKAR RAI S/O LATE SHRI MANA RAKHAN RAI R/O VILL. AND P.O. DHARNI DIST. GHAZIPUR UTTAR PRADESH-232336. 8:GS-182020M-CHANDRA KANT PRASAD S/O SRI RAMADHAR SAH R/O VILL AND P.O.-LATEHAR DIST-LATEHAR JHARKHAND-829206 9:GS-183225N-PRADEEP KUMAR CHATURVEDI S/O SHRI SURENDRA NATH CHAUBEY Page No.# 3/29 R/O 868/16 KRISHNA NAGAR NAINI ALLAHABAD UTTAR PRADESH-211003 10:GS-185164A-RAJESH S S/O SUBRAMANI YAN R/O SOUTH KADAVARAYAR STREET KALLAR PASUPATI KOVIL P.O.-PASOPATHI KOVIL DIST- THANJAVIR TAMIL NADU-614206 11:GS-185256M-K BALU S/O KANDASAMY R/O 1/5 MANAKKADU PIRANDAGAM VELA KAVUNDANPATTI P.O.-VELLUR (TK) NAMKKAL TAMIL NADU-637212 12:GS-181915Y-A. SANJAY GANDHI S/O S. ANNASAMY R/O 36 KAMARAJAR ST KANJIVOY P.O.-MELAPARUTHIKUDI DIST-CUDDALORE TAMIL NADU-608302 13:GS-177085W-BHS ISHWARA RAJU S/O SURYA NARAYANA RAJU R/O D NO. 4/23 INDRAPALEM DIST- KAKINADA EG ANDHRA PRADESH-533006 14:GS-003858F-S.D. NAUTIYAL S/O SHRI B.D. NAUTIYAL R/O VILL- BASELI P.O.-CHERABDLAR PATTI-RAIKA DIST- TEHRI GARWAL UTTARAKHAND-249165 15:GA-183433H-RAJENDRA PRASAD PANT S/O LATE HARI BALLABH PANT R/O VILL- RAJOULI P.O.-VIJAYPUR DIST-BAGESHWAR UTTARAKHAND-263640 Page No.# 4/29 16:GS-168705A-JAGDISH SINGH S/O RAM CHANDER SINGH R/O VILL- KHIRIYA P.O.-SALEMPUR DIST- MAINPURI UTTAR PRADESH-205265 17:GS-185570A-MAYANJ SAXENA S/O LATE HAR SWAROOP SAXENA R/O HOUSE NO. 313 SHYAM BHAWAN BEHARIPUR KEHARWAN BAREILLY P.O.- CITY POST OFFICE BAREILLY UTTAR PRADESH-243003 18:GS-181089X-ARUN KUMAR B S/O BABY N R/O VASUMATHY BHAWAN VALIYA PARMAPU P.O.-KARTHIKAPALLY ALAPUZHA KERALA-690516 19:GS-173993F-DHARMENDRA KUMAR PANDEY S/O LATE VACHAS PATI PANDEY R/O 538 KA/751 TRIVENI NAGAR (NEAR ALHUDA MODEL SCHOOL) LUCKNOW UTTAR PRADESH-226020 20:GS-176824L-RAJESH KAMBOJ S/O MEHER SINGH KAMBOJ R/O PREM PURI COLONY MITTAL NURSERY NEAR SWAMY SIKSHA NIKETAN BEHAT ROAD SAHARANPUR UTTAR PRADESH-247001 21:GO-3658P-MANORANJAN BRAHMA S/O NALENDRA BRAHMA R/O VILL-PURANI GORAIBARI P.O.-UDALGURI DIST-UDALGURI ASSAM-784509 22:GO-4134W-NARENDRA MALVIYA S/O PANNALAL MALVIYA Page No.# 5/29 R/O VILL AND P.O.-DHAMNOD MUKTANAND PARISAR COLONY THEDHARAMPURI DIST-DHAR MADHYA PRADESH-454552 23:GS-162547A-OM PRAKASH VARSHNEY S/O SHRI MANGI LAL R/O CHAUMUHAN P.O.-CHAUMUHAN DIST-MATHURA UTTAR PRADESH-281406 24:GS-196143K-GIREESH G S/O GOPI N R/O OTTAKANDATHIL MUTHUKULAM MUTHUKULAM SOUTH P.O.-ALAPPUZHA KERALA-690506 25:GS-180137M-DINESH KUMAR S/O SOHAN LAL R/O VILL-BAIRAL P.O.-AMARGARH DIST-BULANDSHAHAR UTTAR PRADESH-203398 26:GS-178462N-RAJEEV KUMAR SHARMA S/O SHRI R.N. SHARMA R/O SRINANDAN PATH WEST OF DISTRICT BOARD OFFICE PLUNCHIPAL CHAWK CHAPRA SARAN BIHAR-840301 27:GS-182204L-MADHU DIVAKARAN S/O K DIVAKARAN R/O DRA-112A NANDANAM HOUSE NEAR KOLLAVILLA TEMPLES KESAVADASAPURAM PATTOM P.O.-THIRUVANANTHAPURAM KERALA-695004 28:GS-183435N-BHUWAN CHANDRA SINGH S/O CHANDAN SINGH Page No.# 6/29 R/O VILL-JAMRAR (NAULA) P.O.-NAULA DIST-ALMORA UTTARAKHAND-263658 29:GS-169634W-NANDLAL GOND S/O SHRI SURREV GOND R/O S/9/38/BEHIND POLICE CHOWKI SAHABGANJ FAIZABAD UTTAR PRADESH-224001 30:GS-188554N-RAJU KUMAR PRASAD S/O RAMANANDAN PRASAD R/O WARD NO. 1 SIGANL COLONY MARIANI ASSAM-785634 31:GS-163009Y-SHRI OM PRAKASH S/O SHRI VIJENDRA SINGH R/O VILL AND P.O.-KACHORA VIA ACHNERA DIST- AGRA UTTAR PRADESH-283101 32:GO-3658L-ASHOK KUMAR TYAGI S/O LATE KANTI PRASAD R/O VILL AND P.O.-CHODIALA T AND G ROORKEE DIST-HARIDWAR UTTARAKHAND-247667 33:GS-171185L-GIRJESH MISHRA S/O SHRI RAM AWADH PRASAD MISHRA R/O A-37 AVAS-VIKAS COLONY SHAHPUR P.O.-GITA VATIKA DIST- GORAKHPUR UTTAR PRADESH-273006 34:GS-192341X-RAJIV KUMAR TIWARI S/O BIRENDRA KUMAR TIWARI R/O MAIN COLONY P.O. AND P.S.-SUDAMDIH DIST- DHANBAD JHARKHAND-828126 Page No.# 7/29 35:GS-175840W-JITENDRA KUMAR YADAV S/O SURYA DEO YADAV R/O VILL AND P.O.-JIGANI DIST-BALLIA UTTAR PRADESH-277121 36:GS-179481L-D EESWARAN S/O P D HARMALINGAM R/O 56 VAIGAI COLONY ANNA NAGAR MADURAI TAMIL NADU-625020 37:GO-3840L-PASHUPATI NATH OJHA S/O BADRI NATH OJAH R/O VILL-OJHA KE CHAPARA P.O.-HANUMAN GANJ DIST-BALLIA UTTAR PRADESH-277001 38:GS-194484W CHANDRA PRATAP SINGH S/O CHANDRA PAL SINGH R/O 539 SANJEEV NAGAR POLICE SOCIETY COLONY P.O.- ML NAGAR NEON DIST- BHOPAL MADHYA PRADESH-462038 39:GS-194477A-LAXMI NARAYAN DUBEY S/O SHANKAR DAYAL DUBEY R/O VILL-GHUREHATA (PARUHAN TOLA) P.O.-MAUGANJ DIST-REWA MADHYA PRADESH-486331 40:GS-183149M-RAVINDER KUMAR S/O BRIJ PAL SINGH R/O VILL- BHANGERI P.O.-MILAP NAGAR ROORKEE DIST- HARIDWAR UTTARAKHAND-247667 41:GS-181886P-VINOD M S/O MAHARAJAN P R/O VILL-NEDUM THARAYIL Page No.# 8/29 KEERIKADU SOUTH P.O.-KAYAMKULAM DIST- ALAPUZHA KERALA-690502 42:GS-183145W-MADAN KUMAR S/O BHOLA DAS R/O VILL-BETWAN BAZAR P.O.-MUNGER DIST-MUNGER BIHAR-811201 43:GS-183388F-PARTHA PRATIM DUTTA S/O LATE MADAN MOHAN DUTTA R/O F/R-4/1 JYANGRA (S) 24 PARGANAS (N) KOLKATA WEST BENGAL-700059 44:GS-176540F-SANJIT KUMAR DAS S/O LATE SACHINDRA CHANDRA DAS R/O VILL- DHAKAPARA P.O.-DAYER BAZAR DIST- NADIYA WEST BENGAL-741164 45:GS-175910K-GYAN SINGH PATEL S/O SHRI KARTIK RAM PATEL R/O VILL AND P.O.-DHAWALPUR DIST-RAIPUR CHATTISGARH-493889 46:GS-192452P-SANJAY KUMAR SAH S/O LATE SHRI LALLAN SAH R/O BHAKRAPARA PART-2 DOLAIGAON OPPOSITE DULARI MEDICAL HALL P.O. AND DIST-BONGAIGAON ASSAM-783380 47:GS-176788L-VIJAY PRASAD S/O LATE BADRI PRASAD R/O VILL AND P.O.-SADAR BAZAR JAGDISHPUR DIST-BHOJPUR (ARA) BIHAR-811214 Page No.# 9/29 48:GS-176135K-VIJANI NARAIN S/O RAM PALAT UPADHYAY R/O VILL-DEORIYA (BUZURG) P.O.-DEORIYA DIST- AMBEDKARNAAGR UTTAR PRADESH-224137 49:GS-194573P-HARI NARAIN ROY S/O SUBIR KUMAR ROY R/O VILL AND P.O.-NASSIGRAM DIST-BURDWAN WEST BENGAL-713165 50:GS-185565P-ABHAYA PAL SINGH S/O SHEESH PAL SINGH R/O HOUSE NO. 487 GALI NO. 487 GALI NO. 3 ANANDPURI MUZAFFARNAGAR UTTAR PRADESH-251001 51:GS-185566X AMIT KUMAR S/O SHRI BALENDRA SINGH R/O VILL AND P.O.-TANA DIST- MAZAFFAR NAGAR UTTAR PRADESH-247773 52:GS-174206F-AVARAN SINGH S/O SHRI PUNJABI SINGH R/O VILL AND P.O.-MOHAKMPUR DIST- ALIGARH UTTAR PRADESH-202145 53:GS-176106P-DHANANJAY KUSHWAHA S/O SHRI RAJ NARAIN R/O VILL-JAGDISHPUR P.O.-BANKAT (SEWAPURI) DIST-VARANASI UTTAR PRADESH-221403 54:GS-164446L-LALIT MOHAN OJHA S/O LATE HIRA BALLABH OJHA R/O VILL-KAPHALAUJI P.O.-SINGALI DIST-PITHORAGARH UTTARAKHAND-262543 55:GS-174894L-ARABINDA KUMAR PAN Page No.# 10/29 S/O LATE SHRI BISHWA RANJAN PAN R/O NEAR KM HIGH SCHOOL P.O.-BISHNUPUR DIST- BANKURA WEST BENGAL-722122 56:GS-181892H-RAMESH S/O SHRI SABHAJIT YADAV R/O VILL AND P.O.-NOORPUR KALAN DIST-AMBEDKARNAGAR UAATR PRADESH-224139 57:GS-180206X-SURAJ BHAN SAINI S/O SHRI HARPRASAD SAINI R/O MOHALLA - KOT KALAN P.O.-SHIKARPUR DIST- BULANDSHAHAR UTTAR PRADESH-203395 58:GO-04024F-JP SURYABANSHI S/O BP SURYABANSHI R/O TANSEN ROAD IN FRONT OF MPEB GWALIOR MADHYA PRADESH-474002 59:GO-3561A-JP YADAV S/O RAM KARAN YADAV R/O VILL-KATAHRI P.O.-SAHASHEPUR DIST-SANT RAVIDASNAGAR (BHADOHI) UTTAR PRADESH-221306 60:GS-176193N-RAJPAL SINGH S/O SRI NATTHU SINGH R/O VILL- HASANGARH P.O.-REJUA (JALESAR) DIST-ETAH UTTAR PRADESH-207302 61:GS-181390A-TAHIR BAHARUDDIN SIDDIQUI S/O SHRI BAHRUDDIN SIDDIQUI R/O VILL-AHMADPUR PAWAN P.O.-MANAURI TEHSIL SADAR DIST-ALLAHABAD UTTAR PRADESH-212208 Page No.# 11/29 62:GS-185919M- P KARTHIKEYAN S/O SHRI G. PALANIVELU R/O 2/224 RLY STATION ROAD VANDALUR CHENNAI TAMIL NADU-600048 63:GS-177012K-S ASHOK S/O G SUBBAIAH R/O 4/80 A TAMZHINI STREET KURINJI NAGAR THANAK ANKULAM P.O.-THIRUNAGAR MADURAI TAMIL NADU-625006 64:GS-178566P-MUKESH KUMAR SHARMA S/O SH. RAM PAL R/O VILL AND P.O.-KALRUHI THE-AMB DIST-UNA HIMACHAL PRADESH-177203 65:GS-177011F-G KRISHNAMOORTHY S/O L GABURANNAN R/O H NO. 205 VEERAPATHRA SWAMY VOTTOM KURUMANS COLONY P.O.-PACHAL TIRUPATTUR DIST- VELLORE TAMIL NADU-635601 66:GS-176133-AJAY GUPTA S/O GULAB CHANDRA GUPTA R/O VILL AND P.O.-SOHAON DIST-BALLIA UTTAR PRADESH-277504 67:GS-164357M-RAJ KUMAR S/O LATE KANWAR BHAN PRUTHI R/O HOUSE NO. 858 WARD NO. 20 DURGA COLONY ROHTAK DIST- ROHTAK Page No.# 12/29 HARYANA-124001 68:GS-176542M-PERUMAL K S/O KALIANNAN R/O NO. 110 C KANAK KAMAADAI ELACHIPALAYAN P.O.-TIRUCHENGODE NAMAKKAL TAMIL NADU-637211 69:GS-177010Y-JOY C.L. S/O C.R. LONAPPAN R/O CHULLY HOUSE P.O.-KALLUR DIST-THRISSUR KERALA-680317 70:GS-162678L-TULARAM SHRIRAME S/O DHARMAJI SHRIRAME R/O VYENKATESH NAGAR BUILDING NO. 6 TYPE-E/21 2ND FLOOR NANDAN VAN NAGPUR MAHARASTRA-440024 71:GS-164442-PANKAJ KUMAR RANA S/O KS RANA R/O BASANT VIHAR COLONY CHOTI MUKHANI P.O.-MUKHANI HALDWANI DIST-NAINITAL-263139 72:GS-169552N- HARENDRA OJHA S/O SHRI G D OJHA R/O VILL AND P.O.-SINGALI DIST-PITHORAGARH UTTARAKHAND-262543 73:GS-177054W-PAWAN KUMAR K.V.S. S/O SHRI K.V. APPAVADJANULU R/O 103-16/B/A HUMAYUN NAGAR HYDERABAD-500028 74:GS-176323L-INDRA PRASAD Page No.# 13/29 S/O SHRI ANANT NARAYAN PRADHAN R/O RAM JANKI NAGAR NEAR DURGA MANDIR P.O.-BASARAT PUR DIST-GORAKHPUR UTTAR PRADESH-273004 75:GS-176877K-SANJEEV KUMAR SRIVASTAVA S/O BIPIN BEHARI SRIVASTAVA R/O 293/211 OLD HAIDER GANJ LUCKNOW UTTAR PRADESH-226004 76:GS-177464M-SACHIN KUMAR GOEL S/O SHRI KANWAR SAIN R/O G.T. ROAD PURKANJ MUZAFFARNAGAR UTTAR PRADESH-251317 77:GS-173831W-SURENDRA KUMAR S/O SHRI JIT SINGH R/O VILL- GAOERHERI P.O.-SARSAWA DIST- SHARANPUR UTTAR PRADESH-247232 78:GS-176679Y-TRIGUNA PRASAD MANDAL S/O SHRI KP MANDAL R/O VILL- BAHBANIPUR PONUTANGRAM DIST- PURULIA WEST BENGAL-723121 79:GS-174808P-SHEO KUMAR NIRALA S/O SHRI RAMJI RAM R/O VILL-SALARPUR P.O.-RASOOLGARH DIST-VARANASI UTTAR PRADESH-221007 80:GS-163221A-SHEELENDRA KUMAR S/O RAM KHILARI R/O 23/3 VIBAHV P.O. AND DIST-HATHRAS NAGAR HATHRAS UTTAR PRADESH-204101 Page No.# 14/29 81:GS-178375A-NIJOY BASUMATARI S/O LATE KRISHNA BASUMATARI R/O VILL AND P.O.-BARJURI P.S.-SAMAGURI DIST-NAGAON ASSAM-782139 82:GS-174318F-THAKUR KAMLESH KUMAR S/O THAKUR INDRADEO SINGH R/O 3/30 BIHAR SAHARA STATE P.O.-KHORABAR DIST- GORAKHPUR UTTAR PRADESH-237010 83:GS-176043X-RAJESH KUMAR VERMA S/O LATE S K VERMA R/O HOUSE NO. B-1/205 HIMSAGAR APARTMENT PLOT NO. 11 GEATER NOIDA GAUTAM BUDHA NAGAR UTTAR PRADESH-201310 84:GS-185504X-VISHNU PRAKASH S/O SHRI RAM LAKHAN R/O VILL- GOHLIYA PURWA P.O.-NANAMU VIA BILHAUR DIST- KANPUR NAGAR UTTAR PRADESH-209202 85:GS-194886N-GANESH KHADE S/O SHRI KHADE RANAJIT BABU RAO R/O VILL AND P.O.-RAJOURI TEHSIL JAMKHED DIST-AHMEDNAGAR MAHARASTRA-413204 86:GS-164406K-HIRA BALLABH BHATT S/O LATE KESHAV DUTT BHATT R/O PAWAN VIHAR COLONY DIN P.O.-DIN DIST-PITHORGARH UTTARAKHAND-262501 87:GS-182205N-P ANANDARAJ S/O SHRI A PANDIA RAJAN Page No.# 15/29 R/O 3/176A RC STREET VILL AND P.O.-INAM REDDIA PATTI DIST-VIRUDHU NAGAR TAMIL NADU-626003 88:GS-188332Y-TUPPAD S/O CHANDRASHEKHAR GANAPPA R/O PL NO. 12B VIDYUT NAGAR NEAR RAILWAY STATION DIST-JALNA MAHARASTRA 89:GS-174865W-RAMESH CHAND BHARMOTA S/O DASS RAM R/O SHIV MANDIR WALI GALI CENTRAL TOWN HOSHIARPUR PUNJAB-144001 90:GS-194924Y-ARVIND SINGH R/O 90 RCC (GREF) C/O 99 APO 91:GS-170783W-SOBARAN SINGH S/O THAKUR SINGH R/O HOUSE NO. 62 AMBEDKAR NAGAR (NALEPAR PIPAL WALI GALI) SIRSAGANJ DIST-FIROZABAD UTTAR PRADESH-205151 92:GS-176116-RAKESH CHANDRA SRIVASTAVA S/O LATE JAISINGH PRASAD SRIVASTAVA R/O H/NO. 172 MOH-BADEKAZIPUR DIST-GORAKHPUR UTTAR PRADESH-273001 93:GS-163438A-RAM ASRE GAUTAM S/O BHAWANI DIN R/O MOHALLA-PAGAMBERPUR (NEW COLONY) P.O.-BILDKI DIST-FATEHPUR UTTAR PRADESH-212635 94:GS-172858F-SUSHIL CHAND GARKOTI Page No.# 16/29 S/O LATE TRILOCHAN GARKOTI R/O NEAR HYDLE COLONY TALLA PATAN P.O.-LOHAGHAT DIST-CHAMPAWAT UTTARAKHAND-262524 95:GS-170080P- V KASHIRAJAN S/O T K VARATHA RAJAN R/O HOUSE NO. 3 THIRD STREET BALAJI AVENUE P.O.-THATCHANALLUR TRIUNELVELI TAMIL NADU-627358 96:GS-183391F-S B BARMAN S/O LATE RANJIT BARMAN R/O VILL-BIJOYPUR P.O.-BARKHOLA DIST-CACHAR ASSAM-788110 97:GS-175604P-PRADEEP KUMAR S/O LATE KUNJU PILLAI R/O KEERTHANAM P.O. ALLUMPEEDIKA DIST. KOLLAM KERALA-690547 98:GS-181284F-V BALABASKARAN S/O V. VADIVELU R/O VILL. KOTHAPURINATHAM P.O. PERIYABABUSAMUTHARAM DIST. PONDICHERRY PONDICHERRY-605102 99:GS-179798-GANESH SINGH BUM S/O LATE GOVARDHAN SINGH BUM R/O VILL. JAKHANI P.O. PITHORAGARH UTTARAKHAND-252501 100:GS-172281M-DHARAMVEER SINGH S/O LATE SUMER SINGH Page No.# 17/29 R/O 105/8 JAGRITI VIHAR MEERUT CITY UTTAR PRADESH-250004 101:GS-175938K-GYANESHWAR PRASAD S/O LATE MEGHU MALLAH R/O BEHIND DESHABANDHU VIDYAPITH GIRLS HIGH SCHOOL DESHBANDHU FARA (LAKE TOWN MAHASAKTI KALIBARI) P.O. SILIGURI TOWN DIST. JALPAIGURI WEST BENGAL-734004 102:GS-171648P-YOGAMBER SINGH S/O KALYAN SINGH RAWAT R/O VILL. AND P.O. NISHNI PATTY PAIDULSHYUN DIST. PAURI GARHWAL UTTARAKHAND-246001 103:GS-181836K-MUKUL ARYA S/O KASHI RAM R/O HOUSE NO.471 SAINI NAGAR (RLY MAL GODOWN ROAD) TOWN KHATAULI DIST. MUZAFFAR NAGAR UTTAR PRADESH-251201 104:GS-173893W-SUNAHARI LAL S/O NATHU RAM R/O KHERIA KHURD P.O. GONDAI DIST. FIROZABAD UTTAR PRADESH-283204 105:GS-165306L-RAJENDRA PRASAD S/O JAGANDHU RAM R/O VILL. BACHUVAPAR P.O. TERHI DIST. AZAMGARH UTTAR PRADESH-274304 Page No.# 18/29 106:GS-176151F-BALDEV SINGH S/O TELLU RAM R/O VILL. BHERI P.O. BHAROLI KALAN THE-JHANDDUTTA DIST. BILASHPUR HIMACHAL PRADESH-174035 107:GS-175701M-EDISON TJ S/O JOSE TK R/O THAZHATHA HOUSE JUBLEE NAGAR P.O. NADA THANA DIST. TRISSUR KERALA-680751 108:GS-166581X-G BOBAN KUTTY S/O C GEORGE R/O THADATHIL PUTAIN VEED PALAMUKKU P.O. KANNANALLOR DIST. QUILON KERALA-691576 109:GS-176689H-M S RAO S/O MATHANGI KOTI NANCHARAJAH R/O VILL. BOBBARLANKA P.O. ATHGARH DIST. CUTTAK ORISSA-754029 110:GS-171455P-MRIGEN CHANDRA PATRA S/O PRAVAKAR PATRA R/O C/O SANCHITA PATRA H/NO.832 PATPUR DHUAGOLI P.O. BANKURA DIST. BANKURA WEST BWNGAL-722101 111:GS-164323Y-SANTHOSH KUMAR S/O PS NARAYANAN NAIR Page No.# 19/29 R/O KARIMPANAKKU SHIYIL HOUSE VELLAPPARA P.O. KONNI DIST. PATHANAMTHITTA KERALA-689691 112:GS-166583H-SUSEELAN P S/O LATE K K KUNHAMBU NAMBIAR R/O MADHURYAM EACHUR P.O. EACHUR DIST. KANNUR KERALA-670591 113:GS-171721H-JAYANTA CHAUDHARY S/O LATE JITENDRA KUMAR CHAUDHARY R/O C/O S K DUTTA CHAUDHARY BORBIL NO.1 PURNIMANAGAR P.O. DIGBOI DIST. TINSUKIA ASSAM-786171 114:GS-172009A-V KRISHNAN S/O S VENKATTAN R/O VILL. DUMPPADDY P.O. SARAKKAPPILLAIYUR TALUK-OMALUR DIST. SALEM TAMIL NADU-636305 115:GS-167338M-HIMMAT SINGH MANRAL S/O LATE P S MANRAL R/O MANRAL BHAWAN RADHIKA COLONY HARI NAGAR KUSUM KHRA HALDWANI-263139 116:GS-172863M-R GOVINDARAJU S/O RAMASAMY R/O VILL. ALAGANAMPATTY P.O. KARUVALLI TALUK OMALVR Page No.# 20/29 DIST. SALEM TAMIL NADU-636305 117:GS-178929X-M HARIHARAN S/O H MUTHUKRISHNAN R/O 10 JOTHANDA RAMMA KOVIL STREET RAJAPALAYAM TAMIL NADU-626107 118:GS-176089A-RAKESH KUMAR SHARMA S/O RAJE LAL SHARMA R/O VILL. BAHORAPUR P.O. MANGRAWAN DIST. AZAMAPUR UTTAR PRADESH-276205 119:GO-4111T-RAJ KUMAR S/O BHARAT SINGH R/O HOUSE NO.1197 SECTOR 2 BAHADURGARH JHAJHAR HARYANA-126507 120:GS-180133W-MOHAN CHANDRA JOSHI S/O RAM DUTT JOSHI R/O VILL. DINGDAR P.O. KUKROLI (THAL) DIST. PITHORAGARH UTTARAKHAND-262552 121:GS-181725M-MANOJ KUMAR GHOSH S/O GULU KARTA GHOSH R/O HOUSE NAME SHIVALOY VILL. PANDA PARA P.O. JALPAIGURI DIST. JALPAIGURI WEST BENGAL-735101 122:GS-163010N-ANISUL REHMAN S/O FAZZUL REHMAN Page No.# 21/29 R/O HOUSE NO.-WZ-102 KALA NIWAS 1ST FLOOR NARAINA VILLAGE NEW DELHI-110028 123:GS-177174P-RAJA RAM MEENA S/O RAM PRASAD MEENA R/O PLOT NO.26 SAKET NAGAR HINDAUN ROAD CHUNGI KE PASS KARAULI RAJASTHAN-322241 124:GS-190525X-DHIRAJ KUMAR S/O MUNNI PRASAD R/O VILL. LOHARPURA P.O. SADIPUR DIST. NAWADA BIHAR-805104 125:GO-3671P-TIRMAL SINGH S/O LATE MAHRAJ SINGH YADAV R/O VILL. NAGLA MUNSHI (KASER) P.O. KASER DIST. ALIGARH UTTAR PRADESH-202001 126:GS-182493L-CHANCHAL CHAKRABORTY S/O NITYA RANJAN CHAKRABORTY R/O 2 TOLLYGUNGE CIRCULAR ROAD KOLKATA WEST BENGAL-700033 127:GO-3662N-PREM CHAND RAJWAR S/O LATE MANI CHAND RAJWAR R/O VILL. SALANI GOATH (CHANDFARM) P.O. TANAKPUR DIST. NAINITAL UTTARAKHAND-262309 Page No.# 22/29 128:GS-193151X-MADDE PRAVIN RAMCHANDRA S/O MADDE RAMCHANDRA GIRAYAPPA R/O 12 SHRIDHAR APARTMENT P.O. JAYSINGPUR DIST. KOLHAPUR MAHARASTRA-416101 129:GS-4128H-PENUMAKA VEERA SWAMY S/O P VENKATESWARA RAO R/O 9-55 PAIDIKONDLAPALEM P.O. VEERANKI LOCK DIST. KRISHNA ANDHRA PRADESH-521250 130:GO-4201W RAM PRAKASH GUPTA S/O LATE KEDAR NATH GUPTA R/O VILL. AND P.O. BHARWA SUMERPUR DIST. HAMIRPUR UTTAR PRADESH-215002 131:GS-161610X DORI LAL S/O LATE JHALLU MAL R/O PT NO.44 KH NO.184/3 NEAR SHRI RAM HOSPITAL BANJAR ROAD PRABH NAGAR JODHPUR RAJASTHAN-342027 132:GS-162257H-ANIL KUMAR TIWARI S/O BRIJ RAJ TIWARI R/O HOUSE NO.7/10/17 SARYU NAGAR P.O. DEVAKALI DIST. FAIZABAD UTTAR PRADESH-224001 133:GS-173595A-V. GURUVANANTHAM S/O G. VELLAISAMY Page No.# 23/29 R/O NO.175 SALLIYAR NEW STREET AVARAMPATTI P.O. RAJPALAYAM DIST. VIRUDHUNAGAR TAMIL NADU-626117 134:GS-171828X-SHANKAR A S/O CHENNAPPA R/O H. NO. 9-7-93 GAJUPET STREET DIST. NIZAMABAD TELANGANA-503001 135:GS-176254A-NAND KISHOR DANGWAL S/O BALAK DANGWAL RAM DANGWAL R/O F-148 SUNARGOWN ATHOORWALA P.O. ATHOORWALA VIA DOIWALA DIST. DEHRADUN UTTARAKHAND-248202 136:GS-176142A-GIRJESH KUMAR SHARMA S/O LAKSHMI CHAND SHARMA R/O VILL. AHAMADPURI P.O. PARIKSHITGARH DIST. MEERUT UTTAR PRADESH-250406 137:GS-164424M-HARIGANE PRASAD S/O BANSHRAJ R/O VILL. NAIBASTI P.O. CHANDERU DIST. BULANDSHAHAR UTTAR PRADESH-203001 138:GS-176232F-INDERJEET SINGH S/O GHANSHYAM SINGH R/O VILL. BARIYAR P.O. NEWAS TEHSIL GOLA DIST. GORAKHPUR Page No.# 24/29 UTTAR PRADESH-273407 139:GS-183686X-SANJEEV KUMAR S/O KAMAL KUNAR SHARMA R/O HOUSE NO.3/397 GALI NO.7 GURANA ROAD BARAUT BAGHAPAT UTTAR PRADESH-250611 140:GS-174083A-RAJESH PRASAD PANDEY S/O SHARDA PRASAD PANDEY R/O VILL. TEEKAR P.O. CHANDIPUR DIST. SULTANPUR UTTAR PRADESH-228151 141:GS-180193L-KUMAR RAJESH S/O SURESH PRASAD VERMA R/O VILL. AND P.O. GULABBAGH DIST. PURNIA BIHAR-854326 142:GS-176861V-SATISH KUMAR S/O MOOLCHAND R/O 63/1 GHER KHATTI NEW MANDI MUZAFFARNAGAR UTTAR PRADESH-251306 143:GS-180134Y-TK SAHOO S/O DINBANDHU SAHOO R/O VILL. RASARASIK P.O. AND MANDALAM MOPIDEVI DIST. KRISHNA ANDHRA PRADESH-521125 144:GS-163013F PREM KUMAR S/O SH. SHYAM SUNDER SHARMA R/O VPO NANGAL CHAUDHARY DIST. MOHINDER GARH Page No.# 25/29 HARYANA-123023 145:GS-166827Y-JOY VV S/O LATE V A VARGHESE R/O VATTATHARA HOUSE POOCHAKKAL P.O. CHERTHALA DIST. ALLEPPEY KERALA-688526 146:GS-170939H-DINESH KUMAR S/O JAI PRAKASH R/O VILL. AND P.O. SATWAI DIST. MEERUT UTTAR PRADESH 147:GS-172254H-KRISHNA NAND BHATT S/O LATE B B BHATT R/O SHAGUN VATIKA 130 VINAYAKPURAM SEC-12 VIKASH NAGAR LUCKNOW UTTAR PRADESH-226022 148:GS-183431X-RAVINDRA SHAH S/O GOVIND LAL SHAH R/O BADRI VISHAL COLONY BHANDARY FARM P.O. HARIPURNAIK DIST. NAINITAL UTTARAKHAND-263139 149:THE SECRETARY MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS TRANSPORT BHAWAN 1 PARILIAMENTARY STREET NEW DELHI-110001. 150:THE SECRETARY MINISTRY OF FINANCE DEPARTMENT OF EXPENDITURE Page No.# 26/29 NORTH BLOCK NEW DELHI-110001. 151:THE SECRETARY PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND TRAINING MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL PUBLIC GRIEVANCES AND PENSIONS NORTH BLOCK NEW DELHI-110001 Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. S K MEDHI, Advocate for the Respondent : MR. K KALITA (R, MR K KASHYAB(R-55,20,64,96,68,81,97, 120,121,107,MR. B BORAH(R-55,20,64,96,68,81,97, 120,121,107,),MR. K KALITA(R- 55,20,64,96,68,78, 81,97, 120,121,107,MS L HMAR (R-3,18,45,60,73,87,92, 118,142,148),MR K KASHYAB (R-3,18,45,60,73,87,92, 118,142,148),MR. I H SAIKIA (R-3,18,45,60,73,87,92, 118,142,148),MR. M R CHOUDHURY (R-3),MR. B BORAH (R-3,18,45,60,73,87,92, 118,142,148) BEFORE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MICHAEL ZOTHANKHUMA ORDER 05.12.2025 Heard Mr. S. K. Medhi, learned counsel for the review petitioner and Mr. I. H. Saikia, learned counsel for the writ petitioners/respondents. 2. The learned counsel for the review petitioners submits that the impugned order dated 23.11.2021 passed in WP(C) 6603/2014, which has been decided in line with the judgment and order dated 18.02.2020 passed in WP(C) 1537/2015 (GS-173517H- Sri C. Chandra Kumar vs. the Union of India and 5 others) and the subsequent judgment and order dated 24.09.2021, passed by the Division Bench of this Court in WA 104/2020 (Union of India and 5 others vs. Shri C. Chandra Kumar), should be reviewed. He submits that the review is necessary, inasmuch as, all the writ petitioners in WP(C) 6603/2014 were not similarly situated with the writ petitioners in WP(C) 1537/2015. He submits that out of Page No.# 27/29 the 148 writ petitioners in WP(C) 6603/2014, only 61 writ petitioners were holding the post of Superintendent B/R Grade-II, as on 01.01.1996. Therefore, in terms of the judgment passed in WP(C) 1537/2015 and the judgment and order dated 24.09.2021 passed by the Division Bench in WA 104/2020, only 61 writ petitioners in WP(C) 6603/2014 could avail the benefits provided in the terms of the recommendation of the 5th and 6th CPC. 3. The counsel for the review petitioners submits that the remaining 87 writ petitioners in WP(C) 6603/2014 were overseers, who had been appointed on different dates and years. He submits that the benefits provided in WP(C) 6603/2014 could only be given to the overseers, depending upon their dates of appointment to the post of Overseers. 4. Mr. I. H. Saikia, learned counsel for the writ petitioners submits that he has got no quarrel with the submission made by the learned counsel for the review petitioners, inasmuch as, the benefits of the 5th and 6th CPC would accrue on Superintendents B/R Grade-II/Overseers, on the date of their appointment as overseers. However, as there was a merger and amalgamation of the post of overseers and Superintendent B/R Grade-II, which was re-designated as Junior Engineer w.e.f. 01.01.1996, only those overseers, who were re-designated as Junior Engineers w.e.f. 01.01.1996, would get the benefits in terms of the order passed in WP(C) 6603/2014 w.e.f. 01.01.1996. 5. I have heard the learned counsels for the parties. 6. The relevant portions of the recommendations made by the 6th CPC is reproduced hereinbelow as follows:- Page No.# 28/29 “Border Roads Organisation Overseer (Civil) 7.39.22 Higher pay scale has been demanded for the post of Overseer (Civil) in Border Roads Organisation on the ground that the minimum qualification for the post is Diploma in Engineering. The post carries minimum direct recruitment qualification of Diploma in engineering. These minimum qualifications had been prescribed in 1996. Fifth CPC, in their Report submitted in 1997, had recommended the scale of Rs.5000-8000 for all posts carrying minimum direct recruitment qualifications of Diploma in Engineering. This recommendation was accepted. The post should consequently have been extended the scale of Rs.5000-8000 w.e.f. 1.1.1996. This was, however, not done. The Commission, accordingly, recommends that the post of Overseer may be upgraded and merged with their promotional post of Superintendent BR Grade-II (present scale Rs.4500-7000) and the combined cadre extended the scale of Rs.5000-8000. Since the Commission has recommended merger of the scales of Rs.5000-8000, Rs.5500-9000 and Rs.6500-10500, the post will be placed in the revised Pay Band PB-2 of Rs.8700-34800 along with a grade pay of Rs.4200. Commission also advises the Government to implement this retrospectively from 1.1.1996, at least for the purposes of fixation of pay. Superintendent Grade-II 7.39.23 The post of Superintendent Grade II in the Civil Engineering and Electrical & Mechanical Cadre has been extended the pay scale of Rs.4500-7000 even though the minimum qualifications of direct recruitment include diploma in Engineering, Fifth CPC had recommended placement of all posts requiring minimum entry level qualification for direct recruitment of Diploma in Engineering as Rs.5000-8000.. Even though the recommendation was accepted by the Government, it has not been extended in respect of this post because only some of the posts are filled through direct recruitment. This is not the correct interpretation of Fifth CPC recommendation as per which all posts carrying minimum qualification of Diploma in Engineering for DRs had to be placed in the scale of Rs.5000-8000. The post of Superintendent Grade II has an element of direct recruitment, minimum qualifications for which is Diploma in Engineering. The Commission, accordingly, recommends that the post of Superintendent Grade II may be placed in the Pay Band BP-2 of Rs.8700-34800 along with a grade pay of Rs.4200 corresponding to the pre-revised scale of Rs.5000-8000 that is now being merged with the scales of Rs.5500-9000 and Rs.6500-10500. Other posts similarly placed and carrying minimum qualification of diploma in Engineering should also be extended this pay scale.” 7. The 61 petitioners, out of the 148 writ petitioners in WP(C) 6603/2014 Page No.# 29/29 were holding the post of Superintendent B/R Grade-II as on 01.01.1996. On the other hand, the remaining 87 writ petitioners held the post of Overseers with a Diploma in Engineering on different dates. In terms of the 5th and 6th CPC recommendations, the post of Overseers merged with the post of Superintendent Grade-II w.e.f. 01.01.1996 and they would be entitled to the scale of pay of Rs.5,000/- to Rs.8,000/- and all other benefits w.e.f. 01.01.1996. It is needless to add that if Overseers were appointed subsequent to 01.01.1996, their benefits in terms of the 5th and 6th CPC, would apply only from the date of their appointment. 8. On considering the above, this Court does not find any reason to review the order dated 23.11.2021 passed in WP(C) 6603/2014, except to clarify the fact that the recommendations of the 5th & 6th CPC would be paid to those Overseers, on the basis of their dates of appointment. The only exception being that Overseers, appointed prior to or on 01.01.1996, would have to be given the same benefit as Superintendent B/R Grade-II Engineers w.e.f. 01.01.1996. 9. The review petition is accordingly disposed of. JUDGE Comparing Assistant