DELHI PUBLIC SCHOOL v. STATE OF U.P. AND 41 OTHERS
WRIA/7917/2020 · 2025-01-22
Saurabh Shyam Shamshery
body2025
DailyLaw.ai
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 23828 (ALL) · dailylaw.ai ]
DailyLaw.ai
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 23828 (ALL) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
Neutral Citation No. - 2025:AHC:11166 Court No. - 10 Case :- WRIT - A No. - 7917 of 2020 Petitioner :- Delhi Public School Respondent :- State Of U.P. And 41 Others Counsel for Petitioner :- Kaushalendra Nath Singh,Vinayak Nath Singh Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C.,Madan Gopal Pandey,Manoj Goswami,Manoj Kumar Yadav,Manorama Goswami,Pawan Kumar Pandey,Raj Kumar Yadav,Satya Prakash,Ugrasen Panday Hon'ble Saurabh Shyam Shamshery,J.
1. Heard Mr. Kaushalendra Nath Singh, learned counsel for petitioner and Mr. Madan Gopal Pandey, learned counsel for contesting respondents. 2. The impugned order, dated 14.07.2020, is reproduced hereinafter:-
"पबबधक,
ददलल पबबबक सकक ब, इबनदररपपरम
गरजजयरबरद।
शलमतल सलमर तयरगल, अधयक,
गरजजयरबरद पपररटस एससजसयपशन,
करयररबय एफ०एफ०-1,
ररधर कक षण अपरररमरर शरसल
नगर गरजजयरबरद दररर अधसहसतरकरल कप समक परररनर पत ददनरबक 01.07.2020
पसतपत कर अवगत कररयर गयर हह दक
ददलल पबबबक सकक ब,
इबनदररपपरम गरजजयरबरद दररर अपनप सकक ब मर बमबप समय सप सपवरयर दप रहप कप छ दशकक/
दशदककरओब एबव अनय सरटफ कमरचरररयय कस 30
जकन 2020
कस सपवरएर समरप करनप कर नसदरस जररल दकयर गयर
रर जजसकप कम मर गरजजयरबरद पपरररस एससजसयपशन गरजजयरबरद दररर उन सभल दशकक/
दशदककरओब एबव अनय सरटफ
कमरचरररयय कस इनकक ननकरल वरपस ददबरनप हपतप अनपरसद दकयर गयर रर।
उक पकरण कक जटच हपतप अधसहसतरकरल दररर अपनप करयररबय पत सबखयर-737/एस०रल०-सल०एम०/2020 ददनरबक 02.07.2020
दररर जजबर दवदरबय दनरलकक गरजजयरबरद एबव बपजसक दशकर अजधकररल गरजजयरबरद कक कमपरल गदठत कर
पकरण कक सबयपक रप सप जरबचकर आखयर उपबबध कररयप जरनप हपतप दनदरदशत दकयर गयर जजसकप कम मर जजबर
दवदरबय दनरलकक,
गरजजयरबरद दररर अपनप करयररबय पत सबखयरय- एस०रल०/11558-59/2020-21 ददनरबक 10.07.2020
दररर पकरण कक सबयपक रप सप जरबचकर आखयर पपदषत कक गयल हह,
जस पत कप सरर सबबग हह।
अतएव जजबर दवदरबय दनरलकक एबव बपजसक दशकर अजधकररल गरजजयरबरद कक सबयपक जरबच अरखयर कक पदत आपकस
इस दनदरश कप सरर पपदषत हह दक जटच आखयर मर उदलजखत तथयय कर शत-
पदतशत अनपपरबन कररकर अनपपरबन
आखयर अधसहसतरकरल कस एक सपरह मर अवगत कररयर। सबबगकय-
यरसपरर। (
दशव पतरप शपकब)
नगर मजजसरटपर गरजजयरबरद।"
3. The argument of learned counsel for petitioner has merit that the City Magistrate has no power to interfere with the functions of the school namely Delhi Public School. 4.
Learned counsel for contesting respondents tried to convince this Court that in
certain circumstances the City Magistrate has a power to interfere, however, the Court is not convinced since no provision of law is shown in support of said submission except a reason that it was passed during Covid-19 Pandemic which has now lost its efficacy. 5. At this stage, the Court also takes note that that there is a specific challenge to the termination orders at the instance of respondent nos. 6 to 42. who have filed substantive writ petition bearing no. Writ-A No. 9123 of 2020, therefore also, the impugned order is not justified. Accordingly, the impugned order, dated 14.07.2020, is set aside and this petition is disposed of. 6. The connected writ petition i.e. Writ-A No. 9123 of 2020, is de-tagged and Registry is directed to put the said writ petition for final arguments in the next week at 2 PM. Order Date :- 22.1.2025 Saurabh Digitally signed by :- SAURABH High Court of Judicature at Allahabad