- 1 - !" ! ## $% & ! "## $ % & # ### ' ! " # $ ##& ' ( $& # # # % !) # % ! ' ''# (( ( '# ( '#(! '# ## ' # ' % ' *+ * , % Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '"! -./011203./4.325678-2011233098/62.9:0::;.2<2567 =>5:?298 @4 A@9<.A8.@9 095 @;52; @9 /29829A2 50825 !) .9 @! @9 8-2 4.32 @4 8-2 55.8.@903 ./8;.A8 095 2//.@9/ %>5:2 0<090:2;2 B-2;2.9 8-2 ;.03 @>;8 ;2A@;525 8-2 A@9<.A8.@9 @4 8-2 011233098/4@;8-2@4429A2/>952;2A8.@9((095 (!; B2A8.@9(@495.09#2903@52$4@;/-@;8C#D& -2;09E/@48-210;8.2/B@>3562A@9/.52;25-29A24@;8- 0/12;8-2.;;09E.9:/.98-2;.03@>;84@;A@9<29.29A2 ()*+,-.-/*,+.* ( 8./8-2A0/2@48-21;@/2A>8.@98-08;.0-2/-B0;0.0- /@9 @4 ;. >;>/.550.0- 3@5:25 0 A@?130.98 /808.9: 8-08 -./ B.42 ?8 -0;08-. -05 6229 8@ 8-2 3095 03@9: B.8- A@B/ -29 /-2 B0/ :;0F.9: 8-2 A08832 .550.0- 2/-@50??0 -0.8;0 0?052<0110 095 0:0110 -0<2 06>/25 -2; B.8- 0 4.38-7 309:>0:2 095 0//0>3825 -2; '>;8-2;-2/808258-08-./B.42B0/5;0::258@8-2#@3.A2 808.@9678-20AA>/258./4>;8-2;/808258-08-2-05 ;2A2.<250?2//0:2/808.9:-./B.42B0/30.5@98-2/8;228 - 3 - .9 4;@98 @4 8-2 -@>/2 @4 0AA>/25 @ 67 A@9/>?.9: 1@./@9 9;2A2.<.9:8-2/0.5.94@;?08.@94;@?-.//./82; 8-2 A@?130.9098 B298 8@ 8-2 /1@8 095 /0B 8-08 -./ B.42 B0/62.9:0//0>3825678-206@<2?298.@9250AA>/258 .//808258-088-2743250B074;@?8-2/1@80482;/22.9: -.???25.08237-2/-.4825-./B.428@8-2-@/1.8034@; 8;208?298 -@B2<2; /-2 5.25 @9 G! 0;@>95 06@>80? 98-2/0?25070;@>95(1?-2 3@5:25 0 A@?130.98 0:0.9/8 8-2 12;/@9/ 90?25 .9 8-2 A@?130.98 A0/2 A0?2 8@ 62 ;2:./82;25 67 8-2 =>;./5.A8.@903 1@3.A2 .9 0 ;.?2 @() 482; A@95>A8.9: 8-2 .9<2/8.:08.@9 A-0;:2 /-228 A0?2 8@ 62 4.3250:0.9/8;..550.0-095?80/-@50??0 @ 1;@<2 8-2 A0/2 @4 8-2 1;@/2A>8.@9 8-2 1;@/2A>8.@9 2H0?.925 ! B.892//2/ 0/ #/ 8@ ! 095 :@8 ?0;E25 G 5@A>?298/ 0/ H/# 8@ G 095 03/@ .5298.4.25 8B@ ?082;.03@6=2A8/0/ /095 98-2@8-2;-0958-2 52429A2 :@8 ?0;E25 8B@ /8082?298/ @4 >?9.8-0 095 #(+0-2/-B0;0770 ;2/12A8.<237 0/ H/ 095 -2;.03@>;80482;A@9/.52;.9:8-22<.529A2@40338-2/2 - 4 - B.892//2/ 6@8- @;03 095 5@A>?2980;7 ;2A@;525 8-2 A@9<.A8.@9.9;2/12A8@48-2@4429A2//80825/>1;0 20;5 ;. 0=295;0 2557 320;925 A@>9/23 4@; 8-2 011233098/095?8 0/-?.#08.3320;925.:-@>;8 @<2;9?298#32052;4@;8-2;2/1@95298 ! 8./8-2/>6?.//.@9@4320;925A@>9/234@;8-2011233098/ 8-088-2=>5:?298@4A@9<.A8.@910//25678-2;.03@>;8 ./12;<2;/20952;;@92@>/0958-2/0?2./@11@/258@8-2 2<.529A2@9;2A@;5-2;24@;28-2/0?2./3.06328@62 /280/.52 8 ./ 4>;8-2; />6?.8825 8-08 8-2;2 B0/ 0 A.<.3 5./1>82 628B229 # 095 8-2 0AA>/25 @92 @4 8-2 .9521295298 B.892//2/ -0<2 />11@;825 8-2 A0/2 @4 8-2 1;@/2A>8.@9<29 8-@>:- 8-21;@/2A>8.@9 1;@=2A825 8-2 5208--0/@AA>;;255>28@.9/8.:08.@9@;.9/>38A0>/258@ 8-2 52A20/25 8-2 40A8/ ;2?0.9 8-08 8-2;2 B0/ 0 A.<.3 5./1>82628B2298-2A@?130.90980950AA>/25@ ) 8./4>;8-2;/>6?.88258-088-2A@?130.9098-053@5:250 A@?130.98 0482; 4@>; 507/ 4;@? 8-2 5082 @4 0332:25 .9A.529848-2.9A.5298-05;20337@AA>;;25@90AA@>98@4 - 5 - .9/8.:08.@9 @; .9/>38 67 8-2 0AA>/25 /-2 B@>35 -0<2 5./A3@/25 8-2 /0.5 40A8/ 624@;2 8-2 5@A8@; .??25.08237 0482;-0<.9:05?.88258@8-2-@/1.803-252307.93@5:.9: 8-2 A@?130.98 B@>35 62 40803 8@ 8-2 A0/2 @4 8-2 1;@/2A>8.@9 G 8 ./ 4>;8-2; />6?.8825 8-08 8-@>:- 8-2 1;@/2A>8.@9 -0/ /80825 8-08 8-2 52A20/25 -05 B;.8829 0 5208- 9@82 095 A@??.8825 />.A.52 -2 /0.5 5208- 9@82 -0/ 9@8 6229 1;@<25 67 8-2 1;@/2A>8.@9 9 8-206/29A2 @41;@@4 8-08 /-2-05B;.8829032882;624@;2/-2A@>35A@??.8/>.A.52 8-2 ;20/@9/ 0//.:925 67 8-2 @>;8/ 623@B .9 ;2952;.9: 8-2 A@9<.A8.@9 A099@8 62 0AA21825 095 .8 ;2I>.;2/ 8@ 62 /280/.520E.9:/>A-/>6?.//.@9/8-2320;925A@>9/23 4@;8-2011233098/1;07/8@033@B8-2011203 320;925 .:- @>;8 @<2;9?298 #32052; 4@; 8-2;2/1@952988082<2-2?29837=>/8.4.258-2=>5:?298 @4 A@9<.A8.@9 095 @;52; @9 /29829A2 10//25 67 8-2 ;.03 @>;8095/-24>;8-2;/808258-088-22<.529A2@4#/( 095 0;2 ;232<098 33 8-2/2 8-;22 B.892//2/ -0<2 />11@;825 8-2 A0/2 @4 8-2 1;@/2A>8.@9 .9 ;2/12A8 @4 - 6 - A;>2387095-0;0//?29809503/@06@>88-2.9/>38A0>/25 8@8-2<.A8.? 8 ./ 4>;8-2; />6?.8825 8-08 8-2 ?0992; .9 B-.A- 8-2 0//0>38?052678-20AA>/2532058@A0>/2.9=>;78@-2; ;21>808.@9 .9 8-2 /@A.287 0/ 0 ;2/>38 @4 B-.A- /-2 A@??.8825 />.A.52 -2 .9A.5298 -05 @AA>;;25 @9 !-@B2<2;/-25.25@9G!-252307 .9 3@5:.9: 8-2 A@?130.98 -0/ 6229 2H130.925 67 8-2 A@?130.9098 8-08 -2 B0/ <2;7 6>/7 .9 :288.9: 8-2 8;208?298 8@ -./ B.42 -2;24@;2 -2 A@>35 9@8 4.32 8-2 A@?13.098B.8-.908.?2 8./4>;8-2;/>6?.88258-088-2;.03@>;84>;8-2;;23.25 @98-25@A>?2980;72<.529A2/>A-0/H#(+208-@82 / 12; H#( .8 ./ 1;@<25 8-08 /-2 B0/ .9/>3825 624@;2 /-2 5.25 -2 /0.5 H#( -0/ 6229 1;@<25 8-;@>:- 8-2 2<.529A2 @4#/ 095 B-@ B2;2 8-2 ;2308.<2/ @4 8-2 52A20/250958-27B2;2B2330B0;206@>88-2-095B;.8.9: @48-252A20/25 - 7 - ( 8 ./ 4>;8-2; />6?.8825 8-08 ?2;2 52307 .9 3@5:.9: 8-2 A@?130.988-08.8/234A099@8628-2:;@>958@5./A;25.88@ 8-2A;25.6.3.87@48-2B.892//2/-2129529A7@48-2A.<.3 A0/2628B2290AA>/250958-2A@?130.909803/@?079@8 628-2;232<098:;@>958@5;0B8-205<2;/2.942;29A28-08 8-27-0<26229403/237.?13.A0825.98-./A0/2 -2 ;.03 @>;8 0482; -0<.9: A@9/.52;25 8-2 2<.529A2 03@9: B.8- 8-2 ' ;21@;8 @1.925 8-08 8-2 0AA>/25 0;2 :>.387 @4 8-2 @4429A2/ /80825 />1;0 -2;24@;2 .982;42;29A2B.8-8-2/0.54.95.9:/?079@86292A2//0;7 0<.9:/0.58->/320;925.:-@>;8@<2;9?298#32052; 1;07/8@5./?.//8-2011203 0<.9: -20;5 320;925 A@>9/23 4@; 8-2 ;2/12A8.<2 10;8.2/ 095 03/@ 12;>/25 8-2 4.95.9:/ @4 8-2 ;.03 @>;8 .9 ;2A@;5.9:8-2A@9<.A8.@98-21@.98/B-.A-B@>350;./24@; ?7A@9/.52;08.@90;2J - 8 - ! 24@;205<2;8.9:8@8-2@8-2;40A8/.8./;232<0988@;242; 8-2=>5:?298@48-2@9,632>1;2?2@>;8.98-2A0/2@4 -2 @9D632 >1;2?2 @>;8 .9 10;0:;01-/ @)G095-2350/>952;* ! !" # $ !# !# % & $ # ! ! ' # ! " ( )*+ & , - , # !# . / , & ! !# # 0 ! # ! 1 Crl.A No. 221/2025 dated 17.01.2025 - 9 - 1$ # " " 0 !1 , #" ! & # ! !# % 2 " % " ! " ! , " , % ( #" 3&. ! # # # 4* " " # " !# ( )*+ & 56 ( * ( 78 9 # 6# # ( " 4*4): ! # ! ( )*+& ! # # !# ! " !# " # # " ! - 10 - #;; # <#! # % " # "! & 0 !# ( )*+ ! ! # ! % # # !# # " ( )*+= 9A0;24>3;205.9:@48-206@<2/0.5=>5:?298.8?0E2/ .8 A320; 8-08 .9 @;52; 8@ ?0E2 @>8 09 @4429A2 >952; 2A8.@9(!@4#/12A.4.A0628?2980/A@982?13082567 2A8.@9 @4#-0/8@62?052@>88./4>;8-2;-235 8-088-2.98298.@9@48-20AA>/258@0.5@;.9/8.:082@;8@ 0628 8-2 52A20/25 8@ A@??.8 />.A.52 ./ 0 ?>/8 4@; 088;0A8.9:2A8.@9(!@4# ) 909@8-2;A0/2.98-2A0/2@4 8-2 @9,632>1;2?2@>;8-2358-088-20332:25-0;0//?298 2 (2011) 3 SCC 626 - 11 - ?2825 @>8 /-@>35 -0<2 3248 8-2 <.A8.? B.8- 9@ @8-2; 0382;908.<26>88@1>8092958@-2;3.420958-08.9A0/2/ @4 0628?298 @4 />.A.52 8-2;2?>/8 62 1;@@4@45.;2A8 @; .95.;2A80A8@40628?2988@A@??.8/>.A.52 G 9 A0;24>3 ;205.9: @4 8-2 5.A80 @4 8-2 @9,632 >1;2?2 @>;8.9;2/12A8@40628?2988@A@??.8/>.A.529@B.8./ ;232<098 8@ ;242; 8-2 6;.24 40A8/ @4 8-2 A0/2 095 03/@ ;232<0988@;242;8-24.95.9:/@48-2;.03@>;8 -21;@/2A>8.@9.9@;52;8@1;@<28-2A0/2:@82H0?.925 !B.892//2/0/#/8@!#62.9:0B.892//8@ 8-2 .9I>2/8 ?0-0F0; B-.A- ./ ?0;E25 0/ H# -0/ /808258-08-2-0/044.H25-.//.:908>;2.98-2-@/1.803 # 62.9: 09@8-2; .9I>2/8 B.892// /80825 8@ -0<2 044.H25 -./ /.:908>;2 08 @<2;9?298 @/1.803 0<090:2;2 2 4>;8-2; 521@/25 8-08 -2 B0/ A03325 67 8-21@3.A2088-28.?2@41;210;.9:8-2/2.F>;2?0-0F0;.9 ;2/12A8@48-2A-.8/0.58@-0<26229;2A@<2;254;@?8-2 /B2082;@48-252A20/25-2/0?2./?0;E250/H# 98-2A;@//+2H0?.908.@9-205?.88258-088-@>:--2-0/ - 12 - 044.H25 -./ /.:908>;2 8@ 8-2 /0.5 ?0-0F0; -2 B0/ 9@8 0B0;2@48-2A@98298/8-2;2@4 #(62.9:07@>9:2;6;@8-2;@40AA>/25@-2/80825 8@ -0<2 3@5:25 0 A@?130.98 0:0.9/8 0AA>/25 @ 0/ 0AA>/25@095@8-2;/-05.9/8.:0825@;060825-./B.42 8@A@??.8/>.A.52205?.88258-088-2;2B0/05./1>82 .9;2/12A8@41;@12;87628B229-.?/2340950AA>/25@ 2-0/4>;8-2;521@/258-08.9;2/12A8@48-2/0.5.//>2 0AA>/25 @/ 095 B2;2 06>/.9: -.?/234 095 -./ B.42 8-08 8-27 /-@>35 :@ 095 5.2 2 4>;8-2; 521@/25 8-08 B-29-2B0//20;A-.9:8-2/B2082;@4-./B.420954@>95 8-088-2;2B0/0A-.8.98-2/B2082;B-.A-A@980.9258-2 -095B;.8.9: @4 -./ B.42 B-.A- .95.A082/ 8-08 8-2 0AA>/25 0;2;2/1@9/.6324@;-2;5208- ( '>;8-2; -2 /80825 8@ -0<2 -09525 @<2; 8-2 /0.5 A-.8 8@ 8-2 1@3.A2 -2 1@3.A2 -0<2 A@95>A825 /2.F>;2+?0-0F0; @98-2/0.55208-9@820958-2/0?2./?0;E250/H# 095;2A@<2;7@48-2/0.55208-9@82./?0;E250/H#( 2/>11@;8258-2A0/2@48-21;@/2A>8.@9 912;>/03@4 H#(.801120;/8-08.9055.8.@98@0AA>/25@/095 - 13 - 8-2 90?2/ @4 @8-2; 12;/@9/ B2;2 03/@ ?298.@925 @B2<2; 8-2 =>;./5.A8.@903 1@3.A2 -0<2 4.325 8-2 A-0;:2 /-228@937.9;2/12A8@40AA>/25@/095 -20AA>/25-0<2529.258-2B;.8.9:/4@>95@9H#(67 /808.9: 8-08 8-2 52A20/25 5.5 9@8 E9@B 8-2 B;.8.9: 095 ;205.9: 8-2;24@;2 8-2 B;.8.9: @4 8-2 32882; B@>35 9@8 0;./2@B2<2;8-2/0?2-0/6229A@98;@<2;825678-2 2<.529A2@4#/095 338-2B.892//2/<.F#( 095 0;2A@9/./8298.98-2.;2<.529A28-088-252A20/25 -05 B;.8829 8-2 5208- 9@82 095 .8 B0/ 4@>95 .9 -2; /B2082;-@>:-8-2B;.8.9:/@98-2/0.55208-9@82B0/ A@9<2;825678-252429/28-08A099@8620AA218254@;8-2 ;20/@98-088-240?.37?2?62;/0;28-262/812;/@9/8@ /120E06@>88-2B;.8.9:/@48-209@8-2;40?.37?2?62; 28-080/.8?078-21;@/2A>8.@9/-@>35-0<2A@?10;25 8-2 5./1>825 B;.8.9:/ B.8- 8-2 @8-2; B;.8.9:/ @4 8-2 52A20/2548-2/0.5B;.8.9:/-056229/>6=2A8258@' 8-20>8-298.A.87B@>35-0<262290 250958-2;21@;8 B@>35 -0<2 6229 :.<29 67 8-2 A@?128298 >8-@;.87 9 8-206/29A2@48-2/0.5244@;8.9:288.9:8-2;21@;84;@? - 14 - 8-2 A@?128298 0>8-@;.87 .8 B@>35 62 <2;7 5.44.A>38 8@ 0AA218 8-08 8-2 5208- 9@82 -0/ 6229 B;.8829 67 8-2 52A20/25 -./ 0/12A8 /-@>35 -0<2 6229 A@9/.52;25 67 8-2;.03@>;8B-.32A@9/.52;.9:8-25208-9@82 ! 9 055.8.@9 8@ 8-2 06@<2 4.95.9:/ 8-2 52307 .9 4.3.9: 8-2 A@?130.980:0.9/88-20AA>/25./03/@@92@48-2?082;.03 :;@>95 8@ 5./A0;5 8-2 0332:08.@9/ ?052 0:0.9/8 8-2 0AA>/25 8 ./ 03/@ 92A2//0;7 8@ ?298.@9 8-08 0AA>/25 @ 095 #( 0;2 8-2 6;@8-2;/ 095 8-2;2 ./ 0 A.<.3 5./1>82.9;2/12A8@48-21;@12;871295.9:0?@9:8-2? 0<.9:A@9/.52;258-2@<2;03340A8/095A.;A>?/809A2/@4 8-2 A0/2 0? @4 8-2 A@9/.52;25 @1.9.@9 8-08 8-2 ;.03 @>;8 -0/ A@??.8825 :;0<2 2;;@; .9 ./@308.9: 8-2 0332:08.@9/ .9 ;2/12A8 @4 8-2 11233098/ 8-@>:- 8-2 0<2;?298/ @4 8-2 H#(+5208- 9@82 5./A3@/2/ 8-2 0332:08.@9/0:0.9/80338-212;/@9/?298.@925.98-2/0.5 5208-9@82 ) 98-23.:-8@48-2@6/2;<08.@9/?05206@<21;@A2258@ 09/B2;8-206@<21@.98/0;20/>952;*+ #@.98@ * 98-2C2:08.<2D - 15 - #@.98@ * 98-2C44.;?08.<2D G AA@;5.9:371;@A2258@10//8-24@33@B.9:* .& -2;.?.90311203./033@B25 ..& -2 =>5:?298 @4 A@9<.A8.@9 095 @;52; @9 /29829A2 50825 !) 10//25 .9 @! 67 8-2 55.8.@903 ./8;.A8 095 2//.@9/%>5:20<090:2;2.//280/.52 ...& -2 011233098/ 0AA>/25 @/ 095 0;2 0AI>.8825 4@; 8-2 @4429A2/ 1>9./-0632 >952; 2A8.@9/(((!; B.892//2A8.@9( @4# .<& 0.36@95/2H2A>825.4097/8095A09A23325 012 $ % " ./8@*3@*G