Research › Search › Judgment

Madras High Court · body

2025 DAILYLAW 20689 (MAD)

BHUVANESWARI v. SAMPOORNAM(DECEASED)

CMP/2808/2020 · 2025-07-10

N Mala

Transfer Petitionbody2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

CMP No. 2808 of 2020 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS DATED: 10-07-2025 CORAM THE HONOURABLE MRS.JUSTICE N. MALA CMP No. 2808 of 2020 AND SA NO. 603 OF 2001,SA NO. 604 OF 2001,CMP NO. 2811 OF 2020,CMP NO. 2812 OF 2020,CMP NO. 2814 OF 2020,CMP NO. 2815 OF 2020,CMP NO. 2816 OF 2020 1. BHUVANESWARI W/o.Damodharan, Kombupalayam, Hamlet Of Nanjal Keezhampadi Village, Erode Taluk And District. Appellant(s) Vs 1. Sampoornam(deceased) W/o.Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therkuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Taluk And District. 2.SIVAKAMI W/o.Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellottamparappu Village, Erode Taluk And District. 3.ARUKKANIAMMAL W/o.Ramana Gounder, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 4.LAKSHMI W/o.Subbanan, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 5.S.Sumathi No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 6.THANGAVEL No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 7.K.S.Kumarasamy S/o.Selambna Gounder, No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 8.K.Vijayalakshmi No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 9.KALPANA W/o.M.Satheesh Kumar, Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows, Temple Town Street, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet, Chennai 600 044. 10.N.Udayakumar S/o.V.K.Nallasamy, No.A11, https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode 6378 002. Respondent(s) SA No. 603 of 2001 1. BHUVANESWARI Appellant(s) Vs 1. SAMPOORNAM 2.SIVAKAMI 3.ARUKKANIAMMAL 4.LAKSHMI 5.SUMATHY 6.THANGAVEL 7.K.S.Kumarasamy 8.VIJAYALAKSHMI . Respondent(s) https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 SA No. 604 of 2001 1. BHUVANESWARI Appellant(s) Vs 1. SAMPOORNAM 2.SIVAKAMI Respondent(s) CMP No. 2811 of 2020 1. BHUVANESWARI W/o.Damodharan, Kombupalayam, Hamlet Of Nanjal Keezhampadi Village, Erode Taluk And District. Appellant(s) Vs 1. Sampoornam(deceased) W/o.Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therkuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Taluk And District. 2.SIVAKAMI W/o.Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellottamparappu Village, Erode Taluk And District. 3.ARUKKANIAMMAL W/o.Ramana Gounder, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 4.LAKSHMI https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 W/o.Subbanan, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 5.S.Sumathi No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 6.THANGAVEL No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 7.K.S.Kumarasamy S/o.Selambna Gounder, No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 8.K.Vijayalakshmi No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 9.KALPANA W/o.M.Satheesh Kumar, Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows, Temple Town Street, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet, Chennai 600 044. 10.N.Udayakumar S/o.V.K.Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode 6378 002. Respondent(s) https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 CMP No. 2812 of 2020 1. BHUVANESWARI W/o. Damodharan, Kombupalayam, Hamlet Of Nanjal Keezhampadi Village, Erode Tk And Dist Appellant(s) Vs 1. Sampoornam(deceased) W/o. Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therukuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Tk And Dist 2.SIVAKAMI W/o. Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellorttamparappu Village, Erode Tk And Dist 3.KALPANA W/o. M.Satheesh Kumar Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows Temple Town St, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet Chennai-44 4.N.Udaya Kumar S/o. V.K. Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode -02 Respondent(s) CMP No. 2814 of 2020 1. BHUVANESWARI W/o. Damodharan, Kombupalayam, https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 Hamlet Of Nanjal Keezhampadi Village, Erode Tk And Dist Appellant(s) Vs 1. Sampoornam(deceased) W/o. Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therukuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Tk And Dist 2.SIVAKAMI W/o. Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellorttamparappu Village, Erode Tk And Dist 3.KALPANA W/o. M.Satheesh Kumar Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows Temple Town St, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet Chennai-44 4.N.Udaya Kumar S/o. V.K. Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode -02 Respondent(s) CMP No. 2815 of 2020 1. BHUVANESWARI W/o.Damodharan, Kombupalayam, Hamlet Of Nanjal Keezhampadi Village, Erode Taluk And District. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 Appellant(s) Vs 1. Sampoornam(deceased) W/o.Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therkuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Taluk And District. 2.SIVAKAMI W/o.Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellottamparappu Village, Erode Taluk And District. 3.ARUKKANIAMMAL W/o.Ramana Gounder, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 4.LAKSHMI W/o.Subbanan, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 5.S.Sumathi No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 6.THANGAVEL No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 7.K.S.Kumarasamy S/o.Selambna Gounder, No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 8.K.Vijayalakshmi No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 9.KALPANA W/o.M.Satheesh Kumar, Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows, Temple Town Street, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet, Chennai 600 044. 10.N.Udayakumar S/o.V.K.Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode 6378 002. Respondent(s) CMP No. 2816 of 2020 1. BHUVANESWARI W/o. Damodharan, Kombupalayam, Hamlet Of Nanjal Keezhampadi Village, Erode Tk And Dist Appellant(s) Vs 1. Sampoornam(deceased) W/o. Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therukuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Tk And Dist https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 2.SIVAKAMI W/o. Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellorttamparappu Village, Erode Tk And Dist 3.KALPANA W/o. M.Satheesh Kumar Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows Temple Town St, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet Chennai-44 4.N.Udaya Kumar S/o. V.K. Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode -02 Respondent(s) CMP No. 2808 of 2020 PRAYER To set aside the abatement caused by the death of 1st respondent in above SA. CMP No. 2811 of 2020 PRAYER To bring on record respondent 9 and 10 the legal heirs of the 1st respondent as respondents 9 and 10 in this appeal. CMP No. 2812 of 2020 PRAYER To condone the delay 4350 days in filing the set aside the abatement petition caused due to death of the deceased 1st respondent in the above SA. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 CMP No. 2814 of 2020 PRAYER To set aside the abatement caused due to death of the 1st respondent in the above SA. CMP No. 2815 of 2020 PRAYER To condone the delay of 4350 days in filing the set aside the abatement petition caused due to death of the deceased 1 st respondent in the above SA. CMP No. 2816 of 2020 PRAYER To bring on record respondent 3 to 4 the legal heirs of the 1 st respondent as respondents 3 to 4 in this appeal. For Petitioner(s) in all CMPs: M/s.L.Ramu COMMON ORDER (1)The above miscellaneous petitions are filed to condone the delay in filing the petitions for setting aside the abatement caused due to the death of the 1 st respondent in both the second appeals ; to set aside the abatement and to bring on record the LRs of the deceased 1 st respondent as respondents 9 and 10 in the above Second Appeals. (2)Heard both sides. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 (3)The relationship is not disputed. Being satisfied with the reasons stated in the affidavit filed in support of the miscellaneous petitions filed to condone the delay of 4350 days, CMP.Nos.2812 and 2815/2020 are ordered. (4)Consequently, CMP.Nos.2808, 2811, 2814 and 2816/2020 are also ordered. (5)Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that as regards 2 nd respondent, he seeks time to get instructions. (6)Hence, post the matter on 17.07.2025. 10-07-2025 AP Index:Yes/No Speaking/Non-speaking order Internet:Yes Neutral Citation:Yes/No https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 CMP No. 2808 of 2020 To 1.Sampoornam(deceased) W/o.Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therkuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Taluk And District. 2.SIVAKAMI W/o.Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellottamparappu Village, Erode Taluk And District. 3.ARUKKANIAMMAL W/o.Ramana Gounder, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 4.LAKSHMI W/o.Subbanan, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 5.S.Sumathi No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 6.THANGAVEL No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 7.K.S.Kumarasamy S/o.Selambna Gounder, No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 8.K.Vijayalakshmi No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 9.KALPANA W/o.M.Satheesh Kumar, Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows, Temple Town Street, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet, Chennai 600 044. 10.N.Udayakumar S/o.V.K.Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode 6378 002. SA No. 603 of 2001 To 1.SAMPOORNAM 2.SIVAKAMI 3.ARUKKANIAMMAL 4.LAKSHMI https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 5.SUMATHY 6.THANGAVEL 7.K.S.Kumarasamy 8.VIJAYALAKSHMI . SA No. 604 of 2001 To 1.SAMPOORNAM 2.SIVAKAMI CMP No. 2811 of 2020 To 1.Sampoornam(deceased) W/o.Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therkuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Taluk And District. 2.SIVAKAMI W/o.Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 Of Vellottamparappu Village, Erode Taluk And District. 3.ARUKKANIAMMAL W/o.Ramana Gounder, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 4.LAKSHMI W/o.Subbanan, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 5.S.Sumathi No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 6.THANGAVEL No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 7.K.S.Kumarasamy S/o.Selambna Gounder, No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 8.K.Vijayalakshmi No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 9.KALPANA W/o.M.Satheesh Kumar, Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 Meadows, Temple Town Street, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet, Chennai 600 044. 10.N.Udayakumar S/o.V.K.Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode 6378 002. CMP No. 2812 of 2020 To 1.Sampoornam(deceased) W/o. Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therukuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Tk And Dist 2.SIVAKAMI W/o. Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellorttamparappu Village, Erode Tk And Dist 3.KALPANA W/o. M.Satheesh Kumar Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows Temple Town St, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet Chennai-44 4.N.Udaya Kumar S/o. V.K. Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode -02 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 CMP No. 2814 of 2020 To 1.Sampoornam(deceased) W/o. Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therukuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Tk And Dist 2.SIVAKAMI W/o. Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellorttamparappu Village, Erode Tk And Dist 3.KALPANA W/o. M.Satheesh Kumar Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows Temple Town St, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet Chennai-44 4.N.Udaya Kumar S/o. V.K. Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode -02 CMP No. 2815 of 2020 To 1.Sampoornam(deceased) W/o.Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therkuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 Taluk And District. 2.SIVAKAMI W/o.Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellottamparappu Village, Erode Taluk And District. 3.ARUKKANIAMMAL W/o.Ramana Gounder, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 4.LAKSHMI W/o.Subbanan, No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 5.S.Sumathi No.91, Merkku Veethi, Pattinathaar Veedu, Therkku Puthu Palayam, Vadakku Puthu Palayam(post) Unjalur(via), Erode 638 152. 6.THANGAVEL No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 7.K.S.Kumarasamy S/o.Selambna Gounder, No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. 8.K.Vijayalakshmi No.37, Ulavan Nagar, Erode 9. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 9.KALPANA W/o.M.Satheesh Kumar, Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows, Temple Town Street, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet, Chennai 600 044. 10.N.Udayakumar S/o.V.K.Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode 6378 002. CMP No. 2816 of 2020 To 1.Sampoornam(deceased) https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 W/o. Duraisamy Gounder, Pattanathar Veedu, Therukuppuudupalayam, Hamlet Of Vengambur Village, Erode Tk And Dist 2.SIVAKAMI W/o. Sundaram, Arikkaranttur Hamlet Of Vellorttamparappu Village, Erode Tk And Dist 3.KALPANA W/o. M.Satheesh Kumar Flat No.9, Second Floor, Sb Jain Alphine Meadows Temple Town St, Tiruneermalai Main Road, Chrompet Chennai-44 4.N.Udaya Kumar S/o. V.K. Nallasamy, No.A11, Pokkuvarathu Nagar, Lakkapuram Post, Erode -02 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis CMP No. 2808 of 2020 N.MALA J. AP CMP No. 2808 of 2020 AND SA NO. 603 OF 2001,SA NO. 604 OF 2001,CMP NO. 2811 OF 2020,CMP NO. 2812 OF 2020,CMP NO. 2814 OF 2020,CMP NO. 2815 OF 2020,CMP NO. 2816 OF 2020 10-07-2025 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis