- 1 - ! "# $ #%%&' ( ! " # $ %%% ! " # $ &"# $ % % % ' (%% % % % $ $ $) *+ * , Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )$# -./011203./04./.567489:-2;<=6925:87>85?.>:.8505= 84=2485/25:25>2=0:2=% % %.5 8 (%% 85:-27.3287:-2==.:.8503./:4.>:05=2//.85/<=62 05=@0 -2 405A 87 :-2 104:.2/ .5 :-2 4.03 8<4: B.33 C2 >85/.=242=-25>2784:-784>85?25.25>2 *+,-./0/1,.-0, : ./ :-2 >0/2 87 :-2 148/2><:.85 :-0: :-2 >89130.505: C2.56:-270:-2487:-2?.>:.938=62=0>89130.5:/:0:.56 :-0: -./ =0<6-:24 ) -0= >89132:2= -24 05= :-24207:24/-2-0==./>85:.5<2=-24/:<=.2/ /124:-2 42D<2/:87) -268:-240=9.::2=:8:-2:0.384.56>30// /.:<0:2=0: 030?033.8B5 :./7<4:-24/:0:2=:-0:85 %& %%048<5=E %%0 9 ) B25::8 030?033.:80::25=:-2:0.384.56>30//03856 B.:--2474.25=/-B.5. $<4:-24.:.//:0:2=:-0:/-2=.= 58: 42:<45 :8 -24 -8</2 85 :-0: =0@ 2.56 105.>A2= 0C8<: :-2 /.:<0:.85 -2 /:0:2= :8 -0?2 /204>-2= 784 :-2 B-2420C8<:/ 87 -./ =0<6-:24 / -2 >8<3= 58: 62: :-2 - 3 - >8442>: .578490:.85 -2 38=62= 0 >89130.5: C27842 :-2 183.>2/:0:.56:-0:-./=0<6-:24B0/78<5=9.//.56 <4.56 :-2 .5?2/:.60:.85 :-2 >89130.505:32045: :-0: -./ =0<6-:24 -0= C225 A.=50112= C@ :-2 0>></2= 0?.56 32045: :-2 /0.= 70>: -2 38=62= 852 9842 >89130.5: 060.5/: :-2 0>></2= 0/ 124 F 7:24 426./:24.56 :-2 >0/2 060.5/: :-2 0>></2= :-2 ;<4./=.>:.8503 183.>2 -0?2 32045::-0:C8:-:-2?.>:.905=:-20>></2=B242/:0@.56 0: 05=4.:05=0 04011050-033. 03<A / 0 104: 87 :-2 .5?2/:.60:.85 :-2 ;<4./=.>:.8503 183.>2 B25: :8 :-2 130>2 /2><42=:-2905=C48<6-::-29:8:-2183.>2/:0:.85 7:24/2><4.56:-2 142/25>287) -24/:0:2925:B0/ 42>84=2= /124:-2/0.=/:0:2925:.:42?203/:-0::-2 0>></2=-0=>899.::2=/2F<030//0<3:85-24=<4.56-24 /:0@B.:-:-20>></2= -2427842:-2;<4./=.>:.8503183.>2 -0?2 .5/24:2= 2>:.85/ "# 05= & 87 :-2 5=.05 2503 8=2 "784 /-84: G H# 7:24 >85=<>:.56 :-2 .5?2/:.60:.85/<C9.::2=:-2>-0462/-22: & 5 84=24 :8 148?2 :-2 >0/2 87 :-2 148/2><:.85 :-2 148/2><:.85 2F09.52= EB.:52//2/ 0/) :8 ) E 05= 68: 904A2= & =8><925:/ 0/ F/ :8 & 05= 03/8 - 4 - .=25:.7.2= 90:24.03 8C;2>:/ 0/ / :8 -2 4.03 8<4: 07:24 01142>.0:.56 C8:- 8403 05= =8><925:04@ 2?.=25>2 85 42>84= 425=242= :-2 >85?.>:.85 87 :-2 0>></2= ( 204= 4. 291040;< 320452= >8<5/23 784 01123305: 05= 4. 291040;< 320452= >8<5/23 784 01123305: 05= 4. 0:.3320452=.6-8<4:8?245925:320=24784 :-242/185=25::0:2 E : ./ :-2 /<C9.//.85 87 :-2 320452= >8<5/23 784 :-2 01123305::-0::-27.5=.56/87:-24.038<4:.542>84=.56 :-2 >85?.>:.85 042 124?24/2 .332603 05= 8118/2= :8 :-2 2?.=25>28542>84= -2427842:-2/092./3.0C32:8C2 /2:0/.=2 % : ./ 7<4:-24 /<C9.::2= :-0: :-8<6- :-242 042 /892 >85:40=.>:.85/ 05= 89.//.85/ .5 :-22?.=25>2 87 90:24.03 B.:52//2/:-24.038<4:42>84=2=:-2>85?.>:.85B-.>-./ <5/</:0.50C32 570>::-2?.>:.9-0=:<452=-8/:.3205= 58: /<1184:2= :-2 >0/2 87 :-2 148/2><:.85 .5 42/12>: 87 A.=501844012 5/1.:287-24-8/:.3.:@:-24.038<4: 01142>.0:2= :-2 2?.=25>2 05= 42>84=2= :-2 >85?.>:.85 B-.>-./2448528</ - 5 - : ./ 7<4:-24 /<C9.::2= :-0: 0 /2>85= >89130.5: >092 :8 C2 426./:242= C@ :-2 >89130.505: C0/2= 85 :-2 .578490:.8542>2.?2=C@) >>84=.56:8) -2-0= /225 :-2 0>></2= 5204 0621<40 .4>32 -8B2?24 :-2 2?.=25>2 87 ) B8<3= .5=.>0:2 :-0: /-2 -0= C225 :8 :0.384.56>30//03852 -2>85:40=.>:.85.542/12>:87) -0?.56/225:-20>></2=0:0621<40C<//:81/-8<3=58: -0?2C225>85/.=242=C@:-24.038<4: : ./ 7<4:-24 /<C9.::2= :-0: :-8<6- ) ( /:0:2= :8 -0?2 >85=<>:2= /18: 90-0I04 0: 05=4.:05=0 B-242 .: ./ 033262=:-0:C8:-) 05=:-20>></2=B242/:0@.56784 /-84:24124.8=-8B2?24) (-0/58:>.:2=05@38>03.:2/ 0/B.:52//2/:8:-2/0.=90-0I04584>.:2=:-28B52487 :-2-8</28452.6-C8<4/0/B.:52//2/:8=218/20C8<::-2 /:0@ 0: :-2 /0.= 130>2 85+925:.85.56 :-2 .5=2125=25: B.:52//2/:8:-2/0.=90-0I04B8<3=>420:20=8<C: -2 /0.==8<C:/-8<3=-0?2C2256.?250/0C2527.:87=8<C: :8 :-2 0>></2= 5 70>: :-2 0>></2= -0= /:0:2= .5 -./ /:0:2925: B-.>- B0/ 42>84=2= <5=24 2>:.85 87 4 :-0:-2B0/0442/:2=C@:-2183.>2B-25-2B0/ 0: 090506040 - 6 - :./7<4:-24/<C9.::2=:-0::-24.038<4:>899.::2=05 24484 .5 01142>.0:.56 :-2 2?.=25>2 87 )/ 05= 1481243@0/042/<3:87B-.>-:-2.91<652=;<=6925:./ 10//2=B-.>-./3.0C32:8C2/2:0/.=2 //<>-320452= >8<5/23784:-201123305:140@/:80338B:-2011203 24 >85:40 :-2 320452= .6- 8<4: 8?245925: 320=24 ?2-2925:3@ ;</:.7.2= :-2 ;<=6925: 87 >85?.>:.85 10//2= C@ :-2 4.03 8<4: 05= -2 7<4:-24 /<C9.::2= :-0: :-2 25:.42>0/2./C0/2=85:-22?.=25>287:-2>89130.505: ?.>:.905=) -2?.>:.9B0/09.5840/85:-2=0:2 87 :-2 .5>.=25: -2 -0= 58: 853@ C225 0C=<>:2= C<: 03/8 C225 /<C;2>:2= :8 /2F<03 0//0<3: -2 92=.>03 42>84= B8<3= .5=.>0:2 :-0: /-2 -0= C225 /<C;2>:2= :8 /2F<03 0//0<3: -2427842 :-2 4.03 8<4: -0/ 4.6-:3@ 42>84=2= :-2 >85?.>:.85 07:24 01142>.0:.56 :-2 8403 05= =8><925:04@2?.=25>28542>84= :./7<4:-24/<C9.::2=:-0:2?25:-8<6-) -0/:<452= -8/:.32:-22?.=25>2B-.>-/-2/<1184:2=:-2>0/287:-2 148/2><:.85-0/:8C2>85/.=242= -22?.=25>287) B8<3= .5=.>0:2 :-0: /-2 -0= C225 /<C;2>:2= :8 /2F<03 0//0<3:07:24/-2B0/0C=<>:2= -2/0.=0/12>:-0/C225 - 7 - /<1184:2=C@:-292=.>032?.=25>2 ) -0//<1184:2= :-2>0/287:-2148/2><:.85/:0:.56:-0:-2-0=/225B-25 0>></2= B0/ 0C=<>:.56 :-2 ?.>:.9 / 033 :-2 B.:52//2/ 042 >85/./:25: .5 :-2.4 2?.=25>2 :-0: :-2 ?.>:.9 B0/ 0C=<>:2=05=/<C;2>:2=:8/2F<030//0<3:C@:-20>></2= :-2 >85?.>:.85 42>84=2=C@ :-2 4.03 8<4: ./ 148124 05= ;</:.7.0C32 -2427842.5:2472425>2B.:-:-2/0.=7.5=.56/ ./ 58: :250C32 0A.56 /<>- /<C9.//.85/ :-2 320452= .6- 8<4: 8?245925: 320=24 140@/ :8 =./9.// :-2 011203 0?.56 -204= :-2 320452= >8<5/23 784 :-2 42/12>:.?2 104:.2/05=03/8124</2=:-27.5=.56/87:-24.038<4:.5 42>84=.56:-2>85?.>:.85.:./>3204:-0::-27.5=.56/87:-2 4.038<4:.5425=24.56:-2>85?.>:.85B242C0/2=85:-2 2?.=25>2 87 )/ 05= 05= 03/8 :-2 92=.>03 2?.=25>2 & -2 4.03 8<4: 07:24 01142>.0:.56 :-2 2?.=25>2 87 ) 2/12>.033@ :-2 2F09.50:.85+.5+>-.27 81.52= :-0: /-2 -0/ /<1184:2= :-2 >0/2 87 :-2 148/2><:.85 -8B2?24 -24 >48//+2F09.50:.85 -0/ C225 .65842= -2 92:-8= .5 B-.>-:-24.038<4:01142>.0:2=:-22?.=25>287) .5 - 8 - 9@?.2B./58:148124784:-2420/85:-0::-22?.=25>287 :-2 B.:52// -0/ :8 C2 420= 0/ 0 B-832 -2 2?.=25>2 B-.>- .5>3<=2/ 2F09.50:.85+.5+>-.27 >48//+2F09.50:.85 05=42+2F09.50:.85 20=.56:-22?.=25>2.501.>A05= >-88/2905524./<5/</:0.50C32 ( -2 2?.=25>2 87 ) B8<3= 682/ :8 /-8B :-0: .5.:.033@ /-2 /<1184:2= :-2 >0/2 87 :-2 148/2><:.85 -8B2?24 .5 :-2 >48//+2F09.50:.85 /-2 -0/ 0=9.::2= :-0: /-2 B0/ 52.:-24 A.=50112= 584 /2F<033@ C225 0//0<3:2= C@ :-2 0>></2= -8<6- :-2 92=.>03 2?.=25>2 B8<3= .5=.>0:2 :-0:/-2B0//<C;2>:2=:8/2F<030//0<3::-270>:4290.5/ :-0: .: ./ 0 ;</: 81.5.85 : ./ 522=32// :8 /:0:2 :-0: >85?.>:.85>0558:C2/</:0.52=853@85:-2C0/./872F124: 81.5.85 E -2 4.03 8<4: >899.::2= 24484 .5 01142>.0:.56 :-2 2?.=25>2 87 877.>.03 B.:52//2/ :-0: :-2@ -0?2 >85=<>:2= /18:90-0I0487:-2130>2B-242.:.//0.=:-0:) B0/ /:0@.56 03856 B.:- 0>></2= 0: 05=4.:05=0 B-.>- ./ 2448528</784:-2420/85:-0::-28B52487:-2-8</284 52.6-C8<4/8438>03.:2/-0?258:C225>.:2=0/B.:52//2/ 584 2F09.52= 784 :-2 1<418/2 87 >8448C840:.85 5 :-2 - 9 - 0C/25>2 87 105>- B.:52//2/ B-8 042 :-2 38>03.:2/ .: ./ -04=:8C23.2?2:-0::-2148/2><:.85-0/148?2=:-0:) B0/ A21: .5 :-2 130>2 B-242 :-2 183.>2 -0?2 >85=<>:2= :-2/18:90-0I04 % 542+01142>.0:.56:-22?.=25>287033:-2B.:52//2/C8:- 8403 05= =8><925:04@ 09 87 :-2 >85/.=242= 81.5.85 :-0::-24.038<4:-0/>899.::2=640?22448458:853@.5 01142>.0:.56 :-2 2?.=25>2 87 ) C<: 03/8 8:-24 =8><925:04@ 2?.=25>2 -2427842 :-2 >85?.>:.85 87 :-2 0>></2= >0558: C2 /</:0.52= -</ :-2 ;<=6925: 87 >85?.>:.85 05= 84=24 87 /25:25>2 10//2= C@ :-2 4.03 8<4:./3.0C32:8C2/2:0/.=2 25>2 148>22=:810//:-278338B.56* .# -2>4.9.503011203./0338B2= ..# -2 ;<=6925: 87 >85?.>:.85 05= 84=24 85 /25:25>2 =0:2=% % %10//2=.5 8 (%%C@:-2 ==.:.8503./:4.>:05=2//.85/<=62 05=@0.//2: 0/.=2 ...# -201123305:0>></2=./0>D<.::2=784:-287725>2/ 1<5./-0C32<5=242>:.85/05=E&87 - 10 - .?# 0.3C85=/2F2><:2=.705@/:05=>05>2332= 5?.2B87:-2=./18/0387:-212:.:.85125=.56 / =82/ 58:/<4?.?2784>85/.=240:.8505=:-2/09204203/8=./18/2=87 0>>84=.563@ 234 & ' $ ./:8 *38 *