Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Tripura · body

2025 DAILYLAW 1937 (TRI)

SHRI NAYAN DEBNATH AND 119 OTHERS v. UNION OF INDIA AND 4 OTHERS

WP(C)/520/2025 · 2025-12-12

Biswajit Palit

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA AGARTALA W.P(C). No.520 of 2025 1. Shri Nayan Debnath, S/O-Nirmal Debnath, aged 23 years, resident of Paschim Taranagar, Mohanpur, P.O.-Mohanpur, P.S.-Sidhai Police Station, District-West Tripura, Pin-799211. 2. Shri Bishal Goala, S/O-Ganesh Goala, aged 25 years, resident of Simla Colony, Brahma Kunda, P.O.-Mohanpur, P.O.-Simna Colony BO, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799212 3. Shri Miton Kumar Debnath, S/O-Maran Kumar Debnath, aged 21 years, resident of Khamar Bari, Champaknagar, P.O-Champaknagar, P.S.-Jirania Police Station, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799045 4. Rakesh Hosen, S/O-Amin Uddin, aged about 23 years, resident of Ward No.3 Joynagar, P.O-Birendra Nagar, P.S.-N.C.C., Dist.-West Tripura, Pin- 799045. 5. Shri Rahul Debnath, S/O-Uttam Debnath, aged about 21 years, resident of Khamar Bari, Madhya Debendra Nagar, P.O.-Champak Nagar, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799045. 6. Shri Sagar Pal, S/O-Shyamal Pal, aged about 20 years, resident of Lowgang, Bagafa, P.O.-Lowgang, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799144. 7. Shri Sourab Deb, S/O-Nitya Ranjan Deb, aged 25 years, Resident of Madhupur School Chowmuhani, P.O.-Bishalgarh, Dist.-Sepahijala, Pin-799102. 8. Dilhar Hussain, S/O-Abdul Karim, aged 22 years, resident of Hurua, P.O.-East Hurua, Dist.-North Tripura, Pin-799253. 9. Shri Akash Debnath, S/O-Sambhu Debnath, aged 23 years, resident of Dukhini Para, P.O.- Srinagar B.O., Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799143. 10. Shri Rajib Malakar, S/O-Narayan Malakar, aged 25 years, resident of East Ratacharra, P.O.-Purba Ratacharra, Dist.-Unakoti, Pin-799290. 11. Shri Jayanta Das, S/O-Babul Ch. Das, aged 21 years, resident of Gorifa, P.O.-Gorifa, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799143. 12. Shri Dipan Sahaji, S/O-Bimal Sahaji, aged 20 years, resident of South Karaichara, P.O.- Karaichara, Dist.-Unakoti, Pin-799263. 13. Shri Joydip Paul, S/O-Paritosh Paul, aged 21 years, resident of Radhanagar, Kumarghat, P.O.-Uttar Radhanagar, Dist.-Unakoti, Pin-799290. 2 14. Shri Prasenjit Roy, S/O-Amarkrishna Ray, aged 26 years, Resident of 60 Ghar Para, Dudhpur, P.O.-Dudhpur, Dist.-North Tripura, Pin-799288. 15. Shri Dipankar Gope, S/O-Upananda Gope, aged 26 years, Resident of Kamalnagar Margang Para, P.O.-Moharcharra, Dist.-Khowai, Pin-799203. 16. Shri Sanjib Das, S/O-Satyendra Das, aged 27 years, resident of Chitaldhar, Kadamtala, P.O.-Bakbaki, Dist.-North Tripura, Pin-799251. 17. Shri Akash Singha, S/O-Ajit Singha, aged 25 years, Resident of Dhalipukur, Golaghati, P.O.-Golaghati, Dist.-Sepahijala, Pin-799102. 18. Shri Chiranjit Das, S/O-Gouranga Das, aged 21 years, Resident of Ward 3 Chowmuhani, P.O.-Kumariakucha, Dist.-Sepahijala, Pin-799103. 19. Shri Partha Pradip Das, S/O-Biswajit Das, aged 21 years, Resident of Bishramganj, P.O.- Bishramganj, Dist.-Sepahijala, Pin-799103. 20. Shri Amarjit Debbarma, S/O-Haricharan Debbarma, aged 28 years, resident of Rajkandi, P.O.-Rajkandi, Dist.-Unakoti, Pin-799290. 21. Md. Ariful Islam, S/O-Jahangir Miah, aged 19 years, resident of Joypur Middle road, Ramnagar, P.O.-Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799001. 22. Shri Manish Sarkar, S/O-Mintu Sarkar, aged 18 years, resident of Dusamanta Narayan Para, Barjala, P.O-Birendranagar, P.S.- Jirania, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799045. 23. Shri Bishal Debbarma, S/O-Surja Kumar Debbarma, aged 25 years, resident of Chankap, P.O- Chankap, Dist.-Dhalai, Pin-799286. 24. Shri Rukan Sarkar, S/O-Pramode Sarkar, aged 19 years, resident of Laxman Para, Amtali, P.O.- Amtali, P.S.-Amtali, Pin-799130. 25. Shri Kamal Roy, S/O- Arjun Roy, aged 22 years, resident of West bank of Amar Sagar, Udaipur Nagar Panchayet, P.O.-Udaipur, P.S.- Udaipur, Dist.- Gomati, Pin-799120. 26. Shri Sayan Dey, S/O- Jagatpriya Dey, aged 19 years, resident of Masjid Kajipara, Paschim Khilpara, P.O.- Khilpara, Dist.- Gomati, Pin-799114. 27. Shri Joydip Karmakar, S/O-Late Rakesh Karmakar, aged 22 years, resident of Ichar Bil near I.C.D.S Center, P.O-Karailong, Dist.- Khowai, Pin 799205. 28. Shri Swarup Sarkar, S/O-Badal Sarkar, aged 21 years, resident of Chalita Bari, P.O- Moharchhara, Dist.-Khowai, Pin-799203. 3 29. Shri Koushik Das, S/O- Kishore Kumar Das, aged 18 years, resident of Dushmanata Narayan Para, Jirania, P.O.-Birendranagar, P.S. Jirania, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799045. 30. Shri Uday Munda S/O- Mangal Munda, aged 20 years, resident of Mantala, Narendrapur Chaa Bagan, P.O.- Sidhai SO, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799212. 31. Shri Kishan Das S/O- Late Kartik Das, aged 24 years, resident of North Durgapur, Paschim Gandacchara, P.O.-Sarma, Dist.- Dhalai, Pin-799284. 32. Shri Pranoy Deb, S/O- Pradip Deb, aged 21 years, resident of SamatalPadmabil, P.O.-SamatalPadmabil BO, Dist.- Khowai, Pin-799201. 33. Shri Joydip Malakar, S/O-Jayanta Malakar, aged 23 years, resident of Kuchainala, P.O-Kuchainala, Dist.- Dhalai, Pin-799287. 34. Shri Parag Das, S/O-Prabir Chandra Das, aged 20 years, resident of Jamjuri Para, Upendranagar, P.O-Upendranagar, Pin- 799105, Dist.- Gomati, Pin-799105. 35. Shri Nayan Tanti, S/O-Bipin Tanti, aged 25 years, resident of Darang near Darang I.C.D.S Center, P.O- Kuchainala, Dist.-Dhalai, Pin-799287. 36. Shri Sujan Debnath, S/O-Arun Debnath, aged 22 years, resident of Ward NO.5 Nath Para, Magur Chara, P.O.-Magur Cherra, Dist.- South Tripura, Pin-799143. 37. Shri Saroj Singha, S/O-Suchitra Singha, aged 25 years, resident of Lalshingmura Manipuri Para, P.O.-Lalshinghmura, P.S.- Bishalgarh, Dist.-Sepahijala, Pin-799102. 38. Shri Srikanta Das, S/O-Sashadhar Das, aged 27 years, resident of Ramendranagar, Chalita Chari, P.O- Chalita Chari, Dist.- South Tripura, Pin-799145. 39. Shri Rabi Rudra Paul, S/O-Haripada Rudra Paul, aged 22 years, resident of Belabar, P.O.- Arundhatinagar, P.S.-Arundhatinagar, Dist. West Tripura, Pin-799003. 40. Shri Antar Das, S/O-Ranjit Das, aged 19 years, resident of Doul Bari, near Doulbari I.C.D.S Center, P.O.- Doulbari, Dist.- South Tripura, Pin-799145. 41. Shri Dipak Debnath, S/O-Narayan Debnath, aged 19 years, resident of Basantanagar, Kakraban, P.O.- Kakraban, 4 P.S.- Kakraban, Dist.- Gomati, Pin-799105. 42. Shri Kajal Das, S/O-Kanai Lal Das, aged 22 years, resident of Ujan Dudhpur, P.O- Dudhpur, Dist.- North Tripura, Pin-799288. 43. Shri Shubra Das, S/O-Satish Das, aged 28 years, resident of Dhupirband, P.O.-Dhupirband, Dist.- North Tripura, Pin-799253. 44. Shri Manmohan Nath, S/O-Manik Nath, aged 24 years, resident of Anandbazar Rajnagar Laxmipur, Dharmanagar, P.O.- Rajnagar Laxmipur, Dist.- North Tripura, Pin-799254. 45. Shri Sourodip Das, S/O-Haricharan Das, aged 24 years, resident of Radhapur, P.O.- Halflongcherra, P.S.-Dharmanagar, Dist.- North Tripura, Pin-799254. 46. Shri Akash Das, S/O-Arjun Kumar Das, resident of Prasanna Das Para, Kanchanmala, P.O.- Kanchanmala, P.S.-Amtali, Dist. West Tripura, Pin-799130. 47. Shri Bijoy Debnath, S/O-Dilip Debnath, aged 23 years, resident of Ward No.4 Pathai Mog Para, P.O.- Sabroom, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799143. 48. Shri Ripan Debnath, S/O- Sanjit Debnath, aged 19 years, resident of Magurcherra, P.O.- Magurcherra, Dist.- South Tripura, Pin-799143. 49. Shri Riman Datta, S/O- Nepal Chandra Datta, aged 22 years, resident of Ashwini Mahajan Para, Dakshin Bhuratali, P.O.- Fulchari, Dist. South Tripura, Pin-799143. 50. Shri Akash Natta Das, S/O-Ranjit Natta Das, aged 27 years, resident of Bagmara, Khash Madhupur, P.O.- Amtali, P.S.- Amtali, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin- 799130. 51. Shri Kishan Chakraborty, S/O- Dulal Chakraborty, aged 22 years, resident of Brindaban Para, Chittamara, Belonia Rajnagar, P.O.- Chittamara, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin- 799155. 52. Shri Rajkumar Sabdakar, S/O- Rajendra Sabdakar, aged 25 years, resident of Dhupirband, P.O.-Dhupirband, Dist.- North Tripura, Pin-799253. 53. Shri Dipak Das, S/O- Nibaran Das, aged 23 years, resident of Kamrangatali, P.O.-Kamrangatali, P.S.-Melaghar, Dist.-Sepahijala, Pin-799105. 54. Shri Dipu Sarkar, S/O-Swarupananda Sarkar, aged 22 years, resident of Sarkarpara, Dudhpur, P.O- Dudhpur, Dist.-Unakoti, Pin-799288. 55. Shri Jiban Das, S/O-Har Kumar Das, aged 25 years, resident of Birendrapara, Michhuria, P.O.- Michhuria, Dist.- Dhalai, Pin-799278. 5 56. Shri Arghadeep Chowdhury, S/O-Late Badal Chowdhury, aged 23 years, reasident of Bamutia, P.O.-Bamutia, P.S.- Lefunga, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799211. 57. Shri Dibakar Roy, S/O-Dhanendra Roy, aged 23 years, resident of Santi Palli Charipara, P.O.- Charipara, P.S.-Amtali, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799003. 58. Shri Shri Ujjal Das, S/O-Manmohan Das, aged 25 years, resident of Gukul Nagar, P.O.-Michhuria, Dist.-Dhalai, Pin-799278. 59. Shri Biswajit Das, S/O-Manik Das, aged 26 years, resident of Kamal Nagrar, Haradhan Palli, P.O.-Champaknagar, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799045. 60. Shri Joybrata Roy, S/O-Ganesh Roy, aged 28 years, resident of Goutam Nagar, South Rajnagar, P.O.-Rajnagar, P.S.-Rajnagar, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin- 799150. 61. Shri Ripan Debnath, S/O-Late Gouranga Debnath, aged 26 years, resident of Radhanagar, P.O.-Radhanagar, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799153. 62. Shri Sajal Debnath, S/O-Narayan Debnath, aged 23 years, resident of Saha Para, Magur Chara, P.O.-Sabroom, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799143. 63. Shri Shri Prasenjit Das, S/O-Prahlad Das, aged 25 years, resident of Chandipur, P.O.-Chandipur, Dist.-North Tripura, Pin-799277. 64. Pratap Das, S/O-Chitta Ranjan Das, aged 21 years, resident of Basantanagar, Kakraban, P.O.-Kakraban, P.S.-Kakraban, Dist.-Gomati, Pin-799105. 65. Shri Balaram Das, S/O-Uttam Das, aged 28 years, resident of Kakraban, Basanta Nagar, P.O.-Kakraban, P.S.-Kakraban, Dist.-Gomati, Pin-799105. 66. Shri Sagar Sarkar, S/O-Rakhal Sarkar, aged 19 years, resident of Paschimpara, Rangamati, P.O.- Rangamati, Dist.- South Tripura, Pin-799101. 67. Shri Bappi Majumder, S/O-Uttam Majumder, aged 23 years, resident of Nayanpur, P.O.-Mongtukupara, Dist.-Khowai, Pin-799205. 68. Shri Mintu Das, S/O-Rintu Das, aged 23 years, resident of Brajendra Nagar, P.O.-Brajendra Nagar, Dist.-North Tripura, Pin-799261. 69. Shri Utpal Ghosh, S/O-Uttam Ghosh, aged 21 years, resident of Karailong, P.O.-Karailong, Dist.-Khowai, Pin-799205. 70. Shri Bapan Sarkar, S/O-Pradip Sarkar, aged 25 years, resident of Kayamani, G.P. Kakraban Block, Udaipur, P.O.-Kakraban, P.S.-Kakraban, Dist.- Gomati, Pin-799105. 6 71. Shri Chiranjit Das, S/O-Gouranga Das, aged 21 years, resident of Kumariakucha, Ward No.3, P.O.-Kumariakucha, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799103. 72. Shri Suman SUKLA Das, S/O-Chandan Shukla Das, aged 24 years, resident of Ward NO.3 Chowmuhani, Kumariakucha, P.O.-Kumariakucha, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799103. 73. Shri Anup Das, S/O-Ranjan Das, aged 21 years, resident of Kamala Nagar, P.O.-Champak Nagar, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799045. 74. Shri Abhijt Deb, S/O-Sribash Deb, aged 19 years, resident of Harerkhola, Kamalpur, P.O.-Kamalpur, P.S. Kamalpur, Dist.-Dhalai, Pin-799285. 75. Shri Swarup Sarkar, S/O-Badal Sarkar, aged 22 years, resident of Chlita Bari, P.O.- Mohar Cherra, Dist.- Khowai, Pin-799203. 76. Shri Abhijit Das, S/O-Ajit Das, aged 28 years, resident of Samatal Padmabil, P.O.-Padmabil, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799201. 77. Litan Mia, S/O-Babul Mia, aged 21 years, resident of Kamrangatali, P.O.- Kamrangatali, Dist.-Sepahijala, Pin-799105. 78. Mustafa Kamal, S/O-Achalat Miah, aged 19 years, resident of Uttar Maharani, P.O.- Tripureswari Colony, Dist.-Gomati, Pin-799013. 79. Saiful Islam, S/O-Rafique Miah, aged 23 years, resident of Ward No.8, Indranagar, P.O.- Melaghar, P.S.- Melaghar, Dist.- Sepahijala, Pin-799115. 80. Shri Uttam Das, S/O-Ras Mohan Das, aged 22 years, resident of 24, Banduar, P.O.- Bazar Amtali, Dist. Gomati, Pin-799105. 81. Shri Abhisek Santal, S/O-Rabi Santal, aged 24 years, resident of 22, Satni Thal, Paschim Belchara, P.O.- Paschim Belchara, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799201. 82. Shri Sakti Suklabaidya, S/O-Nitya Ranjan Suklabaidya, aged 27 years, resident of 42, Ward No.5, East Manik Bhander, P.O.- Manik Bhander, Dist.- Dhalai, Pin-799287. 83. Shri Bipul Paul, S/O-Bhakta Paul, aged 23 years, resident of Puratan Bampur, Amarpur, P.O.-Bampur, Dist.-Gomati, Pin-799101. 84. Sahanaj Miah, S/O-Kabir Miah, aged 23 years, resident of R.K. Pur, Rajarbag, Udaipur, P.O.- R.K. Pur, Dist.- Gomati, Pin-799120. 7 85. Shri Biswajit Sarkar, S/O-Nikhil Sarkar, aged 24 years, resident of 2 No Bangali Para, Paschim Malbasa, P.O.-Malbasa, P.S.-Amarpur, Dist.-Gomati, Pin-799101. 86. Shri Pankaj Sarkar, S/O-Matilal Sarkar, aged 25 years, resident of Dhanchari, N.C. Nagar, P.O.- Bishalgarh, P.S.- Bishalgarh, Dist. Sepahijala, Pin-799102. 87. Shri Nayan Debnath, S/O-Krishna Debnath, aged 22 years, resident of Kepram Para, Paschim Noagaon, P.O.-Purba Noagaon, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799035. 88. Shri Hriday Lodh, S/O-Sadhan Lodh, aged 22 years, resident of ward No.3 Majumder Para, Muhuripur, P.O.-Muhuripur, P.S.-Baikhora, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799142. 89. Shri Rupesh Bardhan, S/O-Sanjit Bardhan, aged 23 years, resident of Haripur, Ganda Chara, P.O.-Sarma, P.S.-Ganda Chara, Dist.-Dhalai, Pin-799284. 90. Shri Rituraj Deb Roy, S/O-Priyatosh Deb Roy, aged 22 years, resident of Palatana, Udaipur, P.O.-Kakraban, P.S.-Kakraban, Dist.-Gomati, Pin-799105. 91. Shri Sajal Das, S/O-Mintu Das, aged 23 years, resident of 100 Card Para, Dakshin Radhanagar, Belonia, P.O.-Radhanagar, P.S.-P. R. Bari, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799153. 92. Shri Subhankar Das, S/O-Dulal Das, aged 20 years, resident of Garurband, Urmai, P.O.-Urmai, P.S.- Sonamura, Dist.-Sepahijala, Pin-799115. 93. Shri Bikash Shil, S/O-Swapan Chandra Shil, aged 23 years, resident of Laxmipur, P.O-Laxmipur, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799155. 94. Shri Sujan Das, S/O-Sukumar Das, aged 28 years, resident of Ward No.1 ,Majlishpur, P.O- Ranirbazar, P.S.-Raniebazar, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799035. 95. Shri Ujjal Das, S/O-Biswajit Das, aged 19 years, resident of 210, R K Nagar Habitation, Old Agartala Block, Khashnoagaon, P.O.-Khayerpur, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799008. 96. Sourav Hossain, S/O-Anu Miah, aged 22 years, resident of Rajdharnagar, Jamjuri, P.O.-Jamjuri, Dist.-Gomati, Pin-799013. 8 97. Shri Subendu Das, S/O-Samir Das, aged 22 years, resident Dudhpuskarini, P.O.-Ichachara, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799105. 98. Shri Sujan Nama, S/O-Krishna Nama, aged 18 years, resident of Uttar Rangamura, Sapmara, P.O.- Radhanar, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799153. 99. Shri Supratim Sahaji, S/O-Haritosh Sahaji, aged 19 years, resident of Ghoshpara, Amtali, P.O.-Amtali, P.O.-Amtali, P.S.-Amtali, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799130. 100. Shri Narayan Sukla Baidya, S/O-Nalini Sukla Baidya, aged 24 years, resident of SamatalPadmabil, P.O.- Samatal Padmabil, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799201. 101. Shri Biplab Das, S/O-Bishnu Pada Das, aged 26 years, resident of Radhanagar/North Krishnapur, P.O.-Radhanagar, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799153. 102. Shri Jyotirmoy Das, S/O-Bishnu Pada Das, aged 22 years, resident of Radhanagar/North Krishnapur, P.O.-Radhanagar, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799153. 103. Shri Sagar Sarkar, S/O-Swapan Sarkar, aged 24 years, resident of 4 No Tilla, North Krishnapur, Ρ.Ο.-Radhanagar, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799153. 104. Shri Biswajit Nama, S/O-Santosh Nama, aged 27 years, resident of Sitakhala, Konaban, P.O.- Konaban, P.S.-Madhupur, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799100. 105. Shri Sajan Das, S/O-Sukumar Das, aged 28 years, resident of Ward No.1, Majlishpur, P.O.-Ranirbazar, P.S.-Ranirbazar, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799035. 106. Shri Rakesh Das, S/O-Jatan Das, aged 24 years, resident of Ward No.2, Khandakar Para, Bagabasa, P.O.-Bagabasa, P.S.-Bagabasa, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799115. 107. Shri Joydip Suklabaidya, S/O-Jadu Suklabaidya, aged 19 years, resident of Putiachara, Kamalpur, P.O.-Noagaon, Dist.-Dhalai, Pin-799285. 108. Shri Prasanta Das, S/O-Ram Lal Das, aged 27 years, resident of Kuchainala, P.O.- Kuchainala, Dist.- Dhalai, Pin-799287. 109. Shri Suhel Yadav, S/O-Saheb Yadav, aged 20 years, resident of BilashChara, Ganga Nagar, P.O- Bilashchara, Dist.- Dhalai, Pin-799285. 9 110. Shri Rahul Debnath, S/O-Hare Krishna Debnath, aged 23 years, resident of Ward No.1, Killamura, Purba Nalchar, P.O.-Nalchar, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin- 799115. 111. Shri Dipankar Biswas, S/O-Dulal Biswas, aged 23 years, resident of Krishnapur, Teliamura, P.O.- Mongtukupara, Dist.-Khowai, Pin-799205. 112. Shri Sumitra Sarkar, S/O-Prantosh Sarkar, aged 23 years, resident of Nandan Kanan Para, Harina, P.O.-Harina Bazar, P.S.-Sabroom, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin- 799145. 113. Shri Utpal Debnath, S/O-Uttam Debnath, aged 25 years, resident of Ratan Nagar, P.O.- Ranirbazar, P.S.-Ranirbazar, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799035. 114. Shri Dipankar Paul, S/O-Dilip Paul, aged 22 years, resident of Icharbil, P.O.-Karailang, P.S.-Teliamura, Dist.-Khowai, Pin-799205. 115. Shri Mrinal Das, S/O-Mantu Das, aged 28 years, resident of Laxmipur, Kobrakhamar, P.O.-Ranirabazar, P.S.-Ranirbazar, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799035. 116. Shri Raju Biswas, S/O-Girendra Biswas, aged 23 years, resident of Chankhala, P.O.- Ghilatali, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799203. 117. Shri Rabindra Rudra Paul, S/O-Pradip Rudra Paul, aged 23 years, resident of Chittamara, Belonia, P.O.-Chittamara, P.S.-Belonia, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin- 799155. 118. Shri Joy Deb, S/O-Jiban Chandra Deb, aged 22 years, resident of BamanChhara, P.O-Bamancherra, Dist.-Dhalai, Pin-799286. 119. Shri Haradhan Tripura, S/O-Subash Tripura, aged 26 years, resident of 5 No Ward, Ranga Tilla, P.O.- Belonia, P.S.-Belonia, Dist.-South Tripura, Pin-799157. 120. Shri Bikram Majumdar, S/O-Subal Majumdar, aged 23 years, resident of No.3 Kamrangatali, Ward P.O.-Kamrangatali, Dist.-West Tripura, Pin-799105 ---Petitioner(s) Versus 1. Union of India, Represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, North Block, Central Secretariat, New Delhi-110001. 2. Staff Selection Commission(SSC), Represented by its chairman, Block No.-12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003. 3. The Chairman, Staff Selection Commission, Block No.-12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003. 10 4. Central Reserve Police Force(CRPF) Represented by the Director General(Recruitment), Government of India, Block No.1, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003. 5. The Director General(Recruitment), Central Reserve Police Force(CRPF), Government of India, Block No.1, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003. ----Respondent(s) For Petitioner(s) : Mr. Subham Majumder, Adv. For Respondent(s) : Mr. Bidyut Majumder, DSGI. HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT Order 12/12/2025 Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Majumder appearing on behalf of the petitioners. Also heard Learned DSGI, Mr. B. Majumder appearing on behalf of respondent Nos.1, 4 & 5. None appeared on behalf of respondent Nos.2 & 3 inspite of service of notice. Heard both the sides. The matter is taken up for hearing and disposal. The petitioners of this case have filed this writ petition seeking the following reliefs: “(i) ISSUE RULE calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show cause as to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued for calling for the records, lying with the officials respondents, for rendering substantial and conscionable justice to the petitioners and for quashing/ setting aside the impugned Notification No. F. No. A. VI-1/2025-Rectt(SSB)-CT/GD-2025, dated (Annexure-2 infra) and the PET/PST examinations conducted in correspondence thereto for candidates from Tripura along with any results thereof; 08.08.2025 (ii) ISSUE RULE calling upon the respondents to show cause as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued for mandating/directing the respondents to revoke/rescind the impugned Notification No. F. No. A. VI-1/2025-Rectt(SSB)-CT/ GD-2025, dated 08.08.2025 (Annexure-2 infra), whereby intimation of conduct of the Physical Efficiency Test (PET) and Physical Standard Test (PST) events for the Constable 11 (GD) Examination-2025 in CAPFs, SSF, Rifleman (GD) in Assam Rifles, and Sepoy in NCB for CBE qualified/shortlisted candidates was notified, and to further revoke/ rescind the entire conduct of the said PET/PST tests held in AR Aizawl, 34 Assam Rifles, Aizawl, Mizoram, for the candidates from Tripura, and thereafter, to conduct fresh PET/PST tests for the Petitioners and similarly situated candidates from Tripura at venues in Agartala, Tripura, such as the Assam Rifles Ground, Agartala or CRPF Group Centre, Adarani, Agartala, ensuring proper and fair conditions, including standardized tracks and adequate safety measures; (iii) ISSUE RULE calling upon the respondents to show cause as to why a Writ of Prohibition and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued for prohibiting the respondents from acting in furtherance of the results of the conduct of the Physical Efficiency Test (PET) and Physical Standard Test (PST) examinations held pursuant to the impugned Notification No. F. No. A. VI- 1/2025-Rectt(SSB)-CT/GD-2025, dated 08.08.2025 (Annexure-2 infra), and from proceeding with any results, selections, or subsequent recruitment stages arising from the PET/PST tests conducted in AR Aizawl, 34 Assam Rifles, Aizawl, Mizoram, for the candidates from Tripura; (iv) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rules absolute in terms of Prayer (ii) above; AND/OR (v) Any other relief(s) as to this Hon'ble High Court may deem fit and proper; AND For such gracious act of kindness, the humble petitioners, as in duty bound, shall ever pray.” At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the petitioners drawn the attention of the Court that the present petitioners against the advertisement dated 05.09.2024 for the post of constable (GD) in Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs) (Annexure-A) applied for those posts and after scrutiny of their applications, admits cards were issued in favour of the petitioners along with other eligible candidates, directing them to appear for written examination (computer-based examination) scheduled to be held on various dates w.e.f. 04.02.2025 to 25.02.2025. After issuance of the admit cards, the petitioners along with other eligible candidates appeared for the written examination on their 12 respective scheduled dates. On 17.06.2025, the result of the written examination was declared and the petitioners were duly qualified in the said examination. After that according to Learned Counsel, on 12.08.2025 although it was signed on 08.08.2025 (Annexure-2) DIG Recruitment CRPF vide No.F.No.A.VI-1/2025- Rectt(SSB)-CT/GD-2025 issued one notice (Annexure-2). For the sake of convenience, the relevant portion of notice is mentioned herein below: Central Reserve Police Force F. No. A.VI-1/2025-Rectt(SSB)-CT/GD-2025 (Nodal Force) Important Notice The PET/PST events of CT(GD) Exam-2025 in CAPFs, SSF, Rifleman (GD) in Assam Rifles and Sepoy in NCB for CBE qualified/shortlisted candidates is scheduled from 20/08/2025 onwards. The E Admit cards for PET/PST stage can be downloaded by shortlisted candidates from the link https://www.crpfonline.com/const qd capfs nia ssf assam rifle 2025 pet pst 0104.php available on CRPF website (i.e. https://rect.crpf.gov.in). All candidates are directed to bring printed copy of E-Admit card at the time of PET/PST. Candidates will not be permitted for PET/PST without their Admit Cards. (Reference: SSC write up No. HQ-C-3007/5/2025-C-3 dated 17/06/2025) Referring the same, Learned Counsel for the petitioners, Mr. Majumder submitted that although the same was signed on 08.08.2025 but actually it was uploaded in the website on 12.08.2025 wherein it was directed by the respondent- authority for physical efficiency and physical standard test scheduled to be held w.e.f. 20.08.2025 to 28.08.2025 and to appear for those tests at Mizoram. It was further submitted that since from the year 2012-2024 in such type of examination, the physical standard test and physical efficiency test used to be taken at Agartala for the candidates of these region. But this time, 13 the authority selected the place at Mizoram, Aizawl and the altitude of Agartala, Tripura and the altitude of Mizoram are totally different, resulting which when the petitioners appeared for the said tests, they developed certain physical discomforts and although they appeared in the exam but due to breathing and some other problem, they could not qualify the exam, resulting which the present petitioners have been seriously prejudiced and submitted that the ‘doctrine of legitimate expectation’ was not been followed in this case. According to Learned Counsel, if such type of examination could take place at Agartala, in that case there was every possibility that the petitioners could qualify the physical standard test and physical efficiency test but for choosing the venue at AR Aizawl, 34 Assam Rifles, Aizawl, Mizoram the petitioners became unsuccessful in the exam for which they have compelled to file this writ petition before this Court praying for revocation/rescind of the impugned notification dated 08.08.2025 (Annexure-2). It was further submitted that in this matter Assam Rifles was not a necessary party because the examination was conducted by SSC. So, Learned Counsel for the petitioners urged for allowing this writ petition and to quash the notification dated 08.08.2025 (Annexure-2). On the other hand, Learned DSGI, Mr. B. Majumder on behalf of respondent Nos.1, 4 & 5 appeared and submitted that this writ petition was not maintainable because Assam Rifles was not made party in this case and furthermore, all the present petitioners appeared in the physical test and after that they got 14 disqualified and after disqualification, they have approached this Court with the reliefs they sought for which at this stage, cannot be considered and urged for dismissal of this writ petition. It was further submitted by Learned DSGI that petitioner ought to have seek redress before the ensuing date of examination that is prior to 20.08.2025. So, after the test and also after appearance in the test, no cause of action lies with the petitioners to seek any redress before this Court. So, Learned Counsel urged for dismissal of this writ petition. I have heard both the sides and perused the relevant papers. It is the admitted position that the present petitioners after appearing in the physical standard test and physical efficiency test which took place on and from 20.08.2025 to 28.08.2025 where they could not qualify the test, approached this Court seeking redress. Thus, it appears to this Court that the petitioner have failed to make out any case in their favour for interference by this Court and this Court does not find any scope to entertain this writ petition in absence of any valid cause of action and accordingly, the same stands dismissed. However, no order is passed as to costs. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. JUDGE Purnita MOUMITA DATTA Digitally signed by MOUMITA DATTA Date: 2025.12.17 12:01:56 +05'30'