APHC010265472006 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI (Special Original Jurisdiction) MONDAY,the EIGHTEENTH DAY OF AUGUS TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FIVE PRESENT HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA AND HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENUTHURUMALLI GOPALA KRISHNA RAO WRIT PETITION NO: 21887 OF 2006 Between: I .The Commissioner of Police, Vijayn 2.The Director General of Police, A.P, Hyderabad. 3. Government of Andhra Pradesh, represented by its Principal Secretary, Home Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad. -4'.. r'iity. Petitioners/ Petitioners AND I. Md.Azijulla, S/o.Kasim, aged about 54 years, working as No. 1735, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada 13.06.1969) A.R.Sub-lnspector City, (date of appointment 2 J D.Koteswara Rao, S/o.Anjaial;i, aged about 51 years, working as Head Constable No.670, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.02.197!) 3. Abdul Rafee, S/o.Abdul Satlar, aged about 54 years, working as Head Constable No.912, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.07.1970) 4. K.Gandhiji, S'o.Narasimha Rao, aged about 52 years, working as Head Constable jayawada City, (date of appointment 15.12.1969) No.551, City Armed Reserve, 5. V.Joseph, S/o.Paramanandam, working as Head Constable No.724, aged about 51 years. City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.04.1971) 6.) M.P.RiKoteswara Rao, S/o.Subbaiah, aged about 54 years, working as Head Constable No.660, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.07.1970) 7. K.Ga idhi, S/o.Yesuratnam, aged about 49 years, worki.ig as Head Constable No.620, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 1 5.02.1 972) 8. Ch.Raja Ratnam, S/o.Somaiah, aged about 55 years, working as Head Constable No.647, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 13.06.1969) 9. V.Babu Rao, S/o. Venkanna, aged about 55 years working as Head Constable No.552, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada, (date of appointment 1 5.04.1 966) 10. .Lazer, S/o.Prakasam, aged about 57 years, working as Head Constable No.776, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada, (date of appointment 01.07.1970) lyMd.Yacob, S/o.Ahamed, aged about 52 yours, working as Mead Constiible (date of appointment No. 1124, City Armed Reserve, '/i!a_> awada City. 15.01.1971) r 12. Sri Abdul Sattar, S/o.Sk.Hussain, working as Head Constable about 49 years, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada 15.03.1972) No.649, aged City, (date of appointment (9 Y.F-.a na Swamy, S/o.Yesuramulu, aged about 52 years, working Cons able No. 152, Machavaram Crime PS, Vijayawada appointment 16.01.1971) ^^P.S.Prakasha Rao, S/o.Balarama Murthy aged about 49 years, of Police No. 1441, Police Controle Room, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.12.1971) as Police City, (date of working as SI 15. Abdul Khader, S/o.Ali Baig, aged about 53 years, working as Inspector of Police, No. 1283, Law and Order Patamata Police Station, Viajayawada City, (date of Asst. Sub appointment 14.02.1972) 16. Abdul Jaleel, S/o.Sk.Ismail, aged about 54 years, working No. 1011, Citv Armed Reserve, Vijayawaua 13.04.i968) T as Head Constable City, (date of appointment 17. K.Musalaiah, S.o.Anjaneyulu, aged about 52 years, working as Head Constable City, (date of appointment No.732, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada 14.06.1974) 18. P.Sambasiva Rao, S/o.VenkaJa Ratnam, aged about 52 years, working as Head Constable, No.895, City Armed Reserve, appo; litment 15.07.1970) Vijayawada City, (date of 19. T.Israia), aged about 51 years, working as Head Constable, Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of No.506, City Armed appointment 14.02.1972) 20 j A.Raveendranadh Babu, S/o.Krishna Rao, aged about 52 years, ''^Head Constable No.193, II Traffic PS, Vijayawada 14.05.1974) working as City, (date of appointment 2ll P.Venkateswara Rao, S/o.Tataiah, aged about 51 years, ^ Constable No.503, VC and Enforcement on 14.02.1972) working as Head deputation, Vijayaw'ada City Unit. "1' (date of appointment M.K.Chintaiah, S/o.Chittaiah, aged about 54 years working as Head Constable No.544, III Tiaffic Police Statjr vi, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 14.09.1973) 23. M.V.Prasada Rao, S/o.Narasimha Rao, aged about 50 years, working as Asst.Sub- Vijayawada City, (date of appointment Inspector of Police, III Traffic PS, 14.1 1.1973) Md.Husman, S/o.Md.Ibraheem, aged about 55 years, working as Head ConsI ^ble No.472, City Armeo Reserve, Vijayawada C'ty. (date of appointment 16.04 1966) * 25. M.Subba Rao, S/o.Hanumanthu Rao, aged about 50 years. Constable No. 165, Pamidimukkala Police appointment 15.07.1970) working as Head Station, Vijayawada City, (date of 26. D.Maheswara Rao, S/o.Vci:kaiah, aged about 60 years. Constable No.747, City Armed Reserve, 29.;; 1962) 27. Md.\ aseen, S/o.Sabha, aged about 62 years. Retired as b-aad Constable No.474, CAR, Vijayawada City, (date of 28. Abdul Jabbar, S/o.Abdul Raheem, aged about 59 years. Constable No.676, City Armed Reserve, appointment 15.06.1966) 29. J.Simhachalam, S/o.Laxmaiah, aged about 51 years working Constable No. 171, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City. 15.02.1972) Retired Head Vijayawada, (date of appoinlmeni r appointment 19.03.1963) Retired as Head Vijayawada City, (da*^" Head (date of appointment as GO. Khalifa Khaja Valli, S/o.Kasim, aged about 54 years, working as Head Constable No. 129, III 'i>affic Police Station, Vijayawada City, (date of appoin’^^ment T 07.12.1968) 31. Abdul Mazeed, S/o.Md.Sabha, aged about 50 years, working as Constable No.502, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.09.1971) Police 32. B.S.Ch.Bose, S/o.Sundara Rao, aged about 53 years, working Constable, No.333, Crime Station-II Circle, Vijayawada City, (date of appoi '.tment 15.1 1.1970) ^ as Head 53yN.Ba;achandrudu, S/o.Nageswara Rao, aged about 56 years, working as Reserve —/ Sub-Inspector of Police, No.529 ,City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.04.1966) <5^ . A.Waheed, S/o.Md.Ibrahim, aged about 50 years, working as No.652, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City. 14:02.1972) Constable, (date of appointment . M.Rajendra Babu, S/o.Jona, aged about 55 years, working as Police Constable, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment No.1488, I Traffic Police Station, 15.02.1971) 3^ Y.Satyanaraya.ia, S/o.Maniky.:'- Rao. aged about 49 years, working as Head Constable, No. 1 061, L&O Governorpet PS, Vijayawavia City, (date of appointment 15.10.1974). 37. Abdul Salam, S/o.Abdul Gahi, aged about 53 years, working as Head Constable, No. 1075, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 13.06.1969) 38. S.G.P; akasha Rao, S/o.Ananda Rao, aged about 49 year.>. Const, .ble. No.925, City Armed Reserve, appoii.tment 14.02.1972) v.'orking as Police Vijayaw. da City, (date of 39. Md.PGaasim, S/o.Md.Raza, aged about 60 years, Rtd.Head City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City. 40. D.Venkateswara Rao, S/o.Anjaneyulu, aged about 51 years. Constable No.717, City Armed Reserve, appointment 16.04.1971) Constable, No.584, (date of appointment 28.1 1.1962) working as Head Vijayawada City, (date of working as 41. Sk.Chinna Fakruddin, S/o.Sk.Fakruddin, aged about 51 years. Head Constable, No.555, City Armed Reserve,Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.09.1971) w'orking as Head Vijayawada City, (date of 42. K.Gandhi, S/o.Mallikarjuna Rao, aged about 52 years, Constable, No.60, L&O Govemorpet PS, appointment 16.08.1971) 9P.A.Babu Rao, S/o.Venkateswara Rao, aged about 50 years, working as Asst.Sub- Inspector, No. 113, Govemorpet PS, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.07.1970) 44. Abdi 1 Haq, S/o.Abdul Gani, aged about 60 years, Rtd.Hcad Constable, No.611, (date of appointment 19.03.1963) City /\rmed Reserve, Vijayawada City. 45. Md.Yusuf, S/o.Abdul Azeez, aged about 60 years. Retired Head Constable, No.511, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.04.1966) 46. Abdul Raheem, S/o.Abdul Azeez, aged about 60 years. Retired Constable, No. 1282, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada appointment 28.12.1962) 47. H.Samson, S/o.John Sadrak, ^ged about 47 years, working as Constable, No. 1032, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada appointment 14.09.1974) Head City, (date of Head City, (date of (1*4^ G.Nageswara Rao, S/o.Venkateswara Rao, aged about 51 years, working as Head Constable, No.556, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 14.02.1972) ©P.Rama Rao, S/o.Somaiah, aged about 56 years, working as Asst,Sub-Inspector of Police, No. 1477, Kankipadu Police Station, Vijayawada City, (date of appoi itment 15.01.1970) (s^N.Sri.ilhara Rao, S/o.Veera Raghavaiah, aged about 53 years, working as Head Vijayawada City, (date of appointment Constable, No.367, III Traffic PS, 14.09.1971) Head Constable, City, (date of appointment 51. J.Pitchaiah, S/o.Pullaiah, aged about 52 years, working as No.487. City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada 13.06.1969) 52. Md.Mustafa, S/o.Ishaq, aged about 60 years. Retired Head Constable, No.484, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City. (date of appointment 15.04.1966) (^pP.Pandu Ranga Rao, S/o.Subba Rao, aged .about 62 years, Rtd.Head Constable, No.65, III Traffic PS, Vijayawada City. (date of appointment 16.1 1.1963) 5^D.Papa Rao, S/o.Venkateswara Rao, aged about 57 years, working as Head Constable, No.933, L&O II Town PS, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 15.07.1970) 55. A.Vayunandana Rao, S/O.Varada Rajulu, aged about 54 years, working as Head Constable, No.750, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appcii ment 13.04.1968) / i _J. - —Uir-. •' ii • 56. Jannu Venkateswara Rao, S/o.Chalamaiah, aged about 59 Constable, No.521, City Armed Reserve, appointment 15.04.1966) years, Rtd.Head Vijayawada City, (date of 7. T.Venkateswara Rao, S/o.China Venkaiah, aged about 64 Constable, No.491, City Armed Reserve, appointment 07.07.1961) years, Rtd.Head Vijayawada City, (date of 58. S.Yohan, S/o.S.Y.Das, aged ab- ut 49 years, working as Head No. 1004, I Traffic PS, Vijayawada City, (date of Constable, appointment 14.09.1974) fs9J. Abdul Waheed, S/o.Azeem, aged about 51 years, working as Head Constable No.854, III Traffic PS, Vijayawada City. (date of appointment 15.01.1970) 60. V.Prakash, S/o.Sowri, aged about 52 years, working as Head Constable, No.839, L&O Hi Town PS, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 14.10.1970) T 61. Sk.H issain, S/o.Silar, aged about 60 years, working as (Rtd) No.466, City Armed Reserve, 15.04.1966) Police Constable Vijayawada City, i^date of appointment Rtd.Head Constable, 62. G.Veera Swamy, S/o.Venkatappayya, aged about 59 years. No.463, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada 15.04.1966) City, (date of appoinii'. iClil /■ 63. T.Sriramulu, S/p.Kotaiah, aged about 49 years, working as Head Constable, No.253, Penamaluru PS, Vijayawada City. (date of appointment 14.05.1974) 64. Shafivur Rahiman, S/o.Abdul Kayum, aged about 56 years, working as Head Vijayawada City, (date of Constable No. 179, City Armed Reserve, appointment 14.04.1974) years, working as SI PS, Vijayawada City, (date of . Vadlani.Venkateswara Rao, S/o.Punnaiah, aged about 56 of Police, No.613, Ibrahimpatnam Crime appointment 13.07.1966) Reserve Sub- Inspector of Police, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 10.C4 1966) 66i P.Ramudu, S/o.Raghavaiah. aged about 61 years, Rtd. Armed Head City, (date of 67. M.P.l^ aradhi, S/o.Subba Rao, aged about 57 years, working as Constable No. 1159, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada appointment 15.04.1968) 68. M.Radha Krishna Rao, S/o.Subba Rao, aged about 54 years, workiin, Asst.Sub- Inspector, No. 126, Ibrahimpatnam PS, Vijayawada, (date of appointment 16.07.1971) V.J.Prasad, S/o.Jeevaratnam, aged about 52 years, working as Sub-Inspector of Vijayawada City, (date of appointment Police, No. 14, Vuyyuru Rural PS, 15.09.1971) 2^J.Venkata Reddy, S/o.Ramanujula Reddy, aged about 58 years. Head Constable, No.1483, L&O Tcv-n PS, Vijayawad. City, (date of appointment 17.07.1963) working as 1 m :1 Cc- ::;,able. P.td.He. City, (datf; of appointment .It 60 y: 71. Ch.Venkateswara Rao, 13/o.Varadaiah, aged aV No.981, City Armed Reserve. Vijayawada 28.11.1962) able. Rtd.Head Con City, (date of appointnte..nt 72. M.Rabu Rao, S/o.Venkata Ra'^r.am, aged abont .53 years. No ' /•, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada 15.U 1971) Ch.Satyanarayana, S/o.Somaiah, aged about 48 years, wor ^ Constable, No.357, Kankipadu PS, Vijayav/ada City. (dal. as Poiire e of .ap’joinvmen- 17.08.1971) Rtd.Sub-Inspector of 74. K.Bhaskara Rao, S/o.Narasimha Rao, aged abottt 62 years. Police, No. 1291, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 14.04.1962) s SI of '.vorklng \bjayawada City, (date of 75y M.A.Ndurthuja, S/o.Meer Hussain, aged about 56 years. Police, No.569, Governcrpet Crime PS, appointmen 15.08.1966) 76. D.Jagan Mohan Rao, S/o.Satyanara^ ana, aged rbout 67 ^ .tars, Rtd.R .-.terve Sub-Inspector of Police, No.657, City Armed ^^ escrve, Vi_,.,yaw-ada City. (' vte of appointment 28.11.1962) /^^V.S.Narayana, S/o.Narasimh^ Rao, aed about C Insp ctor of Police, No. x 27 7, City Armed appointment 05.12.1962) ^8)t.D'. .-vasulu, S/o. Veerabhadraiah, aged about 64 ye?'-;', Rtd. ^ Inspt '•or of Police, No.666, City Armed appointment 28.11.1962) :b- Rtd.lfescrve Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of rr\ ‘/ems Resein'i" Sub- liriyavvadn City, (■'.'te of Reserve, 79. K.Nelabaludu, S/o.Venkaiah, aged about 62 years, Rtd. Sub- Inspector of Pr 'ice, Vijayawada, (dateofapj' No. 1260, Police Control Room, 14.04.1962) ■ -xlt 1 '.''orking as SI of City Zone (on deputation) (d ’.tc of I P.V.Bhaskara Rao, S/o.Seethaiah, aged about 57 years. Police, No.1442, Intelligence, Vijayawada appointment 15.09.1963) 8l\. P.Koteswara Rao, S/o.Adi Seshu, aged abn^ut 62 years, P,td.Head Constable, y No.158, Kana^.adu PS, Vijaya'-ad? City. (date of appointment 06.05.i :'73) 82. B.Veera Swamy, S/o.Adinarayana, aged about 52 years, v'orkmg as Herd Constable, No.68, I Traffic PS, Vijayav/ada City, (date of appointment 17.01.1971) Rtd.Head Con.s'.able, Ci ty, (date of appointment (a tan Baig, aged about 53 years. No.542, City .Armed Reserve, Vijayawada 15.C7 968) 83. Rahimutallah Baig, S/o. PJd.Hcad Constable, (date of appointment 14.12.1 969) 4) Ch.B, uskara Rao, S/o.Somaiah, aged about 59 years. No.553, il Traffic PS, Vijayawada City. Police Constiib:326, ^yK.P.Ranga Rao, S/o.Ramaiah, aged about 71 years, Rtd.as ' (date of .-.ppointment 06.07.1" ' IV Traffic PS, Vijayawada City. / / 86. Ahamad Saheb, S/o.Akbar Sabeb, aged about 58 years. Inspector, No.779, City Armed Reserve, appointment 13.07.1966) Rtd.Reserve Sub- Vijayawada City, (date of . K.Sudhakara Rao, S/o.Suraiah, aged about 60 years. Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City. Rtd.Constable 524, City (date of appointment 14.02.1972) 88'! M.Satyanandam, S/o. Venkaiah, aged about 62 years. Retd.Head Constable, (date of appointment No.62, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City. 14.02.1972'' 89. G.VenJcateswara Rao, S/o.Redv ,.^ed about 63 year . Rtd.Police Constable, No.655, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 14.02.1972) 90. Md. Yunus, S/o.Isman, aged about 51 years, working as SI of Police, No.786, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment Central Crime Station, III Circle, 15.11.1971) f A.Vepkateswara Rao, S/o.Nagcswara Rao, aged about 62 years, Rtd.Head Cor. 3i:;ble, No.480, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 19.06 1962) ^2JM.Muralikrishna Murthy, S.^'o.Satyanarayana, aged about 62 years, Rtd.SI of Police, No. 166, Police Control Room, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 12.03.1960) 93. P.V.Nandana Rao, S/o.Nageswara Rao, aged about 64 years, Rtd.Sub-Inspector of Station-11, Vijayawada City, (date of Police, No. 1229, Central Crime 10.02.1959) appointment ([*9^ P.Papa Rao, S/o.Veera Swamy, aged about 63 years, Rtd.Head Constable No.651, Kankipadu PS, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 14.12.1960) Retired 95. T.Bhaskara Rao, S/o. Venkata S aged about 66 years. Reserve Sub-Inspector No.515, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City, (date of appointment 27.02.1958) -V 96. B.Bala Raju, S/o.Raghavulu, aged about 50 years, working as Constable No.3 i0, City Armed Reserve, Vijayawada City. 15.07.1970) Head (ckite of appointment Respondents/ Respondents (Dismissed for default as against RR2,6,11, 13, 14, 20 to 22, 24, 30, 33 to 36, 43, 48 to 50, 53, 54, 57, 59, 65, 69, 70, 73, 75, 77, 78, 80, 81, 84, 85, 87, 88, 91, 92 and 94 as per the Court order dated 27/06/2011) / Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue an appropriate Writ or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of Certiorari calling for the records, relating to and connected with order dt. 07.06.2002 in O.A.No.5293 of 2002 on the file of the Hon'ble A.P.A.T., Hyderabad and to quash the same by holding as erroneous and contrary to law. lA NO: 1 OF 2006fWPMP 27764 OF 2006 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased suspend the operation of the order dt. 07.06.2002 in O.A.No.5293 of 2002 on filed of Hon'ble A.P.A.T. Hyderabad pending disposal of the above W.P. Counsel for the Petitioners: GP FOR SERVICES I Counsel for the Respondents: SRI GOPALA RAO GANDRAKOTA The Court made the following order: APHC010265472006 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI (Special Original Jurisdiction) a-: MONDAY, THE EIGHTEENTH DAY OF AUGUST TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FIVE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA AND THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VENUTHURUMALLI GOPALA KRISHNA RAO WRIT PETITION No.21887 OF 2006 Between: 1. Commissioner of Police, Vijayawada City. 2. Director General of Police, A.P., Hyderabad. 3. Government of A.P., rep. by its Principal Secretary, Home Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad. ...Petitioners AND 1. Md Azijulla, S/o.Kasim, Working as A.R.Sub-lnspector No. 1735, City Armed REserve, Vijayawada City, Date of Appointment 13.06.1969, and others. ...Respondents G.P. for Services I Mr.Gopala Rao Gandrakota Counsel for the Petitioners Counsel for the Respondents: The Court made the following ORDER: (per Hon’ble NJS,J) Heard Mr.R.S. Manidhar Pingali, learned Assistant Government Pleader for Services-I appearing on behalf of the petitioners. \ a The present writ petition is filed against the orders dated 07.6.2002 in O.A. No.5293 of 2002 on the file of the erstwhile Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal at Hyderabad. 2. It is noted that the learned counsel for the respondents is no more. Be that as it may. The learned Assistant Government Pleader while placing a copy of the orders in W.P.No.4424 of 2004 & batch, dated 04.12.2006 and 3. WP_21887_2006 W.P. No. 19875 of 2006, dated 05.7.2010, states that in the light of the said orders, the present writ petition may be allowed and remanded for fresh consideration in accordance with law. He also submits that the orders in the connected batch of writ petitions which were allowed and remitted back to the Tribunal for disposal of the O.As., became final and ultimately the O.As filed by the applicants therein were dismissed by the Tribunal. However, no orders to that effect were filed. 2 We have perused the orders dated 27.6.2011 by virtue of which the present writ petition was dismissed for default as against respondent Nos.2, 6, 11, 13, 14, 20 to 22, 24, 30, 33 to 36, 43, 48 to 50, 53, 54, 57, 59, 65, 66, 69, 70, 73, 75, 77, 78, 80, 81, 84, 85, 87, 88, 91,92 and 94. 4. Considering the submissions made and for the reasons alike in the orders in W.P.No.4424 of 2004 & batch, dated 04.12.2006 and W.P. No. 19875 of 2006, dated 05.7.2010, the impugned orders dated 07.6.2002 passed by the Tribunal in O.A. No.5293 of 2002 are set aside as against the respondent Nos.1, 3 to 5, 7 to 10, 12, 15 to 19, 23, 25 to 29, 31, 32, 37 to 42, 44 to 47, 51, 52, 55, 56, 58, 60 to 64, 67, 68, 71, 72, 74, 76, 79, 82, 83, 86, 89, 90, 93, 95 and 96. 5. Accordingly, the writ petition is partly allowed. No order as to costs. Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed. 6. Sd/- N. NAGAMMA ASSISTANT REGI^AR //TRUE COPY// SECTION OFFICER To. 1. One CC to Sri. Gopala Rao Gandrakota Advocate [OPUC] 2. Two CCs to GP For Services I, High Court of Andhra Pradesh [OUT] 3. Two CD Copies gsc HIGH COURT DATED;18/08/2025 ORDER WP NO. 21887 OF 2006 ands;^ % S 0 6 SEP 2025 partly allowing the WP WITHOUT COSTS