- 1 - ! "# $ # % & !" #$!" %&!%!"& ' $%!"% "#!$%!"% ' ' %$ %!"! ( ( %##) !$ * * +' Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ,-. /01-.-23 405-5-23 -. 6-708 9: 5,0 405-5-230/ 90-3; <;;/-01089:5,0=23=>//0356-38-3;.265,0 2>/5.9072? ?,0/0-35,0 2>/5.9072?,<10=23=>//0357:,0785,<55,0 405-5-230/ ,<. 9003 62>38 ;>-75: 26 5,0 26603=0. >380/ 0=5-23.%##)<38!$ 2638-<303<7 280 62/.,2/5@ A % ,04</5-0.?2>7890/060//08<.40/5,0-//<3B-3;.9062/0 5,0/-<7 2>/562/=23103-03=0 '()*+,-,.)+*-) 5 -. 5,0 =<.0 26 5,0 4/2.0=>5-23 5,<5 23 %!%!"! <5 <92>5 !! <C 5,0 <==>.08 90-3; < 8/-10/ 26 5,0 9>. 90</-3; 0; 2 " %$#& ?<. 8/-1-3; 5,0 .<-8 10,-=70 23 5,0 3<5-23<7 ,-;,?<: -3 < /<., <38 30;7-;035 C<330/ .2 <. 52 038<3;0/ ,>C<3 7-60 <38 8<.,08 <;<-3.5 </>5- )!! =</ 90</-3; /0;-.5/<5-23 2 ! %!!<.</0.>7526?,-=, ."<38,<10 .>.5<-308.-C470-3D>/-0.<385,025,0/5,/00-3C<50.26 5,0 .<-8 =</ ,<10 .>.5<-308 ;/-012>. -3D>/-0. C23; 5,2.05?2-3C<50.?,2.>.5<-308;/-012>.-3D>/-0.8-08 - 3 - ,0/062/0 < =2C47<-35 =<C0 52 90 /0;-.50/08 9: 5,0 =2C47<-3<35<;<-3.55,0405-5-230/,0/0-3 $ <.08 23 5,0 =2C47<-35 26 5,0 =2C47<-3<35 5,0 D>/-.8-=5-23<7 427-=0 ,<10 /0;-.50/08 < =<.0 <;<-3.5 5,0 405-5-230/ -3 /-C0 2&!%!"! 650/ =238>=5-3; 5,0 -310.5-;<5-23 .>9C-5508 5,0 =,</;0 .,005 <;<-3.5 5,0 405-5-230/,0/0-3 E 3 2/80/ 52 4/210 5,0 =<.0 26 5,0 4/2.0=>5-23 5,0 4/2.0=>5-230F<C-308)?-530..0.<.."52)<38;25 C</B08"#82=>C035.<.F."52"#,0/-<7 2>/5 <650/,<1-3;=23.-80/085,001-803=026<775,0?-530..0. 925,2/<7<3882=>C035</:/0=2/8085,0=231-=5-23<38 5,0.<C0,<.9003<66-/C089:5,044077<50 2>/5 & 0</8 ,/-</<C0.,?</< 0;8070</308=2>3.0762/ 405-5-230/<38 ,/- <;0.,?</<44<70</308-;, 2>/5 210/3C03570<80/62/5,0/0.4238035G 5<50 # 5 -. 5,0 .>9C-..-23 26 5,0 70</308 =2>3.07 62/ 5,0 405-5-230/5,<55,0=23=>//0356-38-3;.265,0 2>/5.9072? </0 40/10/.0 <38 0//2302>. 62/ 5,0 /0<.23 5,<5 -5 -. 2442.08525,001-803=023/0=2/8,0/062/05,0.<C0 -.7-<9705290.05<.-80 - 4 - ) 5 -. 6>/5,0/ .>9C-5508 5,<5 5,2>;, 5,0 4/2.0=>5-23 ,<. 0F<C-308.010/<7?-530..0.3230265,0?-530..0.,<10 8042.08 /0;</8-3; /<., <38 30;7-;035 8/-1-3; 26 5,0 10,-=70 9: -5. 8/-10/ 3 6<=5 5,0 -3C<50. -3=7>8-3; 5,0 8/-10/265,0=</,<8900352?<5=,<C9<7<4/2;/<CC0 <385,/2>;,2>55,03-;,55,0:?0/0<?<B0308<38-35,0 C2/3-3;5,0:?0/0=2C-3;52?</8.8>4--35,0.<-8=</ ,2>;, 5,0 <==-8035 ,<8 2==>//08 23 <==2>35 26 5,0 30;7-;03=0 26 5,0 8/-10/ 26 5,0 </>5- )!! 10,-=70 -3 2/80/52<1<-75,090306-526=2C403.<5-235,0405-5-230/ ,<.9003-C47-=<5086<7.07: 5 -. 6>/5,0/ .>9C-5508 5,<5 0103 5,0 82=>C035</: 01-803=0 0.40=-<77: 5,0 .B05=, ?2>78 -38-=<50 5,<5 5,0 <==-8035,<82==>//0832523<==2>35265,030;7-;03=026 5,0 405-5-230/ ,2?010/ 5,0 .B05=, ,<. 325 9003 /0<8 4/240/7: "! 5-.6>/5,0/.>9C-55085,<55,0 2>/5.,<10525<B0-352 <==2>35 5,0 =23=045 26 =>74<970 /<.,30.. <38 =>74<970 30;7-;03=0-3=<.0.26/2<8<==-8035.,030;7-;03=0-3 =<.026<3<==-8035=<390;<5,0/086/2C5,0<55038<35 - 5 - =-/=>C.5<3=0.,0/-<7 2>/5,<.32580<75?-5,-35,<5 =2350F5 "" 5 -. 6>/5,0/ .>9C-5508 5,<5 5,0 2>/5. ,<10 52 .00 5,0 4/-C</: =<>.0 62/ 5,0 .<-8 <==-8035 ,0 C0/0 6<=5 26 2==>//03=026<3<==-8035820.32530=0..</-7:-C47:5,<5 -5 C>.5 90 2?08 52 .2C0230A. 30;7-;03=0 0 6>/5,0/ .>9C-5508 5,<5 5,0 2>/5. 9072? ,<10 =2CC-5508 <3 0//2/-3<44/0=-<5-3;5,001-803=0<387<?4/240/7:<.< /0.>75 26 ?,-=, 5,0 -C4>;308 D>8;C035. </0 4<..08 2?010/ 5,0 6-38-3;. </0 4<50357: 0//2302>. <38 >3<==045<970 03=0 5,0 =231-=5-23. /0380/08 9: 5,0 2>/5.9072?</0/0H>-/085290.05<.-80<B-3;.>=, .>9C-..-23. 70</308 =2>3.07 62/ 5,0 405-5-230/ 4/<:. 52 <772?5,0405-5-23 "% 70</308 -;, 2>/5 210/3C035 70<80/ 10,0C0357: D>.5-6-08 5,0 =23=>//035 6-38-3;. <38 ,0 6>/5,0/.>9C-55085,<55,001-803=0265,0-3C<50.265,0 </>5- )!! 10,-=70 <..>C0. ;/0<50/ .-;3-6-=<3=0 <. 5,0: </05,0-3D>/08?-530..0.,0<==-80352==>//088>052 5,0 /<., <38 30;7-;035 <=5 26 5,0 405-5-230/ ,0 .<-8 <==-8035325237:=<>.08-3D>/-0.52.2C0265,0-3C<50. - 6 - 9>5 <7.2 ?<. 5,0 /0<.23 62/ 5,0 80<5, 26 5,0 25,0/ 5?2 -3C<50.265,0=</ " 5-.6>/5,0/.>9C-55085,<55,0.B05=,?,-=,-.C</B08<. F""=70</7:80C23.5/<5085,0/<.,<3830;7-;035<=526 5,0 405-5-230/ . 40/ 5,0 .B05=, 5,0 10,-=70 ?<. .>442.08 52 90 23 5,0 7065 .-80 26 5,0 /2<8 <. -5 ?<. =2C-3; 6/2C 8>4- 52 <3;<7>/> ,2?010/ -5 .<:. 25,0/?-.0 -C-7</7:5,0</>5- )!!=</?<.5290235,0 7065.-80265,0/2<8<.-5?<.=2C-3;6/2C<3;<7>/>52 8>4- . 5,0 <==-8035 ?<. 23 ,0<8 23 =277-.-23 5,0 5,02/:26 ?2>7890<447-=<970 "$ ,001-803=0 26 .% <38 ?,2 ?0/0 5,0 -3C<50. 26 </>5- )!! =</ ?2>78 =70</7: 80C23.5/<50 5,0 =>74<970 /<.,30.. <38 =>74<970 30;7-;03=0 3 25,0/ ?2/8. 5,0 82=5/-3026 <447-0.525,0=<.023,<38 06>/5,0/.>9C-55085,<55,06-38-3;.265,0 2>/5.9072? -3/0=2/8-3;5,0=231-=5-23<38-5.=236-/C<5-23</04/240/ <38 /0701<35 350/60/03=0 ?-5, 5,0 .<-8 6-38-3;. ?2>78 325 <44/24/-<50 03=0 5,0 405-5-23 80.0/10. 52 90 8-.C-..08<B-3;.>=,.>9C-..-23.70</308-;, 2>/5 210/3C03570<80/4/<:.528-.C-..5,0405-5-23 - 7 - "E <1-3; ,0</8 5,0 70</308 =2>3.07 62/ 5,0 /0.40=5-10 4</5-0.<38<7.240/>.085,06-38-3;.265,0 2>/5.9072? -5 -. /0701<35 52 5<B0 3250 26 =0/5<-3 <.40=5. 9062/0 <810/5-3;525,06<=5.5-.<3>38-.4>5086<=55,<55,0 2>/5. 9072? ,<10 /0=2/808 5,0 =231-=5-23 62/ 5,0 26603=0.>380/ 0=5-23%##)<38!$ 26 "& ,04/-C</:=238-5-23.62/<447-=<9-7-5:26 0=5-23%#26 </0 5,<5 -5 -. 5,0 C<330/ -3 ?,-=, 5,0 10,-=70 -. 8/-103-5C>.5908/-1030-5,0//<.,7:2/30;7-;0357:<38 .>=, /<., <38 30;7-;035 8/-1-3; .,2>78 90 .>=, <. 52 038<3;0/ ,>C<3 7-60 6 5,0.0 =238-5-23. </0 .<5-.6-08 5,0403<75:=2350C47<508>380/5,0.<-8.0=5-2362772?. ,0 ?2/8 I/<., <38 30;7-;035 8/-1-3;J ,<. 52 90 8050/C-308-35,07-;,5265,06<=5.<38=-/=>C.5<3=0.26 5,0;-103=<.0,0.05?2?2/8.</0-3=<4<9702690-3; .003-3-.27<5-23,040/.23?,28/-10.5,010,-=7023 5,0/2<8-.325237:7-<9705290,078/0.423.-97062/5,0 <=59>5<7.27-<97062/5,0/0.>75 "# ,0 4/-3=-470 26 82=5/-30 26 .0/10. 5?2 4>/42.0. 230 5,<5 <3 <==-8035 C<: 9: -5. 3<5>/0 90 C2/0=23.-.5035?-5,-5.90-3;=<>.089:5,030;7-;03=0 - 8 - 62/ ?,-=, 5,0 2442.-50 4</5: -. /0.423.-970 5,<3 9: <3: 25,0/ =<>.0 3 .>=, < =<.0 5,0 C0/0 6<=5 26 5,0 <==-8035 -. 4/-C< 6<=-0 01-803=0 26 .>=, 30;7-;03=0 0=2387: -5 -. 52 <12-8 ,</8.,-4 -3 =<.0. ?,0/0 5,0 =7<-C<35-.<970524/2105,0<==-80359>5=<33254/210 ,2?5,0<==-80352==>//08 ") <1-3; =23.-80/08 5,0 4/-3=-470 .5<508 .>4/< -5 -. 30=0..</: 52 /060/ 5,0 01-803=0 26 <77 5,0 ?-530..0. 52 <.=0/5<-3<.52?,05,0/2/3255,06-38-3;.</0D>.5-6-<970 "90-3;5,0=2C47<-3<35,<.8042.08-3,-.01-803=0 5,<5,0?<.230265,0-3C<50.265,0=</,0=</?<. 90-3;8/-1039: ,/-8,</< <:<B0-..5<50852905,0 9<=B.0<50/265,0=</06>/5,0/.5<5085,<55,0 9>. ?,-=, ?<. =2C-3; 6/2C 8>4- 52?</8. <3;<7>/> ?<.=2C-3;<5,-;,.4008<38,-55,0=</23-5./-;,5.-80 <. < /0.>75 ,0 .>.5<-308 -3D>/-0. ,03 5,0 4</5-=>7</ H>0.5-23 ?<. 4>5 52 ,-C 5,<5 5,0 .B05=, ?2>78 -38-=<50 5,<5 -5 ?<. < ,0<8 23 =277-.-23 ,0 <8C-5508 5,0 .<C0 1035,2>;,,0.5<508-35,0=/2.. 0F<C-3<5-235,<55,0 9>. ?<. 210/5<B-3; 5,0 72//: <5 5,0 5-C0 26 5,0 .<-8 - 9 - <==-8035 ,2?010/ ,0 8-8 325 .5<50 5,0 .<C0 -3 ,-. .5<50C035C<809062/05,0427-=0 " -C-7</7:.%<38G25,0/-3C<50.265,0=</,<10 8042.08 5,<5 5,0 9>. ?,-=, ?<. 90-3; 8/-103 9: 5,0 <==>.08=<C0235,0?/23;.-80<38=<>.085,0<==-8035 2?010/5,0.05,/00?-530..0.90-3;5,0-3C<50.265,0 =</3010/8042.08<92>55,0=>74<97030;7-;03=0 %! $ -. .<-8 52 90 <3 -3C<50 26 5,0 9>. ==2/8-3;52,0/8>0525,0/<.,<3830;7-;03=0265,0 >. 9: -5. 8/-10/ 5,0 <==-8035 ,<8 2==>//08 2?010/ 5,0 4/2.0=>5-23 ,<. 325 4/28>=08 <3: 82=>C035.52.,2?5,<5.,0?<.5/<107-3;-35,0.<-89>. 21. E.5<50852905,0?-530..52.425C<,<K</0,<. 5>/308,2.5-70 %% 3=</06>7/0<8-3;265,001-803=026C<50/-<7?-530..0. 3230265,0?-530..0.,<108042.085,<55,0 9>. ?<. 8/-103 9: 5,0 405-5-230/ -3 < /<., <38 30;7-;035 C<330/2?010/<775,0?-530..0.,<108042.085,<5-5 ?<.90-3;8/-103-3<,-;,.4008,0.<-86<=5C<:325 905,0/0<.2362//0=2/8-3;5,0=231-=5-23<.-5-.=235/</: 525,07<?7<-882?39:5,023A970 >4/0C0 2>/5-35,0 - 10 - =<.0 26 -3 4</<;/<4, 2.$<38E?,-=,/0<8<.>380/* I ! ! ! " !# ! ! ! # ! ! ! $! ! % ! & # ! ! ! ! & !! % # % 1 1998 (8) SCC 493 - 11 - ! & ' # ! & ! ! # ! & ! (& " $ & " $ ! ) & ! & " * 3=</06>7/0<8-3;265,08-=5>C265,023A970 >4/0C0 2>/5 -5 C<B0. -5 =70</ 5,<5 C0/0 8/-1-3; 5,0 10,-=70 -3 ,-;, .4008 -. 325 .>66-=-035 52 ,278 5,<5 5,0 <==>.08 -. 62>38;>-75:265,0/<.,<3830;7-;035<=5 % 35,07-;,5265,029.0/1<5-23.C<80<9210<C265,0 =23.-80/0824-3-235,<55,0=23=>//0356-38-3;./0=2/808 9: 5,0 2>/5. 9072? -3 /0380/-3; 5,0 =231-=5-23 26 5,0 - 12 - <==>.08</0>3.>.5<-3<970,0/062/04/2=008524<.. 5,062772?-3;* - ,0 /-C-3<701-.-2305-5-23-. -- ,0 D>8;C035 26 =231-=5-23 <38 2/80/ 26 .03503=0 8<508 "#!$%!"% 4<..08 -3 2 %$%!"! 9: 5,0 88-5-23<7 -1-7 '>8;0 <38 ' 8>4- <38 D>8;C035 <38 2/80/ 8<508 %&!%!"& 4<..08 -3 /7 2$%!"% 9: 5,0 /-3=-4<7 0..-23.'>8;08>4-</0.05<.-80 --- ,0405-5-230/-.<=H>-550862/5,026603=0.>380/ 0=5-23.%##)<38!$ 26 -1 <-79238.0F0=>508-6<3:.5<38=<3=07708 /01 2 3 $ .. -.5 2*" 7 2*&