Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 16614 (KAR)

RUDRESH T v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.A/1156/2018 · 2025-01-13

K Somashekar, S Rachaiah

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # $%!% $%! %## &' () %## *+ &' %## &' ) !" # $% & % ' "((() # $*& % !$& % ( (() ((() Digitally signed by SREEDHARAN BANGALORE SUSHMA LAKSHMI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) + ()! % %% ( )($& () ( , ! % - %## *+ &' ) . , , !) !!) # $ % & % !!) *"((() # $*& % !$& % ( (() ((() + ()! % % % %% ()(()( , ! % - 3 - % !" % , / 012 / ,!% $ /& ) 34546787109::4095064067571;<=><?>34@=2;841><? A<1B7A>7<120>42( (()012<6246<1541>41A420>42 ((() :05542 71 4557<15 054 <+ ()! <1 >34 ?794 <? >34 227>7<109 75>67A> 012 4557<15 =2;4 01;09=6= C346471 >34 0AA=542 <5) 012 064 A<1B7A>42 ?<6 >34 <??41A45 :=17530D94 =1246 4A>7<15 )(* ( () ( 6 C ! <? 12701 4109 <24 $?<6 53<6>EF& 34 601G <? >34 :06>745 71 >34 6709 <=6> C799 D4 A<15724642341A4?<6>3?<6A<1B41741A4 -./012324/103/ >75>34A054<?>34:6<54A=>7<1>30>>340AA=542 <5) 012 302 7997A7> 6490>7<1537: C7>3 40A3 <>346 AA=542 <D471;>34C7?4<?110HH0<C20302>3450727997A7> 6490>7<1537: 4B41 >3<=;3 534 C05 8066742 012 30B71; 0 - 4 - 3=5D012012A3792641AA=542 <)C05C<6G71;05>34 %<645> ??7A460>>0A342><>345072B7990;4 ! >750994;4271>34A306;45344>>30>0AA=542 <5)012 71?=6>34601A4<?A<88<171>41>7<1012095<C7>3A6787109 A<15:760AH >6742 >< G799 67 110HH0 <C20 DH ;7B71; 494A>67A 53<AG <C4B46 34 5=6B7B42 <1 <D>07171; >34 :6<:46 >640>841> B41 >341 0AA=542 <5) 012 272 1<> 5><: >3476 A<88<1 71>41>7<1 >< A<887> 8=6246 <? 110HH0<C20 1 )+(!()! >34 0AA=542 <5) 012 71 ?=6>34601A4 <? >3476 A<88<1 71>41>7<1 012 A<15:760AH 0550=9>42 110HH0<C20C7>30176<1C3449D<I6<2<13753402 012 A345> :<6>7<1 012 A0=542 54B464 71@=6745 012 G79942 378 34640?>46 71 <6246 >< A<1A409 >3476 0A> >34 0AA=542 :465<15 648<B42 >34 >7945 <? >34 6<<? 012 095< A0=5422080;4><>34D0AG2<<6<?>343<=5471<6246>< A640>4057?5<84<1487;3>30B4G79942>345072110HH0 <C20 " >75?=6>3465>0>4271>34A306;45344>>30>>340AA=542 < <1 >34 5084 20H 302 71?<6842 >34 6490>7B45 012 147;3D<=65 <? >34 24A40542 0D<=> >34 71A7241> >< 24:7A> - 5 - >30>>3471A7241>C052<14DH5<84=1G1<C1:465<151 0227>7<1 >< >34 71?<680>7<1 ;7B41 >< >3476 6490>7B45 534 302 9<2;42 0 A<8:9071> D4?<64 >34 @=67527A>7<109 :<97A4 0;0715>5<84=1G1<C1:465<1534@=67527A>7<109:<97A4 0?>46 64;75>4671; >34 A054 :6<A44242 C7>3 >34 71B45>7;0>7<1 =671; 71B45>7;0>7<1 >34H ?<=12 >30> >34 0AA=542 <5) 012 C464 71B<9B42 71 >34 5072 71A7241> 06645>42 >348 64A<6242 >3476 5>0>4841>5 012 ?7942 >34 A306;45344>0;0715>D<>3>340AA=542 1<6246><:6<B4>34A054>34:6<54A=>7<14I087142 " C7>14554505,5)>< ";<>806G42 +2<A=841>505 I37D7>5)>< +012095<7241>7?742>3480>46709<D@4A>5 ) >< ) 1 >34 <>346 3012 >34 24?41A4 A<12=A>42>344I08710>7<1<?<14C7>145510849H,) 012 ;<> 806G42 47;3> 2<A=841>5 05 I37D7>5 ) >< 34 6709 <=6> 0?>46 A<15724671; >34 <609 012 2<A=841>06H 4B7241A4 <1 64A<62 A<1B7A>42 0AA=542 <5)012?<6>34<??41A455>0>4241A4>34H 064D4?<64>375<=6> 4062 6 4>37? 9406142 A<=1549 ?<6 >34 0::49901> 71 6787109 ::409 <))" () 9406142 A<=1549 - 6 - 617G4>3?<660A3719406142A<=1549?<6>34 0::49901> 71 6787109 ::409 <)(!+ () 012 67@0HG=8060@0;49406142*?<6645:<1241> >0>471D<>3>340::4095 + 406142 A<=1549 ?<6 >34 0::49901> 0AA=542 <) 71 6787109 ::409 <))" () B434841>9H 5=D87>>42 >30> >34 @=2;841> <? A<1B7A>7<1 012 <6246 <1 541>41A4 :05542DH>346709<=6>75A<1>606H><>344B7241A4<1 64A<623464?<64>34508475970D94><D454>05724 )( > 75 ?=6>346 5=D87>>42 >30> >34 6709 <=6> 305 1<> 0::64A70>42 >344B7241A4<1 64A<62 :6<:469H ,341 >34 A05475D0542<1A76A=85>01>7094B7241A4846464A<B46H <?A46>07180>4670950994;42><30B4D44164A<B46420>>34 715>01A4 <? >34 0AA=542 064 1<> 5=??7A741> >< 3<92 >34 0AA=542 ;=79>H <? >34 <??41A4 =19455 7> 75 45>0D975342 DH >34:6<54A=>7<1:6<:469H )) 34:6<54A=>7<180719H649742<1>3464A<B46H<?80>46709 <D@4A>510849H +012 )(C37A3C46464A<B4642 05:46I37D7>5))012)012095<01<>34664A<B46H <? ) 05:46I) <C4B46>34548030J0654B41 >3<=;3 0994;42 >< 30B4 D441 :6<B42 >30> 7>549? 75 1<> - 7 - 5=??7A741> ><3<92 >34 0AA=542 064 ;=79>H <? >34 <??41A45 <C4B46>346709<=6>305?07942><0::64A70>4>34?0A>5 :6<:469H <154K=41>9H >34 78:=;142 @=2;841> 75 :05542C37A37564K=7642><D464*9<<G42 ) >75?=6>3465=D87>>42>30>>344B7241A4<?,5"012 C3<064>34C7>145545><>34905>5441>34<6H3<C4B46 >3476 4B7241A4 C05 1<> >< D4 A<15724642 ?<6 >34 6405<1 >30> <1 640271; <? >34 4B7241A4 71 7>5 41>764>H 71 ?0A> >34H30B41<>5=::<6>42>34A05445:7>4>34H2721<> 5=::<6>>34A054>346709<=6>C6<1;9H0::64A70>42>34 4B7241A4?<6>34:=6:<54<?905>5441>34<6HC37A3750 8017?45>466<6A<887>>42DH>346709<=6> ) > 75 ?=6>346 5=D87>>42 >30> >34 6709 <=6> ?07942 >< A<157246 >34 :64B7<=5 A<12=A> <? 5<84 <? >34 C7>145545 10849H>34D6<>3465<?>3424A405423424?41A4305 D44145>0D975342DH>340AA=542>30>>34D6<>3465<?>34 24A40542 302 4187>H C7>3 >34 24A40542 71 645:4A> <? 5<84 :6<:46>745 012 >3464 C05 0 A<8:9071> 9<2;42 0;0715> >34 D6<>3465 <? >34 24A40542 DH >34 24A40542 012 375 C7?4 C3< 75 06607;142 05 0AA=542 < 1 >34 5072A<8:9071>>3424A40542302802405>0>4841>>30> - 8 - 34 302 0 >3640> DH 375 D6<>3465 B41 >3<=;3 >3<54 2<A=841>5 30B4 D441 806G42 05 I5) >< ! >34 A<1>41>5 >3464<? C464 1<> A<15724642 DH >34 6709 <=6> :6<:469H )! >75?=6>3465=D87>>42>30><1640271;<?>344B7241A4<? 5<84<?>34C7>145545C3<0645072><D4>34C7>145545>< >348<>7B410849H,5 ><012><7>C<=921<>D4 5=??7A741> >< 0667B4 0> 0 A<1A9=57<1 >30> >34 8<>7B4 305 D441 45>0D975342 1 ?0A> >34 24A40542 2=671; 375 97?4>784 302 1<> 5=5:4A>42 >34 7997A7> 6490>7<1537: <? 375 C7?4C7>30AA=542 <)0>01H:<71><?>784 ) > 75 ?=6>346 5=D87>>42 >30> C341 >34 24A40542 302 5=5>0714271@=6H0994;42><30B4D441A0=542DH0AA=542 <5) 012 DH ;7B71; 494A>67A 53<AG >34 24A40542 272 1<> ;7B4 01H 5>0>4841> D4?<64 >34 <A><6 <6 01H <>346 0=>3<67>H 0;0715> 0AA=542 <5) 012 1 ?0A> >34 0AA=542 <D471;>34C7?4;<>378>640>420>27??4641> 3<5:7>095 A<154K=41>9H 34 5=6B7B42 34 6709 <=6> <=;3>><30B4A<15724642>3454?0A>5:6<:469H )" > 75 ?=6>346 5=D87>>42 >30> >34 6709 <=6> 64A<6242 >34 A<1B7A>7<1 <1 >34 D0575 <? 055=8:>7<1 012 :645=8:>7<1 - 9 - C37A3 75 09741 >< >34 A6787109 @=675:6=241A4 41A4 >34 @=2;841><?A<1B7A>7<175970D94><D454>057240G71; 5=A3 5=D87557<15 9406142 A<=1549 ?<6 >34 0::49901> 0AA=542 <):60H5><2758755>340::409 ) 406142 A<=1549 ?<6 >34 0::49901> 0AA=542 <) 305 649742<1>34?<99<C71;@=2;841>5C37A306405=1246* ! " # $% & #'()!! & * )+ , -- )+, . /0-# ! 1!. 2 3+--$ )+2 1 (1984) 4 SCC 116 2 (1989) 2 SCC 706 3 (2008) 3 SCC 210 4 CRL.A.1326 OF 2015 dated 19.11.2020 5 CRL.A.1540 OF 2015 dated 23.04.2021 6 AIR 2017 SC 1246 7 2020 SCC OnLine KAR 1649 - 10 - ) 1 6787109 ::409 <)(!+ () 6490>71; >< 0AA=542 < 75 A<1A46142 >34 9406142 A<=1549 ?<6 0::49901> 0AA=542 < 02<:>42 >34 06;=841>5 <? 0AA=542 <) 012?=6>346345=D87>>42>30>C341>3441>764A054C05 D0542<1A76A=85>01>7094B7241A4>346709<=6><=;3>>< 30B4 0::64A70>42 >34 4B7241A4 C7>3 =>8<5> B7;7901A4 0B71;?07942><A<157246>344B7241A4:6<:469H645=9>42 71 :05571;>34 78:=;142 @=2;841> C37A3 75 64K=7642 >< D454>05724 )+ > 75 ?=6>346 5=D87>>42 >30> >34 A<8:9071> 9<2;42 DH 0AA=542 < C05 1<> A<15724642 DH >34 1B45>7;0>71; ??7A46 :6<:469H 012 78:97A0>42 346 71 >34 ?0954 A054 71 <6246 >< 0B<72 >34 ;41=714 71B45>7;0>7<1 <? >34 A054 3464751<4B7241A4A<994A>42DH>341B45>7;0>71; ??7A46 <6 :6<2=A42 DH >34:6<54A=>7<1 0;0715>0AA=542 < >< 53<C >30> 534 C05 71B<9B42 71 >34 A<887557<1 <? >34 8=6246 <? 346 3=5D012 <14 <? >34 C7>145545 30B4 5:<G410D<=>>34:64541A4<?0AA=542 <)71>34B7A717>H <?>343<=544IA4:>5<84C7>145545C3<06471787A09>< 0AA=542 < - 11 - ( > 75 ?=6>346 5=D87>>42 >30> >34 4B7241A4 <? , C3< 5>0>42 >< 30B4 64A47B42 >34 A<1?4557<1 5>0>4841> ?6<8 0AA=542 <012 >34 6709 <=6> 0A>42 =:<1 7> C37A3 75 =15=5>0710D94 1 ?0A> >34 5>0>4841> 0994;42 >< 30B4 D4418024DH>340AA=542 <A011<>D4A<15>6=42050 A<1?4557<15>0>4841> 1640271;<?>3441>7644B7241A4 <? , >34 :6<54A=>7<1 272 1<> :6<2=A4 01H 2<A=841> >< 53<C >30> 0AA=542 < 302 >60B4942 71 >34 0=>< <? ,<1>3420>4<?>340994;42A<1?4557<15>0>4841>5072 ><30B4D441;7B41><, ) > 75 ?=6>346 5=D87>>42 >30> >34 6709 <=6> C6<1;9H 055=842 >30> 0AA=542 <5) 012 302 A<887>>42 >34 8=6246 71 ?=6>34601A4 <? A6787109 A<15:760AH 71 <6246 >< 5=5>071 >34 7997A7> 6490>7<1537: C37A3 75 A<1>606H >< >34 4B7241A4<164A<62012>345072A<1B7A>7<175C7>3<=>01H D0575 3464?<64 >34 5084 75 970D94 >< D4 54> 05724 0G71;5=A35=D87557<159406142A<=1549?<60::49901> 0AA=542 <:60H5><099<C>340::409 9406142 * ?<6 645:<1241> >0>4 B434841>9H@=5>7?742>34@=2;841><?A<1B7A>7<1012<6246 <1 541>41A4 :05542 DH >34 6709 <=6> 012 34 ?=6>346 - 12 - 5=D87>>42 >30> >34 A9<>345 <? 0AA=542 <) C37A3 064 806G42 05 5+ 012 )( 30B4 A<1>07142 D9<<25>0715 <C4B46 34 305 1<> 4I:907142 05 >< 3<C 375 A9<>345 A<1>071425=A3D9<<25>0715 > 75 ?=6>346 5=D87>>42 >30> 0AA=542 < 305 8024 0 A<1?4557<15>0>4841>><,0D<=>>3471A7241>012095< 5340A>425=5:7A7<=59HC37A3A640>422<=D>71>348712<? >341B45>7;0>71; ??7A46,341>341B45>7;0>71; ??7A46 >3<6<=;39H A<12=A>42 >34 71B45>7;0>7<1 7> 64B40942 >30> 0AA=542 <5) 012 302 A<887>>428=6246 71 <6246 >< 5=5>071 >3476 7997A7> 6490>7<1537: 34 4B7241A4 <? ," C<=92 7127A0>4 >30> 0AA=542 <) C05 A<871; ?6<8 >34 3<=54 <? 0AA=542 < 0> >34 <22 3<=65 012 7> 75 45>0D975342>30>>348=6246302>0G41:90A4<1>345084 20H ! > 75 ?=6>346 5=D87>>42 >30> >34 :6<54A=>7<1 305 45>0D975342099>34A76A=85>01A4510849H905>5441>34<6H 8<>7B4 012 64A<B46H <? 80>46709 <D@4A>5 <C4B46 >34 0AA=5423021<>4I:90714205><3<C>34HC464711<A41> <?>34<??41A453464?<647>A01D4;0>34642?6<8>34 ?0A>5012A76A=85>01A45<?>34A054>30>>340AA=542302 - 13 - A<887>>42>348=6246<?>3424A40542110HH0<C20 41A4>34A<1B7A>7<164A<6242DH>346709<=6>305>< D4 5=5>07142 0G71; 5=A3 5=D87557<15 9406142 * :60H5><2758755>340::4095 ?>46 30B71; 34062 9406142 A<=1549 ?<6 >34 645:4A>7B4 :06>745012095<:46=542>34?71271;5<?>346709<=6>71 64A<6271; >34 A<1B7A>7<1 7> 75 0::6<:670>4 >< A<157246 099 >342<A=841>5012095<>344B7241A4<?099>34C7>145545 7124>07905080>>46<?64*0::64A70>7<1<??0A>501290C " ,5)012064>3420=;3>465<?0AA=542 <012>34 24A40542 34H 272 1<> 5=::<6> >34 A054 <? >34 :6<54A=>7<1 , 75>346490>7B4<?>3424A40542424:<542>30> 06<=12>3644H40650;<0AA=542 <09<1;C7>3346905> 5<1302B757>423753<=5401210660>42><378>30>5<84 >3644 =1G1<C1 :465<15 30B71; 805G5 <1 >3476 ?0A45 71>6=242 71>< >34 3<=54 012 G79942 346 3=5D012 ?>46 340671; >34 5072 14C5 34 5>0>42 >< 30B4 71?<6842 >34 <>3465012<1>34760667B09099<?>348C41>><>345:<> 4 ?=6>346 5>0>42 >30> 34 50C >34 5A414 <? A6784 012 0287>>42>30>>34>7945<?>346<<?C464>0G41<??012>34 - 14 - D0AG2<<6<?>343<=54C05D6<G41%=6>3463450C>30> >3424A40542C059H71;<1>34?9<<6710:<<9<?D9<<2 ,! 75 095< <14 <? >34 3406*50H C7>145545 4 5=::<6>42>34A054<?>34:6<54A=>7<1 + , C3< 75 >34 6490>7B4 <? 0AA=542 < 4 5:40G5 0D<=> >34 7997A7> 6490>7<1537: <? 0AA=542 <5) 012 <C4B46 >3464 75 1< 24?717>4 4B7241A4 64;06271; >34 0994;428=6246 ( ,"75A<1572464205080>46709C7>1455AA<6271;>< 378<1)+(!()!06<=12)(((:80?>46A<8:94>71; 375C<6G$A<15>6=A>7<1<?37514C3<=54&?<6>3420H34 C05;<71;><3753<=54C37A37557>=0>420>0901@0012 345072><30B45441>340AA=542 <)C3<C05A<871; ?6<8>343<=54<?>3424A4054206<=12))((:8<1375 8<><6AHA94 012 0AA=542 <) 5>0>42 >< 30B4 ;<14 ><C0625 0901@0 34 6709 <=6> A<15724642 378 05 0 C7>1455 >< >34 905> 5441 >34<6H 012 0A>42 =:<1 375 4B7241A4 ) , 75 5>0>42 >< D4 >34 C7>1455 >< >34 A<1?4557<1 <? 0AA=542 <AA<6271;><378345>0>42><30B4>0G41 - 15 - D<>3 110HH0 <C20 012 375 C7?4 71 375 0=>< >< >34 3<5:7>09?<6>640>841>4?=6>34624:<542>30>0AA=542 < 5>0>42 >< 30B4 8024 0 A<1?4557<1 5>0>4841> 64;06271; >34 8=6246 <? 346 3=5D012 DH 346549? 012 0AA=542 <) ,75>3449246D6<>346<?>3424A4054245>0>42>< 30B4 B757>42 >34 3<=54 <? >34 24A40542 012 8024 0 5>0>4841> D4?<64 >34 :<97A4 64;06271; >34 7997A7> 6490>7<1537:D4>C4410AA=542 <5)012 ,+ 75 >34 C7>1455 >< I37D7>5 ! 012 " 4 5=::<6>42>34A054<?>34:6<54A=>7<1 ! ,)( 75 >34 575>46 <? 0AA=542 < 34 305 1<> 5=::<6>42>34A054<?>34:6<54A=>7<1 ,5)) 012 ) 064 >34 C7>145545 ><I 1246 >375 8030J06 >34 D7G4 <? 0AA=542 <) C05 547J42 012 >34 508475806G4205 <>330B45=::<6>42>34A054 <?>34:6<54A=>7<1 " ,) 75 0 C7>1455 >< I+ 1246 >375 8030J06 01 76<16<217;3>H01201494A>67A09A<79C46464A<B4642012 - 16 - 547J420>>34715>01A4<?0AA=542 <713463<=544 5=::<6>42>34A054<?>34:6<54A=>7<1 ,)! 75 0 C7>1455 >< I)) C37A3 75 A<15724642 05 547J=648030J06=1246C37A3>34A9<>345<?0AA=542 <) C464 547J42 0> 375715>01A4 71 375 3<=54 3<54 A9<>345 0647241>7?74205 5+012)(45=::<6>42>34A054 <?>34:6<54A=>7<1 ,5)012)"064>34C7>145545><I) ,)75 >34 H<=1;46 D6<>346 <? 0AA=542 < <>3 30B4 1<> 5=::<6>42>34A054 + ,) 75 >34 %<645> =062 4 C05 C<6G71; =1246 0AA=542 <)45072><30B4;7B41>34578A062C37A3 C05:=6A30542DH378><>340AA=542 <)IA4:>>30> 34 305 1<> 5>0>42 01H>371; 0D<=> >34 <B46> 0A> <? >34 0AA=542 !( ,)C05C<6G71;050<97A4<15>0D94<?645:<1241> <97A44A066742>34%012301242<B46>345084>< >340;75>60>4 !) ,)+ >< , 064 >34 <97A4 ??7A7095 C3< C464 C<6G71;0>>34645:<1241>:<97A45>0>7<10>>346494B01> - 17 - >784012>34H5>0>42><30B4275A306;42>3476645:4A>7B4 2=>74571>3471B45>7;0>7<1 ! ,!C05C<6G71;05402<15>0D9445072><30B4 64A47B42 0 A<8:9071> 9<2;42 DH 0AA=542 <) <1 ((() 0D<=> >34 875A374? A0=542 >< 375 D7G4 DH =1G1<C1:465<15 ! , 6 44>3090G5387 C05 C<6G71; 05 A741>7?7A ??7A46 012 534 5>0>42 >< 30B4 5=D@4A>42 >34 06>7A945 C37A3 C464 541> DH>34 :<97A4 ?<6 A3487A090109H575 012 5=D87>>4234664:<6>05:46IAA<6271;><346>34 7>485A<1>07142E F9<<26<=: !! ," 67 37B0:60502 C05 C<6G71; 05 01 5575>01> 1;714465>0>42>< 30B4:64:064205G4>A3<?>343<=54 C3464 >34 71A7241> 302 >0G41 :90A4 012 5=D87>>42 375 64:<6>05:46I ! , 67 =6=53<>3080 C05 >34 01A30H0>3 4B49<:841> ??7A46 C3< 5=D87>>42 >34 55455841> 4;75>46<?>343<=54<?>3424A4054205:46I !" ,670B71260402<15>0D94<?>34645:<1241> :<97A4 4 5072 >< 30B4 B757>42 >34 3<=54 <? >34 - 18 - 24A4054201254A=642>3471?<680>7<10D<=>>3471A7241> %=6>346345>0>42>30>0?>4664A47B71;>34A<8:9071>?6<8 0AA=542 < C7?4 <? >34 24A40542 301242 <B46 >34 5084><>34 <?>34A<1A46142:<97A45>0>7<1 ! ,+*67301453C05C<6G71;050<97A4<15>0D94 0> >34 @=67527A>7<109 :<97A4 4 75 5>0>42 >< 30B4 0AA<8:01742 , 012 34 302 D441 >< >34 :90A4 <? <AA=6641A409<1;C7>3, ! , (*6737B0G=806 C05 C<6G71; 05 0 <97A4 =D*15:4A><6 1 ((!()! 06<=12 )(( :8 34 75 5>0>42><30B464A47B4271?<680>7<164;06271;>3471A7241> >36<=;3 0 C7649455 84550;4 4 302 D441 >< >34 3<=54 C3464 >34 71A7241> 302 >0G41 :90A4 012 1<>42 >30> >34 >7945<?>346<=>4C464>0G41<??012>34D0AG2<<6<?>34 3<=54 C05 D6<G41 4>A %=6>346 34 24:<542 >30> 34 A<12=A>42>34:06><?71B45>7;0>7<106645>42>340AA=542 012:6<2=A42378D4?<64,! !+ , )*6 0;30B41260 0D= C05 C<6G71; 05 01 55<A70>4 6<?455<6 0> <B461841> 75>67A> ,419<AG <5:7>09 01;09=6= 5072 >< 30B4 A<12=A>42 0 - 19 - :<5>8<6>48 <? >34 2402 D<2H <? >34 24A40542 012 5=D87>>42064:<6>05:46I ) ( , *634530;767301260C056=1171;0A9717AB7J 7@0H0 9717A 1 ((!()! 34 75 5>0>42 >< 30B4 64A47B42 0 :0>741> 10849H 110HH0 <C20 30B71; 0 375><6H <? D=61 71@=6745 ?>46 >640>71; >34 5072 :0>741> 5>0>42><30B4755=420:645A67:>7<105:46I ) , *6706530 C05C<6G71;05001;4%<645> ??7A460>::7101;02701;44412<6542>30>0AA=542 <) C05 C<6G71; C7>3 378 012 095< :6<2=A42 6494B01> 2<A=841>5 6490>71; >< 0AA=542 <) >< >34 1B45>7;0>71; ??7A46 , ! * 67 672306 07 C05 C<6G71; 05 01 5575>01> <97A4=D*715:4A><6424:<542>30><1 ((() 34 64A47B420A<8:9071>?6<80AA=542 <)>30>375D7G4C05 D=61>DH5<84=1G1<C1:465<15?>4664A47B71;>345072 A<8:9071>3464;75>46420A05405 < () , *67050B060@C05C<6G71;050:<97A4A<15>0D94 0>@=67527A>7<109:<97A44755>0>42><30B4A0667427>485 - 20 - 012 640A342 >3<54 7>485 >< % 012 <D>07142 >34 412<654841> ! , "*67=6453 =806 C05 C<6G71; 05 0 <97A4 15:4A><6 5>0>42 >< 30B4 A<12=A>42 71B45>7;0>7<1 012 5=D87>>42A306;45344> ,)*67C05C<6G71;0555>=D*715:4A><6305D441 4I087142DH>34<=6>0?>46755=01A4<?5=88<15<84 2<A=841>5 30B4 D441 806G42 >36<=;3 378 B7J I5 >< " ?>4630B71;0109HJ42>344B7241A4<?099>34C7>1455457> 754B7241>>30>>3441>764A05475D0542<1A76A=85>01>709 4B7241A44?<6402B46>71;><>34?0A>5<?>34A0547>75 0::6<:670>4><64?46>34@=2;841><?>34<1/D94=:6484 <=6> 6490>71; >< >34 A0545 C37A3 064 2409> C7>3 A76A=85>01>7094B7241A434<1FD94=:6484<=6>71 >34A054<?4 /'4 556%7 /83 /68 3492 71 :060;60:3 <5 012 ! C37A3640205=1246 8 (2023) 6 SCC 399 - 21 - ! " # $% & ' & & ()&' && ( $*+,-% - & **. # *+,- & $% -,/01 $% & "2 & 32 )& "2 & 32 $4545%*-&/65#$4545%-&$%,6.#7" 4545&*,50 -! 8 9 101<>346A05471>34A054<?8/9/898 / / 556 %7 885+ :060;60:3 <) <?>345072@=2;841>C37A36402505=1246 :*67 9 (1984) 4 SCC 116 - 22 - # $*% 9 9 ! 9 9 &2& ' & ( # )& *+ ,5/# & $% *5-/0 : ; : ; 2 9 $4% $% $-% $6% - 23 - 9 1 A064?=9 640271; <? >34 0D<B4 5072 @=2;841>5 <? >34 <1/D94 =:6484 <=6> 7> C<=92 7127A0>4 >30> 717>7099H >34 D=6241 9745 <1 >34 :6<54A=>7<1 >< :6<B4 >34 A054 D4H<126405<10D942<=D>C7>3<=>940B71;01H971G571>34 A3071 <? A76A=85>01A45 ? <14 <? >34 A76A=85>01A45 75 875571; >34 D414?7> <? 2<=D> C<=92 D4 ;7B41 >< >34 0AA=542 + 0B71;64;062><>34:671A7:94590722<C1DH>34<1/D94 =:6484 <=6> 71 >34 0D<B4*5072 @=2;841>5 7> 75 0::6<:670>4 >< 2409 C7>3 >34 A054 <1 3012 1 <6246 >< 64*0::64A70>4>34A054>34?<99<C71; :<71>506464K=7642 ><D4A<15724642>34H064 % < 1 % ( 1 % " 0& <7&!&==>!=?"@# - 24 - "( 37575<14<?>34A76A=85>01A45>30>305><D4:6<B42DH >34 :6<54A=>7<1 71 <6246 >< 45>0D9753 >34 A054 34 :6<54A=>7<171>34:64541>A0544I087142,"05>34 C7>1455><>34905>5441>34<6HAA<6271;><,"34 C05 :6<A44271; >< 0901@0 7990;4 ?6<8 0>3H02G0 <1 )+(!()! 06<=12 )((( :8 0?>46 ?7175371; 375 A<15>6=A>7<1C<6G45>0>42><30B454410AA=542 <) C3<C05A<871;?6<8>343<=54<?>3424A4054206<=12 ))(( :8 <C4B46 71 >34 A6<55*4I08710>7<1 34 272 1<> 5:4A7?7A099H 841>7<142 >34 A<9<=6 <? >34 8<><6AHA94 012 >34 A9<>345 <?>34 24A40542 %=6>346 71 >34 A6<55* 4I08710>7<1 34 0287>>42 >30> 34 272 1<> ;7B4 375 5>0>4841> 7884270>49H 0?>46 >34 71A7241> 3<C4B46 34 5072 >< 30B4 ;7B41 375 5>0>4841> D4?<64 >34 :<97A4 D490>429HC37A371?0A>C<=92D4?0>09><>34A054<?>34 :6<54A=>7<1 1 ?0A> >34 :6<54A=>7<1 272 1<> :6<2=A4 01H4B7241A4><53<C>30>>343<=54<?,"C05D471; A<15>6=A>4271>340>3H02G0B7990;4 ") ,341 >34 4B7241A4 <? ," 272 1<> 715:764 >34 A<1?7241A4<?>34<=6>716490>7<1><>34905>5441>34<6H >346709<=6><=;3>1<>><30B40A>42=:<1>344B7241A4 - 25 - <?,"<C4B46>346709<=6>0A>42<13754B7241A4 01264*0::64A70>42>344B7241A471>340D541A4<?A<;41> 4B7241A4 3464?<64 >34 4B7241A4 <? ," 71 <=6 A<15724642 B74C 75 1<> 5=??7A741> >< 3<92 >30> >34 :6<54A=>7<130545>0D975342>34905>5441>34<6H % (?!A= " 34:6<54A=>7<1305>6742><45>0D9753>348<>7B4?<6>34 8=62465:46>34B4657<1<?>34:6<54A=>7<1>345072 8=6246 302 >0G41 :90A4 2=4 >< 01 7997A7> 6490>7<1537: D4>C441>340AA=542 <5)01234:6<54A=>7<1305 ?=6>346 >6742 >< 45>0D9753 >30> 0AA=542 < D471; >34 C7?4<?>3424A405423027997A7>6490>7<1537:C7>30AA=542 <)1<6246><5=5>071>3450727997A7>6490>7<1537:D<>3 0AA=542 <5) 012 5>0>42 >< 30B4 A<887>>42 >34 8=6246<?>3424A405421<6246><45>0D9753>348<>7B4 >34:6<54A=>7<1305649742<1>344B7241A4<?,5 ! 012 " , 75 >34 6490>7B4 <? 24A40542 4 24:<542 71 375 4B7241A4 >30> 06<=12 H4065 012 8<1>350;< C341 34 C05 0> 375 3<84 0AA=542 < 09<1; C7>3 346 5<1 - 26 - B757>423753<=5406<=12)((71>3487217;3>01205G42 378 >< <:41 >34 2<<6 ,341 34 <:4142 >34 2<<6 534 10660>42 >34 71A7241> >30> 5<84 =1G1<C1 :465<15 302 G799423463=5D012C7>3C40:<15?>46340671;>34502 14C5 34 71>780>42 >34 5072 ?0A> >< <>346 ?674125 012 6490>7B45 012 099 <? >348 C41> >< >34 3<=54 <? >34 24A4054201250C>30>>3424A40542C059H71;710:<<9 <?D9<<2012>34>7945<?>346<<?C464>0G41<??012>34D0AG 2<<6C05D6<G414>A475>34340650HC7>1455 1;<71; >36<=;3 375 4B7241A4 34 272 1<> 24:<54 >30> >34 0AA=542 <) C05 :64541> 71 012 06<=12 >34 :90A4 <? <AA=6641A4 3464?<64 375 4B7241A4 71 645:4A> <? 8<>7B4 9<545 7>5 57;17?7A01A4 "! ,! 75 01<>346 C7>1455 C3< 24:<542 71 5=::<6> <? , 012 095< 24:<542 0D<=> >34 7997A7> 6490>7<1537: <? 0AA=542 <5) 012 7879069H , 095< 24:<542 71 5=::<6> <? >34 4B7241A4 <? , 71 645:4A> <? >34 7997A7> 6490>7<1537: <? 0AA=542 <5) 012 <C4B46 >34 4B7241A4<?,5!012751<>5=??7A741>><0667B40>0 A<1A9=57<1>30>>348<>7B4305D44145>0D975342>36<=;3 >34764B7241A4 - 27 - " ,C05010=><267B464305D4414I087142?<6>34 :=6:<54 <? 45>0D975371; >34 4I>60*@=27A709 A<1?4557<1 AA<6271;><3780AA=542 <5>0>42><30B4A<1?45542 0D<=>>348=6246<?3463=5D012012095<71B<9B4841><? 0AA=542 <) 012 346549? <C4B46 <1 ;<71; >36<=;3 >34 4B7241A4 <? , 7> A01 D4 ;0>34642 >30> >34 :6<54A=>7<1305?07942><45>0D9753>30>0AA=542 <302 >60B4942 71 >34 5072 0=>< <1 >34 20>4 <? >34 0994;42 5>0>4841>5072><30B4D441;7B41DH3463464?<64>34 4B7241A4<?,095<9<5457>557;17?7A01A4 "" ,75>34D6<>346<?>3424A405423<=;33424:<542 0D<=>>347997A7>6490>7<1537:D4>C4410AA=542 <5)012 >3424?41A430545>0D975342>30>3430224:<5420;0715> 0AA=542 <5)012<1>345>641;>3<?4187>H1?0A> , 0287>>42 71 375 A6<55*4I08710>7<1 >30> 34 C05 5=88<142 DH >34 @=67527A>7<109 :<97A4 71 645:4A> <? 875A374? 5>0>42 >< 30B4 A0=542 >< >34 D7G4 <? 0AA=542 <) C341 7> C05 :06G42 71 ?6<1> <? >34 3<=54 <? >34 24A40542 4 ?=6>346 0287>>42 >30> 375 5>0>4841> C05 64A<6242 DH >34 :<97A4 71 645:4A> <? >34 5072 71A7241> ,3415=A3D471;>34?0A>4B7241A4<?,6490>71;>< - 28 - >348<>7B471<=6A<15724642B74C9<5457>557;17?7A01A4 1 ?0A> I5) >< ! C<=92 7127A0>4 >30> >3464 C464 0 1=8D46 <? 275:=>45 4I75>42 D4>C441 >34 D6<>3465 71 645:4A><?788<B0D94:6<:46>745 " 1 ?0A> >34 6709 <=6> 53<=92 30B4 0::64A70>42 >34 0B46841>5 <? >34 A<8:9071> 9<2;42 DH 0AA=542 < 0G71; 0994;0>7<15 0;0715> >34 711<A41>5 064 K=7>4 A<88<1 <C4B46 >34 5072 0994;0>7<15 064 64K=7642 >< D4 :6<B42 DH >34 :6<54A=>7<1 D4H<12 6405<10D94 2<=D> B41 <1 0 A<1@<71> 640271; <? >34 905> 5441 >34<6H 012 8<>7B471<=6A<15724642B74C>34:6<54A=>7<1305?07942 >< 45>0D9753 >3454 >C< A76A=85>01A45 0;0715> 0AA=542 <5)012 % "=?A="@ " 34 1B45>7;0>71; ??7A46 5>0>42 >< 30B4 A<12=A>42 547J=648030J06505:46I5+012))I+756490>71; ><>3464A<B46H<?C3449D<I6<217;3>H012494A>67AA<79 012 >34 5084 7>485 C464 547J42 012 64A<B4642 71 >34 :64541A4<?,) 344B7241A4<?,) C<=92095< 7127A0>4>30>>3464A<B46HC054??4A>420>>34715>01A4<? - 29 - 0AA=542 < 012 >34 5084 7>485 C464 547J42 71 >34 3<=54<?24A4054245:7>4>34A6<55*4I08710>7<130B71; D441 2<14 1<>371; 305 D441 497A7>42 >< 275A6427> 375 4B7241A46490>71;><64A<B46H "+ 7879069H>344B7241A4<?,)!C<=92095<7127A0>4>30> 64A<B46H<?80>46709<D@4A>510849H 5+012)(C464 4??4A>42 0> >34 715>01A4 <? 0AA=542 <) 71 375 3<=54 <C4B46>3464A<B46H<?D9<<25>07142A9<>345<?0AA=542 <)7>549?751<>5=??7A741>><3<92>30>3475;=79>H<?>34 <??41A4 ?<6 >34 6405<1 >30> >34 D9<<2 ;6<=: <? >34 24A40542 305 1<> D441 :6<:469H 45>0D975342 DH >34 :6<54A=>7<1 ( 1>375A<1>4I>7>756494B01>><64?46>34@=2;841><?>34 <1FD94=:6484<=6>71>34A054<?; 3) 556 %7 88559<8 34 <1FD94 =:6484 <=6>71:060;60:3 <5"012 (349205=1246 4. 7 B&< B&< 7 10 (2024) 3 SCC 481 - 30 - 4, 7 C ! DEE! 4*E *5E455+ 46E*5E 455+ 8 EE 5 7 9 ) 1A064?=9640271;<?>3427A>=8<?>34<1FD94=:6484 <=6> 7> 80G45 7> A9406 >30> L 8 7 9 ?>46 30B71; A<15724642 >34 ?0A>5 012 A76A=85>01A45 <? >34 A054 71 >375 :64541> A054 >3<=;3 >34 64A<B46H <? D9<<25>07142 A9<>345 C05 4??4A>42 0> >34 715>01A4 <? 0AA=542 <) 012 095< >34 64A<B46H <? 76<1 6<2 17;3>H - 31 - 012 494A>67A A<79 C464 64A<B4642 0> >34 715>01A4 <? 0AA=542 <713463<=54>30>7>549?751<>5=??7A741>>< 3<92>30>0AA=542 <5)012302A<887>>428=6246<? >34 24A40542 71 <6246 >< 5=5>071 >3476 7997A7> 6490>7<1537: 1<=6A<15724642<:717<1>346709<=6>305A<887>>42 ;60B4466<671A<15724671;>344B7241A4<?C7>145545C3< 30B4 24:<542 0D<=> >34 8<>7B4 ?<6 >34 8=6246 3464?<64>34?71271;5<?>346709<=6>7164A<6271;>34 A<1B7A>7<130B4><D454>05724 1>3497;3><?>34<D546B0>7<1580240D<B4C4:6<A442 ><:055>34?<99<C71;* $7& 346787109::4095064099<C42 $77& 34 @=2;841> <? A<1B7A>7<1 20>42 ( (() 012<6246<1541>41A420>42((():05542 71 4557<15 054 <+ ()! <1 >34 ?794 <? >34 227>7<109 75>67A> 012 4557<15 =2;4 01;09=6=06454>05724 - 32 - $777& 34 0AA=542 <5) 012 064 0AK=7>>42 ?<6 >34 <??41A45:=17530D94=12464A>7<15)(* ( ()( 6 C !<? $7B& 34D079D<125<?0AA=542 <5)0127?01H 5>012A01A49942 $B& 34?71424:<57>42 7? 01H 53099 D4 64>=6142 >< >340::49901>50?>46:6<:467241>7?7A0>7<1DH>34 6709<=6> $B7& 4;75>6H 75 2764A>42 >< >601587> >34 <67;7109 64A<62509<1;C7>3>34@=2;841><?>375<=6>>< >346709<=6>?<6>3C7>3 5( &% ' ! 5( & ' ! 55 75> <)9 <)