Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 147685 (PNJ)
M/S GARG FARM SERVICE AND ANR v. STATE OF PUNJAB AND ORS
CRM-M/50282/2019 · 2025-12-22
Manisha Batra
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 147685 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 147685 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"#$!%&'&"()**
+',-,. !,/&%!($(" 0!,
***! & &"(!,'
1!,'2'
!"#2(34($" 0!,'
***!'5"($!( '
) 67
*
!"#$
%""
"$ &'($)
$*+,$ !"#$
%"" -""
8*
$. " %/ ' #" 0 "% " "% ,$/
"# '
%" 1'$
"%
",/$ )$ -" 2302 $ 4 / $
%/ ' #" 3* 4 $ 33 "% 5## # 6 %" " 7 # 6 $ 8 '/ 4 "% 5## '/ 4 $/" 8 $// ')1' "# $! ,$$ %",#/' " $ 6
$ )."'"% /$ 9' #$/$$:/$;$/8$ $)"<$ $8). "$ )',," "%$#$/$%"$ #",/$
<%%$#"%#$/!$%"'""% "$/"%
"$$$%"," #",/$$ )%/ ). MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
" $ $$= "2%, 8"8 $/'/ )'"",$'%$#'' "!""%# 6;
"$$##' -" $ ,' #",/$ 3
$//$" ,$ ,' #",/$ " 34 #",/$$ 9$ 5## 5#" # ""%2&$:$,!#'#"" -"($.>',$8""/"""%"-" %,8$
";#",/$$##* "#*"%%,$ %"' 0*0=*"#*"%## :"/3?&)$ <$#-": 4$!,$'%$#' $ $ =. $ 8#8$,$'%$#' )." -"2" ""
"#" ! @ ; #",/$$ #" " $/ $#* "% $ ## $ $ $$ $,/ $#/ "% $, $# 1' %", 8 %// ' $ ). #",/$$
$/ $,/$/"8 '/.%// %",-"AA8$$ "!""-" ; ,$ 8" $,/ 8 $##" /. " "%%# "% % #'/'$/
%%# <$ $ $/" 8 :", -"AA $ :", -"AA5$#""
$/ $,/$ "$/ :",-"AA5 8$).%#'/'$/
%%#<$ $"5## ; @$)"$".,$! /-" $ 4 ;"8$ #! " 44 $8#$#! #""%:"/ $ )%"' ")?$ "%:"/3?&B#$,/
"#"%","#$#! #"$ 8$ #/$ ") ,)$ 0
% # "% $%"$ " "%%# "% % MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
3
#'/'$/
%%#<$ $"4 $"8#$'"#8$! '"""34 ;"'), /."
"8 #$' "# " 4 " %%# $ $ ## 8$ '#$ ).,%",'/#",$." -"2" "
" "#" ! @ $$ !"# -" 2 2 3 $ 6 ;.$/"1' "%#$,/ $ #""8#$'"#8$/"! '"" -""8" $,$'%$#'%,""$ ",/". 1'"%
" %# $,/8$ "$/ 5## @$)"$". :$ $)$ %"" $ ""%8$#! "
$ 8# $,/ $ "8 4? $#! #"$ "%3?"%:"/'#$,/$/" "#"%",
" /!$ 5#%#$" $#! 1', $ 8$$##" /. #/$ "),)$
%#!"" $ #" /. '), ). " % #'/'$/
%%##', @#
%%# <$ $ $ ' 5## @# "%
"%, ! " $ ; " $ %/ $ $$/ $$ '" "% /# )%" 9" #" "% #'/'/$"#"'($)-$$8#8$$/.$//"8 $ /#"%"8$$$//." 8$ #"""
"//,)$ ## "8#$'"#8! '" ,$'%$#' $ ,$* #",$.
" -" 2 " "
""#"!@ 8"$ $ , $,)$ ## $ )'/ ""%",#",$. MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
0
6
C/ $// $ $ #" $ "% # 6 8"!,",$'%$#'//"#*"=)%"$/" )' $. ## , " ) ,)$ ' ')#/$' " ')#/$'
"')#/$'!"%#/$'*"%#"38//)/$)/%"', 8$$// ,' #",/$$$##' "#/'
" $ #",, $ "%%# ' " %$/' "% $)"! ," $,/ $ ' . $ !"/$ "!" "% #" 3* 4 $ 33"%# 68#'$)/' #"
$"%# 4
$" "% #",/$ $ $% #" /,$. ! # / ). #",/$$ /$ $$ $ ',," "$8//$" -"""%$#$/ ,' #",/$ %" #",," "% "%%# $// ! %",$,"$!%/ "$ ! " $ 6 8/ ' "# "% ,"" %'
"# )%"/$ $/"'8$. )."'
@$ #"'/%""$$' $,' #",/$$8//$',,"" $"'$$)/."% /$8 1'$ " 8" $ ' ' /. "/. $/ "% ,)$ ## $ ",$'%$#'"%$,;$,/ 1'"8 $8%",$$/ $#*$ ,$'%$#'"%$ ,$$/" -"2" """#"!@ < $/%,$ """#$")/ ")/%" $// %##.$#! "%$$,/"$##"'$)/%"$ #$"%,)$ 5#",/$"$//$"$## MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
8$" )."$.,"#" ""$.#"'/ $% =# $"$)/ /# $! $#$ $ ## 8$ #"$!$."%"!""%# 65%'$' $). $ $#" ' #" 3 "% # 6 $#" $'". 9" #" #'/' %$/ " $* " "% $%"$ %$#$8//$""/$8$ $ $#"$)$ $ ,#$#$/,$8"'$/.(' #"', ;"8" #$ " ")/ %" #" '# "% )' "% ,$'%$#' #",$. $ 8 " ")/ " ,$$ 1'$/. "% " '# ,$'%$#' ).C/$//$"#'""%"' ,' #",/$$)'"%"#"%/$8' $ #",/$$8//$',,"" $/$)/")1'$ 1'$, ;")'$',/$ #"'/%""$/ '" $'" # $ !!"# $%%#&$ $ ' !()# $%%*)+
/$ $#"'/8/$$//$" $ ,$ ,' #",/$ $ $/" , "% /. %/ " )$/%"%" -" $$$' $$$)/ #$"% ,)$ $ $$#!
8,'#/$#" $ #) /$)/B$%'$' $"$/$)/" ) "#' $ )$ $#/ 8$ "/ $ )' 8 *"8/ #"$ #"!$#;.$$/)."$$//"' $ $ " ' $/ -" #$ %" 1'$ "% ,' #",/$$ ',,"" $),$ "'B# MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
6
' $"/$#*,$ /$)/") ,
@$ #"'/ %" " -" " 8" $ ,$'%$#' $ ,$* #",$. #" " ")/ %"#" '#"%)'$ 1'$/.#""/"%%,$ " "8#$ #!/. $ $ , $ $%"," ## 8$ ,$'%$#' $ '/ )." -"2" """#" !@ 5'), $" -"$ $!$/"%/ $" )%" "' * 1'$ "% ,' #",/$ 1'$ , 8#
;"'$$ !$/'),""%$
<%""# %'8"'/ )/!$"$!$/""*"
"!""%#"3"%# 68#$" '# )/"8 D,! ' - - && ./0
$!$$%"! #"$//)
" %#$"#'"' #""! ,/.$$##' 8$"$"%$'" 1'$/. "% ## # "% 8#
"%%#8$#",, ""%*!"/! ,$'%$#'$/"'"%'### ""% ##',$#"%,$'%$#'","
:" '" "% #" 4 $ ## $//
" ) , " ) ,)$ "/. ). $" "% %$#$E $ $ ) $ " ", "#'"' ')$# " )#$' $, 1' %",$'%$#'"$$"
"%## $$$#/"%#",,#$ $%%"#$$"#"',"$ "" MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
4
#$ )'/* 8 " ,$' "% ## ""#"#$/%"1'$/."
" %#F" )
"# "% ,$'%$#' $$" " #"!.$# ", =$"' ')$# $ '$!" $)/.)#",,= 8 3 /. . && && -./.0 #$ 1 . &- & &2 #$ 3 & & & - - - ./2 #$ & . ..&- 14 3
)$'$/"%')#"3"%$%"," "!" #/$/. "8 $ $ " " ) $ ," " $ ,$'%$#' "% $ ## "$%" )'""%$,$//")/$)/%"$ #"$!""%$."!""%#%%"' $$ $#1' ## %",$,""$ '/./# ,$'%$#' )'"" $/ $ #"'/ " $! $#$ $ ## $. 8$. #"$! $."!""%# 6$ ## 1'"8$
"/. " $ ,$ $, $ $ 8 8$ $#1' ). '#"C/$%"$ "!""%# 6$ MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
).
$* " $##"' %$# $ $##' " 8 " ,$'%$#' $ ,$* #",$. $ $,/ 8 $8 %", $ $/ $#*,/$#",/$$ )1'$ )."'1'$ $/2%, $ "" %", 8" , ,)$ ## 8$$*"""%#$ #$),$ " (' , ). "'
#% 5 5 ((675 !(* ("!, ! !$ 88$")! $' DG;,$" "')$"#,$//$)/.#$) %$ '"";")#$'$$/$ . $,/"%,)$ $#/8#"//# %", , 8/ H$/ #"$H 8# 8"%"' ")" ,"/.$ $.! ""#" " #$$)$/
"$ $.""'#"%%",$"$ #"# " '# 8$ ,)$ ; #$ %" 1'$/.%$//' $""%',"'I #" 2>$<(<$ $)"$I#$'$$
"9' ,$ ).!$"'<#"%"' $%"$ #""1'/."'%
",/$")'$)/1'$"; $, $ $// ') 1' "# #/' #$ ,' ',,"
$ 1'$ 1'$
"J 0
%##$%'),$ "
!(,#)$%%#&$"*,8
"'8/1'$$,/$#",/$1'$ $/$,$ %"//"8")!$" MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
D , /."$",$'%$#'"% ## )' $/ $ )'" B# . #$ " ) / ")/ %" ,)$ ## 8# 8$ " ,$'%$#' ). , ;
" 8 "/. !"/! $/ "% ## ; #",/$ 1'$ ,$'%$# ' ;
" " #" " ' $ ## $ " )"/." )." ##" /. " $//"8 $ #",/$-"324 "%04 ' #"3* 4 $ 33"%5## #
6$ 8'/4"%5## '/ 4 =' $ $// #"1'$/ "# $ "' "% $ #",/$ 1'$ " $ 1'$ J
%##$$/")$ "")!$",$ )."' !((#($ %% #&$ (( 8"'$#"#/' $"8"8$,/. // ## $ " "##$" " $, 8 #" "% #"$2## $ 8"'/ ) $ $)' "% "# "% /$8 $
")"/.!"/! $/"%## #$")/ ")/ %"#""%,)$ ## ,/$!88$= ). "' 8 !((# $ %% #&$ ! /
& !((# $%% #&$ ,*+ % !(! # $ %% #&$ 6, & . !(!#($%%#&$,,$ 9 !!*#($%%#&$,6" 6
! " #$ $ , "" $ MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
#",/$$5## 5#"$ $8$,/"%## 1'" %", $ $/ $#* * , "% " ; $//$",$ $ $$$-"4"%,' #",/$ $" '# )/"8 D;#",/$$/# "'!9!$5%:! "%*"'
"%0*"#*"%:"/3?&)$<$#-" : 4 $! ,$'%$#' $ $ =.
$ ,$'%$#' ).2" ""
"#"!@ " "",/=/""&$/" -$ ""/ :$#". &$'$/$ "$ >$$/ # "% $##' ($. >',$ " <$8$ $
"" "% 2 &$ :$, !# +//$ $,$ $ ;/;$/8$ $)"<$ $$8//$ # "% ($.$/ <$ #'/' !/",
%%#:$,$$ :$,;$/8$ $)" <$ $ ; $% " '!9!$ 5%:! #",/$$ $ /"" $,/ ). ' $, "% ## )$# ,$$/ " $$,.$#/$$ ."/.; #",/$$ $% " "/. #"$ $,"%## ",.$#/$$ .#/")$""$##/")$J 4
51'=/#%",$)"!," $//$"$ $,/8 $8"'"%$$/ $#*"%:"/3?&##
""'#""%#",/$%"' $$" $!, $ " $ $#1' ## %", $ ," 8" 8$ " $ '/. /# ,$'%$#' " )'" " . #"'/ $! $#$ $. ,$ $ ## $. 8$. $ #"$! $."!""%# 6"$## 1'" MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
8$ " "/. " $ ,$ $, $ $ 8 8$ $#1' )."5!8"%8/$/.$""%/$8 /$ "8$%"# $'"8#$)$ "')#"33"% # 6#$$"$)/.)$ $"8"$ "#' ## 1'" %", " -" 2 " " "
"#"!@ $/ $#*$ $,/8 $8""%
"$/ $#*#"'/ ")"#' ' ,' #",/$
5 !8 "% #'" ,$ $)"! "' "% #" "" $ % "#'" "% " , " #"'%""%%#$// ,' #",/$$,8"'/ $,"' " $)' "% "# "% /$8 ##" /. " $//"8 ;,' #",/$$8//$,' ',,"" $ ). 1'$ 1'$ " $/" 8 $// ')1'
"# $!$%",
**
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI 2025.12.22 15:16 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document