Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 142017 (PNJ)
STATE OF PUNJAB AND ANOTHER v. PUNJAB STATE COMMISSION FOR SCHEDULE CASTES AND ORS
CWP/16755/2022 · 2025-12-12
Namit Kumar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 142017 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 142017 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
! "
** +,
*+**
2
1
3"
4
5 )" 6 !76
" 8
"
8
5 5
" 9 6 1 5 4( 9 :6 1
"
8 * ;
%
#
6 6 ! $%&06 ! "
#
" '
( ) +, *+* $
-
06 "
$ /0 )
"
" )
*+** + * *+* * * *+* * * *+*
2
"
6 1
6 6
6 6 ! % 6 6 "" **<** =
. "
8 * ;
"
" 1
1 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
8 )
*
"
8
"" = > : 1 0 ! =
"6 8 ;6 )
8
A + *+++ ; + *+ 1 *+** ,,B =
" *+* $
-
""
" ** +, *+* :
6 " 8 * C
"
! "
+; + 7"6
"
1
6 :6 #
! "
6 () .% 0 ! "
$
1 D * + ,,,6 "
"
" C
"
8 *6 8 ? "
@)
1
6
"
)
" C
"
8 * "" ; + *++ # *++ %
6
) " 1
"
*
*+++ +E =6 (
" + + *+* *06 "
"
"
1
)
"
"
6 8 ; C 3 ! 1 )
+, ,,;
" 6
% %
1 #
$%
& '''0 2
6 ,,/ 1
(<
3 ! 1 C
"
6 3 ! 1 )
"
"
" 6
"
"
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
+ * *++
*; + *+++
) "
"
"
) 96
"
"
" 1
" =
"
" ,, %(
6 *+**
6 3 ! 1 C
"
A + *+++
"
+ :6
"
8 * ; 1 ) 6
"
F :"
9 )
"
8 *
" #
!
"
6
"
8 * ;6
8 * ;6 )
1 6 ) ) )
"
8 * ; )
"
6 6
)
1
"
=
6 8 * ; 1
"
'
2 ,06 21 F
$ $ 8 ;*, 6 "
*A +B ,
;
"
8 ; + ) "
"
"
"
:
9
) 9 )
" ; D *B +A *++;6 ) 6 9
6 )
F :" ) ) (
"
"
6
6
" ) (
" 1
)
"
"
" )
6
@/ $ 8 + $ 8 ;; ,,06 ,,,0 1
,,,6
" RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
" 2
6 ,BA <"
6 ! "
"
"
= B = ) - ! -
"
"
%
: )
" *+**
"
,BA6 )
@G
"
"
" ) H' 4
" > ,,
"
-
'' 1
* >
"
$
-
"
= ' "
"
"
"
"6 * +;+
" = )
" 1
"
"
) - '
" %
! "
"
"
)
"
= - %
"
( "" :6
" ! % : %
6 " *; )
1
A
7
?-
"
"
" *
"
) 1 -
"
"
) 1 ,, =
0 +;+ I @/
" +A * *+++ * + ,, +; +; ,,B6 6 +E
-
" ) " ;+E = ) 1
"
"
"
6 ) 1 B
1 = %6 "
" 1
! " ) %
& 6
"
6 " RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
6
" )
"
" ) @G
1 - *++A
)(
" 8 * ; %
:
1 # '''06 2
6 ! % ) # *+** 6
1
! ,,B *+
"
)
!
"
"
*A +B ,, +A * *+++
"
"
" %
& :
"
6 "1
"
) B
-" %
6
" A ! % ! " %
: )
"
%6 $
) )
<
; )
"
" : :
6
"
"
"
"
" #
6 "
% 6 ,, ,BB6
= %
D
)(
! 6
"
1
" *++6 )
#
6
" ,,, %6
-
" " ,,B *+++
' ) =
"
" )
" *++A6
(<
" 6 ! % )
"<
(0
"
"
"
8 * ; 1 ? "
"
" $
1
6 = "
%
" RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*+++
"
+* +; *+*+6
+, *
" ** +, *+* *+** *++6
! %
"
"
" ! %
" " ! % 2
"
8 * ; "" +6
" - 1 ,,B
"
8 * ;
*+
"
"
" +, *+* *+*6 ) )
(/ 6 )
1
6
=
"
"
=1 %
8
- " %
D D
"
"
"
"
1
=
*+++ %
) +
"
"
)
" ) )
"
"
8 * ; ) )
!"#$#! RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*+**
%
& '
!(
%
! + , -) . /#(
/!(
) 0 1 (
(
+
2 3
4 !$"$
) %
-6(
!$$7
) %
!#
/
)
) %
/(
%
#:#7##
*
)
!$$
%
)*
!$$$
)
) % -) . ) ) 1 -) . /
//
-) )
(
!#5
% 0
;
%
!8
9
)
!$$7
###
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
* + *+**
) !# -(
2 )
% ##:
%
% !$$7
###
)
!#
< + ,
< % < + ,
) %
!$$7
#
)
%
4
#>!##!
%
-
% 0 2 3 ( 2 ? <
%
%
6
"
! " + *+*6
1
)
B
0
2 3 )
:
)
) %
0
!#
< %
%=
% 0 ###
!#
,
6 ,
) -) @
2 3 (
3 1
%) -4(A
"
"" ** +, *+*6 )
1
6 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*+*
*+**
$
-
*06 ** +, *+*
" B
8!##! =
=
"
)
%
) 2 3 C
2 3
) -2 !$"#
&' %
/ -
,
6 1
" %
""
1
)
"
)
< . >7#:8:8#
3
#$#! *
#$#:##$
D
( 4
D %
:
/-( - (
/ -(
%
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$
-
" ;
"
A
" H3
" 1 % ; 1
1 6
*+**
"
%
4
!!#! %
** *0 "
"
"
"
** +
"
"
1
"
8 * ; :
"
6 ) 8 * ; 1 ! 1
1
( = * +A *+* ) 1
"
"
"
(
"
8 *
"
"
) "
"
8 * ; )
+
6 < )A ** +, *+* *+* 1 + +, *+**6 +, *+* $
-
0 )
)
" 8 + *+* I
! 6 ! 6
"
6
"
8 * 1
;
) ' ) )
2 >1 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
%
2
=
) " +; *+*; - >1
) =
"
" 1 " *+** % ) 2 >1
) "
) H)
""
"
) " ;
= -
" ) "
! %
)
2 3
/
:
;
>#:#! E
" 9 >#"!$$$
) . )
) . )
) . />
/
/!
" * +A *+* H)
" I 6 1 * +A *+*
" 2 = )
"
) %
'
/
:
'
%
B
'
:
) ) )
)
) )
/"
) ./#
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
1 *+** ) . )
) )
) . )
%
! < + ,
3
#$! /!!#
/
:
#8!##! 3
/
:
%
/##/##8
! 1
>#:#! !/
F
"
"
" )
"
*
)
. )
) )
:#:###
!:#"###
!'
%
/!#### $!!###
!###! %
#"!##! 7#/##8
3
A
@ 8 * ;
*+ RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
;;B
:" %
6
"
" B
,
"
? + * *+
" *+ ) *+**
"
"
;B
' ** +, *+* *+* $
2 6
"
8 * 1 )
) )
" C
"
9 6
1
"
""
"
1 ' 1
2
"
8 * ; )
""
" ? "
6
)
" *++ *; + *+++6
"
1
1 ) 6
"" )
"
6
;
%
6 $0 $0 6
6
" $
-
*0
"
8 * ; ;
"
" C 9
6 F )
" 8 * ;
"" 6 )
"
"
" +; +, ,,;
" 1
1 %
" )
" )
1 6 " ) RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
9 )
" ) 2
" + / >1 )
"
"" 1 * +A *+*
"
"
" +
1 8 * ;
; )
" 6 ) *+** )
6
"
" %
"
" 8 * ; "" *+* .3 ! 1 1
6 )
6
1
"
) +; *+*;6 =
- ) "
"
' )
"" ) "
' ; 1
1
) "
6 ) 1 + *+* 2
"
8 C
6 *+
" )
A
6 F :" D
+A + *+,6 !
%
D
1
1 2
) "
"
)
"
)
6
"
) )
"
"
6
" 6 %
6 ) )
"
8 *
H
*++AI %
"
+$*0
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"
*+**
+$*0 -(
-(
)
C
-(
)
-(
C
' )
-(
)
-(
)
-(
C
&'
F
'
F
)
F
F
C
F
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*+**
)
-(
)
-(
)
3
-(
)
-3(
F
-(
)
F
)
F
;
C
F
)
C
F
)
)
3
F
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*
$0 $0
" 6 *+** -(
-(
+
) -(
-(
C ;;B 8 ;;B 0 "
" 8 6 )
-"
C
F
)
)F
)
F
)
)
A '
8 ' @ -"
( RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
""
8 ) )
"
6 8 )
1
;
*+** (
"
6
$0 " 6 "
71
6 71 6 F -"
(
6 6 )
")
" ;;B
-!(
)
-(
) 3
2
G
<
B
3
6
6 )
" 6
) 6 "
" 6 )
"6
6 )
""
(
$B0
=" 1 6 $0 = $0
$0 '
)
.
G'
G'
<
2
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*+** -/(
G <
2
-:(
-8(
-(
C
F
-(
) F
-(
' )
-(
2
-(
)
' ) F
-(
) 2
3
2
,
G'
H
)
+
)F
F
+
)
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*+** ->(
2
I
+
-"(
B
C
)
'
-7(
-8(
-(
F
-(
F
-(
-(
-(
*+
2
'
) C
)
J
)
' -(
' -(
&'
F
F
F
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
A
#
"1
*+** -(
-$(
+
)
-!#(
%'
"
! "
$%&&'(')' ;;B 8
' -(
' -(
8
> ) ' -(
-(
%
)
*
2
) C
3
)
A @/
"
'*'
- 6
7
8
% //7
-7(
F
)
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*+**
"
% -!$8(
) -8(
) 8
D: 2
!$#7(
-(
-(
F
-(
-(
-(
-(
8 -:(
) !"8 ) !"7
) 7
!7>#(
2 !7$
<
<
**
:
' -:(
% !$8
&
'
2 !$#7 -% G
&'
F
F
F
F
!"7 ) !"$ ) !7#
2
-% KJG
!7$7 -% G
!7$7(
3
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*+**
2 !7$ -8( %
3
) !$/
-% KJG
!7>#( 7
<G 43
, )<
"! !$"! &
D
)
'
-8(
3
$
3
B I
@ 0 J ) :!$
%
!$8-!(-( !$"/
-:(
) 8
D
' -:(
*;
) :7
!7$7
/
7
2 #(D
< I %
4 !$8: . %
I
) :
-:(
) 8
'
I
D
<G 43 - (
, 0
J
!$77-:(
!$8
(
2
'
%
D
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
! @
( *+**
;
9
) /
2 !#
D
D
8D %
3
!! 3
< : !$$/
3
A % @ 31
(+,%*-% .*./01,,
*A
' :
) :7
/:>
. 7
% !/7
D0
D D
D
' -(
' -(
7
% !/7
3
I
3
.
!1 :
4 ,,+'%-2' .*./) RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
.%%*.*
*+** .*./5+67 4 8.'-
" I
D D
% //7
9
< . ) ) 9 , //:
3
,
J
L 9 B %
9 0 B %
9 -!$$>( > ) >#>
1
) L ) J4 D
% //7
*
=
3
D
*
'-%% '
.)
%
)
@
+
% #!:
<
B2-( 8:>7*#!! 0 )
) ?=
+
L 9
%
. J4 ##7 1 //#8
3
3
RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
, 8.2'.'-
** +,
* * *+* 2
*+** 7 6
A
1
)
(
",9%/-2' .*..:;3! , 3 $ * .'-. ' 1
)
1
6 "
" +, *+* *+* $
- 6 )
"
(< 2
"
*
: ! **2.*.-5+67 4
"
)
D -
*06 "
J
<8
J
<8 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document