Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2025 DAILYLAW 142017 (PNJ)

STATE OF PUNJAB AND ANOTHER v. PUNJAB STATE COMMISSION FOR SCHEDULE CASTES AND ORS

CWP/16755/2022 · 2025-12-12

Namit Kumar

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

! " ** +, *+** 2 1 3" 4 5 )" 6 !76 " 8 " 8 5 5 " 9 6 1 5 4( 9 :6 1 " 8 * ; % # 6 6 ! $%&06 ! " # " ' ( ) +, *+* $ - 06 " $ /0 ) " " ) *+** + * *+* * * *+* * * *+* 2 " 6 1 6 6 6 6 ! % 6 6 "" **<** = . " 8 * ; " " 1 1 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document ) 8 ) * " 8 "" = > : 1 0 ! = "6 8 ;6 ) 8 A + *+++ ; + *+ 1 *+** ,,B = " *+* $ - "" " ** +, *+* : 6 " 8 * C " ! " +; + 7"6 " 1 6 :6 # ! " 6 () .% 0 ! " $ 1 D * + ,,,6 " " " C " 8 *6 8 ? " @) 1 6 " ) " C " 8 * "" ; + *++ # *++ % 6 ) " 1 " * *+++ +E =6 ( " + + *+* *06 " " " 1 ) " " 6 8 ; C 3 ! 1 ) +, ,,; " 6 % % 1 # $% & '''0 2 6 ,,/ 1 (< 3 ! 1 C " 6 3 ! 1 ) " " " 6 " " RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document + * *++ *; + *+++ ) " " " ) 96 " " " 1 " = " " ,, %( 6 *+** 6 3 ! 1 C " A + *+++ " + :6 " 8 * ; 1 ) 6 " F :" 9 ) " 8 * " # ! " 6 " 8 * ;6 8 * ;6 ) 1 6 ) ) ) " 8 * ; ) " 6 6 ) 1 " = 6 8 * ; 1 " ' 2 ,06 21 F $ $ 8 ;*, 6 " *A +B , ; " 8 ; + ) " " " " : 9 ) 9 ) " ; D *B +A *++;6 ) 6 9 6 ) F :" ) ) ( " " 6 6 " ) ( " 1 ) " " " ) 6 @/ $ 8 + $ 8 ;; ,,06 ,,,0 1 ,,,6 " RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document " 2 6 ,BA <" 6 ! " " " = B = ) - ! - " " % : ) " *+** " ,BA6 ) @G " " " ) H' 4 " > ,, " - '' 1 * > " $ - " = ' " " " " "6 * +;+ " = ) " 1 " " ) - ' " % ! " " " ) " = - % " ( "" :6 " ! % : % 6 " *; ) 1 A 7 ?- " " " * " ) 1 - " " ) 1 ,, = 0 +;+ I @/ " +A * *+++ * + ,, +; +; ,,B6 6 +E - " ) " ;+E = ) 1 " " " 6 ) 1 B 1 = %6 " " 1 ! " ) % & 6 " 6 " RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 6 " ) " " ) @G 1 - *++A )( " 8 * ; % : 1 # '''06 2 6 ! % ) # *+** 6 1 ! ,,B *+ " ) ! " " *A +B ,, +A * *+++ " " " % & : " 6 "1 " ) B -" % 6 " A ! % ! " % : ) " %6 $ ) ) < ; ) " " : : 6 " " " " " # 6 " % 6 ,, ,BB6 = % D )( ! 6 " 1 " *++6 ) # 6 " ,,, %6 - " " ,,B *+++ ' ) = " " ) " *++A6 (< " 6 ! % ) "< (0 " " " 8 * ; 1 ? " " " $ 1 6 = " % " RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document *+++ " +* +; *+*+6 +, * " ** +, *+* *+** *++6 ! % " " " ! % " " ! % 2 " 8 * ; "" +6 " - 1 ,,B " 8 * ; *+ " " " +, *+* *+*6 ) ) (/ 6 ) 1 6 = " " =1 % 8 - " % D D " " " " 1 = *+++ % ) + " " ) " ) ) " " 8 * ; ) ) !"#$#! RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document *+** % & ' !( % ! + , -) . /#( /!( ) 0 1 ( ( + 2 3 4 !$"$ ) % -6( !$$7 ) % !# / ) ) % /( % #:#7## * ) !$$ % )* !$$$ ) ) % -) . ) ) 1 -) . / // -) ) ( !#5 % 0 ; % !8 9 ) !$$7 ### RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document * + *+** ) !# -( 2 ) % ##: % % !$$7 ### ) !# < + , < % < + , ) % !$$7 # ) % 4 #>!##! % - % 0 2 3 ( 2 ? < % % 6 " ! " + *+*6 1 ) B 0 2 3 ) : ) ) % 0 !# < % %= % 0 ### !# , 6 , ) -) @ 2 3 ( 3 1 %) -4(A " "" ** +, *+*6 ) 1 6 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document *+* *+** $ - *06 ** +, *+* " B 8!##! = = " ) % ) 2 3 C 2 3 ) -2 !$"# &' % / - , 6 1 " % "" 1 ) " ) < . >7#:8:8# 3 #$#! * #$#:##$ D ( 4 D % : /-( - ( / -( % RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document $ - " ; " A " H3 " 1 % ; 1 1 6 *+** " % 4 !!#! % ** *0 " " " " ** + " " 1 " 8 * ; : " 6 ) 8 * ; 1 ! 1 1 ( = * +A *+* ) 1 " " " ( " 8 * " " ) " " 8 * ; ) + 6 < )A ** +, *+* *+* 1 + +, *+**6 +, *+* $ - 0 ) ) " 8 + *+* I ! 6 ! 6 " 6 " 8 * 1 ; ) ' ) ) 2 >1 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document % 2 = ) " +; *+*; - >1 ) = " " 1 " *+** % ) 2 >1 ) " ) H) "" " ) " ; = - " ) " ! % ) 2 3 / : ; >#:#! E " 9 >#"!$$$ ) . ) ) . ) ) . /> / /! " * +A *+* H) " I 6 1 * +A *+* " 2 = ) " ) % ' / : ' % B ' : ) ) ) ) ) ) /" ) ./# RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 1 *+** ) . ) ) ) ) . ) % ! < + , 3 #$! /!!# / : #8!##! 3 / : % /##/##8 ! 1 >#:#! !/ F " " " ) " * ) . ) ) ) :#:### !:#"### !' % /!#### $!!### !###! % #"!##! 7#/##8 3 A @ 8 * ; *+ RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document ;;B :" % 6 " " B , " ? + * *+ " *+ ) *+** " " ;B ' ** +, *+* *+* $ 2 6 " 8 * 1 ) ) ) " C " 9 6 1 " "" " 1 ' 1 2 " 8 * ; ) "" " ? " 6 ) " *++ *; + *+++6 " 1 1 ) 6 "" ) " 6 ; % 6 $0 $0 6 6 " $ - *0 " 8 * ; ; " " C 9 6 F ) " 8 * ; "" 6 ) " " " +; +, ,,; " 1 1 % " ) " ) 1 6 " ) RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 9 ) " ) 2 " + / >1 ) " "" 1 * +A *+* " " " + 1 8 * ; ; ) " 6 ) *+** ) 6 " " % " " 8 * ; "" *+* .3 ! 1 1 6 ) 6 1 " ) +; *+*;6 = - ) " " ' ) "" ) " ' ; 1 1 ) " 6 ) 1 + *+* 2 " 8 C 6 *+ " ) A 6 F :" D +A + *+,6 ! % D 1 1 2 ) " " ) " ) 6 " ) ) " " 6 " 6 % 6 ) ) " 8 * H *++AI % " +$*0 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document " *+** +$*0 -( -( ) C -( ) -( C ' ) -( ) -( ) -( C &' F ' F ) F F C F RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document *+** ) -( ) -( ) 3 -( ) -3( F -( ) F ) F ; C F ) C F ) ) 3 F RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document * $0 $0 " 6 *+** -( -( + ) -( -( C ;;B 8 ;;B 0 " " 8 6 ) -" C F ) )F ) F ) ) A ' 8 ' @ -" ( RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document "" 8 ) ) " 6 8 ) 1 ; *+** ( " 6 $0 " 6 " 71 6 71 6 F -" ( 6 6 ) ") " ;;B -!( ) -( ) 3 2 G < B 3 6 6 ) " 6 ) 6 " " 6 ) "6 6 ) "" ( $B0 =" 1 6 $0 = $0 $0 ' ) . G' G' < 2 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document *+** -/( G < 2 -:( -8( -( C F -( ) F -( ' ) -( 2 -( ) ' ) F -( ) 2 3 2 , G' H ) + )F F + ) RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document *+** ->( 2 I + -"( B C ) ' -7( -8( -( F -( F -( -( -( *+ 2 ' ) C ) J ) ' -( ' -( &' F F F RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document A # "1 *+** -( -$( + ) -!#( %' " ! " $%&&'(')' ;;B 8 ' -( ' -( 8 > ) ' -( -( % ) * 2 ) C 3 ) A @/ " '*' - 6 7 8 % //7 -7( F ) RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document *+** " % -!$8( ) -8( ) 8 D: 2 !$#7( -( -( F -( -( -( -( 8 -:( ) !"8 ) !"7 ) 7 !7>#( 2 !7$ < < ** : ' -:( % !$8 & ' 2 !$#7 -% G &' F F F F !"7 ) !"$ ) !7# 2 -% KJG !7$7 -% G !7$7( 3 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document *+** 2 !7$ -8( % 3 ) !$/ -% KJG !7>#( 7 <G 43 , )< "! !$"! & D ) ' -8( 3 $ 3 B I @ 0 J ) :!$ % !$8-!(-( !$"/ -:( ) 8 D ' -:( *; ) :7 !7$7 / 7 2 #(D < I % 4 !$8: . % I ) : -:( ) 8 ' I D <G 43 - ( , 0 J !$77-:( !$8 ( 2 ' % D RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document ! @ ( *+** ; 9 ) / 2 !# D D 8D % 3 !! 3 < : !$$/ 3 A % @ 31 (+,%*-% .*./01,, *A ' : ) :7 /:> . 7 % !/7 D0 D D D ' -( ' -( 7 % !/7 3 I 3 . !1 : 4 ,,+'%-2' .*./) RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document .%%*.* *+** .*./5+67 4 8.'- " I D D % //7 9 < . ) ) 9 , //: 3 , J L 9 B % 9 0 B % 9 -!$$>( > ) >#> 1 ) L ) J4 D % //7 * = 3 D * '-%% ' .) % ) @ + % #!: < B2-( 8:>7*#!! 0 ) ) ?= + L 9 % . J4 ##7 1 //#8 3 3 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document , 8.2'.'- ** +, * * *+* 2 *+** 7 6 A 1 ) ( ",9%/-2' .*..:;3! , 3 $ * .'-. ' 1 ) 1 6 " " +, *+* *+* $ - 6 ) " (< 2 " * : ! **2.*.-5+67 4 " ) D - *06 " J <8 J <8 RAVINDER SINGH 2025.12.12 16:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document