- 1 - !!" #$%% &$'( ! " # !! $ ! #%$ & ! ' #($ ! ) * " # ! + ! '$ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - & + '' '', + + & '''' -'' + .! #'$ + & + / ... ! #$ # . $ + & ) ) / 01213142%4564 7-''74501368173... 2265674%86596:68%421;;674;<2=114=%8<><#014?137>50 >131>>12 57 %; />6%8 7<>5/ 37> ;07>5$ 6; (137>1 506; 7<>5 ?0%8814=64= 501 ?7>>1?541;; 73 %4 7>21> 2%512 '''' (9 @06?0%4%AA86?%56747 36812(906B<421> >21>.! <81 #'$ 73 6:68 >7?12<>1 721 57 ;5>6C1 733 %4 6;;<1 @%; >1D1?512 ' #6$ 01;<6564 7-''@%;3681237>% 26>1?567457501213142%4557E<65%422186:1>:%?%45A7;;1;;674 73501;<65;?012<81A>7A1>59%4257A%92%B%=1;%5501>%5173 ;'A1>B74503>7B5012%5173501;<6556885012%5173 2186:1>973A7;;1;;674 - 3 - #66$ 01A8%645633?8%6B1250%501@%;5017@41>73;<65 ;?012<81A>7A1>591?8%6B1250%5;64?101@%;%A1>B%4145 >1;62145 73 742%8 64 7>21> 57 B%4%=1 501 A>7A1>561; 64 14=%8<>< 01 0%2 1F1?<512 % A7@1> 73 %557>419 2%512 '--%42%AA764512501213142%45%4206;3%501>%;06; %557>419 57 27 ;1:1>%8 %?5; 2112; %42 5064=; 14<B1>%512 501>164 1 ?8%6B12 50%5 501 A7@1> 73 %557>419 @%; >1:7C12 %42 64 65; A8%?1 % 3>1;0 A7@1> 73 %557>419 2%512 -- @%; 1F1?<512 %<507>6G64= 501 3%501> 73 501 213142%45 57 27 %?5; 2112; %42 5064=; B14567412 501>164 01>137>1 01 ?74514212 50%5 501 36>;5 A7@1> 73 %557>419 2%512 '-- ;57721FA>1;;89>1:7C12(9501;<(;1E<145A7@1>73%557>419 2%512--%51>5013%501>73501213142%45%22>1;;12 % 81551> 2%512 --- 6437>B64= 501 A8%645633 50%5 01 6; >1;6=464= 3>7B %88 >1;A74;6(686561; 145><;512 57 06B <421> 501 A7@1>73%557>4192%512--01>137>101?74514212 50%55013%501>73501213142%45>1:7C12501A7@1>73%557>419 2%512 -- 1 ?74514212 50%5 501 3%501> 73 501 213142%45@%;A1>B6551257>1;62164501;<65A>7A1>59647>21> 57 018A 06B B%4%=1 501 %33%6>; 73 06; :%>67<; A>7A1>561; 64 14=%8<><0<;01?8%6B1250%5501A7;;1;;674735013%501> - 4 - 73501213142%45@%;A1>B6;;6:1644%5<>1%4201@%;(7<4257 0%42 7:1> :%?%45 A7;;1;;674 73 501 ;<65 A>7A1>59 57 501 A8%645633 1 ?8%6B12 50%5 501 3%501>73 501213142%45 262 475 ;<>>1421>A7;;1;;674<456801261274'-'01>1%351> 501 213142%45 ?74564<12 57 >1;621 64 501 ;<65 A>7A1>59 1 ?8%6B1250%5011FA1?512501213142%4557:78<45%>689;<>>1421> 501 :%?%45 A7;;1;;674 73 501 ;<65 A>7A1>59 @06?0 262 475 0%AA14 07<=0 501 A8%645633 ?8%6B12 50%5 01 >1E<1;512 501 213142%45 57 :%?%51 501 A>7A1>59 501213142%45 5<>41227@4 501 >1E<1;5; 745>%>689 01 36812 % ?7BA8%645 (137>1 501 %=%> A786?1 ;5%5674 74 '' %881=64= 50%5 501 A8%645633 0%2 <48%@3<889 %551BA512 57 26;A7;;1;; 06B 3>7B 501 ;<65A>7A1>591501>1%351>36812%;<6564 7 '37> A1>A15<%864D<4?5674@06?0@%;26;B6;;1237>474A>7;1?<5674 01A8%645633501>137>1;7<=0537>%26>1?567457501213142%4557 E<65%422186:1>:%?%45A7;;1;;67473;<65;?012<81A>7A1>5957 501A8%645633 #666$ 01 ;<65 @%; ?7451;512 (9 501 213142%45 @07 214612501?8%6B73501A8%64563350%506;3%501>@%;A1>B6551257 >1;621 64 501 ;<65 ;?012<81 A>7A1>59 1 %8;7 214612 50%5 06; 3%501> @%; A8%?12 64 A7;;1;;674 73 501 ;<65 ;?012<81 A>7A1>59 - 5 - <421>501A7@1>73%557>4192%512--1?8%6B1250%5 01 @%; % 514%45 64 501 ;<65 A>7A1>59 1 ?74514212 50%5 01 64656%512 % A>7?11264= %=%64;5 A8%645633 (137>1 501 145 745>7881><421>1?5674-73501%>4%5%C%145745>78?5 -7@1:1>501A1565674@%;26;B6;;1274501=>7<4250%5 501>1@%;47D<>%8>18%5674;06A738%4287>2%42514%45(15@114 501A8%645633%42213142%45 4741 0%4201?8%6B1250%506; 3%501>@%;475642<?5126457501;<65A>7A1>59<421>501A7@1> 73%557>4197>%;%514%45(<5745017501>0%4201?8%6B12 50%501@%;64A7;;1;;67473501;<65A>7A1>59%;%8%@3<8514%45 %42 50%5 501 ;5%9 73 06; 3%501> %874= @650 501 213142%45 4%5<>%889?74564<121:14%351>%881=12>1:7?%567473501A7@1> 73%557>419 #6:$ %;1274501;1?745145674;501>6%87<>53>%B12 50137887@64=6;;<1;) - 6 - ! " # $ % #:$ &014 501 ;<65 @%; ;15 27@4 37> %>=<B145; 501 213142%4536812%4%AA86?%5674<421> >21>.!<81#'$736:68 >7?12<>172157;5>6C127@46;;<1774501=>7<4250%5 501 A>7?11264= 64656%512 (9 501 213142%45 (137>1 501 >145 ?745>7881><421>1?5674-73501%>4%5%C%145745>78?5 - @%; 26;B6;;12 %42 % 364264= 73 3%?5 @%; >1?7>212 50%5 501>1@%;47D<>%8>18%5674;06A738%4287>2%42514%45(15@114 501 A8%645633 %42 213142%45 01>137>1 01 ?8%6B12 50%5 6;;<1 7@06?0@%;%8>1%2921?6212(9501>145?745>7881>?%4475 (1=7416457%=%64(137>15016:687<>506;%AA86?%5674@%; 7AA7;12(9501A8%645633@07?8%6B12501213142%450%2?8%6B12 64 501 @>65514 ;5%51B145 50%5 01 @%; % 514%45 64 501 ;<65 - 7 - A>7A1>59 %42 501>137>1 501 >6%8 7<>5 3>%B12 %4 6;;<1 %; 57 @01501>501213142%45A>7:1;50%501@%;%514%4564501;<65 A>7A1>59 01 >6%8 7<>5 %351> ?74;621>64= 501 ?745145674; <>=12 64 501 %AA86?%5674 %; @188 %; 501 7(D1?5674; 501>164 >1D1?512501%AA86?%56746451>B;735016BA<=4127>21>74501 =>7<42 50%5 501 213142%45 0%2 A1>;6;514589 36812 %AA86?%5674; 741 %351> 501 7501> %42 50%5 01@%; >13<;64= 57 ?742<?5 ?%;1 21;A651 501 26>1?5674; 6;;<12 (9 506; 7<>5 64 &7, '' %42 &7'-'' 5 %8;7 0182 50%5 501 %AA86?%5674 @%; 36812 %5 501 3%= 142 73 501 A>7?11264=; ;64?1 501 6;;<1 @%; 3>%B12 (%;12 74 501 %:1>B145; B%21 64 501@>65514;5%51B145501;%626;;<1?%4475(1;5><?C733 164=%==>61:12(9501;%627>21>501213142%456; (137>1506;7<>5 01 81%>412 ?7<4;18 37> 501 213142%45 ?74514212 50%5507<=0501>6%87<>53>%B126;;<1774,'' 501E<1;5674@01501>501213142%45@%;%514%457>475262475 %>6;137>?74;621>%567464:61@73%?%51=7>6?%821?6;674(9501 >145?745>7881>64A>7?11264=<421>1?5674-73501%>4%5%C% 145745>78?5-@01>165@%; 018250%5 501213142%45 - 8 - 262 475 A>7:1 50%5 501>1 @%; % >18%5674;06A 73 8%4287>2 %42 514%45(15@114501A8%645633%42501213142%4501501>137>1 ?745142;50%56;;<1747874=1>%>6;1;37>?74;621>%5674%42 501>137>1501>6%87<>5B<;50%:1;5><?C7336;;<17 1> ?745>% 501 81%>412 ?7<4;18 37> 501 A8%645633 ?7451421250%5%46;;<1733%?57>8%@@7<82%>6;1@01>1741 A%>59 %;;1>5; % 3%?5 7> % 81=%8 A7;65674 %42 501 7501> A%>59 21461; 65 1 ?745142; 50%5 A1><;%8 73 501 @>65514 ;5%51B145 =71; 57 ;07@ 50%5 501 213142%45 0%2 ?8%6B12 50%5 01 @%; % 514%4564501;<65;?012<81A>7A1>591%8;7?745142;50%5501 213142%45 %AA>7%?012 501 >145 ?745>7881> 57 21A7;65 501 >145 <421> 1?5674 - 73 501 %>4%5%C% 145 745>78 ?5 - %;;1>564=50%501@%;%514%45<421>501A8%64563301>137>101 ?745142;50%51:14%;A1>501<421>;5%4264=73501213142%45 01 @%; % 514%45 64 501 ;<65 A>7A1>59 %42 501>137>1 501 >6%8 7<>50%23>%B12%46;;<1@01501>213142%45A>7:1;50%5016; %514%4564501;<65A>7A1>59150<;?745142;50%5501>1@%; 47 1>>7> ?7BB65512 (9 501 >6%8 7<>5 64 3>%B64= %4 6;;<1 1;621; 01 ?745142; 50%5 501 A15656741> 0%; (114 36864= @>65 A1565674;741%351>5017501>?0%8814=64=:%>67<;7>21>;A%;;12 (9 501 >6%8 7<>5 1 ?745142; 50%5 1:14 @014 501 ;<65 6; - 9 - 86;512 37> %>=<B145; 501 213142%45 0%; 36812 %AA86?%5674; (1%>64=7 , %42 -37>%2D<26?%5674735017<>5311 A%9%(81 A>72<?5674 73 27?<B145; %42 >1:61@ 73 501 7>21> A%;;12 (9 501 6;5>6?5 7<>5 74 7 1 501>137>1 ?745142; 50%5 501 213142%45 0%; (114 36864= B6;?061:7<; %AA86?%5674; 741 %351> 501 7501> %42 01 6; A>7?>%;564%564= 501 %2D<26?%5674 73 501 26;A<51 (137>1 501 >6%8 7<>5 1 %8;7 64:6512501%5514567473506;?7<>557%26>1?56746;;<12(9506; 7<>564&7;, ''%42'-''@01>1506;7<>5 0%226>1?512501>6%87<>55726;A7;1733501;<65747>(137>1 ''''1 %8;7 ?745142; 50%5 64 &7''' 501 213142%45 0%2 <421>5%C14 475 57 3681 %49 3%4?63<8 %AA86?%5674; (137>1501>6%87<>5 0%:1 ?74;621>12 501 ;<(B6;;674; 73 501 81%>412 ?7<4;1837>501A8%645633%;@188%;50181%>412?7<4;1837>501 >1;A742145; , 01 A8%645633 ?8%6B12 50%5 501 3%501> 73 501 213142%45 @%; 642<?512 6457 501 ;<65 ;?012<81 A>7A1>59 <421> 501A7@1>73%557>4192%512--1%8;7?8%6B1250%5 501 3%501> 73 501 213142%45 0%2 51>B64%512 501 A7@1> 73 - 10 - %557>419 %42 ?74;1E<14589 01 @%; (7<42 57 0%42 7:1> A7;;1;;67473501;<65;?012<81A>7A1>598%645633%8;7?8%6B12 50%5 501 213142%45 ?74564<12 57 >1;621 64 501 ;<65 ;?012<81 A>7A1>59%351>50121%507306;3%501>%4221;A651(164=?%8812 <A74(9501A8%645633570%427:1>A7;;1;;67401>13<;125727 ;7 01 A8%645633 501>137>1 36812 ;<65 37> % 26>1?5674 57 501 213142%45 57 E<65 %42 2186:1> :%?%45 A7;;1;;674 73 501 ;<65 ;?012<81A>7A1>5901213142%4526247521495015658173501 A8%645633 57 501 ;<65 ;?012<81 A>7A1>59 4 501 ?745>%>9 01 ?8%6B1250%501@%;%514%4564501;<65;?012<81A>7A1>59%42 50%506;3%501>@%;475A8%?1264A7;;1;;67473501;<65;?012<81 A>7A1>59<421>501A7@1>73%557>41901>6%87<>5501>137>1 3>%B126;;<17%42A8%?12501(<>214<A74501213142%45 57 A>7:1 50%5 01 @%; % 514%45 64 501 ;<65 ;?012<81 A>7A1>59 &014501;<65@%;;1527@437>%>=<B145;501213142%4536812 %4 %AA86?%5674 >1E<1;564= 501 >6%8 7<>5 57 ;5>6C1 733 6;;<1 7 74 501 =>7<42 50%5 501 >145 ?745>7881> 0%2 A%;;12 %4 7>21> 64 A>7?11264=; <421> 1?5674 - 73 501 %>4%5%C% 145 745>78?550%5501>1@%;47D<>%8>18%5674;06A738%4287>2%42 514%45(15@11406B%42501A8%64563301>6%87<>5@%;>6=05 643>%B64=%46;;<1%;57@01501>501213142%45A>7:1;50%501 - 11 - @%;514%4564501;<65;?012<81A>7A1>59%;74?1501213142%45 0%2 5%C14 % ?745145674 50%5 01 @%; % 514%45 64 501 ;<65 A>7A1>59 01 ;%62 6;;<1 ?%4475 (1 ;5><?C 733 64 :61@ 73 501 %;;1>5674;73501213142%4550%5501>145?745>7881>0%2><81257 501?745>%>9%420%2018250%5501>1@%;47D<>%8>18%5674;06A 738%4287>2%42514%45(15@114A8%645633%42213142%4514?1 501>1@%;471>>7>?7BB65512(9501>6%87<>564>1D1?564=501 %AA86?%5674 36812 (9 501 213142%45 @%>>%4564= 6451>31>14?1 64 506;@>65A1565674 06; 7<>5 0%; ;114 50%5 501 213142%45 0%; (114 A1>;6;514589 36864= %AA86?%5674; 741 %351> 501 7501> 64 501 >6%8 7<>5%420%;A>75>%?512%46447?<7<;;<6537>A7;;1;;67437> B7>1 50%4 ' 91%>; 06; 7<>5 0%2 6;;<12 ;1:1>%8 26>1?5674; 37> 1%>89 26;A7;%8 73 501 ;<65 %42 <4B6423<8 73 501 ?74;1E<14?1;501213142%45@145%(7<536864=%AA86?%5674;741 %351> 501 7501> 50%5 577 @014 501 ?%;1 @%; 86;512 37> 364%8 %>=<B145; - %:64=>1=%>257501?742<?573501213142%45656; 7489%AA>7A>6%51576BA7;11F1BA8%>9?7;5;7%;57?7BA14;%51 501A8%64563337>50187;;7356B1648656=%5674 - 12 - 14?1 501 @>65 A1565674 6; 01 213142%456;(7<4257A%9?7;573;A%9%(8157501 A8%645633 (137>1 501 >6%8 7<>5 74 501 41F5 2%51 73 01%>64= 3 213142%45 3%68; 57 A%9 501 ?7;5 501 %AA86?%5674; 36812 (9 501 213142%4563%49;0%88;5%42>1D1?512%42501>6%87<>5;0%88 475 1451>5%64 %49 3<>501> %AA86?%5674 (9 501 213142%45 %42 A8%645633;0%88%22>1;;%>=<B145;%42>6%87<>5;0%88?74?8<21 501A>7?11264=;@65064%A1>6727350>11B7450;3>7B5012%51 73>1?16A573%?7A973506;7>21> )*' &%( % 6;57)87)