Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 139799 (PNJ)
RANDHIR SINGH & ORS v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS
RFA/5592/2015 · 2025-11-12
Harkesh Manuja
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 139799 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 139799 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
RFA No.5592 of 2015
!
/+!
4 4 4 4 56
3 )"!)9: !+2/)" ,!%+ = +/ !' % !" , +/ !' 2 /%!+/ '" 2%)"-")% & !'=?:,! 596
" 0,!!+!') *%)%!),%%+ % &'" )+!' % &'" )+!' % &'" )+!' % &'" )+!' #" )+- 0!" /+ !' '" , )"@"&"&"% ! !' +.!( "#+
"/+@ !%+ )D 015 (O&M)
+ + + +BBBB
"!+/
"!+/
"!+/
"!+/
4 4 4 4
"D''"@"()*+,"!/+
"#$"% &'()*+,"!/+!' %#'"-#"(
" #+. # +!'0+ ) !1 %+ +/ )%" 2'% "'"% (("3" EEEE
(
(
(
(7 "#8 7 "#8 7 "#8 7 "#8 3 -"3 +/ 0 ! "00"#78( ,'"## :0")23!'#" )))#
"!';/ ,+.!<8(-'2 !' " ) ,>.%%!%+ ,!( =?: ' "00##" !1#" )+- -" 0"
" ,)@"$!*"#.A9(=( % &+!'!"!.!+32 /%!1% !
" ) ,+. # /+ !' 0"!% " )!@% "!%+ +/@"$!*"#.!" + )"!)F99F0")%
'*!"!+/"3" "" )+!' '*!"!+/"3" "" )+!' '*!"!+/"3" "" )+!' '*!"!+/"3" "" )+!' !"% % &!+!'"@",>.%%!%+ 0 ,) "@+. ! +/ ,+@0 "!%+ A !*" ,+/#" )ABC+ #+ & -%!' "## !"!.!+3 2 /% )D.)&@ !%G!",!)'. )
BB?9 BB?9 BB?9 BB?9+/ +/ +/ +/9B 9B 9B 9B7 H8 7 H8 7 H8 7 H8
,%%+ ,%%+ ,%%+ ,%%+ 9 9 9 999 99 99 99BBBB
00##" ! 00##" ! 00##" ! 00##" !77778888
0+ ) ! 0+ ) ! 0+ ) ! 0+ ) !
'"00##" ! #(
" "
"## & '" 2 #"%) !+ !' -" %!%,!.)&(+ 0"!7'% "/ 23/ ,
!%!%+ /%#). ) ?: 7/+ '+! ;!' =?: ,!<8 "! ! 0"!#3 "##+-) -'%# &" !% & !' 1I0",>."!'",>.%)#" !% !'%/"*+."0+*%)). )
" ") %)@ !'"! !' @"!! - !" )")D.)%,"!).0+ 23!'%+ + + + +?J ?J ?J ?J+/ +/ +/ +/9: 9: 9: 9:!%!#)"KKKK4" 4" 4" 4" !' !' !' !'L-'23!'%@%#"#3%!."! 0+,)% &'"*2 '#) !%!# A 9:(:B(:FB1I 0 ", 2%) +/!'@"$!*"#."") /%! #*" ! 0+!%+ /+@ ! I 1
-")
"/! . )
"! !' !'@ #" ) . ) -%!' +.! 4"!" 4"!" 4"!" 4"!" ."!) !%!#) %) )23 !' MOHMED ATIK 2025.11.13 17:12 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
RFA No.5592 of 2015
"2+* ,+ 0"!#
"2+* =
",>. /+! !' !%! * '"## #*
56
* 0% ,%0#+/0"%! 0"!#3"##+-)% * !"! +/ " * !"! +/ " * !"! +/ " * !"! +/ " '#) !%!#)/+ )"@"&"&"% ! !'+.!("'"
"##!"!.!+32 ,>.%%!%+ ,!( 5:6
+*@2 +*@2 +*@2 +*@29 9 9 9(9 (9 (9 (9 !%$ M' M' 015 (O&M)
K+ %)% &!'0,.#%"/",!" 2+*( ,+.0#) -%!' !' "+ "/+ + %))*%-!'"!"##!'"00"#/%
"!#3 ",,0!) " ) !' "@ " ' 2+* ' #" ) +- % !' "00 =9? " -## " !' #" ) +- ,>.%%!%+ )"!)=F9?("'#) +!'%",>.%)#" )("!!'. %/+@ ' )"! +/ +!%/%,"!%+ . ) ,!%+ !%!#) !+ ,%* BC +/ !' "2+* *" ,,'"&%)!'%(!'#" '"##2 !%!#)/+"##!'!"!.!+32 #*" !0+*%%+ +/!',!L
*%-+/!'!" )!"$ 232+!'!
"%!3" )/+&" !+/D.!" )/"%, % !@+/!'"/+@ !%+ ))
"3" " " ) +!'<
"3" " " ) +!'<
"3" " " ) +!'<
"3" " " ) +!'< ," 7.0"8 +%@%#""@+. !+/@"$!*"#.
!*" ,+/#" )ABC+ '"2 "-"))!++!'%@%#"# /%!" )% !!"*"%#"2#. ) ,!(=?:""00#%,"2#!+!'0 )% &"00#%,"!%+ 78(%/" 3'"##"
(99 (99 (99 (99BBBB
'!'0"$% &1"+ ) 1 '!'0+!"2#
1 ,!" ),%,.@!" ,+/!'," +!
"/+@ !%+ )( !'% +.! % +/ ! #/%#)23!'#" )+- )*!+ '23 "##+-) !+ !' G! ! % )%,"! 00"# "%% & +.! +/ ",>.%%!%+ )"! - % !' "00"# "%% & +.! +/ ! #) !%!#)!+,%*!',+@0 "!% @"!+/9:(:B(:FB1I0",(/+ ,!%+ : +/ !' ,! '3 " "#+ '
"2+*"%) @"$! *"#. + ",,+. ! #" )+- (% 2+!'!'",>.%%!%+ 32 /%!"*"%#"2#!+!'@(. )! !'!'%)+ /",!" )"00#3% &! %,+@0 "!%+ (!'0 !"00"# ),%%+ %4"!"% &'" )+!' 4"!"% &'" )+!' 4"!"% &'" )+!' 4"!"% &'" )+!'
" ) !' "00##" !1#" )+- .A9:(:B(:FB1I0",2%) +/!'@"$!*"#."") #"#3%!."!)#" )+- N"#+ &- )!'"@ ))0+*%%+ +/" !",>.%%!%+ ##"#+!" ))%0+)+/ 74 8 74 8 74 8 74 8
1+ 1+
2
+!) +/ !' !+2 %,"!) )"!) +/ !'
"!%+ (/+@ + '#) . ! +/ %!%+ ( !' &!'
"#% +!' +!' +!' +!'
" %) )23 -%!'
" ) MOHMED ATIK 2025.11.13 17:12 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment