Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 13936 (KAR)

DR K S SUNDARAM v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WP/16015/2013 · 2025-02-25

N S Sanjay Gowda

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

1 !"#!"$%#& ' ( )*+,(,- ./+,0)1!2/,( $ ,*3//456/112 (/ /*1721,+-,,*3//45*575*58 9$,1,7,--,/-:7/1(//1 /,()16*+5(87/ , ,4,*,.)+5,*.,7(/;"!< (,11,065,-,* ./+,0)192/,( $,1/=*,*1,6,(7) $,1#*+78> (5 6*,/.,*82:,(1-/*1 ,1,57>,(- ,+, ,4,*,.)+5 ,*.,7(/;"!< (,-2,,*.,::, ./+,0)1<2/,( $(,*.,::, $,1?!?16( "1678>,2,*,.,(, ,*.,7(/;"!< < -16,2,--, ./+,0)1!"2/,( $(,(5@+, $,1"<)16,7 1 6,4,(/>/(/ 2 ,*+2,;"9< " -1=,+-,4,162 ./+,0)1"2/,( $( @/16,+(5 $,1<(5(,-,,+,*, >)7,,+ ,*.,7(/;"!"< ! -1,05,,*) ./+,0)1"<2/,( $6/--/+,*//A $,1 (5 6*,::,,(+/* 57,>,.,(,2,*,.,(, ,*.,7(/;"!< 9 (,(,2,*,@,-2 ./+,0)192/,( $,(, 5-6,5,6 $,1B*+,5*,+ <1678>,2,*,.,(, ,*.,7(/;"!< ? -12/+,,0//* ./+,0)1"<2/,( $(6+,(.0 (/6-,* $,1<) / /,(7216/(*.75 6867 )11/*,6,775, 1 ,.,(,*.,7(/;"!9? B -1,*)-,165--,7 ./+,0)1!2/,( $6,*(,3 $,1<!16( ,> 6-5,2)1)11/*,6,775 ,*.,7(/ -1 ,C//-)71,*, ./+,0)1<2/,( $ ,33,+6-/+ 3 $,1< 6,C51(//1 , ,4,*,.)+5 ,*.,7(/;"!< (5 *6,(7,7 ./+,0)1!2/,( $,1/ 5 6/*6,*+ $,1B6)(86,+ (+( 6,*165*,.,( ,*.,7(/;"!9 -1/*),>653, ./+,0)1"92/,( $ *6,(7,7 $,1B6)(86,+ (+( 6,*165*,.,( ,*.,7(/;"!9 (5)*57,>653, ./+,0)1?2/,( $ *6,(7,7 $,1B6)(86,+ (+( 6,*165*,.,( ,*.,7(/;"!9 < (5 ,33,+6-/+ ./+,0)1"<2/,( $0+)7 6,7)D < 6,C51(//1 , ,4,*,.)+5 ,*.,7(/;"!< /:(/ /*1/+0265 7+/( (56,--/+,A5)77, ./+,0)1!92/,( $0+)7,6,-,* $,1"$6)(86,+( , ,4,*,.)+5 ,*.,7(/;"!< " -1 ,C//-)716,*, ./+,0)1<2/,( 4 $ ,33,+6-/+ $,1< 6,C51(//1 , ,4,*,.)+5 ,*.,7(/;"!< /:(/ /*1/+0265 7+/( (56,--/+,A5)77, ./+,0)1!92/,( $0+)7,6,-,* $,1"$6)(86,+( , ,4,*,.)+5 ,*.,7(/;"!< ! (5+,-6,77,@,7, ./+,0)1"92/,( $6,5>66 5* $,1"2,7) /1(//1 ,7, 5:,72,- ,*.,7(/;"! 9 (56,--/+ ./+,0)1""2/,( $(56,77,@,7, $,1"2,7) /1(//1 ,7, 5:,72,- ,*.,7(/;"! ? (5=,7,35 ./+,0)1"2/,( $=/*>,1(,-,* $,17,1:, 6(5:,(1-/*1 <45*+,::,,+ , ,4,*,.)+5 ,*.,7(/;"!< B (5,6,-,* 6,* ./+,0)1!?2/,( $,1/6,--/+ 6,* $,19$916( ,+,*.,7(/;"!< 5 -1,2//-, 6,*)- ./+,0)1"2/,( $,6,-,* 6,* $,19$916( ,+,*.,7(/;"!< -16,*+(,>,7, ./+,0)12/,( $=/*).:,7/++2 $,1(/>/(/=577,./ =5*,2,>,*,.,( 1,**/(.6,11,,+ ,*.,7(/;"!!9 E/1515*/( %2(5 =, ,*16+48,1/& ' 6/1,1/A ,(*,1,>, /:,(1-/*1A (0,*/4/7:-/*1 =5>, ,)+6,<167( ,*.,7(/;"! /:(/ /*1/+0251 /8(/1,(2 6/--5 5*/( ,*.,7(//4/7:-/*1)16(512 6@+,5,6,+ )-,(,,(>/ 1 ,*.,7(/;"! E/ :*+/*1 %2(5,(/*+(,(, ,+A(#' (5 ,**)(+48,1/A(#& 6/ /@(51:/1515* ,(/A57/+)*+/((1587/ !,*+9A 16/* 151)15*A*+5,:(,25*.18,77A(16/(/8(+ A(-16/ (/ :*+/*1 ,*+16/:,(15/ ,*+/18 6/ / @(51 :/1515* 8-5*. * A( :(/75-5*,(2 6/,(5*. 5* F.():165 +,216/)(1-,+/16/A77@5*.' 6 6/ :/1515*/( ,(/ 16/ :)(86, /( A 16/ 51/ 5* 16/ (/ 5+/*15,7 7,2)1 %81( ,2)1& 8,(4/+ )1 A ,8(/ .)*1, A16/7,*+,1)(4/2$A115./(/4577,./6/ ,5+7,2)15 A(-/+0216/*+5,*/+58,7 85,15*) 5*. #:/(,154/ 85/12 5-51/+ 6/ 7,*+ 5* D)/ 15* ,7*. @516 16/16/(7,*+ 11,772-/, )(5*.B?B,8(/ @, :(: /+A( ,8D)5 515*45+/:(/75-5*,(2*15A58,15*+,1/+95 )/+ )*+/(/815*9%&,*+%&A16/,*.,7(//4/7:-/*181 B9! %F16/ ,5+ 81 A( 6(1& 6/ A5*,7 *15A58,15* )*+/( /815* B%& A 16/ ,5+ 81 @, 5 )/+ * < 6/ 8-:)7 (2,8D)5 515*A7,*+5 A(16/A(-,15*A16/7,2)1 8,77/+ F)(16/( G1/* 5* A *3,*,:)(, ,2)1 02 16/ /8*+ (/ :*+/*1 ,*.,7(/ /4/7:-/*1 )16(512 %F A( 6(1& 6/ :/1515*/( 6,4/ 8,77/+ 5*1 D)/ 15* 16/ :(/75-5*,(2 ,*+ A5*,7*15A58,15* 5* A,(, 16/2:/(1,5*116/5( 51/ (5 =, ,*1616/7/,(*/+8)* /7A(16/:/1515*/( )0-51 16,1*7,2)1@6,1 /4/(5 A(-/+)1A16/7,*+ 5* (/ :/81A@658616/A5*,7*15A58,15*5 5 )/+/ )0-51 16,1 16/ 86/-/51 /7A5 ,0,*+*/+,(./86)*> A16/ ,5+7,*+ 7 ,(//516/(@516+(,@*A(-16/,8D)5 515*(3) 16,4/(/-,5*/+ 75>/16,1@516*+/4/7:-/*1@6,1 /4/( / )0-51 16,116/03/815* A57/+0216/:/1515*/( 5* (/ :* / 1 16/ :(/75-5*,(2 *15A58,15* 6,4/ *1 0//* 8* 5+/(/+,1,77/, /(1 16,116/: / 5*5 1577@51616/ :/1515*/( /(/,+)1:,(,A(-16/-/-(,*+)-A16/ @(51:/1515*15 /G1(,81/+6/(/5*0/7@' !" # $%$ !" & & & & & !" & & & # & $ ' $%$ & ( <6/7/,(*/+8)* /78-:7,5* A6 157/+5 8(5-5*,15* / )0-51 16,116/,)16(515/ ,(/*13) 15A5/+5*5* 5 15*.16,1 16/ 7,*+ 5* D)/ 15* ,(/ (/D)5(/+ A( 8-:7/15*. 16/ 86/-/ +/ :51/ +/7/15*. 16/ 5-57,(72 :7,8/+ 7,*+ ,+4,*8/ 165 )0-5 5* 6/ 6, (/75/+ * 16/ 545 5* /*86 3)+.-/*1 +,1/+ :, /+ 5* ?"$" 8$@ !# <$< 8 "(5,(/*+(,(, ,+16/7/,(*/+++515*,74/(*-/*1 +48,1/ ,::/,(5*. A( 16/ (/ :*+/*1 )0-51 16,1 16/ :/1515*/( 6,4/ :)(86, /+ 16/ 51/ 5* D)/ 15* ,A1/( 16/ 5 ),*8/A16/:(/75-5*,(2*15A58,15*H5* -/8, / 16/26,4/ :)(86, /+ 16/ 51/ ,A1/( 16/ 5 ),*8/ A 16/ A5*,7 *15A58,15* 51 /7A/ )0-51 16,1, 16/ 51/ ,(/4,8,*116/(/5 **//+ 15 )/16/*158/8,775*.):*16/88):,*1 16,*+4/(16/ : / 5* A 16/ 51/ 16/ 88):,*1 6,4/ (/A) /+ 1 ,AA5G 16/5( 5.*,1)(/ 16/ 5.*,1)(/ A 16/ @51*/ / ,(/ 01,5*/+ @657/ +(,@5*. 16/ -,6,C,( ,1 16/ 15-/ A 1,>5*. 4/( 16/ : / 5* / )0-51 16,1 /4/* 5A 16/ 86/-/ 5 *1 5-:7/-/*1/+ 16/ :(:/(15/ + *1 (/4/(1 0,8> 1 16/ :/1515*/( , 16/2,(/4/ 1/+5*16/ !(5 ,**)(16/7/,(*/+8)* /7A(16/(/ :*+/*1 6, ,7 (,5 /+ , :(/75-5*,(2 03/815* 1 16/ :/1515*/( ,::(,865*. 165 )(1 ,A1/( 7*. 2/,( A 16/ 5 ),*8/ A 16/A5*,7*15A58,15* 9/ )0-51 16,116/:/85,7,*+8D)5 515* AA58/(6, 1,>/* 16/ : / 5* ,*+ 5* 1)(* 6,*+/+ 51 4/( 1 16/ *.5*//(5*. /:,(1-/*1 A 16/ / )0-51 16,1 16/ 9 86/-/ 5 )0 1,*15,772 5-:7/-/*1/+ / )0-51 16,1 16/ :(:/(15/ 5*D)/ 15*,(/4/ 1/+5*16/ ? *16/)(1D)/ 15*5*.65-*8/(1,5*, :/81 A16/ -,11/(6/ )0-51 , A77@ 0, /+*16/5* 1()815* ' %,& )1A",8(/ <.)*1, A115./(/4577,./84/(/+ 0216/A5*,7*15A58,15*,8(/ .)*1, ,(/+/#*15A5/+ %0&6/7,2)15 A(-/+,*+ 51/ ,(/,7711/+*,*/G1/*1 A7,*+-/, )(5*.,8(/ .)*1, %8& 6/ ,@,(+ ,-)*1 ,(/ +/: 51/+ 5* 16/ /A/(/*8/ )(1*"H*0+26, 87,5-/+(@516+(,@*16/ ,5+ ,-)*1 B A,( , 16/ +/7,2 * 16/ :,(1 A 16/ :/1515*/( 5* ,::(,865*.165 )(1,*+ -/A16/-:)(86, 5*.16/7,*+ ,A1/( 16/ 5 ),*8/ A 16/ 5-:).*/+ *15A58,15* 5 8*8/(*/+ 16/2 -,2 *1 0/ /*1517/+ 1 6,4/ 16/ ,8D)5 515* :(8//+5*. D), 6/+ )1 16/ 7,(./( D)/ 15* A @6/16/( 16/ 86/-/ 6, 7,: /+0216/:/(,15*A/815*9A16/ ,5+81(/-,5* 1 0//G,-5*/+/815*9A16/ ,5+81(/,+ , A77@ ' 10 ) * + & & & & ,&& - & . /$0 & $1 & # & 2 ( 1 5 *1 5* +5 :)1/ 16,1 16/ (5.5*,7 86/-/ /-:6, 5C/ 16/(/D)5(/-/*1A)1575C,15*A16/7,*+-/, )(5*. B?B ,8(/ 5* 115./(/ 4577,./ A( @6586 /G1/*1 16/ :(/75-5*,(2 *15A58,15* @, 5 )/+ @/4/( 16/ A5*,7 *15A58,15* @, *72 A( I A 16/ /G1/*1 6@* 5* 16/ :(/75-5*,(2*15A58,15*;",8(/ <.)*1, *16/ ,5+/G1/*1 A",8(/ <.)*1, ,8(/ .)*1, @/(/+/#*15A5/+6/ 5 7/A1 @516 B ,8(/ .)*1, A( 5-:7/-/*15*. 51 86/-/*16,1B,8(/ .)*1, 16/6, A(-/+16/ 7,2)1 *72 * ,* /G1/*1 -/, )(5*. ,8(/ .)*1, 8./*1 /G:7,*,15* @6,1 /4/( 5 A(168-5*. , 1 @62 16/ (/-,5*5*.",8(/ .)*1, 6,4/(/-,5*/+)*)1575C/+ 65 )(1 +/85 5* 5* 16/ 8, / A ! " # $ %$$&' ! $ (/:(1/+5*()** +,- . ,*, 5 A5--/* / 11 .)5+,*8/A(+/85+5*.165 8, /@6/(/5*515 6/7+16,1)*7/ 16/ 86/-/ 5 5-:7/-/*1/+ )0 1,*15,772 51 7,: / 6/* 16/ 86/-/7,: / 16/,8D)5 515*:(8//+5*. ,7 7,: / 15 ,7 :(A51,07/1(/A/(1165 )(1 +/85 5*5* 16/ 8, / A !& $$ / $ (/:(1/+ 5* ()), (0, @6/(/5* 51 5 6/7+ 16,1 5A 16/ ,8D)5(/+ 7,*+ 5 *1 )1575C/+ A( /4/(,7 2/,( 02 16/ ,8D)5(5*. 0+2(,)16(512A(16/:)(: /A(@658651@, ,8D)5(/+515 10/6/7+16,116/,8D)5(/+0+2(,)16(512A,57 1/G/(85 /51 (5.61 4/( 16/ 7,*+ * )86 , 51),15* 16/ (5.61 A 16/ 7,*+@*/((/454/ 1/4/(2 1,./A16/:(8//+5*. 16/ 716 5A *1 7/16,(.2 5 +5 8/(*507/ 4/* ,A1/( 2/,( A 16/ 5 ),*8/ A 16/ A5*,7 *15A58,15* " ,8(/ B .)*1, 6,4/ (/-,5*/+ )*)1575C/+ 6,4/ 16/(/A(/ * 6/ 51,15* 5* 67+5*. 16,116/,8D)5 515*:(8//+5*. 6,4/7,: /+ < 6/ */G1 D)/ 15* 16,1 A,77 A( -2 8* 5+/(,15* 5 @6/16/(16/7,*+5*D)/ 15*@)7+8*15*)/10/4/ 1/+5*16/ J 12 " 6@ 16,1 16/ 4/ 15*. A 16/ 7,*+ 5* 6, 1,>/* :7,8/ 16/ */8/ ,(2 :(/#(/D)5(/-/*1 5 16,1 16/ : / 5* A 16/ 7,*+ ).61 1 6,4/ 0//* 1,>/* 02 16/ 4/(*-/*1 A(- 16/ 88):5/( 5* , -,**/( >*@* 1 7,@ 6/(/,A1/( 51 ).61 1 6,4/ 0//* 1(,* A/((/+ 1 16/ A 16/ / 1@ :(/#8*+515* ,(/ *1 :(/ /*1 16/ )(1 @577 0/ )*:/( ),+/+1,88/:116,116/4/ 15*.6, 1,>/*:7,8/ 5 6/7+02 16/:/G)(15*16/8, /A! ! $ % / ! ! $ (/:(1/+ 5* +()**- , 11 234 16/4/ 15*.A16/7,*+)*+/(/815*!A 16/,*+8D)5 515*81?B<:(/ ):: / 16/,81),71,>5*.A : / 5*,*+157716,15 +*/16/7/.,7:(/ )-:15*A4/ 15*. 8,**1 0/ (,5 /+ 6/ (/7/4,*1 :,(,.(,:6 A 16/ ,5+ +/85 5* ,(//G1(,81/+6/(/5*0/7@' $1 3 ! " 4 5 " 2.6.'$$"&7 & 8 4! 7 9 : 3 & ; 8 ;99 &9 73;<54 ! = & <3 & ! ,7 > &"; 13 & ?; < & @/ ! " << 6$$)0 /0 . & 7 & & /0& & && 7 /0 & % # & && & 7 , & % 7 & ,& & & & % & & 7 /0 & & & & % 7 & & && 7 & /0 & & & % & A'B & & 14 $)/."0 & & & & 7 ( '& # && 8 ! " & C< & 7 & DDDD = 2 & < & 7 3& C < & ( 15 !-,2) /A)772(/A/(1165 )(1 +/85 5*5*16/8, / A!& + 5-6/ ,5+:(15* ,(//G1(,81/+ 6/(/5*0/7@' )$ /#0 " !" 7 & A$$1)2 & 7 7 . 7 & "5+"3E & & 7 7 && & & 7 & & !"7 & & & & 4 5 ; = & ( 9 65 )(1 5* 16/ 8, / A # $## ! $ $$ / $ & $ 1 $&' % ! " # $ ! $# $ ! 16 $ (/:(1/+ 5* ()*) 4(' 6, 6/7+ 16,1 16/ 7,*+ 4/ 1@51616/4/(*-/*1*725A16/: / 5*5 1,>/*5* , -,**/( , :(45+/+ )*+/( /815* !%& A 16/ ,*+ 8D)5 515* 81H ,*+ 16/(/,A1/( 1(,* A/( A 16/ ,-/ 1 16/ (0,*/4/7:-/*1)16(512, :(45+/+)*+/(/815*!%&A 16/ ,(*,1,>, (0,*/4/7:-/*1)16(515/ 81B?96, 1 1,>/:7,8/6/7, 1:,(1A:,(,9A16/ ,5++/85 5*(/,+ , A77@ ' ) DDDDDDD 3 % - F 7 = & 3 - 7 3 & & && . 3& & 7 & < & $2/0 & 5" " & & & 7 ( ? * 16/ 75.61 A 16/ 8, /#7,@ 1 @6586 16/ /7,0(,1/ (/A/(/*8/ ,(/-,+/6/(/5*,04/7/1-//G,-5*/@6/16/(16/ 17 (/ :*+/*1 87,5-16,116/: / 5*A16/7,*+5 1,>/*6, ,*2,88/:1,057512J B 6/16/( 16/ :/1515*/( @/(/ :)1 * ,*2 4,75+ *158/ 8,775*. ):* 16/- 1 6,*+4/( 16/5( : / 5*J 6/ /8*+ (/ :*+/*1 1,*+5 16,116/,@,(+*158/51 /7A8,77 ):*16/ :/1515*/( 1 6,*+ 4/( 16/ : / 5* * ?B 6/ ,@,(+ *158/ :(+)8/+ 5* **/G)(/ < /(5/ 0/,( 16/ +,1/ B6/*1/,116//*+A16/,@,(+*158/ 6@ 16,1 16/5( +5 :,186 1> :7,8/ *72 * "B * @6,1 +,1/ 16/2 @/(/ 1,>/* 1 16/ : 1 AA58/ * @6,1 +,1/ 16/2 @/(/ /(4/+ * 16/ 88):5/( 5 *1 A(168-5*. *+/( 16/ / 85(8)- 1,*8/ 515 6,(+10/75/4/16,116/*158/@65860/,( 16/ +5 :,186#+,1/ , "B 5 /(4/+ * 16/ 88):5/( 0/A(/ ?B 16/ +,1/ * @6586 16/2 @/(/ (/D)5(/+ 1 6,*+4/(16/: / 5* 1**/G)(/#"5 16/-,6,C,(+,1/+""A( 6,45*. 6/7+ 16/ 5* :/815* A 16/ 7,*+ A( , 8/(1,5*5*. 16/ -,7>5/ 1,*+5*.16/(/*6/ ,5+-,6,C,(6, 16/ 5.*,1)(/ A16(//:/( * *16/ ,5+-,6,C,(16/(/5 *-/*15*5*.A 16/5(A)77*,-/ -)867/ 16/5(,++(/ / 18 A1/( 16/ 5* :/815* * "< @6586 16/ (/ :*+/*1 87,5- 1 6,4/ 8*+)81/+ *165*. 6,::/* A( , :/(5+ A */ 2/,( A)( -*16 * ?B 16/ A5( 1 (/ :*+/*1 87,5- 1 6,4/ 1,>/* 16/ : / 5* A 16/ 7,*+ 6/: / 5*-,6,C,(5 :(+)8/+, **/G)(/#!**/G)(/ #! 8*1,5* 16/ 5.*,1)(/ A A54/ :/( * 0)1 16 / A54/ :/( * ,(/ *1 5+/*15A5,07/ ,1 ,77 6/5( *,-/ ,*+ ,++(/ / ,(/*1 6@*,1,776/-,6,C,(5 :(/:,(/+*,8287 127/+ A(-6/,71/(*,154/87)-* ,(/*1/4/* 1()8>AA6/1@ ,71/(*,154/ 87)-* , 1 @6/16/( 16/ @*/( 5 :(/ /*1 ( *1 :(/ /*16,4/3) 1(/-,5*/+75>/16,1 */A16/,71/(*,154/ 87)-* 5 *1 1()8> AA 51 5 *1 /4/* >*@,07/ A(- 16/ -,6,C,(, 1@6/16/(16/7,*+@*/( @/(/:(/ /*1(*1 A16/: / 5*A16/7,*+ 5*D)/ 15*8,-/10/ 1,>/* * ?B 51 5 *1 >*@* @62 16/ 4/(*-/*1 @,51/+A(*/2/,(*/-*166/,81A16/1,>5*.4/(16/ : / 5* * ?B 5 :)075 6/+ 5* 16/ ,C/11/ * "<%**/G)(/#?&) 10/8,) /*:/(5+A75-51,15* 5 :(/ 8(50/+A(:)075 65*.16/,81A1,>5*.4/(16/: / 5* 19 51+/ *1-/,*16,1518)7+0/:)075 6/+,*215-/16, 1 0/:)075 6/+@5165*,(/, *,07/15-/ 1 5 :(/85 /72 )*+/( 5-57,( 85(8)- 1,*8/ 16,1 165 )(1 5* 16/ 8, / A !& ! # $## + 5- 6, +5 0/75/4/+ 16/ 87,5- A 16/ (/ :*+/*1,)16(515/ 16,4/1,>/*4/(16/: / 5* < ( 2/1 ,*16/( (/, * 1 165 8, / +/ /(4/ 1 0/ ,77@/+ "6/4/(*-/*18,**1,+:1+5AA/(/*12,(+ 158> A( +5AA/(/*1 :/:7/ 5* 16/ -,11/( A @516+(,@,7 A 16/ 7,*+ A( ,8D)5 515*6/(/ :*+/*1 6,4/*1:7,8/+,*2-,1/(5,7, 1 @62 ,8(/ .)*1, A 16/ 7,*+ 84/(/+ 02 16/ A5*,7 *15A58,15* 8,-/ 1 0/ @516+(,@* A(- 16/ ,8D)5 515* A 16/ ,5+ +/#*15A5/+ 7,*+ ,*+ 16/ 7,*+ 5* D)/ 15* : / 16/ ,-/ A/,1)(/ 16/ (/ :*+/*1 ,(/ *1 3) 15A5/+ 5* 875*.5*. 1 16/,8D)5 515*A16/ /7,*+ ! * 67+5*. ,- A(15A5/+ 02 16/ :/G )(1 3)+.-/*1 5* 16/ 8, / A !& &# +! !- $% " $$ / %$$ ! ! $ (/:(1/+ 20 5*+()**- , 11 ,,26/:/G)(16, 165 1 ,25*:,(, ?!A165 +/85 5*' A2+ & E & & & " $6 & < " & & $A1)G4 & & " 7 & 6A6' #. 4 &5 " 3 & & + & & # . && & 3 C < && & & &7 & & " $6 & < 7 21 & & & & ( 915 ,7 6/7:A)71(/A/(116/:/G)(1 3)+.-/*1 5* 16/ 8, / A # ! $ $$ / & ! $ (/:(1/+5*+()*)- 2 11 4(*6/ (/7/4,*1:,(,.(,:6 ,(//G1(,81/+6/(/5*0/7@' 6' & & & & & & & % & # 6A & " & & & & : &- E & & & & & " & & & 6$3 & & & & & 22 3 7 & & & ; && # & 6A &" & & & & " $6 & < ( ?(,7716/,A(/ ,5+(/, * ,77@16/ /:/1515* 02 +/87,(5*.16,116/5-:).*/+,8D)5 515*:(8//+5*. 6,4/7,: /+ 5* A,(, 16/2:/(1,5*116/:/1515*/( 51/ (+/(, 1 8 1 $8-$#