Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 138875 (PNJ)
DEV DUTT SONI v. SMT SITA DEVI SINCE DECEASED THR LRS AND ORS
FAO/4528/2024 · 2025-12-22
Pankaj Jain
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 138875 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 138875 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
! "#$%$ & ' ()( * + , &$ (((((( --..& */%+% ,0( ,$ *$ %$&#
"#%" 1( 1/ 2% &" 1/% ((((( %- &"&%
33333
'
42 ( ,5
! "#$ ! !! %! & $
' $() $(
*"+, &
$
(
*,
$ ' ! - ) !,
( . //// 5 6 (
/. #
. )! .) $ 0 !( 1)2 $
345 6 DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
. )
&
77849:*
: (
;
;< !.(5 6 )*! &
99:* ! (
(
-( ! ( ( )
(
4 + 4
93
9= !.) $(
< ! * >#
. )! .) $ 0 !(
1)? $
34 5
6
. )
&
77849:*
: (
;
;< !.(5 6 )*!&
99:* ! (
(
-( ! ( ( )
(
4 @)
( ( :
. ) (
34 . : ()
(
(( ! ( )
= ;
$(
. )A.
+
) !). ( ! ( )
DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
. ) ( &
77849:* (
(
8 , 33B # @( ! + $ (
C<? 5&!( 1) $
6 33B5 6
!(
)
.( ! ( <
) (
#
0
+. &
( *
!" # $$
$ !" % $ !"
& $ $'
( $
!" ' #
" !" ( !" ' # )# ) ! ) # ) # !"$ "
*# ! * # )& * $ $
$
+ ) #
" # & ++++ ++++ ++++ ++++ ( % $ , - ." /0$ 1) # - 2&3 ( , )&
!$ #45 /3 )& & &# ! ) # ) # # # ) $ ! & # !" # $ !"6 /3
7))) 8&7 ) & - 8& # )
"$ DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
) ! - 8& ! ))) 8&6 /3 - 2 &# - & ))) 8& $
, 6 /&3 1+) - & $ $ # ))) 8&6 /&3 $ ) #$ !" )) $$ 6 /&3 $ $ !"
,
)&
# 6 /&3 . % # 2 8& $
9 6 /&3 )& $ $$ .
%
# 2 8&6 /+3 +$ !"$ # !" # )
# !$ & )& ! "
"$ ! $ !"6 /+3 )& )# &$
$ !" ! !" 6 /+3
"$ * )& # !" $ )) # #
) # 6 /+3 )!$ - 8&
#
# :5 8 ) - ;& )58 2 ;& 6 /+3 )& )) )$
$ :58 ) - & )58 2 & 6 /+&3 )
)&
$ $
+$ ) # ) # ) ! DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
# )& ! $ )&
# )# !$ 6 /+&3 )& ) & & 6 "$ $' # - )
% 6 ) " $ 6 506
!"
! #$ 506 #"%&"& &
! ""&"
&
' ++++ ++++ ++++ ++++< B
33B
#( * ' ( =/3 ( # % $
, - ." /0$ 1) # - 2&3 /3 + ! /3
&
# > /?3 )) &# ! ) #
) # # # ) $ ! &
$ !" # $ !" 1+) =9 )) 5
$ !" ) #
#
# # ) #
" )$
$ !" ) # <
&
33B ( *
' )/3 + ! *= ++++ ++++ ++++ ++++ /3 $ !"< ) ! ) #
# " 5"
"
)&# !" DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
! ! ) # +) ) ! # $ !"
# )= /3 ! ) # # $
& )#6 /3 ! $ ) # )&# )#
! !$ + $ +
) ) + #
# )! & # $ 6 ++++ ++++ ++++ ++++ /$3 < ) ! " ) $& # )) # $
# ) # $ !" ! )) $ !" # !"
56 ++++ ++++ ++++ ++++ /3
) #<
! 5 /3 $ !" # # #
) 8& # ! # # )
! # )
)6 /3 $ !" # #
# !
# +& # 6 /3 $ !" # $ # ) # $ !" )) # 6 ++++ ++++ ++++ ++++< 7
=9
33B(
:$
DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
< (
)
.( !< 3
87
33B (
C< ?$
34 ).) .( !<
# ( * *
' )( )& ."
-) # )) # $ !" ) # ! ))
2 2
< 9 #! ) . 34 . ( <
$(
! D ( <? :( !() ( ( <
#$( . (
( <. ( &
99:*<
'
4 ' (
" ,
( . ) " # )$ ! A (
$(
( .( !< . ()
)
:
<: (
= ( 9
9= 8
" ,
( . ) " # )$ !. (! ,
( . )
!$( "
# )
&
$
(
!( ' , ( $ B #&! )
()
.<
$(
,
.(.) ( &
= < )
E = ,
. .) DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
( . ) "
#
$ ! #
< 8
-;<, );.( $ ! "
#
$ !( * >00 00 00
#
(. (. '
B 3
9
98 F(
)1
$ ! F( . $ ! @( ! &( 5". 6 9 ( ! ) ( !.( ! ( <
2. $( G(
. >56#F( . ! ( ) .( ! ( <. )
(. .( ! ( $ ! @( !&(5". 69 56$ F( . .)
!(
( ! 1
+ @( !@ 1
+
E , . ! )
( < ( .( $) B 3
998 0 0(&* 4 # BB 3
9
98
F(
) ;
$ ! F(
. H$ !&(, . 5
&; & (1
.6$ (
& ( @( !@)*;I!5.
( ( ; 6 ! " # ) $ !&(9H ( ! ) ( !.( ! ( <
2. $( # . .)
!(
) @( !@
( $ $ ! , ( . DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
! )
( < ( .(
$)
BB 3
9
98 0
0(&*
E B
! ( , )
( .-
;.(( * >00 00 00 4 #
( < );.(F(
! -
< ( )
( <.) 5
. ( . ! 6 ) <
( #. ) ( ! )
( ! ( <J
. F(
) (
( <..( ! &( ! ).( !: (
* 6 # ! !- ( ., (
10 $ $ ! 6 # $ )
( .-
;
6 # )
( . -
( ! ". -
)
(
0(&* &* &*4< ( 2.$(
= #
. ! !- ( ., ( 10 $ $ ! '
373 9=
98
.( ! .),1$ )
.( .) 56
;.(-
.(.) ! )
,1$
#
,1$)
( ( <
( * DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
7@ A!" ! ! !"
$ &
! ) )# # A5))$7 #)
0(&*= 8 #
. 4 - -
;
949 9=
985
0(&*86
;.( -
$ ( $( ( ) $ . .( ! . ( (! *'<
. ( ( @( !K + $ ( C<< !#
+G,'-,
(
B #
. 4 - 1 ! $
"-
'! "-:-15 L*6:98:,:4:98 4
9=
98 5 0(&*B6
"-
(
<( < ( .) ! <
(! ! ) ( .( ! ( <) . (8 ! . $(8(.(8
@ ! -(
* )& B ) # &
# )
!$ & ! "4 /3 $ !" )
/3 $ *) /3 $ ))# /+) !" )
*)3 !
/ 3 ) B# 7 G(
(. (
)
) . (
DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"-:-15 L*6:,:939:98 7
94
98
$
-:;-:-:@-:-:
M-$1 ! "-:-:;- $ # ( .:"-* >
(
<
( (.( ! . ! !( ( ! (
E
& )
) ;.(-
( * >00 00 00 = # ((
8
9
98.) 2.$( G+'
=87 9=
) @( ! + $ ( C<2C @5 @6(
)
> ) @( ! + $ (
C<2C@ $ ) *$ ( C<
) E . .) $ @
. ( #)
) 0 0(&* 8 #
) ! :!< (< !! * ( <5
. ₹9<6
! (
) ) ( (
( C< 2$
34 B #
) @( < .! !. ( .)
$ :
2. $(
( ) ( ! ) ( @+$CC@.) )
#
!. )
! ( ! ) . () 0
)
DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
((
.)
-( )- 5, (
)K 6.)
2.$ @ .(
. (!- @ #
E 7 #)( * 7,+89#' .$#: ! / $&&#$. %%$%&# ;/"% 0-&%$ & ! / #%" / &9+/" +$."$&<
1/ &%/+#$ &
= />/% &<<" $& ,0..,#. ₹ &%/+#$ & = />% / 9# %
8. ; ) .>1 8: ==( , ((
2. ( .K ) !$( G+'
=87:9=
8
9
98
. (
). )@$<*
! (*
()( ! ()
(
) @( !K+ $ ( C<C @(
!) )( $. 00�&#). 7C%,-..%2 -) D #2 52 - ." C#7
( --.$#8$.$:#))
$ ! ()@$ <
(
)
! ( : ₹ . 9< ?( 89#$*#
.! . .)
$ 2. $(
( ) .( ( @+$CC@ 5 6 ( ! . (< (!)
(
+/ ! %%$%&##@ *.)* . )
:! < (< ( !
( ) 610 ! @+$CC@ DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
.6 ) ) .) ) ( .$<$8$.$:
&"$$ &%G (
). ) 6 #. ( .) $
$ ( C< 2 $
34 .6 ₹ #
.. 9<.)
(
) 6 # ) ) ( (
(
6
.)
-( )- , (
)K 5,K 6 6 ! .) $ @+$CC@
( .10*
@ @( %%+&# ! +$".$&%#
+ ! (56:!( ! .(
( ) . (
).) @ &&A+/ /! ,&"/" -/$&< / #"+/ , B +$".$&% ! / 0-.0&$ & ! ,1 /!.. 0-&%$ & .$#: )( +/- % #
*.)* ! .( ! : () @$<( * (
₹
5. 9<6 ( ,-8:,- / #"+/ ,- )' %
"&$!$#$ &
# -( ) - *,K
$ $ (
C< 2 $
34 @$ <
, ! +:;.($ )
(
+:--* ,K <): ! ): ). ) ! ) . !!. ,- ' C/$!$#$ & ! / 9# %
!"#$ %
&
%
DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
₹
' ( ,- ?' %%%%0& ! :0& ,+%
!"#$
% % ) * %
+ %%
, % + % - % . / %
$ ) ( @+$CC@ 5 )6 ,- ' .#+.$ & ! ,1 /!..'
N#
.)$ 5( .) ) O ( ( @+$CC@6 ,- ' 0-. :/4% #./$ &
+. ): :
! . ) )(
. ,- D' # 00&"$ & 8: , -( )- 5,K 6
( ( !(
,- @' --/ *. 8: 1 /"
$ .. @
,- ' $%8+/%. ! %%$%&#
)
. )
< . <( !: (<-@# ?( $0.$&%
I
.)--*,K =8 )
2.$ ) 49 )
( &$ /$&<
L( )
.. @
( ( .( )
(
E 3
! )
! ! )
.
A .?)( @( D( DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
9 - !)
. ! ( )
5
()(
- C < !: % C & . ' DINESH KUMAR 2026.03.20 16:55 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document