Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2025 DAILYLAW 138575 (PNJ)

JASVINDER KUMAR AND ORS v. STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

CWP/31984/2024 · 2025-03-07

Sureshwar Thakur, Vikas Suri

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

!"# $ $ % &'!()**!"#+$$ % ,# -.,$///0 -.,$/10// !"# !$ %&' (! )" #%#* $ +! & # + #%#* $ % ,! ! %*% $ % " -! .%*% $ % * " &/ #%*% $ #%*% $ 222 //03$ 0 !".!! +%!! & $( !" '( +! "( 1 1"%!"'.! '2" '!'1 (!# %(1! (%+!/03%- .!+ 4560%! " 67%! 475%406007%404 !+ 8948%! " 48% ! 406000% 408 " ## . % ' 1" . (!%+!'! # $(! % !&(! .! ,1 ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment -(!," &% #'! !+ # - -$!&'(# $ # '! A !# '"# .(!%! ! =" @" %!"# '# '" '1 -$!B ,"' ,&# #4<44(0AA8# > ?%+!-$!B," . !05!(% . ! +!(-'1B '! (%! (B".! ''" (# $%# '! '2"''% !! ..&;?" # (# +("# '2"(!# +!'!-' 1 # $"-C' "-#'"%-"+"#- "$#.((%!"' ##+ ! #(#-$! ( ! ! '##(! !+ ! " " #" # $ # % # ! # &" # " % ' $ " ! # # # # " ( ! #" ) ) " # "# " ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment "# # ) # # # * ) # #)% # # % " " $ " ! " " + ! #"$ " # # "" " " " "+ $ " ! " # &" " % # # #" , 0< +&%!B," C".1' ,&# # 669< ( 7<07% # > ! " # $% &' ?! ) ' !&+ 00 &% !C".1-$!B," ' ,&# #4<;40(7<7<%# ># ( $)% ?%! # ) &+' $! )*4&56&-)&789&:1# &+! #- )-$ ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment 3 'F '& '1 "# #$% ! + -' 1 ##+ ' - . / " 0 # " 12 " 11 "# " ( . $ # " # " " 3 " # $ + 12 + 3 #" " " +% " # " 12&2 # %#" 4( " "4 #"## 5 " 6 % 71, 03 ! ( ! ! -'1. ..& !(1 " :! . -(!B," B( ' #! ( '" #1 B% # ! ' %1 ) ).! !! '2"(# %!"+1 ( #F.!' '$#( +)!".!')&## .(! ( ! ! ! ).1 '("#B(# ++!'!-'1' . !05 (!C".1% . !+!( # $ B '! -&% ! %!".!!+'# 1- .!# +''% ''"(# $ # '! '2"! '2"''=@ #=@+&% #("! !%! ' ! # $-'1+##B# %!-$!# ++"#-'1+## ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment 5 04 /! 1 $%! C".1+!#(. C".11 -$!B,"' # % 6 ) ) 27 0 8 "&/ 55 8 ' % +!% ! #& . ! !(% . !+!(-'1B '! (%-'1B" ! !' -% &-$ "!$(# +%!" $& $ # +&; ;&!.!$%-+!! # B!%! !& (!.!$( $ # +% !' +##! #$!".!!# +("#1#$1( !'(11 %' ##$+!! .!#$ ," #.!-" # !"1 .! G!+%'#3<<;#$#1!+(! ! ! ##-&(!$ &-$ "!$(# +! & +!"" '(# +& -$ $! 1 '2" )."'#3<<; !+%(!# +%!& H 06 "!1% C".1-$B,"' # .) / 8 993,- /" 3% !!B,"'# ! !"1 .! . .&. 1"#( '1% ! !.!$&$1"'! ( "'!1"#( '1% +!"1 .!%'#+!( -'1B"&C".1 84 / #8 4 9: ;< )= :<=;7 > 9 :;<<:;?@7> : 99;9?AB C ' " / 8 9:@;<<:;?12A " ' - 84 9 :;<<:;2> 9:@;< )= @21 5 /6 D/83< 9 @2?; ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment 9 09 ,2"#$ . !%A09' !C".1 ' # .&)<<5&" &- )& 789&:% . ! +!(-'1B '! (%!B,"%1 ) "''' B(# +%2" !& ($(!# +% # +("#'1 -'1. # +&; ;&!1%-$ ! # -'1. "-C' "#F % -" + ## 1'! 1-$!*&1( ! ! 1+ " ) ' " " + " " # $ " # ? ! * # " + " # + " % % " # " + E # F F F F D "# " " # " #) % " 3 ) F # F # + " # ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment G #G 3 # G$G 9+ " #" <6 #" #" 4 )#5 " ) + + % ) + 5 " ") 3 # + # " + ) " + " #" " " +% " ## " 3 # " " 3 " ) ! # + "# # "D " # #) " " + " "G # # " % # :H> (!# ( 60 "&/ 53 8 ' 3: ; < ( 6%% !% ; <0 "&/ 543 8 ' : 8 % ; < ( = + % ; <0 995,- ' 9 > ,995- '' 3*4:- ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment B # ) " # " " 5 #) " #" 3 #" " # " # 3 ") " # ( # # # ## &# "+ #" " / :H> ( ' '%% &8 1?8 ; <0 "&/ 539 8 ' 3*5: '%% )0 . ")@0 " ; " ( 7 ; <0 "&/ 543 8 ' : / . /%!# '8# . ( ) +0 +78 ; <0 "&/ 55 8 ' 49: #% ; < ( A & ; <0 99,- /'/ ,'(%- 343 : '8 $ ) # . ( ; <0 "&/ 9 8 ' *- ?3 $ ( ; <0 54,- /'/ ,/ - 3 0 ?9" " # 3 % #" + & " & #" # " " % 17 # %" + # #" ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment " # #" # " # + # " "# 0 # @5 # 3 " #" " % # # # +&# # # & ## & + # " 0 0 # !+ # # " 3 & $ ) $ " 0 " # 2+ # " % % # % " 1!!+ "# # & ) + % # # " # # ) " ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment % " I % # % "% + %#) " # # " # " "# # 7( / # ; < ( 8 )% # '%% )0 . ")@ A &&0 . 0 " 0 544,- /// *3 0 > F " "#" ( # 122 177 / 3 ) ( " " " " 3 " "# +3 " +" " 3 " +" "+" +" # +" +" " # 3 # " + # , 0A + !C".1-$!B,"%' # ># ( $)% ?% 99,- '' *5%+!%! ## + 9<$ # # # $%+!# -' 1"-C'"#F -$!*&1( 1 '! # !!$ 0A46;49% !(!'"'( % -"+!"1#$1-$!*&1(1 '! # !&; ;& !'(11 %!-$!B," . !00 03 ( ! =" @ C".1% . ! +!( -'1 B ' ! (%"#1 #$''#"%! !."(# $ # '! ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment -' 1 -$!*&1(1 '! # ! !(- . !# # $%(1'# 1.!.!'1 &; ;&!"#F # %-"+ C"( -#."!*&1(1 '! # !'"#''"1&!'"& .-$# +% 1"'! % "#F.!# %$&.!!&; ;& !.!$%!".!;1#$1&; ;&!!'( 11 3 # # " #" ##" + # "# " "+ ") "1!2 + % " ( ) ) " ?! " + # 997 % $ #" (/B1 99+ % " #" " % # ? 3 < & " #"< ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment * 4 9292 9@ G : 6 < B 9 <C+ B90?; " # 7 % ##" # 9 3 # #"< 0 84 #<*B?@ 9! # / + #" 7 # #" # # # , 7< 1# #$ !C".1-$!B," ' # >+ + ,- ./ '%% )0 1 )0 20 ?%99,- '' 3% . !04+!(% . !!(-'1B '! (%! '# # . # +("# & ( $ ( ! # + ''%-'1"11 F% "; !( # H" 5 : ; > 9 + #" ) " 1!2 " #"?/ 333 ? ": = + % ( 28% + < "&/ 5 8 ' 5 ;# 9 + " # #" :*"*;127 # : ; < ( &' ; < ,9- '' ; ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment 3 ?99 ?99 # " #" " + $ ") # #" + # " ) " ?99 # : % ( . ( ,9- 5 '' ; + #" " # ?99 < $ % '8 . ( 8 ' ,99- 3 '' *3 > F! ?99 ) F F " " #" % # # # # # F : " ; 3 6 ( / / # ,994- '' 3 > F 3 " # ") ?99 + ?99 3 # " F : " ; 3 % " ) () ( . ; < ( A ; < ,9- 5 '' $ " # > F?93 " #" " # " " .= #" # "F / " # #" # F = 3 " ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment 4 # # F : " ; 3 % 6 ) ( 270 ,55- 88 '' 5* > F73 ?99" # " #" " + # " 5 #" " % ?993 F : " ; 9?3 ##" " " " # # 1!2 9+ F "F % "# ( " " "#" 9@3 "#" $ " < ;< ( &' ;< ,9- '' " % % " # " + # #" #" #" + $# ( " #" " # # " , 70 +- .1!( '! ! ( -# ," # "$ .! + &; ;& ! % ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment 9 (#%( $%+!'!! -' . !1% ''"(! " # $ ! . . ! '# 1 . ! 75 ! . %!"-C'# -' 1"#F!$ 0A69%!+&%!"#F (!"-C'# !$ 0A69% !!# +("## +'1 ) ('&$ '! $ 7<0A&; ;&!,'""#$%!( '&$ '-' 1 ''(. -$! .."!$ ''% ! $ 7<0A ' #$ +! ! = 1 @ -' 1 +!!('&$ '%!-$ ! !&$ ( '( '' '(!('&$ '%!"(. ! $ 7<0A%-$! .."!$''%-"1 (%! ! "- . %+! # .&1((' # ''.%! !& ''%+" + (!( '"1! !# +!'!+! "-C'1 (! # !+ # $"#F ! '( !(!#& "-#'" 78 !#. #'2"'=@(# ')( + ).! &; ;&!"-C'# %-. !1(!. ( !('&$ '!$ 7<0A%!"-'1.!"-C' "#F -$ ! ''% -" ' #$ -'1 ! (" %( ("!('%! ( '!-$%!1. .-# ." B#' ( ! #& # $ &% ' "-2"!!$ 7<77% & #-$B";3% + 050<7<77% B"+!(1 #' % %1 -$! %! !"-C'# -' 1' '!"-$! ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment #& "-#'"!(%!'"1"# &(('(!=" @%-" ! %!' - $ #!(!.! )'1 '(!"-C'# 76 ##! 1 ! -&%! + ##+!''% ' '2"!"-C' # %+!'! # $"#F-$!% !&( !'(7<03 "-2"! '1 !".!! .( # +("# + 79 ( ''.#$ 7//0: +$$ % 710//: '<=< <'<9&;*"4>&!" # > ! <'<9!'&6=# > ! ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.03.10 12:02 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment