Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 136547 (PNJ)
MANN COLD STORAGE v. STATE OF HARYANA THROUGH COLLECTOR KARNAL AND ORS.
RFA/1240/2016 · 2025-10-31
Harkesh Manuja
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 136547 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 136547 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
"
# # # #$ $ $ $
%&&'(# %
%(
%
2 3
4. 7&4'8 .&54.&. * 4'9,94'8 4.&'(45 7&4'8(*:&'
%6 2 3 ; .*(&.
<
=
=
=
=/4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*&
*(&
& *(&
& *(&
& *(&
&
$ $ $ $ %>'4*!%.95*(&/4() *%9&&'*>%!.95*(& %()&*++&,,*'(-,*'./'&% %7)4)&:*.*9!!*%; ???? !0%*,1 !0%*,1 !0%*,1 !0%*,1 4.&()4566'%.&%! * *,, ()& *++&*, )*9& *%4&' '(45*,
*5( *'. @>&(4'
,*/ 6
= ; /*;
+%&&'( *++&*,01! 5)*,, <+*&.7;()&,&*%'&...,4 & & & &
=
=
=
=0A1 0A1 0A1 0A1 &544'# &544'# &544'# &544'#"
"
"
"
<<<<
++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'(
!!!!
&+'.&'( &+'.&'( &+'.&'( &+'.&'(00001111
=0A1
=0A1
=0A1
=0A1
++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ! ! ! !
&+'.&'( &+'.&'( &+'.&'( &+'.&'(00001111
=0A1
=0A1
=0A1
=0A1
++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ++&,,*'( ! ! ! !
&+'.&'( &+'.&'( &+'.&'( &+'.&'(00001111
%;*'*
! A
= >(
566' *5@>44(4'-/* % ()& *:&
7%&94(;!
*5( * *,,&'8& )* 7&&' ,*4. ( ()& /* 4(%45(>.8&!*%'*,0)&%&4'*
(&% 1
1111 *%& /*%. ( *%& /*%. (&%( MOHMED ATIK 2025.11.03 18:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
7&%&
&%%&.*() &5(4'
() 4'(*'5&
()& &')*'5&. 6*%:& 7&'&
4(-4'(&%&( 2"3 %4 *++&,,*'(-,*'./ &)4, *'. 4
DD *'. %&+&5(49&,;
% ,*'.*%&4.&'(4* 23
88 *++&,,*'(-,*'./ >%(94.&%.&% 7F&5(4' >'.&% *++&,,*'(-,*'./ ()&*'.5@>4 ()& D 5( ' 5@>44(4',, D"
()&%
!<!-G+& 2<3
&4' &
&%&'5&>'.&% ()& ,&*%'&. &
& &')*'5&. 56+&
=
=
=
=/4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& ()&B&
&%&'5&>%(C1!/)&%&7;
()& *'. 5@>44(4' 5(! D )& ,*'./'&%01 /* +*%(,; *,,/ %:&( 9*,>& H <-G +&% @ (*+%94.&.>'.&%()& D5( %4&
,; (*(4'8! 4' ()& +%&&'( 5* /'&% 4(>*(&. /4()4' ()& %&9&'> 4(%45( *%'*,! 5*6& ( 7& *5 '. E DD 4>&. >'.&% &5 %()&+>7,45+>%+&'*6&,;
% '(4*,*'.566&%54*,
%&5(% 88%4&9&. *8*4'( ()& *
%&*4 /'&%+%&
&%%&.I<
.&%.*(&.E /)4,&.4%&5(4 .&% &5(4' <G
()& D 5( /'&% .64((&.,;! ()& 7F&5(4' >44(4',,&5(%
,,/&.7;
%& ' =
>7&@>&'(,;! *' ,,&5(%4'&J&%54&
+/&%>'. )&%&7; .&(&%64'4'8 ()& 6*%:&( +&%*5%&7&4.&*/*%.
()&%(* &4'8 .4G*(4
4&. ()&%&
! ()& &%&5(4'
()& D5(!/ &
&%&'5& >%( 94.& 4( */*%. .* +&'*(4' H <-G +&% @ ; & & & & 7;&
&%&'5&&(4(4'01
4,&.>'.
D 0
% )%( B()& D 5(C1 *( ( ,/&. ()&%&7; */*%.4'8 7&'&
4( ;*%. 7&4.& */*%.4'8 (*(>(
5*&01! 5&%(*4' ,*'. /'&. 7; ( '>& &(*(&
94,,*8& *7* *%' *5@>4%&. 94.& (4
45*(4' .*( &5(4' A =
()& D %()&.&9&,+6&'(*'.>(4,4K*(4' *'.<!%7*'(*(&!*%'*, *4. *5@>44(4' +%5&&.4'8! DD!/)45)/*.&54.&.7;( 5(4'8()&%&+'.&'((5'4.&%( 5( 7&&' +%&
&%%&. *( ()& 4'(*'5& ' /&%&.&*,( /4() *'. %&F&5(&. %&)(4
45*(4'>'.&%&5(4'= *' /*%. /* +*&. 7; ()& * >'.&%&5(4'
()& D5( &( 9*,>&
()& *5@>4%&. ,*'. (*(>(%;7&'&
4(-4'(&%&( *++&,,*'(01G,*'./'&%01 4'9: /)45)5*6&(7&+*%(,;*,,/&. .*(&.
<! ()&%&7; 8%*'(4 ;*%. 7&4.& */*%.4'8 *,, () 2
>'.&% *( ()& 4( (>(%; ; ()& *%'*,! .*(&. 5( ' ()& ;()4 &%()& 5& &.7; = *'. 5(' . * :&. &.7; '(4'8 ()&% MOHMED ATIK 2025.11.03 18:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
(*(>(%;7&'&
4( *6&!()&+%&&' 2=3
6+ ()&*++&,,*'(-,*' (()&,*'.
%64 9*,>& (*'. 4'5 .*(&. E
(*(&
*%;*'* (*(&
*%;*'* (*(&
*%;*'* (*(&
*%;*'* 464,*%7&'&
4( 2= 3 I) &+) *K * &+) *K * &+) *K * &+) *K *'. '. '. '.
"
"
"
"L ! ,&*%' >'.&%&5(4'= '& ;&*%
()&
DD!()& @>&(4'/*()> 2E3
' 5'(%9&%( ()& 56+&'*(4'*7 7; ()4 >%( *++&,,*'(()*(()& 23 )* +*+&% 7: *++&,,*'(-,*'./
=
=
=
=/4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& 4(-4'(&%&(4'()&4%
*9>%>'.&%() &'(*++&*,/&%&+%&
&%%&.*(()&4' 6+>8'4'8 ()&*
%&*4. /*%.! ,& ,*'./'&%>764(()*(>'.&%464 %64'8+*%(
()&*6&*5@>44(4' 4'5%&*&. ( E= +&% @ ;* %&'.&%&.4'E *'**'.*'()&% *'**'.*'()&% *'**'.*'()&% *'**'.*'()&%1*'.()>!()&*++ ( )4,& %&
&%%4'8( ()& .&544' %&' '. % 9 9&%'6&'(
*%'* '. % 9 9&%'6&'(
*%'* '. % 9 9&%'6&'(
*%'* '. % 9 9&%'6&'(
*%'* *%'&. &'4% 5>'&, *, >764( =
()& D5(/*4>&.' )& %484'*, '(4
45*(4' >'.&% &5 &&'(4%&*5@>44(4'+%5&&.4'85 ()>!,4*7,&(7&%&(>%'&.(()&,*' ' ()& ()&% )*'.! ,&*%'&. (*(& &
*5(>*, *+&5( /4() %&+&5( *7>(()&*5@>44(4'4')*'.7&* /&9&%! )&&%4>,; ++& ()&*5@>44(4'+%5&&.4'8)*9&,* )*9& )&*%. ,&*%'&. 5>'&,
% 4'. >7(*'5& 4' ()& >76 /'&%
& & & & %()& D5(88%4&9&.*8*4'(( &4'(*'5&
,*'./'&% ! ,&*%'&.&'4%5>'&, %&+&&'(4 64,*%54%5>6(*'5&*'./4()%&+ '*'.()&%&9&'>&&(*(&!()&6*%:
;*%. 7; ()4 >%( 94.& F>.86& DDD0%4F)*'*'.*'()&% %4F)*'*'.*'()&% %4F)*'*'.*'()&% %4F)*'*'.*'()&% ++&,,*'(-,*'./'&%4&'(4(,&.
%( %&'.&%&. 4' 5*&
&%'*%. %*'5 &%'*%. %*'5 &%'*%. %*'5 &%'*%. %*'5 *%'*(*:* *'. %! *%'*(*:* *'. %! *%'*(*:* *'. %! *%'*(*:* *'. %! %&+%(&. * M
64( ()*( '5& ()&
%&) '(4
45*(4 '=
*'.()>/*7&;
&5(4'
()& D 5( 4>&. 5'&@>&'(,;,*+&.*'.()&,*'. ,*'./'&% (*(& 5>'&, )* '( 7&&' *7,& 5( ( ()&
4'*, .&(&%64'*(4' &*( E=-G+&%@;*%.8%*'( & ()& +%*;&% 6*.& ' 7&)*,
( &,*+&. % ()& +*%(4& *'. 8'& ()%>8) ( 644' 6*.& ' 7&)*,
( 3
(()& '(4'8 +&5( *%:&( 6&'( &%9 &%9 &%9 &%9 %()& %*'54 %*'54 %*'54 %*'54
<
<
<
< *(4' ;'. &. ' '.4' ,& ( ' *'(&. ()& ) ()& ()& MOHMED ATIK 2025.11.03 18:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
2D3
% *55>'(
.&,*; D5(4>&. 5*''(7&.&*,(/ ( +%&
&% 494, %(45,&
=
() 2 3 I4 *%&.4+&. +*%(4&()*(()&6 ()4 >%(4'
*%;*'**'.*' *%;*'**'.*' *%;*'**'.*' *%;*'**'.*' 4'
*9>%
()& &'(4(,&.
% */* +%944'
()& &'(4(,&.
%,*(4 2 3 ,,
5(7&% 5(7&% 5(7&% 5(7&%"
"
"
" !!!!
<
<
<
< (4: I)& I)&
=
=
=
=/4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& /4()()&%5''&5(&.5*& %&8*%.()&+,&*
*5@>44(4'+ ,*;&..&5,*%*(4'
(4
45*(4'- &.'=
!4(4+&%(4'&'(( ,(/4()4'()&+%&&'(*++&*,*'.() 4, I%4( &(4(4' 5)*,,&'84'8 ()& ()&'(4(>(4'
'.4*
I4()%&+&5((()&.&(&%64'*(4' 4'94&/
()&(*'.(*:&'7; &6*((&%459&%&./4()()&F>.86 E
DDD E
DDD E
DDD E
DDD (4(,&. B%4F %4F %4F %4F *'()&% *'()&% *'()&% *'()&%C*'.()&*6&4()>*& ()& *++&,,*'(-,*'./'&% ' *..4( /*%.
*,, (*(>(%; 7&'&
4( *' ()& D5(0*6&'.&.>+((.
,*(4>6H"N7&4.&*/*%.
4'( ,,+&'.4'8*++,45*(4'01!4
*';!)
0 0 0 0
<
<
<
<
)&()&%+&*:4'8-%&*'&. &- )&()&%%&+%(*7,&
&- & & & & '+%5&&.4'8)*94'87&&',*+&. '->7,45*(4'>'.&%&5(4'=
( ((6&'(4')&%&()*(()&*4.4 ()&*++&,,*'(!4
*(*,,*88%4&9&./ & *4. (4
45*(4' )*94'8 4'9: '
6*%:&(9*,>&!()&+%&&'(*++& ; ()&5>'&, %&+%&&'(4'8 7()( 86&'(.*(&. E
%&'.&%&.
%4F )*' *'. *'()&%9 (*(& %4F )*' *'. *'()&%9 (*(& %4F )*' *'. *'()&%9 (*(& %4F )*' *'. *'()&%9 (*(& &&.H E=-G+&%@>*%&;* .4(4'! ()& ,*'./'&% )*,, *, *'. 4'(&%&( * +%94.&. >'.&% ( .*(&1)&,*'./'&%)*,,*, 4'(&%&(()&%&>+'*/&,, !)*,,*,(*'..4+&. 1 1 1 1
&- &- 4
&.' ()& 4>& ./* :&. +&*, )()& &.7; (*(& (*(& (*(& (*(& ;*%. 7& % ()& 7& MOHMED ATIK 2025.11.03 18:01 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment