- 1 - ! " #$% &$ # ' '()* ')) & ! " # $ #%$ ! " # $ &' # & $ !! (( !(#$ '() )! ! Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !&#($ ** # $ % + + , % --./01 2!& 34 5360 2!! (( 5073/80501 9: 37;52.41/2<3-0 8=8324047=<.5.38:>258;02>>04-0/ ?.43/;=9<0 .4105 0-8324/ !( ' ( ) )! 50=1@38; 0-8324!'2>=41 0-8324!&#!$5@ 0-8324 !&#($ 2> 8;0 50A048324 2> 255.?8324 -8 !' ?041347 90>250 8;0 2.58 2> ** 1138324=< 38: 3A3< =41 0//324/ .170=41 ?0-3=<.170#-8$047=<.5.3/90>2508;3/ 2.58 .4105 0-8324 & 2> ;=5=83:= =7=53B= .5=B/;= =4;38=((&/00B347507.<=59=3< ( 0=518;0<0=5401-2.4/0<>258;0?=5830/ & 3453602!! ((@=/5073/805019: 37; 52.41/ 2<3-0 8=8324 047=<.5. 34383=<<: >25 8;0 2>>04-0/ - 3 - ?.43/;=9<0.4105 0-8324/!''() =41)! 2>=7=34/8=4360B;=<=3=4128;05/248;09=/3/2>8;0 >35/8 34>256=8324 1=801 ( (( 50-03A01 >526 53 =C=/;0B;=5 0405=< =4=705 2> =54=8=B= =;=5/;3 =<6343 -;01.<015390/0A0<2?604825?25=8324#>25/;258 D25?25=8324E$ .5347 8;0 -2.5/0 2> 34A0/837=8324 /260 2> 8;0=--./01?05/24/348;0/=31-=/0@050=550/801=41=>805 -26?<08347 8;0 34A0/837=8324 8;0 -;=570/;008 @=/ >3<01 =/ =7=34/8!(?05/24/>258;0=>250/=312>>04-0/;0?083832405 ;05034=41=428;05@050=550/801=>805>3<3472>8;0-;=570 /;008 1.5347 8;0 -2.5/0 2> >.58;05 34A0/837=8324 34 8;0 ?50/048-=/09:8;04A0/837=8347>>3-05;0?083832405@;2 @=/=550/80124&!(((@=/=55=:01=/=--./012!& =41/.9/0F.048<:506=4101828;0C.13-3=<-./821: 3/9=3< =??<3-=8324 >3<01 90>250 8;0 853=< 2.58 34 5< 3/- 2!!&((@=/50C0-80124(!(((;050>250;03/ 90>2508;3/2.58 0=5401 -2.4/0< >25 8;0 ?083832405 /.9638/ 8;=8 8;0 ?083832405 ;=/ 42 28;05 -53634=< =480-01048/ ;0 =<<07=8324=7=34/88;0?083832405=41=--./012!@;2@=/ - 4 - =</2=550/8011.53478;0-2.5/02>8;0>.58;0534A0/837=83243/ /363<=5--./012!;=/900475=4801507.<=59=3<9:8;0 853=< 2.58 ;0 ?083832405 3/ 50=1: =41 @3<<347 82 -22?05=80 @38;8;0?2<3-0>258;0?.5?2/02>34A0/837=8324=41;0/;=<< >.543/; 8;0 ?=583-.<=5/ 2> 8;0 ?05/24/ 82 @;26 8;0 =62.48 @=/85=4/>05501>526;3/=4B=--2.48828;04A0/837=8347 >>3-05 03/=</250=1:=41@3<<3478285=4/>058;0=62.482> /&(!(&) @;3-; 3/ =A=3<=9<0 34 ;3/ =4B =--2.48 6=348=3401 34 =4B 6=5?08 5=4-; :105=9=1 @;3-;3/42@>500G01 05-2485=<0=5401 ?0-3=<.9<3-52/0-.825@;2 ;=/ 2??2/01 8;0 9=3< =??<3-=8324 /.9638/ 8;=8 8;2.7; 8;0 =<<07=8324=/=7=34/88;0=--./012/!&=41!=50/363<=5 8;0 =62.48 @;3-; @=/ 85=4/>05501 82 8;0 =4B --2.48 2> 8;0?083832405;05034>5268;0=4B=--2.482>=--./012& ;=/ 428 9004 50-2A0501 34 0483508: >25 8;0 50=/248;=88;0 ?083832405 ;=/ 428 -22?05=801 @38; 8;0 ?2<3-0 1.5347 8;0 -2.5/02>34A0/837=832483/24<:>258;0/=3150=/248;0853=< 2.58;=/50C0-801;3/9=3<=??<3-=83248;2.7;38;=/75=4801 - 5 - 507.<=5 9=3< 82 =--./01 2! --251347<: ;0 ?5=:/ 82 13/63//8;0?0838324 ;0 =<<07=8324 34 8;0 -;=570/;008 @;3-; 3/ >3<01 =/ =7=34/8 8;0 =--./01 2/! 82 !( 34 8;0 ?50/048 -=/0 3/ 8;=8=--./012/!=41(;=12?0401! >3-83832./=--2.48/ 348;035/834=4-025?25=8324 2-308:3638012>@;3-;8;0 =--./012&3/;=356=4=41;.70=62.4890<247347828;0 -25?25=8324@;3-;@=/34>3H0110?2/38348;0 4324=4B2> 413=2=15=4-;047=<.5.@=/85=4/>05501828;0/0 ! >3-83832./=--2.48/83/>.58;05=<<07018;=88;0=62.48/ >526 8;0 ! >3-83832./ =--2.48/ 2?0401 34 8;0 35/8 34=4-0 25?25=8324 2-308:<363801@=/85=4/>0550182A=532./28;05 =--./01?05/24/34-<.13478;0?083832405;05034=41>5268;0 =--2.48 2> 8;0 ?083832405 ;05034 ;0 ;=1 85=4/>05501 8;0 =62.4850-03A0134;3/=4B=--2.488228;05=--2.48/=/ ?058;034/85.-8324/2>=--./012/!82&83/8;0-=/02> 8;0?52/0-.83248;=8>258;0/=31?.5?2/08;0?083832405;=1 50-03A01;.70=62.48=/-2663//324>526=--./012/!82 &;0<0=5401 ?0-3=<.9<3-52/0-.825=//.96388018;=8 8;2.7; = 828=< /.6 2> / ! @=/ 85=4/>05501 82 - 6 - 8;0=--2.482>8;0?08383240524<:=/.62>/&)!) ;=/900450-2A050183<<1=80--251347828;0?0838324058;0 =62.48 50-03A01 9: ;36 ;=/ 9004 85=4/>05501 82 28;05 =--2.48/ =/ ?05 8;0 34/85.-8324/ 2> =--./01 2/! 82 & =41 8;0/=31/.963//324;=/4289004 /0532./<:13/?.8019:8;0 <0=5401 ?0-3=< .9<3- 52/0-.825 0=5401 -2.4/0< >25 8;0 ?083832405;=/.41058=B048273A08;0?=583-.<=5/2>8;0/=31 =--2.48/ 82 @;26 ;0 ;=1 85=4/>05501 8;0 =62.48 >526 ;3/=4B=--2.48/2=/8204=9<08;04A0/837=8347>>3-0582 50-2A05 8;0 =62.48 85=4/>05501 >526 ;3/ =4B =--2.48 0 ;=/ =</2 .41058=B04 82 85=4/>05 8;0 =62.48 2> /&(!(&) @;3-; 3/ =A=3<=9<0 34 ;3/ =4B =--2.48 =/ /8=801 =92A0 413/?.801<: ;0 ;=/ 42 28;05 -53634=< =480-01048/ --./01 2! ;=/ 9004 =<50=1: 04<=5701 24 9=3<9:8;0<0=5401 0//324/.170 41058;0-35-.6/8=4-0/ =62>8;02?343248;=88;0?5=:056=109:8;0?083832405 >2575=482>507.<=59=3<4001/8290=4/@0501=>>356=83A0<: /.9C0-882=??52?53=80-24138324/--251347<:8;0>2<<2@347 25105+ - 7 - ;0?08383243/=<<2@01 ;0 ?083832405 3/ 1350-801 82 90 04<=5701 24 9=3< 34 5360 2!! ((2> 37;52.41/2<3-0 8=8324047=<.5.-38: 5073/80501>258;02>>04-0/?.43/;=9<0.4105 0-8324/!( ' ( ) )! 50=1 @38; 0-8324 !' 2> =41 0-8324 !&#!$ 5@ 0-8324 !&#($ 2> 8;0 50A048324 2> 255.?8324 -8 !' 24 8;0 >3<0 2> 8;0 2.58 2> ** 1138324=< 38: 3A3< =41 0//324/ .170 =41 ?0-3=< .170 #-8$047=<.5./.9C0-8828;0>2<<2@347-24138324/+ =$;0 ?083832405 /;=<< 0H0-.80 ?05/24=< 9241 >25 = /.6 2> /( @38; 8@2 /.50830/ >25 8;0 <3B0/.6 82 8;0 /=83/>=-8324 2> 8;0 C.53/13-8324=< 2.58I 9$;0 ?083832405 /;=<< =??0=5 507.<=5<: 24 =<< 8;0 1=80/2>;0=534790>2508;053=<2.58.4<0//8;0 53=< 2.58 0H06?8/ ;3/ =??0=5=4-0 >25 A=<31 50=/24/I -$ ;0 ?083832405 /;=<< 428 1350-8<: 25 341350-8<: 8;50=804258=6?05@38;8;0?52/0-.8324@3840//0/I 1$ ;0?083832405/;=<<42834A2<A034/363<=52>>04-0/ 34>.8.50I - 8 - 0$ ;0?083832405/;=<<428<0=A08;0C.53/13-83242>8;0 53=< 2.58 @38;2.8 ?0563//324 2> 8;0 /=31 2.58 .483< 8;0 -=/0 5073/80501 =7=34/8 ;36 3/ 13/?2/01 2>> >$ 4 8;0 0A048 ?083832405 A32<=80/ =4:240 2> 8;0 9=3< -24138324/ ?52/0-.8324 3/ =8 <39058: 82 /00B -=4-0<<=83242>8;09=3< +*, '% &$ ) $ 3/82+!' <2+' +