Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 13003 (PNJ)
DLF CITY RESIDENTS WELFARE ASSOCIATION AND ANOTHER v. STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
CWP/1528/2021 · 2025-02-13
Sureshwar Thakur, Vikas Suri
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 13003 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 13003 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!! "# $%& '($')%( '"#*' *(($*%$) *) *)%+' !! ,- (%*%' # +*&)* *) %+'( . "# ,$' !! ,- (%*%' # +*&)* *) %+'( . */- 01
*2! 345!6 ( * 7!4
'8!9 :-.6 *
4 .!! ! * 44!006 ( * 7!4
*5 (4-6 *
; 4<6 *
4 .!! ! *<- !86 *8 *:6 +1 7!4
(8 3786 *8 *:6 +16
446 ( *:6 +16
(-04 /6 *:6 +16
:- =86 *:6 +1
; 3!86 **:6 +1
! (!/4 4-46 * 7!4
.< (04786 *
. )+(, ! ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.13 18:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
. )+(, ! *! (46 *
*!-4 846 *
. ) ! . ( !6 ( * 7!4
;-8 76
,!.-8 (42
4!< 46 *
. ) ! . )> ! <5 3!6 ( * 7!4
!4 ;-26
( 4! =475
!1 (-!6 *
. )? @
..8! . ) ! >> ! AAAA
(! 22 B-! 87 ! !8 ! 04 4 7! .!!6 401 04 4 7! .!! 208
0 2 ! 4-/4
22 ! 2 4 !"#$!%&!'() !%#*"#!#$!+%,
-./01-020. %4-/4 4 ! 7! .!!6 4 .!! 4 .1
!-
7! ! 4 -
22- ! !/ 4 ! !8 . < ...! ! ! -4
4 * ! %< . > *C- 6
> *C-
4 2
*C- ? . 01 . )?!! %7 8 ' 26 74016
<!/
4 --4!9 - ! ! "# !16 :--/26 ! ! 8!6 4- 226 4 4 -.! !! !- .D 7 74 4 ! --4!9 - ! 0- 0 88
-46 !2!8
0 /! ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.13 18:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
/! 4 0 ! . -4 4 8 ! !16 7
7/ ! - 4 . 0 ! * -4 7! ! 4 -
22- 7 .1
! !/ 4 ! !8 . < ...! !6 ! 8-!/ 4 28D 28!! 4 !88/8
--4!9 - ! ! 4 2
! 1 0-!8!/D- - ! "# !16 :--/2 ? %4 . .!! ! 0!/ !8 01 !!* !!6 !!/ 4 !-
!88/8 - ! ! - :--/2
. !881 ! "# 4 $
, %4 .4/.4 .. 7!4 4 .!! 881 2 4 4 ! 8/ !8! 4 ..-8!D !1 2 . !0 01 4 (
+1
8 4 2
!!
4
"1- 8D 0-!8!/ .8 ..8D 01 87
4 -1 .!! 4
8 0 2 0881 /
%4 --4! - ! .!2!81 2!/ -. ! !- 8! 8!6 . !881 ! 4
2.!!/ '( ' 2! < ( ! #8D 8 %4 882
#8D 8
' 2! 881 < ( ! ! 2 - 4 .8! ! 2
4 . 08/!/
4 '( /1 %4 --4! - ! 7!4! 4 '( #8D 8
2.881 1!/ 4 1 05
! - 4 8826 4 !/!8 .8!/
4
1 -0 .8!/ $ ! 4 4 ! !8 . .2!!/ - 4 !!1 74! 4 ! 81 ! !8! 4 87
01 87 0- ! 8
C 0-
4 !- -
! .2!!/ 0 < ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.13 18:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
! 21 --4! . -!!/ 4 0! 05
! .8 8.2
!/ - 4 !- 8.2 87 .!/ 7!4! 4 ( 2816 +1 8.2
/-8! E0 * * 6 >@ 4! F4 *
>@G
>@ -8 2 4-H 4 -50 ( 4-8
88 * ! ! E/-8 8.2 * 6 >
> -8 2 4-
8 4 +1 *.2 74!. * 6 >
4 -8 2 4-
%4 ! 7 -81 0-/4
4 ! 4 ! !8 . ! 2.8! *C-
$ . 4 0 ! 2.8!6
B-!1 7 - 01 4 ! !8 .6 74! 4 -82! ! 4 * ! %< . > *C-
* .-8
4 ! . 7-8 47 4
- !/
.!21 -1
"# 4 $$$6 ! 7 ! ! 88!/ 4 -.! !! ! /
4 ..!6 -. 74! 4 --4!9 - ! 7 0!/ ! @ #-46 ! 7 8 22 4 !2!8
0 /! /! 4 !8 .!08
4 ! - ! * -4 .-8
4 ! . 7-8 47 4
28!! ! 7 ! - ! . 81 7 ..! !88/8 0!8 %7 !
"# 4 $$$6 :--/26 ! !/
4
4 ! 8!1 4 7 2 4 4- 0-!8!/ -. 74! 4 --4!9 - - 4 0 ! 4 4 2 8
0 28!4 $ !7
4 06 4 ! !8 ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.13 18:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
. -/4
4 !!! 4 !8! 4-/4- 4
4-8 !/81 4 ! -
C! 28!! ! . /! 4 ! --4!9 - ! *
8. 4 246 4 * ! %< . > *C-
7 !- 01 4 ! !8 . * .-8
4 2 7-8 47 4
4
8. -0!8 !26 4-
! 7 < 01 4 ! !8 . ! 4
4 8! *%
> *C-
7 !6 74! 4 8 4 -8 .. 4 . 01 4 ! !8 . B- 4 /! ! ! 4 0 ! 2.8! $ 6 .! 4!/ -<
< 8 ! ! 8-!/ /!! #$6 !-
47 - ! - 4 *
>@6 88! -.! !! 6 ! ! '8 ! !16
(7/ ! 6 4 ! !8 . 4 !88
!8
< 1 -0!8 . 1 - 4 ! ! ' ! 4 .!/
4 0 ! *%
>
>6 4 !! )* !! ! 220 4 0 -!/ 2 .!88
. 4 ! 4 ! !8 . ! B-! 744 1 ! 4 0 < 01 4 ! !8 . ! -4
4 0 2! *% > +76 4 ! !8 . 4
4 . 2 4
16 0 !881 881!/ 4 2
.C
4 4
4 0 /!!/ 8 -
4 .!! #!881 2
4 220
4 !! )* !! 4
? !! 4 ! ! !8 . B-! 0- 4 ! .. 0 < ! -4
4 ! *% +76 4 ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.13 18:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
220
4 !! )* !! 7 4! !2 /! 881 !!
01 4 ! !8 . 4 4!/
0
! 4! 2 %4 ! 4 .2. 4 .!! .. 4 4! +!/4 - 7!4 4 /! !8 ! 4 . 7! .!! $ . 4 2.8! 6
2
*C- ? 7 !- 01 4 ! % ' 2
% 8!/ 0!/ 4! 4 !- .1 7 ! "# 4 $$$ :--/2 46 0 !!/ --4!9 - ! 01 4 .2!!08 9!/ 8!2!6 ! 4! . ! ..! -4 4 2
4 !!8 ..! 7 8 0!/ !88/881 -
22 !8 .-. $ !7
4 06 ! 7 ! 8! 22 4 4 -.! !! 4 ! ..! 21 !22!81 0 <
4 ...! ! 0 < - *
>@ --
4 0 ! 2
6 2 4 7 1 4 8.6 47
-0!8 . 4 0 < 01 4 ! !8 . . !881 % 8!/
1 - 4 22! % ' 2
E 4 0 ! -2 6 ! ! 2.81 8 4
.7-8 8001
! /-.D8 2!6
-!!/ 4 1 0! 4
4
8. 81 ! ! ! 7!4 4 8 8 2!!!D ! !8 . 4
81 0 - 4 -4!! 4 -
08! 1
.2!!/ - 4 !88/8
--4! - ! D !88/8 8.2H 74! 4
2!/ -. 82!/
!/4 - 4! (!88 -46 4 !88/8
--4! - ! D8.2
8 ! 8 !8! 4 I!/ ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.13 18:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
86 =-!8!/ =1
"76 D =-!8!/ =1
"76 @D +1 =-!8!/
! - 4 4.49
-.8 8.2 ! .. ! 7!88 8
8
88. !- -
:--/2 ! 8-!/ 0-
8!2! .08 !<!/ 76 7/6 ! B-8!16 .6 8 ! !16 4 22 !- -
4 !8!! 2!! * . 4 1.! -02! 01 4 8 ( -86 !8 !.- 4 0 .! 4! - * .-8
4 1.!6 8 4 4
8
1. !8!6 74! 4
!8 4!
! 0-8 2 ! 22 !8 - ! !!8 D.8 0 - ! 01 .2!!08 #*D*!!8 8
- ! 01 .2!!08 #* J 22 !8 - ! !!8 D .8 %4 0 !8! 2.-08 ! - !! %4 !8! $ :8 /1 .8
'( /1 .8
- * !+!#3#!4)
3"
! "#$ %#
"# # ! % %%$ !%
" !%
"$ %
%"& !! $$ &$ '' ! & # % %
"" !&
! &$ #" % $
ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.13 18:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
= '( /1 8
(
)
& %# % # #
%& # %%$' & # %' %! ! %!% % %$
!! )-
!8! 2.-08 ! -
! '( /1 .8
0 < 4 0 8 - E.
1 0-!8!/ 4 0 ! %4 ! 1.! 8 8 4 ! < 01 4 -4!! /! 4 !86 !2- 4 6 ! - ( ! 4 *
>@ 4!/ 0 !-6 0! ! ! ! - ( ! 4 *
>@4!/ 8 0 . %4 ! < !8
2! 4! ! 0-8 2
*
+ ,-
. , *
/0 +
1/ 2 3 45, & %# %#
6 %' 7 ! %$ %$
6 1/ 2 33 45, # # #
6
"# 7 %%$ &! ##
6 1/ 2 333 45, %& %%$' %%&! 6 !# 7 %"& #% &
6 ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.13 18:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
1/ 2 3 45, # %$ %! 6 % 7 # &
6 1/ 8
45, %!% %$ ## '& #
$ 9 +. ? %4 ! 7!4 4 -4!!6 4-
< .2. ! /! 4 !86 6 ! 8! ! .! . !! 5-!! !8 0 0 2!/
- ( ! 4 *
>@6 .!! 74 0 2 C 4!6 1 4 8 !!8 - !!/ 4 !!8 -! 6 6 8 2 4! 881
.- !81 1!/ 4 .!
4
. 01 4
2. -1 -4!! %4 ! !8 !!8 -! 0 47!4 8 0-
..-!1
4!/
88
!816 4 ! !!8 -! 0 47!4 8
..-!1
4!/ 0!/ /
88 6 0- 7!4! 7 24 2 1
%4 !!8 - 6 74
!!/ 4 !!8 -! B- 4 -05 26 ! . 746 4 ! -1 5-!! !8 0 -.6 4-
! 6
!!/ 88 4 05 ! /! 4 2!!0!8!1
- 4 !8 !!8 -!6
! ..! .8!2!1 !-6
! 4 ! - < .8!2!1 !- 7!4! 7 24 2 1 ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.13 18:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
@ * . 4 .81 -02! 048
. )
"#6 4 !88/8 - !6 ! 16 4 0
01 4 !!!-8 88 6
742 4
"#6 4-
8
8. 0-
8.!/ 4 ! ! "# 4 $
,6 4 4 2 4 ..! 882 %46
4! /6 !! 4
"#
!0-! 0 2 4
! !!/ .-.81 --4!9 - !6 B- 4 ! .-.81 --4!9 ! - ! 0 2!/ 4
4 !!!-8 88
$ !7
4 06 4! - . 22- -. 4 . 6
! . 4 0-8 /! -.6 4- 7 .2. ! 8- 4 ! <!/ 0- 7!4! 7 24 2 1 %4 ! 0 1
!! 0 !8 0 4! -6
> ? > !. !/81 7!4 4 ! 0! %4 2! 88- ..8! !6 ! 16 !D6 8 !. 5
6
.720020/ 5 6 3!"
! !"8!#$(+49!#"+!:- !"9 ! !!8#&3! !"9 ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.13 18:05 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment