Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2025 DAILYLAW 128592 (PNJ)

RAMESH KUMAR AND OTHERS v. STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER

CWP/14356/2019 · 2025-12-02

Sandeep Moudgil

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

! "#$%&'()&*&)+&#,' -!! ! "#$%&'(.),',"'/&#,' !! ! "#$%&'(".0,1#&#,' !! ! 2&(2&),.&)1(3+&,)4"005"#$%&'( "00 ! &0163'.),',"'/&%&'(,44"005"#$%&'(1'#)&1*,'*7341'6 8 9:;! < ;<;;: **** !" !# # $ <1'#&&.,"#$307 ! %&' () "* +! ",--. * / 0 " 1 0&2&--3&4% 5 &.'+", +)" "+ 0 6 ", 0 7+ *,8" 8 "" *,8" 86 % ",0'!" ,&994 ) , %" "' !-:39&99; % 5 .',0,,"1 ,+<&;= %-' 7" , +" + ! + + 8"," !0!0!"" %" "' V VISHAL SHONKAR 2025.12.03 18:34 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document CWP-14356-2019 - 2 - -:39&99; 0 8,+ ,>%-' )+*!,!"%08 (' ,&9.&%&9.& ,',,,0," ,!") " ,+0,"+, 1 "",0+," 0 8( 6 ", 0 *, " %:' * , ,,0, +, 0 +1 !"+* "!,393.&999+"0",, +!*", +0 ,,!,","!" *"!" ?+",00+"0, %2' / 0+ ",!"0!" ""0,0!" ,, ,,0, ! ) 0 +1 , " " )"0 ? , , ", &2&--3&4 % 5 &.'/ 0 , ) " ,, 8 ? ,0, " -2&3-3&; % 5 &4' !, ", 80 "","+ %>' , " , + " V VISHAL SHONKAR 2025.12.03 18:34 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document CWP-14356-2019 - 3 - + ", 0! + @ *, #!, #%$ 8*'!" ,&994%&994 ,' ! ,"&9.& , 5A ,4, B; &994 , , 1 ," 5" 8" 8 "" 8*86 1 ? 5" 6 ", 0C 7+ ! D 5" 8( *,8" 8 8" 8 "" *,8" 86 ",0 %.' / +0 6 ", 0 0 + !" ," A&23.&992#,!" , +" ,0+, % 0' &:3.&99. " *1 , ", B&-"!0,)"+ !&2&--3&4% 5 8&.', B:;!", %4' ," , %;' 0 &2&--3&4 % 5 &.' 8# !0) 6 ",0&>3.&992",1 5" +&23.&99.""" #,!" ,&994/") 8 " , , ", 1 ! ? 5" &99; A "," , V VISHAL SHONKAR 2025.12.03 18:34 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document CWP-14356-2019 - 4 - 8#0 +",0+, %9' /"," , !, , >%-' &9.& , ","+,( ,0 , 08*!,!" 0",",, !"+0 " , > &9.& , , 6 ", 0 8 ( 8 ! " " # $% " # & # !# "" " # ' $ $ ! " " ! " " " ( %&3' ( +! ! , ! 6 ",08*,,,+,0+, +)"1 ,"#,"+ 8 "0!88 V VISHAL SHONKAR 2025.12.03 18:34 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document CWP-14356-2019 - 5 - ! *, ,, + + " 00*,"+(, )0,0+,!8E8! + , 8 <)! ,! 1%& ,*( 1(&,4 ,3'3'$ ;03$3=303(6 4,) .),%,(3,' 1* **3*(1'( & 6",0 &23.&992 &:3.&99. - %B&' &.3:&99: &>3:&99; : A,%B-' &33>&99: 393>&99; 2 %B:' *, --3;&99& -&3;&99. > #! %B2' *, 3-34&99- 3&34&994 . B%B>' *, &&&&&99& &&&&&99. 4 %B.' *, 3934&99- 3;34&994 ; %B4' &:3>&99: &-3>&99; 9 7,%B;' *, -43.&99- -.3.&994 %&&' ( , 9 &994 , "+ " !" " /"0 ,,+"+ *, %0'%' , ,9%'&994 , 8 # # ## " # )" ! * # ! # ! +( %&-' " +"+ 0"!" ,&&&994 ,! +!"+,0 " !" !" ",,+,""0 + " 5" V VISHAL SHONKAR 2025.12.03 18:34 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document CWP-14356-2019 - 6 - 0", 0! +(!," " ", 0 *,C8"" "," ,&& &994 , %&:' # 5" , *, 8( %"" , -;3--3&- 3&3&-3&3' 6 ", 0%"" ,:334&999', 8,+0+00", !,,0+,, %&2' ( 0 , +1 , 0,0 00 * * "!,393.&999% 5 ;'* "",0* "" ,0 !" 0 "! ! " 3;34&999 % 5 9' ( ! , " , -.3>-339 ,0 00!, ,,0) "" ,, )"+&2&--3&4 %&>' F ! "" !, 3932-3&> * " ? 0 , >%-' &9.& , " , + ) 0" 0 ?, V VISHAL SHONKAR 2025.12.03 18:34 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document CWP-14356-2019 - 7 - %&.' /,0,0*" !,2>&94:% 5 >' "," " ""! 0 , >%-' &9.& , , " 0 ,0 "6 ",0 0,8 *, ( "" , , , 0,," ,+) ) +" + , ( ,! "," ! , 323>&94: % 5 >' 8 ' "$ , -$ -$ $ "$,. ' " ! " " % ! " " " % # / ! "$ G,H %&4' ( $! "0I , " ",", 0 8 !8E8! *, V VISHAL SHONKAR 2025.12.03 18:34 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document CWP-14356-2019 - 8 - 0 ,+,!! 8 6 ", 0 0 8!8E8!*, ,++ 8C6 ",0"!, %&;' / ", ", " +" ,0+, "+"6 ", 0 ! " C*, @ ,, " " + !,88+" ,0!",,1 ," %&9' (),C*,+" ,0+,,0,)",6 ", 0 ( ! ! !, 0 " , "+0 ,0+, ,,,/? ,",1 ,0!"+" " , %-3' (" ,0 5,", ,>%-' &9.& , ,&&&994 ,(+" ",,0 "+ ", ,) ,+0,43" ,0 ,+ ,+*" , "0 , + ",0 + $! , ! , 393.&999 % 5 ;'3932-3&>% 5 &>'" ,"," V VISHAL SHONKAR 2025.12.03 18:34 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document CWP-14356-2019 - 9 - +*""",, ++!" ,!" %-&' A , >%-' &9.& , , && &994 , +,0 8# + " ,0 !" , ,0+, A0 0,0 " ,00, ,0" %--' ""0, ,, &2&--3&4 % 5 &.' + +0 " "," , 323>&94: % 5 >' + * "(""", 0 !0 , "" , +$!"!" ) ,0 ,, "1 , + / ",,+,,0< " """ %-:' ""0, !! , <1'#&&.,"#$30 "#$& 1. Whether speaking/reasoned? : Yes/No 2. Whether reportable? : Yes/No V VISHAL SHONKAR 2025.12.03 18:34 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document