Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 128441 (PNJ)
MS DUA METALS v. UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS
CWP/32302/2025 · 2025-11-19
Lisa Gill, Parmod Goyal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 128441 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 128441 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
1
!"!#$
%&'( ) *
+,- +.-
/("0"
-
+$
1. +-2 - .- .. 1. +2 - + . .- ..* 2
! "#$
% #&' (
)
*'()+ ,-,./,/. % " 0 (
# #&
#
12(
0/,!3
# 0/,!3 /
)
4% % 5 RITU SHARMA 2025.11.28 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
2
67 125
0 /,!3*
/,!3+ $ ($$ 8
# $ #& 0 9 '() # $ 0
# $ :; <
)
%
4 %##$ $ # =
)
#$ #
# 0/,!3* >?9+
,-,./,/. @/% $ #
# ( A
"
0
($*(A"(+#&
"0(
*"(+ ' (
)
*'()+ 12B
/,!3 % #
$ '() 0 5="
$ 8#&"(0"(
# '() " #$ #
9'()%
# $
"(
# $
% $ "(
# % %
#$ #
) #$% $C $ 12/,!3
"(%# $0 '() RITU SHARMA 2025.11.28 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
3
. )
D (
!"# E D ( $ %& '
'
'
& %
( " ) *+"# ,
- ' ' .& . ' . '
-' "* *+*#
, / /
- ( %
%
'0( "**
*)"#$
ED( ,
- ' , / /
- (
* + % # $$ %&'
'1 * +#
% )*+ @,!==-<B/,/. ,!33/<B/,/. # $
# D9# $ ( !3,./,/. ,-,3/,/. )
#$D( ,=!!/,/.(75/<23.5/,/. % %&#ED( $ %&'
' 3"04(5* ,
- '
' 3"04(+
, / /
- (
* + % #$
4 %#
,=!!/,/. (75/<23.5/,/.*+," -67& -0#8( -(!4" %("0" #!# #8! #8 6("+"
% #% 2
)
% #
4 E $B $ ,=!!/,/. 9: 3+," -67& -0#8( -(!4" %("0" #!# #8! #8 6("5
$ RITU SHARMA 2025.11.28 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
4
3
7 % # 1
"$
% /,!3 "
@ *"@ ,<F32/<!G+)
% #
'() % #&
,-,./,/. $ ,!,!/,/./3!,/,/.@#
$ '()
0 5= -
,=!!/,/. +," -67& -0#8( -(!4"* +%
$ D( -&7 ;;7"*ED( $ %& '
' * +< ,
- '
' 3"04(+ , / /
- (
* + 2 0
3
%( %
"%%4
#!D( A$# D ( /5 ( .& %
0(+*
"!)% (D( $ ,(5 (
% /06%(-( %%4
%
"+""
#
D( 2 / .
' 7( *%%4
**""#
D( -&-5 & %0( "%%4
+8+9% H% 0
# D ( E A$# # ,=!!/,/. 5 RITU SHARMA 2025.11.28 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
5
6!< " #
8 "( # # D(
$
1 * + $ "(8
'() #
'() 0 % 125 /,!3
D(
1 * +
5 6/1 12( $% ($$ #
8
# #
0 #
# #
0 ##
# % 125&
# " $0
# #& % @ " 0
% # #& 125
#
%
# % % /-C 12*!+(
/,!3 % 12 #0
#($$
# $*#% &($$ +I % #0
%$ +(
0
## +($$
#$ #
# #+ # # % RITU SHARMA 2025.11.28 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
6
<, " # & 12J 12 5+E%
# $ #
=- $ $ #+
# $4$$
# # <! 12*!+( /,!3#
% %
4 #
& % 4
12& </ " %
#
12
& 4 #$05# <<C $
& 12 (
0
# # I
# $
# *
# #
% +
<=
% *+(
0# *+
# % 12#& <. I 12 % $&
# $ % %
# $ $
$
# " # $
# $ % $ $ 0 $
# RITU SHARMA 2025.11.28 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
7
*3<3=(+
#
12 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 0000 =!
"
$ 4 % 4 #& %
0# 4 $#
0 $
#$ #
# D
$ 4 $
D% 0 =/
#$
$
12 %
"
12 $ # % $ $ 3< 3=$# % $
I $ $
( * #+ /- ( I $ $ #&# 0#
1<( =<
#
##& 12 RITU SHARMA 2025.11.28 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
8
==%
# $ 0 $ $0 %
3<
3= (
$% $ $ $" % 12 &
% 8 $
$
# # % 0 % 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 000000 6=- %
# $
% $( ## $
12
$ 0 % ##
$
#& ;
!,
H%0
#D( E A$#%
#( $#
12 /,!3
#
K%
#"( $ $ %#$
12/,!3 #($$ % # "( '() % # # # $$ % *%(@+ 4
% D% $$%#
'() #?#&9"% RITU SHARMA 2025.11.28 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
9
$ # $7 0 %%
%
#
$
#$ $3<
3= !! # $D(
% +," -67& -0#8( -(!4"* +
5 6!1 "
$ % $%% D(
D( E
0 7 # %% 0
# D ( ( #
$ $ , (5 2 / . '
- &- 51 * + # % E D ( ,
- ' ,//
- (
1 * +# #D9# $( !- 7
$ $
# !3,./,/. ,-,3/,/. D9# $ (
$ ,
- '
, / /
- (
1 * + # % #
$
%%&# D ( ( # $#
# $ 0 /,
7
$ $
# !3,./,/. ,-,3/,/. D9# $ ( $
,
- '
, / /
- (
1 * + #
%
#
$
% % & # D ( ( # $#
# $ 0 /! "
$ % $
B # # % 0
%
# $ '() *+ 0 "( # $ B&
*+;
RITU SHARMA 2025.11.28 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
10
!/
%
$# % %
$ $(75/<23.5/,/.*+," -67& -0#8( -(!4" %("0" #!# #8!
#8 6("+
,=!!/,/. !<
#
&
$
*+ #
%% !=
$*+
*+
3.- ..5
3+ .5 %&'( ) *
7 &B
LB@
7 #LB@
RITU SHARMA 2025.11.28 12:27 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document