Research › Search › Judgment

Bombay High Court · body

2025 DAILYLAW 12689 (BOM)

RAMDAS CHANDRABHAN PIMPALE v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THROUGH THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR AND OTHERS

WP/4538/2025 · 2025-05-07

Shri Kishore C Sant

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

Ethape ( 1 ) 928-930-936-939 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD 928 WRIT PETITION NO. 4535 OF 2025 Sonali Lavha Pimple Alias Sonali Ashok Gangurde VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Through The District Collector And Others AND 930 WRIT PETITION NO. 4538 OF 2025 Ramdas Chandrabhan Pimpale VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Through The District Collector And Others AND 936 WRIT PETITION NO. 4638 OF 2025 Abhiman Shankarrao Kamble VERSUS The Collector Dharashiv And Another AND 939 WRIT PETITION NO. 4971 OF 2025 Laxman Dattu Gaikawad VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Through Rural Development Department And Others ... Mr. V. D. Salunke, Advocate for the petitioner in WP/4638/2025. Mr. P. P. Dawalkar, AGP for Respondent-State in WP/4638/2025. Mr.Sujit A. Patil h/f Mr. S. B. Choudhary, Advocate for the Petitioner in WP/4971/2025. Mr. P. D. Patil, AGP for Respondent-State in WP/4971/2025. Mr. Mr. Chandrakant Vinayak Bodkhe, Advocate for the Petitioner in WP/4535/2025 WP/4538/2025. Ethape ( 2 ) 928-930-936-939 Mr. K. B. Jadhavar, AGP for Respondent-State in WP/4535/2025. Mr. K. S. Patil, AGP for Respondent-State in WP/4538/2025. CORAM : KISHORE C. SANT, J. DATE : 7th MAY 2025 PC :- 1. Heard the learned Advocates for the respective parties. 2. All these petitions are arising out of orders passed by the learned Collector in respective writ petition holding the petitioners as disqualified under Section 10-1A or under Section 30-1A of the Maharashtra Maharashtra Gram Panchayat Act, 1958, i.e. Sarpanch/ Upasarpanch/Member is directly elected or elected by the member of the gram panchayat, respectively. 3. Admittedly, the elections, in these cases, have taken place in the month of December 2022. Now, the learned Advocate Mr. Salunke has produced on record copy of “Maharashtra Ordinance No. VI of 2023”. By way of said ordinance, time to submit caste validity certificate is extended by one year from the date of ordinance i.e. 13th April 2024. This ordinance is made applicable to the cases where elections have Ethape ( 3 ) 928-930-936-939 been held after 1st August 2022 till 30th April 2025. Clause ([k) of Section 3 sub-section (1) reads as under: “([k) oj uewn dsysY;k dyekae/;s fofufnZ+्቗ dsysY;k eqnrhP;k vkr] oS/krk izek.ki= lknj u dsY;kcnny] T;k O;Drhph fuoM jnn dj.;kr vkyh vkgs fdaok jnn dj.;kr vkyh vlY;kps ekuU;kr vkys vkgs rh O;Drh] vFkok th O;Drh xzkeiapk;rhpk lnL; fdaok ljiap ftYgk परिषदेचा lHkkln fdaok v/;{k fdaok iapk;r lferhpk lnL; fdaok lHkkirh vl.;klkBh fujgZ Bjysyh vkgs rh O;Drh] xzkeiapk;rhpk lnL; fdaok ljiap ftYgk परिषदेचा lHkkln fdaok v/;{k fdaok ;FkfLFkfr] iapk;r lferhpk lnL; fdaok lHkkirh vlY;kps eku.;kr ;sbZy vkf.k vlk lnL; fdaok ljiap] lHkkln fdaok v/;{k] lnL; fdaok lHkkirh Eg.kwu fu;fer vlsy vkf.k oS/krk izek.ki= lknj u dsY;kcnny ;k v/;kns’kkP;k izkjaHkkP;k fnukadkiklwu ckjk efgU;kaP;k eqnrhi;Zr rh O;Drh fujgZ Bj.kkj ukgh% ijarq] tj v’kk O;Drhus] ;k v/;kns’kkP;k izkjaHkkP;k fnukadkiklwu ckjk efgU;kaP;k eqnrhP;k vkr] oS/krk izek.ki= lknj dj.;kr dlwj dsY;kl] frph fuoM.kwd] Hkwry{kh izHkkokus jnn dj.;kr vkyh vlY;kps eku.;kr ;sbZy vkf.k rh] xzkeiapk;rhpk lnL; fdaok ljiap] ftYgk परिषदेचा lHkkln fdaok v/; {k vFkok iapk;r lferhpk lnL; fdaok lHkkirh vl.;kr fujgZ Bjsy.” 4. From reading of the said clause, it is clear that, even where the orders are passed, holding such persons as disqualified, still they are protected by this ordinance. Causes calling in sub-section (2) are the exceptions which reads as under: “(2) iksV&dye (1) P;k rjrqnh iq<hy ckcrhr ykxw vl.kkj ukghr& (d) iksV&dye (1) e/;s fofufnZ+ ्቗ dsysY;k tkxkaoj ;k v/;kns’kkP;k izkjaHkkP;k fnukadkiwohZ] iksV&fuoM.kqdk ?ks.;kr vkysY;k vlrhy( fdaok ([k) T;k lnL;kPkk oS/krk izek.ki=kpk vtZ] iMrkG.kh lferhdMwu Ethape ( 4 ) 928-930-936-939 QsVkG.;kr vkysyk vlsy.” 5. Thus, it is seen that, where already the elections have taken place pursuant to declaration of such disqualifications, are excluded and the cases where the caste validity certificate is refused by the committee, are the cases which are not covered by Sub-section (1) of Section 3. 6. As already observed that it is admitted position that in these cases, the elections have taken place in December 2022, this Court finds that cases are covered by the ordinance. 7. Petitions are, therefore, allowed only unless hit by Section 2 of the ordinance. 8. With this, writ petition stands disposed off. [KISHORE C. SANT, J.]