- 1 - ! " #$# ! % &$!!! #' % &$!$! (! ) ! " # $ % & '& %& & ' " #$ Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ( ! ! ) *% (+, -. ! / / 0& 0&& # /0&& $ 12345346754 869:69954;<7=5 631676>6 7675 4?@1@97367@A5 3@;B16C 6C6;B36D@ 51E= #=535@16F753 35F53354 72 69 -7=5 3@;B16C.$ @1 ::C@E67@21 2 *% ( 8=535;< 7=5 3@;B16C =64 6CC2854 7=5 6::C@E67@21 F@C54 ;< 7=5 359:214517@9=535;<E=6CC51D54@17=@9:57@7@21 =5 F6E79 6::29@75 F23 E219@45367@21 69 ;2315 2B7 F32?7=5:C564@1D963569F2CC289/ =5 359:214517 869 823>@1D 69 5753@163< 99@97617 @1 3@?63<5753@163<51735@421@@G6:B36CB>614@973@E76 E695 869 35D@975354 6D6@197 =@? @1 :5E@6C 695 2# $ 2% ;5F2357=52B372F 3@1E@:6C599@219&B4D5%:5E@6C - 3 - &B4D567@G6:B321* H6CC5D@1D7=67=5=6445?61454 614 6EE5:754 61 6?2B17 2F 9%, 69 ;3@;5 F23 73567@1D ;BFF6C2 614 D267 ;5C21D@1D 72 215 3@ =55?6116 67=<6::6 6C686@ @5 ! =5 96@4 E695 51454 @1 6EIB@776C ;< 61 2345346754 *5F235E21ECB9@212F7=5:5E@6C695 # $ 2% 2A531?517 ;< 23453 46754 * 5173B9754 7=5 ?67753 72 2>6<B>76 72 =2C4 61 51IB@3< 614 @1 7=5 51IB@3< :32E554@1D9 ;5F235 7=5 1IB@3< FF@E53 7=5 @9E@:C@163< B7=23@7< 5J6?@154 * 8@7159959 @5 7=5 E2?:C6@1617 69 ! 9=6428 8@71599 69 ! 614 1A597@D67@1D FF@E53 69 !* 614 ?63>54 42EB?5179 69 J9 72 72 :32A5 7=5 E=63D59 C5A5C54 6D6@197 7=5 359:214517 1 35;B776C 7=5 5C@1IB517 2A531?517 FF@E53 #-.F239=237$5J6?@154=@?95CF69! * 1 E21ECB9@21 2F 7=5 51IB@3< 7=5 1IB@3< FF@E53 9B;?@7754 7=5 51IB@3< 35:237 =2C4@1D 7=67 7=5 E=63D59 C5A5C54 =6A5 ;551 :32A54 EE234@1DC< 14 9=28,E6B95 127@E5 869 953A54727=5359:21451721( 6C21D8@7=7=5E2:<2F 51IB@3< 35:237 614 7=5 35E2??51467@21 2F 7=5 21.;C5 :6C2>6<B>76 5:C< 72 7=5 14 9=28,E6B95 127@E5 869 ?645 21 (( ;<7=5359:214517!@7=2B7E219@453@1D7=596@4 - 4 - 35:C< :57@7@2153 2 =69 :69954 7=5 @?:BD154 23453 2F E2?:BC923< 357@35?517 21 ( B1453 BC5 '#A@$ 2F 631676>6 @A@C 53A@E59 #C699@F@E67@21 21732C 614 ::56C$ BC5H( 5@1D6DD3@5A54;<7=596@4234537=5359:214517 F@C54 61 6::C@E67@21 ;5F235 7=5 3@;B16C 72 957,69@45 7=5 @?:BD15423453:69954;<7=5:57@7@21532=53@;B16C21 699599@1D ;27= 236C 614 42EB?51763< 5A@451E5 6CC2854 7=5 6::C@E67@21 F@C54 ;< 7=5 359:214517 ;< 9577@1D 69@45 7=5 @?:BD154 23453 :69954 ;< :57@7@2153 2 614 4@35E754 :57@7@215327235,@1976757=5359:214517@172953A@E58@7=6CC E2195IB517@6C;515F@79=6CC51D5727=596?5@97=5;5F235 7=@92B37 !5=6A5=56343@=@A6>B?6351DC@C563154 F237=5:57@7@21539614C563154E2B195C3@=6D6E=577@F23 7=5359:214517 7 @9 E217517@21 2F 7=5 C563154 F23 7=5 :57@7@215397=677=5@57=5359:2145178=@C573567@1D7=5 ;BFF6C2 614 D267 ;5C21D@1D 72 7=5 E2?:C6@1617,=@?6::6 67=<6::66C686@45?614546146EE5:7546;3@;56?2B172F - 5 - 9%,614699BE==5=69E2??@7754616E72F?@9E214BE7 614 F6@C54 72 ?6@176@1 6;92CB75 @175D3@7< 614 45A27@21 72 7=5 4B7< =B9 =5 =69 E2??@7754 61 6E7 B1;5E2?@1D 2F 6 2A531?517 953A617 9 9BE= 7=5 1IB@3< FF@E53 21 :32:53 6::35E@67@21 2F 236C 614 42EB?51763< 5A@451E5 =69 =5C4 7=67 7=5 @9E@:C@163< B7=23@7< =69 :32A54 7=5 E=63D59 C5A5C54 6D6@197 7=5 359:214517 =5356F753 7=5 21.;C5 :6C2>6<B>76 =69 35E2??51454 7=5 2A531?517 72 @?:295 :516C7< 2F E2?:BC923<357@35?5176D6@1977=5359:214517614699BE=7=5 @?:BD154234532F 516C7<2FE2?:BC923<357@35?517:69954@9 GB97 614 :32:53 285A53 7=5 3@;B16C 6::35E@6754 614 E219@453547=55A@451E5614?6753@6C92135E234:69954685CC 35692154@?:BD15423453;<9577@1D69@457=523453:69954;< 7=5:57@7@2153299BE=7=596?5@9C@6;C572;5957,69@45 !@7= 7=595 9B;?@99@219 =5 92BD=7 72 6CC28 7=5 :359517 :57@7@21 ( C563154 E2B195C F23 7=5 359:214517 E21751454 7=67 7=5 3@;B16C 21 ?57@EBC2B9C< 5J6?@1@1D 7=5 5A@451E5 :C6E54 ;< 7=5 4@9E@:C@163< 6B7=23@7< @1 7=5 51IB@3< :32E554@1D9 =69 3@D=7C< 957,69@45 7=5 23453 :69954 ;< 7=5 :57@7@21532@1685CC35692154234538=@E=4259127E6CCF23 - 6 - 61<@1753F5351E559B;?@77547=677=5E=63D59F36?54@17=5 9:5E@6C E695 F@C54 ;5F235 7=5 :5E@6C &B4D5 67 @G6:B3 614 7=5 E=63D59F36?54@17=545:637?5176C51IB@3<E214BE754;<7=5 2>6<B>76 8535 215 614 7=5 96?5 =5 8@7159959 @1 7=5 E3@?@16C E695 69 85CC 69 @1 7=5 45:637?5176C 51IB@3< 635 6C92 7=5 96?5 B37=53 7=5 E2?:C6@1617 =69 7B3154 =297@C5 4B3@1D 7=5 45:637?5176C 51IB@3< 69 9BE= 7=5 4@9E@:C@163< 6B7=23@7< F6@C54 72 :32A5 E=63D59 C5A5C54 6D6@197 7=5 359:214517 EE234@1DC<=5:36<9724@9?@997=5:359517:57@7@21 ' 6A@1D =5634 7=5 C563154 E2B195C F23 7=5 :637@59 61421:53B96C2F7=542EB?5179?6456A6@C6;C5;5F235B97=5 92C5:2@177=6763@959F232B3E219@45367@21@9/ !"#$% H 9E2BC4;5D67=5354F32?7=535E2349;5F2357=5 @9E@:C@163<B7=23@7<7=5E2?:C6@16178695J6?@15469 ! =5 451@54 7=5 E2175179 51B?536754 @1 =@9 E2?:C6@17 614 45:2954 7=67 7=5 359:214517 =64 127 45?61454 ;3@;5 614 FB37=53 =5 EC63@F@54 7=67 =5 4@4 127 :6< 61< 6?2B17 72 7=5 359:21451744@7@216CC<=59767547=677=5359:2145177356754 - 7 - =@961@?6C961435@75367547=67=545?6145412;3@;5F32?7=5 E2?:C6@1617 =5 4@9E@:C@163< 6B7=23@7< 5J6?@154 ! , 9=64288@71599727=5@1E@45178=2E675D23@E6CC<45:29547=67 ! 5175354 7=5 2FF@E5 2F 614 EB54 6 :35,?54@76754 9@D16C 67 7=5 2C@E5 614 7=5356F753 7=5< 5175354 7=5 2FF@E5 1 9BE= E@3EB?9761E59 9@1E5 ! =@?95CF 7B3154 =297@C5 72 7=5 :3295EB7@21?BE=5A@4517@63<A6CB5E61127;56776E=54727=5 5A@451E5 2F ! ,9=6428 8@71599 614 72 7=5 5A@451E5 2F !*,1A597@D67@1D FF@E53 =5 3@;B16C 8=@C5 6CC28@1D 7=5 6::C@E67@21@1 636D36:=926142;953A5469B1453/ & ' ( ) ) ( * + , - ' ( * . && ( ' ' ( (/ ( ' ( ) ( . , ( ) 0 ( 0 ( ) ( ( ( ( (( ( ' (/ ( ( ) ) ( *) * ' ( ) - 8 - 1 2 3 0 456 67 585 9 :+ 9 ;<018 01=>?""@A+00#BC/ ( ) )) ( * 5 / + / ( * (' D & . && * + * """ ; ) ( "E"" ( * ) * -/ ( ) & 5 / ' ( */ ( ( ( * ' ( ( / ( / ( ) ' ( ' ' ) ( ' ( *% =5 9B;?@99@21 2F 7=5 C563154 F23 7=5 :57@7@21539 @9 7=67 6C;5@7 7=5 E2?:C6@1617 4@4 127 9B::237 7=5 E6952F@9E@:C@163<B7=23@7<=285A537=55A@451E52F ! , 9=6428 8@71599 614 !*,1A597@D67@1D FF@E53 7=5 E=63D59 C5A5C54 6D6@197 7=5 359:214517 635 :32A54 69 9BE= 7=5 23453 :69954;<7=53@;B16C1554972;5957,69@45 !5 635 6F36@4 85 E61127 6EE5:7 7=5 9B;?@99@21 35145354 ;< 7=5 C563154 F23 7=5 9@?:C5 356921 7=67 7=5 - 9 - E2?:C6@1617 =@?95CF 451@54 7=5 E2175179 51B?536754 @1 =@9 E2?:C6@17614;@464@5B727=5E6952F@9E@:C@163<B7=23@7<@1 7=5 51IB@3< 7=5 E=63D59 2F 45?614 614 6EE5:761E5 2F 7=5 ;3@;5 ;< 7=5 %359:214517 =69 127 ;551 :32A54 8@7= :35:2145361E5 614 :32;6;@C@7< D6@197 7=@9 ;6E>432: 85 635 2F 7=5 A@58 7=67 7=5 3@;B16C =69 3@D=7C< 6::35E@6754 7=5 5A@451E5 614 ?6753@6C9 21 35E234 @1 356E=@1D 61 6::32:3@675 E21ECB9@2151E5@7E6CC9F2312@1753F5351E5@17=5@?:BD154 23453:69954;<7=53@;B16CEE234@1DC<856198537=5:2@17 36@954 6;2A5 @1 7=5 6FF@3?67@A5 614 :32E554 72 :699 7=5 F2CC28@1D/ =5:57@7@21@9;5@1D45A2@42F?53@79 !*+ (!! #') $ !*+ ($! ) $ @972/C2/ ' /