- 1 - !! " # # $$% & ' ( ! " # $"%" & " " '( "(")'*+ ( " ( *+ " ," ( '' ( * ! " # $" "' ,- " "! ",!,, & Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' + $ & ' ' % "!",! " % " ", ,! +" ' ' % ."% % # $ ."% % & /012 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 0;;/5506306234/1/:;862/638"," !," /<6=0==1</?/2@A34/B92=C/630620D012<6 "8", ,! +203/2 "!",! @A34/838177<2/63 50<C: 1<@9605 03 0<7491 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 <: @/>81/ 34<: 8913://E<6=/64067/C/638>34/78C;/6:03<86" - 3 - !" 4/ >073905 C031<F 8> 34/ 70:/ <: 3403 86 !"!",! 03 0@893 + ;"C" D4/6 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 D0: 21<?<6= 0 @/01<6= /="8"(*,**! 86 0:E< * 050=06881 1802 34/ ( @9: @/01<6= /="8"(*)*'*+ 21<?/6@A1/:;862/638" 8D6/2@A 1/:;862/63 8", * 781;8103<86 70C/ >18C 8;;8:<3/ 2<1/73<86 062 7855<2/2 D<34 34/ ?/4<75/ 8> 34/ ;/3<3<86/1" 4/ ;/3<3<86/1 :9:30<6/2 >107391/ 8> 34/ 1<=43 E6// 1<=43 >81/01C /37 062 4/ D0: :4<>3/2 38 660;9160 91:<6= 8C/030:E<"03/14/D0::4<>3/238910E:408:;<305 03 0<7491" 91<6= 34/ 31/03C/63 4<: 1<=43 5/= D0: 0C;9303/2@/58D34/E6//"4/;/3<3<86/17863/62/23403 4/D0:021<?/106240::9>>/1/2;/1C06/632<:0@<5<3A062 4/ 402 :;/63 49=/ 0C8963 >81 31/03C/63" 3 D0: 05:8 :303/2 3403 34/ ;85<7/ 402 1/=<:3/1/2 34/ 70:/ <6 1<C/ 8" ,,! 062 402 ><5/2 7401=/*:4//3 0=0<6:3 34/ 21<?/1: 8> @834 ?/4<75/:" 3 D0: 7863/62/2 3403 4/ D0: /016<6=:"!!!!*;/1C8634"::9744/<:/63<35/2>81 78C;/6:03<86" - 4 - !" 4/ 1/:;862/63: 0;;/01/2 34189=4 34/<1 7896:/5 062 1/:<:3/2 34/ ;/3<3<86 7863/62<6= 3403 34/1/ D0: 6/=5<=/67/ 86 34/ ;013 8> 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 4<C:/5>- 4/ 40268330E/634/?/4<75/3834/5/>3:<2/-8634/7863101A 4/ 70C/ <6 34/ C<225/ 8> 34/ 1802 062 7855<2/2 D<34 34/ @9:" 3 D0: 7863/62/2 3403 34/ 78C;/6:03<86 750<C/2 <: 4<=45A /F81@<3063 <C0=<601A 062 963/60@5/ <6 50D" 4/A 2/6</234/0=/<678C/0628779;03<868>34/;/3<3<86/1" !" 4/1<@960540:>10C/234/0;;18;1<03/<::9/:" 4/;/3<3<86/1D0:/F0C<6/20:" 06286/D<36/::D0: /F0C<6/2 ", 062 F"" 38 D/1/ C01E/2 <6 /?<2/67/" 4/ 1/:;862/63 8" D0: /F0C<6/2 0: " 062F"" 38D/1/C01E/2<634//?<2/67/" !)" >3/14/01<6=34/01=9C/63:34/1<@96054/52 3403 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 <: /63<35/2 >81 78C;/6:03<86 8> :" +!!!!*06234034/40278631<@93/2!G38D012: 34/6/=5<=/67/"678C<6=38:974786759:<8634/1<@9605 4/52 34/ <678C/ 8> 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 03 :" !!!!* ;/1 C8634" - 5 - !+" /<6= 0==1</?/2 @A 34/ :0C/ 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 <: @/>81/ 34<: 8913 ://E<6= /64067/C/63 8> 34/ 78C;/6:03<86" !" 4/5/016/27896:/50;;/01<6=>8134/;/3<3<86/1 7863/62: 3403 34/ 786759:<86 8> 34/ 1<@9605 3403 34/ ;/3<3<86/140:78631<@93/2!G38D012:34/6/=5<=/67/<: 96:9:30<60@5/ <6 50D" / 7863/62: 3403 /?/6 3489=4 34/ :;83C040H01:48D:340334/077<2/6340230E/6;507/03 34/ 7/631/ 8> 34/1802 D4<74 D0: , >//3 D<2/ 8D<6= 38 34/ >073 3403 34/ ?/4<75/ 8> 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 D0: 0 :C055/1 86/ 34/ 2/=1// 8> 6/=5<=/67/ 3403 :48952 40?/ @//6 0331<@93/2 38 34/ 1/:;862/63 8" D0: C81/" 4/1/>81/ 34/ 78631<@9381A 6/=5<=/67/ 8> 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 03 !G <: <67811/73" : :974 34/1/ <: 0 6//2 >81 <6295=/67/ 8> 34<: 8913<634/C033/1" !" 4/:/7862;8<6301=9/2@A34/5/016/27896:/5 >81 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 <: 3403 34/ 1<@9605 40: 786:<2/1/2 34/ >9673<86052<:0@<5<3A8>34/;/3<3<86/103+!G0:0=0<6:334/ ;4A:<705 2<:0@<5<3A :303/2 @A ", 03 !G" 4/ 1<@9605 - 6 - 40: 683 0D012/2 06A 78C;/6:03<86 38D012: >9391/ ;18:;/73:" 4/ 2<:0@<5<3A <: 30E/6 03 +!G /?/6 3489=4 34/1/ <: 0C;9303<86 8> 34/1<=43 5/= @/58D 34/ E6//" 4/ 1<@9605 :48952 40?/ 786:<2/1/2 34/ 58:: 8> >9391/ ;18:;/73: 05:8" 4/1/>81/ 4/ ://E: 1/0::/::C/63 8> 34/ 78C;/6:03<86" !" /1 786310 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/1/:;862/638",:9@C<3:340334/@9:21<?/121<?/6@A 34/ 1/:;862/63 8" 402 C8?/2 683 /?/6 ,!! >//3 >18C 34/@9::306234/1/>81/34/1/D0:686/=5<=/67/8634/ ;0138>34/@9:21<?/1"3<:7863/62/2340334/;/3<3<86/1 @/<6=34/21<?/18>34/:C055/1?/4<75/:4895240?/30E/6 4<:?/4<75/38D012:4<:5/>3:<2/"4/1/>81/34/2/=1//8> 701/ 3403 :48952 40?/ @//6 30E/6 @A 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 D0: C81/" 4/ 1802 @/<6= 0@893 , >//3 D<2/ 06A 4/0?A ?/4<75/ D8952 @/ 0@893 + >//3 <6 D<234 062 :8 <3 D0: 6/7/::01A8634/;0138>34/;/3<3<86/13830E/4<:?/4<75/ 384<:5/>3"4/1/>81/4/7863/62:340334/0;;813<86C/63 8> 34/ 6/=5<=/67/ @A 34/ 1<@9605 03 !! <: ;18;/1 062 7811/73" - 7 - " /78625A 4/ :9@C<3: 3403 34/ 1<@9605 40: =<?/678=/631/0:86:>810::/::<6=34/2<:0@<5<3A03+!G" 4/1/>81/ 34/1/ <: 68 6//2 >81 1/0::/::C/63 8> 34/ 78C;/6:03<86" 6 834/1 D812: 4/ 2/>/62: 34/ <C;9=6/2 B92=C/6386@83478963:" ," 4/ >073 3403 34/1/ D0: 06 077<2/63 <6?85?<6= 34/ ?/4<75/ 8> 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 062 3403 8> 34/ 1/:;862/63 8",<:683<62<:;93/"4/;/19:058>34/'0627401=/* :4//3 03 F"" 062 F"", D8952 :48D 3403 34/ <6?/:3<=03<6= 8>><7/1 0>3/1 348189=4 <6?/:3<=03<86 40: ><5/2 34/7401=/*:4//30=0<6:3@83421<?/1:8>@834?/4<75/:"4/ :;83 :E/374 ;18297/2 03 F"" D8952 :48D 3403 34/ 077<2/63877911/20334/7/631/8>34/1802"4/D<2348> 34/1802D0:0@89338 ,>//3"4/?/1:<868>3/:3<C86A8> 34/" 062" D89522<:758:/3403@8348>34/C402 68330E/6701/38C8?/34/<1?/4<75/:@/58D34033011802 :8 3403 06834/1 ?/4<75/ 78952 ;0:: 34189=4" 3 <: /?<2/63 3403 1/5973067/ 8> @834 34/ 21<?/1: 40: 1/:953/2 <6 34/ 077<2/63" - 8 - " 62/1 34/:/ 7<179C:3067/: 34/ 2/=1//8> 701/ 3403:4895240?/@//630E/6@A@83434/21<?/1:40:38@/ 0::/::/2 @A 34/ 8913" 81C055A 34/ 21<?/1: 8> 4/0?A ?/4<75/:062@<==/1?/4<75/:40?/38@/C81/701/>95"4/ 2/=1// 8> 701/ >81 :C055/1 ?/4<75/: D<55 @/ 86 34/ 5/::/1 :<2/" " 6 34/ 70:/ 86 4062 <3 <: /?<2/63 3403 34/ ;/3<3<86/13489=44020C;5/:;07/864<:5/>3:<2/2<2683 C8?/ 4<: ?/4<75/ 38 34/ /2=/ 8> 34/ 1802" 6 34/ 834/1 406234/21<?/18>34/@9:/?/6<>402C8?/24<:?/4<75/ 3834//2=/8>34/1802834/1:<2/8>34/?/4<75/D8952@/ 0334/7/63/18>34/1802"4/1/>81/34/7401=/*:4//340: @//6 ><5/2 0=0<6:3 @83434/21<?/1:"3 <:/?<2/633403 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 D0: 05:8 03 >0953 >81 683 =<?<6= D0A >81 34/ @<==/1?/4<75/38;0::34189=4" " 86:<2/1<6=34/:/0:;/73:34/1<@9605<6010 8" 786:<2/1: 34/:/ 0:;/73: <6 2/30<5 @93 34/ 78C;0103<?/ 2/=1// 8> 701/ 3403 :48952 40?/ @//6 /F/17<:/2@A@83434/21<?/1:D0:6832<:79::/2<62/30<5" - 9 - 30@19;35A70C/3834/786759:<86340334/2/=1//8>34/ /F3/638>6/=5<=/67/<:!!"6786:<2/1/28;<6<868>34<: 8913 34/ 2/=1// 8> 6/=5<=/67/ 3403 :48952 @/ >0:3/6/2 9;8634/;/3<3<86/1<:G"4/2/=1//8>6/=5<=/67/3403 :48952@/>0:3/6/29;8634/1/:;862/638" <:)G" )" 4/ 6/F3 0:;/73 38 @/ 786:<2/1/2 <: 1/=012<6= 34/ I90639C 8> 34/ 78C;/6:03<86" 4/ ;/3<3<86/1 402 :9>>/1/2 0C;9303<86 8> 34/ 1<=43 5/=" / @/<6= 0 21<?/1 0=/20@893A/01:<:960@5/38;91:9/34/B8@06AC81/" 4/1<@960540:786:<2/1/20@89334/2<:0@<5<3A<62/30<5<6 010 8" 8> <3: B92=C/63" 4/ 1<@9605 683/: 3403 9:9055A34/2<:0@<5<3AD<55@/30E/603 !!G<634/70:/8> 0C;9303<86" 974 0C;9303<86 0>>/73<6= 34/ ;18>/::<86 8> 34/;/3<3<86/1@93786:<2/1<6=34/0=/34/;/3<3<86/1706 020;338:8C/834/1;18>/::<86"4/1/>81/<31/297/234/ >9673<86052<:0@<5<3A38+!G"4/786759:<868>34/1<@9605 3403 34/1/ <: 0 >9673<8605 2<:0@<5<3A 8> +!G @/<6= 0 D/55 786:<2/1/286/<3D8952683@/;18;/138<63/1>/1/<634/ :0C/"8D/?/134/1<@960540:683786:<2/1/234/>9391/ ;18:;/73: 03 055" 4/ 2<:0@<5<3A :9>>/1/2 @A 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 - 10 - D89521/C0<6>8134/1/:38>4<:5<>/"4/1<@960540?<6= 786:<2/1/234/<678C/8>34/2/7/0:/203:" !!!!*;/1 C8634" A 022<6= !G 38D012: 34/ >9391/ ;18:;/73: 34/ />>/73<?/ C953<;5<7062 D8952 @/ :" !!!!* J :"!!!* K:" !!!*;/1C8634"/67/34/;/3<3<86/1<:/63<35/2 962/134/4/028>58::8>>9391/;18:;/73:03:" !!!*F ,F )F+!GK:" )!!*" +" 4/1<@960540:0D012/234/78C;/6:03<868> :"+!!!* 962/1 34/ 4/02 8> ;0<6 062 :9>>/1<6=" 4/ :0C/6//2:38@//64067/238:" !!!!!*" " 4/1<@960540:0D012/20:9C8>:"!!!!* 962/134/4/028>58::8><678C/291<6=34/31/03C/63"3 <:/?<2/63340334/;/3<3<86/17895268340?/1/:9C/24<: 053/1603/0?8703<86035/0:3>810;/1<828>86/A/01:<67/ 4/402387406=/4<:0?8703<86>18C34/21<?<6=38:8C/ 834/186/"4/1/>81/34/;/3<3<86/1<:/63<35/2>810:9C8> :" ,!!!!*962/134<:4/02" " <C<5015A 34/ 78C;/6:03<86 962/1 34/ 4/02 8> 58:: 8> 0C/6<3</: <: /64067/2 >18C :"!!!!* 38 :"!!!!*" - 11 - ,!" '9134/1 34/ 1<@9605 40: 683 786:<2/1/2 34/ /F;/6:/: 962/1 34/ 4/02 8> 786?/A067/" 4/ ><F03<86 8> 34/ 013<><7<05 5<C@ <6?85?/2 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 38 ?<:<3 :/?/105 48:;<305:"/67/0:9C8>:",!!!*<:0D012/2962/1 34/4/028>786?/A067/" , " 4/ 78C;/6:03<86 962/1 1/C0<6<6= 4/02: 28 6831/I9<1/06A/64067/C/63" ,," 4/1/>81/ 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 <: /63<35/2 >81 38305 /64067/2 78C;/6:03<86 8> :" ))!* 962/1 34/ >8558D<6=4/02:* 5" 8" /02: 8C;/6:03<86 D012/2 @A34<:8913 " 0<6062:9>>/1<6= :" !!!!!* ," /2<705/F;/6:/: :"!!!!* " 33/620637401=/: :"!!!* " '882062/F310 6891<:4C/63 :" !!!* " 8::8>/016<6=291<6= 34/31/03C/63;/1<82 :" ,!!!!* )" 8::8>>9391/ /016<6=: :" )!!* +" '<F03<868>013<><7<05 5<C@ :" ,!!!* " '819640;;<6/::062 58::8>0C/6<3</: :"!!!!* " '81786?/A067/ :",!!!* 8305 :",!)!!* - 12 - ," 93 8> 34/ 0@8?/ 78C;/6:03<86 0::/::/2 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 <: /63<35/2 >81 )G 0>3/1 2/2973<6= 4<: 78631<@9381A6/=5<=/67/D4<7478C/:38:" ))!*" ," /67/ 0;;/05 2/:/1?/: 38 @/ 0558D/2 <6 ;013" 4/1/>81/34/>8558D<6=- " 4/0;;/05<:0558D/2<6;013" " 4/0;;/55063<:/63<35/2>810:9C8>:" ))!* 0586=D<34<63/1/:30334/103/8>)G;"0">18C203/ 8>;/3<3<863<5534/203/8>2/;8:<3" " 4/ 1/:;862/63: 8" 062 , @/<6= 21<?/1 062 :/5> <6:91/1 8> 34/ @9: :4055 ;0A 34/ 0@8?/ C/63<86/2 0C8963@A2/;8:<3<6=34/:0C/@/>81/34/1<@9605" " /:3 8> 34/ 812/1 ;0::/2 @A 34/ 1<@9605 1/=012<6= ><F/22/;8:<3/37"1/C0<696053/1/2" 2* % # ' # (%% <:38" 58"+) (