- 1 - ! " #$# " %!&$"""! # ' %!&$"$" (" ) !"#$% & ' ( # ' ( )$$$# % Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )$$$# & ' #* %( %% %%+ , %-$"%$%# . %$"# %$%$ / ) , , 0 0 ! ' 0 ( 1 23453 46754 %-$"%$%# 869954 :; 7<5 631676=6 7675 4>?1?97367?@5 3?:A16B 6B6:A36C? 51D< '<535?16E753 35E53354 72 69 3?:A16B( ?1 88B?D67?21 2%$"# %$%$ F<535:;7<53?:A16B<644?9>?99547<5688B?D67?21E?B54:;7<5 857?7?2153?9<535:;D<6BB51C54?17<?9857?7?21 % <5 E6D79 68829?75 E23 D219?45367?21 69 :2315 2A7 E32>7<58B564?1C963569E2BB2F9 - 3 - <5857?7?2153F69F23=?1C69 ?17<52EE?D52E ?G6;8A36 15 <3? AB=631? 21 %$"%$#% B24C54 6 D2>8B6?17:5E2357<52=6;A=76 2B?D5?G6;68A366BB5C?1C7<67 <5 >645 61 688B?D67?21 72 7<5 857?7?2153 E23 ?99A61D5 2E <6BB)7?D=579 ?1 35985D7 2E # 97A45179 72 688563 69 5H75316B D614?46759E235H6>?167?21E32>67<;66??C<D<22B ?G6;68A36 E23 F<?D< 7<5 857?7?2153 <64 45>61454 6 9A> 2E 9%$$) 853 97A4517 72 >557 7<5 35IA597 <51 7<5 D2>8B6?16175H8359954<?9?16:?B?7;7286;7<596?46>2A177<5 857?7?2153 ?1E23>54 <?> 72 86; 9%$$$) ?1 7276B 72 D219?453 7<5 35IA597 9 9AD< 7<5 D2>8B6?1617 ?1E23>54 7<5 96>5 72 7<5 2=6;A=76 :; B24C?1C 6 D2>8B6?17 5B;?1C 21 7<5 D2>8B6?17 7<5 2=6;A=76 2B?D5 35C?975354 7<5 96>5 ?1 3?>5 2#-%$#% <5356E753 6 7368 F69 B6?4 21 %$"%$#% 2195IA517B; 61 F69 9A:>?7754 :5E235 7<5 3?1D?86B 599?219A4C585D?6BA4C5?G6;68A366C6?1977<5857?7?2153 E237<52EE51D5A14537<5832@?9?2192E 35@517?212E233A87?21 D7# "" - 6954 21 7<5 ?1@597?C67?21 358237 2E 2=6;A=76 2B?D57<586)2=6;A=76E?B546358237A14535D7?21#%'-(2E 7<5 631676=6 2=6;A=76 D7 # " 21 #-#%%$#- - 4 - 35D2>>514?1C 7<5 D2>857517 6A7<23?7; 72 ?1?7?675 4?9D?8B?163; 832D554?1C96C6?1977<5857?7?2153614725173A9751IA?3;727<5 86)2=6;A=76 197?7A7?21 <5356E753 7<5 3?1D?86B 5D35763; 722@531>517 4AD67?21 58637>517' 3?>63;6145D21463; 4AD67?21(@?452345346754#"$%%$#5173A97547<5>67753 72 86)2=6;A=76 72 D214AD7 51IA?3; A1453 AB5 # 2E 7<5 631676=6 ?@?B 53@?D59 'B699?E?D67?21 21732B 614 8856B( AB59# +DD234?1CB;6151IA?3;2EE?D53F6912>?16754:; 7<5 86)2=6;A=76 F<2 E36>54 7<5 37?DB5 2E <63C5 21 -##%%$#69A1453 J ! " #" "" $ $ % #" " ! " &' () * * +&,-./ ! " " " " )" "" &,,01&0 " 2 *3 * "" 3 " 0-,01&0 " +011./ " " ! 4 " - 5 - +0111./ " " 2 " 0-,01&0 5 6.+ 78&989 89 $ ) 8) 9 + &:;;< 1 23453 72 832@5 7<5 D<63C59 7<5 4?9D?8B?163; 6A7<23?7;?1 1IA?3;2#%$#5H6>?1547<355F?715995969 9#72-?5 #?97<5D2>8B6?1617 %?97<5861D< F?71599E237<57368832D554?1C9614 -?97<51@597?C67?1C EE?D53 614 >63=54 # 42DA>5179 69 H9 # 72 # 1 5:A776B 7<5 857?7?2153 <5395BE F69 5H6>?154 69 # 614 >63=547F242DA>5179?5 H9 #614% 297699599>5172E236B61442DA>51763;5@?451D5 7<5 1IA?3; EE?D53 9A:>?7754 7<5 358237 2E 86)2=6;A=76 21 -#$"%$#"69A1453 * " " " ! "#" " +0111./ 0-/,/01&0 " - 6 - + 78&989 89 $) 8) 9+ &:;; " %= 6" /! < 1 8A39A61D5 2E 7<5 6:2@5 358237 7<5 26=;A=76 >645 35D2>>51467?21 72 7<5 2@531>517 21 $-$ %$#" 69 A1453 >? % 8 " 9 " " " " " " ! @" < + DD234?1CB; 7<5 E?397 3598214517 869954 7<5 23453 2E D2>8AB923; 357?35>517 2E 7<5 857?7?2153 A1453 AB5 "'( 2E '(AB59# +@?4523453:563?1C2 % -%$# 46754%##%$%$ " CC3?5@54 :; 7<5 96?4 23453 7<5 857?7?2153 688326D<54 7<5 3?:A16B ?1 88B?D67?21 2%$"# %$%$ - 7 - F<535:; 7<5 3?:A16B 4?9>?9954 7<5 688B?D67?21 E?B54 :; 7<5 857?7?2153 69 976754 " <5 D<6BB51C5 72 7<5 96>5 ?9 :5E2357<?92A37 5<6@5<56347<5B563154D2A195B3?6<59< 67?B E23857?7?2153926B92B563154D2A195B3?A:<69<6BB68A3E23 3598214517 2%!2=6;A=76 614 B563154 44B 2@531>517 4@2D6753?<?@=A>6351CB?E2335982145172# #$ <5 83?>63; D217517?21 2E 7<5 B563154 D2A195B E23 7<5 857?7?2153 ?9 7<67 7<5 23453 869954 :; 3598214517 2# ?9 63:?7363; 5332152A9 614 F?7<2A7 4A5 688B?D67?21 2E >?14 DD234?1C727<5B563154D2A195B7<5D<63C59B5@5BB546C6?197 7<5857?7?2153?17<551IA?3;832D554?1C9<69D2>835<519?@5B; E6?B54 72 832@5 7<5 6BB5C67?219 :; 644AD?1C D2C517 5@?451D5 >21C7<5F?71599595H6>?154:5E2357<5 1IA?3;EE?D537<5 D2>8B6?1617?5 #<?>95BE7A31546:92BA75B;<297?B5727<5 D6955451?547<5D21751792E<?9D2>8B6?17B24C54:5E2357<5 2=6;A=76A37<53<56B92451?547<545>6146146DD58761D5 2E ?BB5C6B C367?E?D67?21 :; 7<5 857?7?2153 <5 B563154 D2A195B EA37<53D217514547<677<2AC< %)7<5861D<F?71599E237<5 7368832D554?1C9<699A88237547<5D695<2F5@53<5?912761 - 8 - 5;5F?71599 72 7<5 ?1D?4517 614 6DD234?1C 72 <?> # 614 9<642FF?71599215<614369<5=<63<6@5?1E23>54<?>6:2A7 7<5 45>614 614 6DD58761D5 2E ?BB5C6B C367?E?D67?21 :; 7<5 857?7?2153 @51 - 7<5 1@597?C67?1C EE?D53 6B92 976754 ?1 <?9 5@?451D5 7<67 # ?1E23>54 <?> 6:2A7 7<5 45>614 614 6DD58761D52E:3?:5:;7<5857?7?21532F5@53 #<?>95BE 7A3154<297?B5727<675EE5D77<535E235>AD<D354?:?B?7;D61127 :5 6776D<54 72 7<5 5@?451D5 2E 9% 614 - 9 9AD< 7<5 6A7<23?7; D2BB5D7?@5B; E6?B54 72 832@5 7<5 45>614 614 6DD58761D5 2E 7<5 ?BB5C6B C367?E?D67?21 :; 7<5 857?7?2153 DD234?1CB;7<5B563154D2A195B9A:>?77547<677<?9D695E6BB9 F?7<?1 7<5 D675C23; 2E K12 5@?451D5. D695 :5E235 7<5 51IA?3; 6A7<23?7;699AD<7<5E?14?1C92E7<551IA?3;6A7<23?7;?97276BB; 853@5395 ?1 167A35 5 6B92 D21751454 7<67 7<5 857?7?2153 <69 :551 6DIA?7754 ?1 7<5 D3?>?16B D695 ?1?7?6754 A1453 7<5 832@?9?219 2E 35@517?21 2E 233A87?21 D7 :; 7<5 2=6;A=76 2B?D5 ?1 85D?6B 695 2%$#- @?45 GA4C>517 46754 #-$%$# :; 7<5 3?1D?86B 599?219 A4C585D?6B A4C5 ?G6;68A36 5@537<5B599 7<5 96?4 GA4C>517 ?9 D21E?3>54 :; 7<?92A37?13B2%$$$ $%$#46754#$+%$# - 9 - ## 2 :A773599 <?9 63CA>5179 <5 35B?54 7<5 E2BB2F?1C 6A7<23?7?59 ?( AB4558 ?1C< 9 <5 2>>?99?2153 2E 2B?D5L3935823754?1# '%(#$ ??( 228 ?1C< 5C? 9 A1G6: 67?216B 61= L39'?@?B8856B2+-#%$$"45D?454 21# #%%$$"( ???( BB6<6:6461=L3993?9<16636;61 ?F63?'?@?B8856B2+$$%$#45D?454 21$%$#%$#+( ?@( 6>553 69<6976752E631676=6'3?7 57?7?21 2-$-%$#" 45D?454 21 %"$%$%%( @( 3?=3?9<16 6C514356886 5C6B6>61? 9 <5 7675 2E 631676=6 L 39 '3?7 57?7?21 2##-%$# 45D?454 21 $"$#%$%#( @?( <614369<5=63 <?>6886 6463 9 <5 631676=6 2=6;A=76 58 :; ?79 5C?97363 '3?7 57?7?212###"#-%$# 45D?45421 $%$%%$%#( @??( A4368869<576752E631676=6L 13 '3?7 57?7?21 2 %%$%$ 45D?454 21-$$#%$%( ?7<7<5959A:>?99?219<5836;9726BB2F7<5857?7?21 #% 7<5 B563154 D2A195B 3? A:<69< 6BB68A3E2335982145172%)2=6;A=76@5<5>517B;D21751454 7<67 7<5 3?:A16B <69 3?C<7B; 35G5D754 7<5 688B?D67?21 E?B54 :; - 10 - 7<5 857?7?2153 :; D21E?3>?1C 7<5 23453 869954 :; 7<5 2@531>517 614 6B92 7<5 35D2>>51467?21 >645 :; 7<5 2=6;A=76 DD234?1C 72 7<5 B563154 D2A195B 7<5 51IA?3; 6A7<23?7; <69 5H6>?154 7<355 F?7159959 72 832@5 7<5 D<63C59 6C6?197 7<5 857?7?2153 6>21C 7<5> # ?9 7<5 D2>8B6?1617 7<2AC<7A3154<297?B5727<583295DA7?21<2F5@534A3?1C7<5 D2A395 2E D3299)5H6>?167?21 <69 64>?7754 7<67 <5 <69 B24C54 7<5 D2>8B6?17) H # :5E235 7<5 2=6;A=76 ?>>54?675B; 6E753 7<5?1D?4517A37<53 %61?1458514517861D<F?71599E23 7<5 7368 832D554?1C9 D675C23?D6BB; 9A8823754 7<5 D695 2E 7<5 6A7<23?7;61445829547<67<56DD2>861?54 -614 #72 7<52EE?D52E7<5857?7?2153614:6954217<596;2E #7<5 76?1754DA3351D;F6935D2@5354677<5:5<5972E7<5857?7?2153 A1453 >6<6M63 H - A37<53 7<5 2B?D5 6B92 95?M54 7<5 42DA>5179 67 7<5 :5<597 2E 7<5 857?7?2153 <?9 @539?21 2E % D2332:236759 F?7< 7<5 7597?>21; 2E - 7<5 1@597?C67?1C EE?D53 5 6B92 D21751454 7<67 7<5 9D285 2E GA4?D?6B 35@?5F ?1 458637>5176B 832D554?1C9 ?9 @53; B?>?754 69 8537<5B6FB6?442F1:;7<?92A376147<521.:B585H2A37 ?1 D67516 2E 7<5 GA4C>5179 A37<53 ?1 7<5 ?197617 D695 7<5 6A7<23?7;<69832@547<5D<63C59B5@5BB546C6?1977<5857?7?2153 - 11 - F?7< 83582145361D5 2E 832:6:?B?7?59 9 9AD< 7<5 6DIA?776B 2E 7<5857?7?2153?17<5D3?>?16B832D554?1C9>6;127:56C32A14 72 6DIA?7 <?> ?1 7<5 458637>5176B 51IA?3; DD234?1C 72 7<5 B563154D2A195B7<535D2@53;2EDA3351D;?17<576:B5436F532E 7<5 857?7?2153 ?9 832@54 :; 7<5 5@?451D5 2E 9% 614 - 1 9AD< D?3DA>9761D59 64@5395 ?1E5351D5 D61 :5 436F1 6C6?197 7<5857?7?21532ED214AD7A1:5D2>?1C2E68A:B?D953@617<5 1IA?3; EE?D53 3?C<7B; 9A:>?7754 7<5 358237 614 :6954 21 7<5 96>5 7<5 3598214517 2# 869954 7<5 23453 2E D2>8AB923; 357?35>517 2E 7<5 857?7?2153 614 7<5 96>5 F69 A8<5B4 :; 7<5 3?:A16BF<?D<4259127D6BBE2361;?1753E5351D5:;7<?92A37 DD234?1CB;<5836;9724?9>?997<5F3?7857?7?21 #- 563154 2@531>517 4@2D675 642879 7<5 D217517?219 36?954 :; 7<5 B563154 D2A195B E23 7<5 3598214517 2% # 5 <6@5 C?@51 2A3 61H?2A9 D219?45367?21 21 7<5 63CA>517 64@61D54 :; 7<5 B563154 D2A195B E23 7<5 35985D7?@5 8637?59 92 6B92 D2>835<519?@5B; 853A954 7<5 5@?451D5 614 >6753?6B9 8B6D54 :5E235 A9 <5 92B5 82?17 7<67 63?959 E23 2A3 D219?45367?21?97<67 - 12 - >3 "" " "" " " "0'&&0101A< # 7 D2AB4 :5 C67<5354 E32> 7<5 35D2349 ?1 23453 72 832@5 7<5 D<63C59 6C6?197 7<5 857?7?2153 :5E235 7<5 51IA?3; 6A7<23?7;7<355F?7159959<64:5515H6>?154:;7<56A7<23?7; 6>21C 7<5> # ?9 7<5 D2>8B6?1617 F<2 B24C54 7<5 D2>8B6?17 21 %$"%$#% :5E235 7<5 2=6;A=76 6C6?197 7<5 857?7?215369853 H #6BB5C?1C7<677<5857?7?215345>61454 ?BB5C6B C367?E?D67?21 72 ?99A5 7<5 <6BB)7?D=57 2E # 97A45179 72 688563695H75316BD614?46759E235H6>?167?21E32>67;6 6??C<D<22B?G6;68A362F5@537<?9F?71599<697A3154 <297?B5 :5E235 7<5 51IA?3; 6A7<23?7; 614 451?54 7<5 D2175179 51A>536754?17<5D2>8B6?17 53D21736<5<699767547<6721 %$"%$#% 67 6:2A7 $# 8> <5 6B21C F?7< 9% 614 - 5175354 7<5 2EE?D5 2E 7<5 861D< F?71599 F535 F6?7?1C 2A79?45 7<5 2EE?D5 <51 <5 51IA?354 7<5 857?7?2153 6:2A7 7<5 F23= 9<5 ?1E23>54 7<67 9<5 <69 6B3564; D2>8B5754 7<5 F23= 61469=54<?>72C2727<5F63495D7?21<5356E753<569=54 <53 72 35D5?@5 9%$$$) <2F5@53 7<5 857?7?2153 35EA954 72 - 13 - 35D5?@57<596>5<51<5=5877<5DA3351D;217<576:B59<5 8A9<54 7<5 96>5 614 7<5 >215; E5BB ?172 7<5 436F53 <5356E753 9%614-51753547<5D<6>:53614D214AD754 7<5 >6<6M63 <2AC< # <69 :551 D3299)5H6>?154 :; 7<5 6A7<23?7;<5451?547<59ACC597?21>645:;7<56A7<23?7;1 853A96B 2E 7<5 5@?451D5 2E 7<?9 F?71599 ?7 ?9 DB563 7<67 67 12 82?172E 7?>5 7<5 857?7?21535?7<5345>61454236DD587547<5 ?BB5C6BC367?E?D67?21<55@?451D52E %F<2?97<5861D<6E23 7<5 7368 832D554?1C9 7<2AC< 9A8823754 7<5 D695 2E 7<5 83295DA7?21 <69 D675C23?D6BB; 64>?7754 7<67 <5 F69 F6?7?1C 2A79?457<52EE?D52E7<5 614<5D6>572=12F6:2A77<5 45>6142E?BB5C6BC367?E?D67?2121B;7<32AC< #<56A7<23?7; 6B92 E6?B54 72 5H6>?15 7<5 9<642F F?71599 - 7<5 1@597?C67?1C EE?D53 6B92 35?7536754 7<5 5@?451D5 2E % 1 9AD<D?3DA>9761D597<535?9129AD<35B?6:B55@?451D56@6?B6:B5 21 35D234 72 832@5 7<5 D<63C59 6C6?197 7<5 857?7?2153 7<67 <5 <69 45>61454 23 6DD58754 7<5 ?BB5C6B C367?E?D67?21 E32> 7<5 D2>8B6?1617) # <2AC< ?7 ?9 D21751454 :; 7<5 B563154 D2A195B E23 7<5 2=6;A=76 7<67 7<5 76?1754 DA3351D; F69 35D2@5354 E32> 7<5 76:B5 436F53 2E 7<5 857?7?2153 E23 F<?D< # <?>95BE <69 C?@51 61 5H8B6167?21 69 4?9DA9954 9A836 - 14 - @51 27<53F?95 >535 35D2@53; 2E 76?1754 DA3351D; ?9 127 9AEE?D?517 72 832@5 7<5 D<63C59 B5@5BB54 6C6?197 7<5 <5 21.:B5 85H 2A37 ?1 7<5 D695 2E ! 35823754 ?1 '"#$%&$"$'#<5B4?18636C368<2%#69A1453 >"$3 " " " " B # +CB # + 801&09 && )) ;'0 D 801&79 & )) 8)9 &1,: D 801&79& )) 8(E 9 &7;F D8 ))"";'-/';"&&9 >&& 4 &:,, B " " B " " " " " 01 &:,, " - 15 - " ? &:,, 3 " 01 4 *" "" " " % " *" 4 " " " " " "" " "< # 51D5?7?9DB5637<67>535B;35D5?@?1C6>2A17:; 7<5 6DDA954 ?9 ?19AEE?D?517 72 5976:B?9< 7<5 CA?B7 ?1 6:951D5 2E 61; D354?:B5 5@?451D5 D21D531?1C 7<5 45>614 614 6DD58761D5 2E 7<5 6>2A17 69 ?BB5C6B C367?E?D67?21 E 7<5 6A7<23?7; E6?B9 72 832@57<545>6146146DD58761D52E?BB5C6BC367?E?D67?21:;7<5 45B?1IA5177<517<5D<63C56C6?1977<545B?1IA517A1:5D2>?1C 2E68A:B?D953@617D61127:59A976?15444?7?216BB;693?C<7B; D21751454 :; 7<5 B563154 D2A195B E23 7<5 857?7?2153 7<67 7<5 857?7?2153 ?9 6DIA?7754 ?1 7<5 D3?>?16B D695 ?1?7?6754 :; 7<5 2=6;A=76 ?1 85D?6B 695 2#- :; 7<5 3B ?973?D7 614 - 16 - 599?219 A4C5 ?G6;68A36 614 7<5 96?4 6DIA?776B GA4C>517 F69 D21E?3>54 :; 7<?9 2A37 ?1 3B2%$$$ $%$# 46754 #$+%$# #+ 9 D2AB4 :5 5B?D?754 E32> 7<5 35D2349 9# 72 - F<2 F535 5H6>?154 ?1 7<5 51IA?3; 832D554?1C9 F535 6B92 7<5 F?7159959 ?1 7<5 D3?>?16B 832D554?1C9 614 7<5; <64 :551 5H6>?154 69 9# 614 " 35985D7?@5B; 9?>?B63 5@?451D5 F69 6B92 4582954 :; 7<5> ?1 7<5 58637>5176B 1IA?3; 1 9AD<D?3DA>9761D597<521.:B585H2A37?17<5D6952E( ) 35823754 ?1 *"#"+& $ $,' <5B4?18636C368<2%+69A1453 >",3 " "" G H* /7 I , 0&/ '/&:?0 " " " J "" G 0&/'/&:?' % "" "" 4 " " " 8 C J 801&79& ))-:,D801&79& ))8)9-;;D801&79 & ))8(E 900:F9< - 17 - #" 51D5 688B;?1C 7<5 E?14?1C9 2E 7<5 21.:B5 85H 2A37 69 51A>536754 9A836 72 7<5 E6D79 614 D?3DA>9761D59 2E 7<?9D695F5635A16:B5726DD5877<5D217517?212E7<5B563154 D2A195B E23 3598214517 2%)2=6;A=76 7<67 7<5 6A7<23?7; <69 832@54 7<5 D<63C59 B5@5BB54 6C6?197 7<5 857?7?2153 F?7< 83582145361D5 614 832:6:?B?7; 23 7<5 E235C2?1C 4?9DA99?219 F56352E7<5@?5F7<677<53?:A16B<6953354F<?B535G5D7?1C 7<5688B?D67?21E?B54:;7<5857?7?2153:;D21E?3>?1C7<5234532E 7<5E?3973598214517DD234?1CB;?1753E5351D5?935IA?354?17<5 ?>8AC154 23453 869954 :; 7<5 3?:A16B 1 7<67 @?5F 2E 7<5 >67753F5619F537<582?1736?9546:2@5?17<515C67?@5614 832D5547286997<5E2BB2F?1C ? <53?7 57?7?21?9- ?? <5 23453 869954 :; 7<5 3?:A16B ?1 88B?D67?212%$"# %$%$46754%-$"%$%# ?9957)69?45 ??? 2195IA517B; 7<5 23453 869954 :; 7<5 E?397 3598214517 46754 %##%$%$ ?1 2@531>517 3453 :563?1C 2 % - %$# ?9 IA69<54 - 18 - ?@ <5 E?397 3598214517 ?9 4?35D754 72 35?197675 7<5857?7?2153F?7<?17F2>217<9E32>7<54675 2E35D5?@?1C7<5D537?E?54D28;2E7<?923453614 5H7514 6BB 7<5 953@?D5 614 >215763; :515E?79 72<?> 563154D2A195BE237<5857?7?21539A:>?77547<677<2AC< 61?1753?>23453?9285367?1C5@539?1D5E32>% ##%$%#7<5 6A7<23?7; <69 E6?B54 72 35?197675 7<5 857?7?2153 B563154 2@531>517 64@2D675 9A:>?7754 7<67 7<5 857?7?2153 ?9 127517?7B547235D5?@586;E237<5853?24E23F<?D<9<5<69127 F23=54 21 7<5 83?1D?8B5 2E K12 F23= 12 86;. 2F5@53 :; D219?453?1C7<585DAB?63E6D79614D?3DA>9761D52E7<5D6957<5 6A7<23?7;?94?35D7547286;%N2E7<596B63;727<5857?7?2153 E32>% ##%$%#7?BB<5335)?197675>517 "+, (""! # ') $ "+, ($" ) $ ?972#B2-