Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12486 (KAR)
BALASAHEBGOUDA S/O SAHEBGOUDA PATIL @ BIRADAR AND ORS v. NINGAMMA W/O DUNDAPPA BIRADAR @ PATIL AND ORS
WP/202191/2021 · 2025-01-08
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12486 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12486 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%" "
&% ' ( )&% '
(
!"
#
$
!"
% ! & # '(
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
#
& # ! !" $)*
+
&
+, ! !" $)*
&
#$ ! !" $)*
!"
++
!" $)*
)
& )*
!" $)*
,
)+
!" $)*
$
*
!" $)*
-
,
- 3 -
!" $)*
*
$*
!" $)*
%
! !(
# . !(
. )* ! . ! **#*#+
#
!( /
(
##, ( (
(
! 0 (
*,#*#* )
!"
"(
##* (
"
(
! ( ##*
)
&
)
!" $)*
#
)
- 4 -
!" $)*
+
!" $)*
$
!" $)*
% ! & 0 #
'
#
&
+ ! 1
!" $)*)
+
&
+$ ! 1
!" $)*)
&
+ !1
!"
!"
+
!" $)*)
- 5 -
%
! !(
# . !(
. # ! (
. ! #*#*#. ! *,*#*# ! ( )$
(
##, ( (
(
! 0 (
*,#*#* !"
"(
##* ( " (
!( ##*
(
2'
)
)
!" $)*)
,
-
!" $)*)
$
,)
!" $)*)
- 6 -
3 " "
4565758698:/;986+<8/##*=586<8> :?<9@ A57/?5 :45 58</? <B<@ "C6>5 986 "( 9;9B989 9>5D96< 458E57/?:4 ?575??56 :/ 9; 2:45 ?<9@ /C?:' 49B5 7<@56
/#**)+#*# E49@@58><8> 98 /?65? 69:56 *,#*#* AF D4<E4 :45<? 9==@<E9:</8 /) 7<@56 C865? ?65? ! C@5 , /7 :45 /65 /7 <B<@ ?/E56C?5 -*$ 7/? ;4/?:2':/9G586:45<?D?<::58;:9:5G58::/<8E/?=/?9:59 E/C8:5?E@9<GD9;?5H5E:56
# 45 65758698: /; :/ ) 986 $ <8
/##* =586<8> :?<9@ A57/?5 :45 58</? <B<@ "C6>5 986
"( 9;9B989 9>5D96< 49B5 7<@56 /#*#-#*# E49@@58><8> 98 /?65? 69:56 *,#*#* AF D4<E4 :45<? 9==@<E9:</8/,7<@56C865??65?! C@5,/7:/ 9G586 :45 D?<::58 ;:9:5G58: :/ <8E/?=/?9:5 9 E/C8:5? E@9<G D9;?5H5E:56
+ 45 ;C<: <8 /##* D9; 7<@56 7/? 65E@9?9:</8 /7 :<:@5 /7 :45 =@9<8:<77; :/ :45 ;C<: @986; 986 7/? ?5E/B5?F/7:45;9G57?/G:4565758698:;
- 7 -
45 =@9<8:<77; E@9<G56 :49: :45 ;C<: @986; A5@/8>56 :/ :45<? =?565E5;;/? 986 :49: :45<? =?565E5;;/? 496 58>9>56 6<;:98: ?5@9:<B5; 7/? EC@:<B9:</8 /7 :45 ;9G5 =?</? :/ :45 F59? -$*45FE/8:58656:49::<@@:45659:4/7:45<?=?565E5;;/? :45<??5@9:<B5D9;;49?<8>:45E?/=>?/D8<8:45;C<:@986;986 @9:5? D458 :45 =@9<8:<77; ;:9?:56 B<;<:<8> :45 ;C<: @986; :45 65758698:; ?57C;56 :/ ;49?5 :45 =?/6CE5 >?/D8 <8 :45 ;C<: @986;45=@9<8:<77;:45?57/?5;/C>4:7/?9?5@<57/765E@9?9:</8 /7:45<?:<:@5:/:45;C<:@986;9867/??5E/B5?F/7=/;;5;;</8/7 :45;9G57?/G:4565758698:;
5758698: /; 986 + 7<@56 9 D?<::58 ;:9:5G58: 658F<8>:45E@9<G/7:45=@9<8:<77;45F9@;/658<56:49::45 =?565E5;;/?/7:45=@9<8:<7749658>9>56:45<?=?565E5;;/?7/? EC@:<B9:</8/7:45;C<:@986;45FE@9<G56:49::45=?565E5;;/?
/7 :45 =@9<8:<77; D9; 5IE@C656 7?/G :45 =/;;5;;</8 /7 :45 ;C<:
@986; 7?/G :45 F59? -$* D4<E4 D9; D<:4<8 :45 J8/D@56>5 /7 :45=@9<8:<77/9865B5?F/85<8:45B<@@9>545?57/?5:45F E/8:58656 :49: :45 65758698: /;+ 986 ) 496 =5?75E:56 :45<?:<:@5:/:45;C<:@986;AFD9F/796B5?;5=/;;5;;</8
- 8 -
) <G<@9?@F 65758698: /; :/ ) 986 $ 7<@56 9 ;5=9?9:5D?<::58;:9:5G58:?5<:5?9:<8>:45E/8:58:</8;C?>56AF :4565758698:/;986+<8:45<?D?<::58;:9:5G58:
, 9;56/8:45;5E/8:58:</8;<;;C5;D5?57?9G56AF :45?<9@/C?:986:45;C<:D9;;5:6/D87/?:?<9@ 458:45 ;C<: D9; ;5: 6/D8 7/? :45 5B<658E5 /7 :45 65758698:; :D/ 9==@<E9:</8;89G5@F/)986/,D5?57<@56AF:45 65758698:/;986+9;D5@@9;65758698:/;:/)986$ ?5;=5E:<B5@F:/9G586:45<?D?<::58;:9:5G58::/<8E/?=/?9:59 E/C8:5? E@9<G; 7/? 65E@9?9:</8 :49: :45F 496 =5?75E:56 :45<? :<:@5 :/ :45 @986; <8 /)* 986 /)*# G59;C?<8> * 9E?5; +$ >C8:9; 986 *$ 9E?5; ?5;=5E:<B5@F ;<:C9:59:/G989@9>5D96<:9@CJ986D4<E47/?G56=9?:/7 :45 ;C<: @986; AF D9F /7 96B5?;5 =/;;5;;</8 45 ;9<6 9==@<E9:</8;D5?5E/8:5;:56AF:45=@9<8:<77;/8:45>?/C86:49: :45;9G5D5?57<@56@/8>97:5?<;;C5;D5?57?9G56AF:45?<9@ /C?:98697:5?:45;C<:D9;;5:6/D87/?5B<658E545F9@;/ E@9<G56:49::4565758698:;4969@?596FE@9<G56:49::45F496 =5?75E:56:45<?:<:@5AFD9F/796B5?;5=/;;5;;</8<8?5;=5E:/7 ;/G5/7:45;C<:@986;986:45?57/?5:45?5D9;8/8556:/7<@5
- 9 -
9==@<E9:</8; :/ 9G586 :45 D?<::58 ;:9:5G58: :/ G9J5 9 E/C8:5?E@9<G
$ 45?<9@/C?:97:5?E/8;<65?<8>:45E/8:58:</8;/7 :45=@9<8:<77;986:4565758698:/;986+986:/)986$ ?5H5E:56 :45 9==@<E9:</8; /;) 986 , <8 :5?G; /7 :45 <G=C>856 /?65? /8 :45 >?/C86 :49: 9 E/C8:5? E@9<G <;
=5?G<;;<A@5 A57/?5 <;;C5; 9?5 ;5::@56 <8 :45 ;C<: 986 /8@F <8 5IE5=:</89@E<?ECG;:98E5;:45/C?:E/C@65I5?E<;5HC?<;6<E:</8 :/9@@/D9E/C8:5?E@9<G97:5?<;;C5;9?5;5::@56:9@;/45@6 :49:9@@/D<8>:459G586G58::/:45D?<::58;:9:5G58:;D/C@6 E498>5:4589:C?5/7:4565758E5?9<;56AF:45;9<665758698:; <8:45<??5;=5E:<B5D?<::58;:9:5G58:
- 5<8>9>>?<5B56AF:45;9<6/?65?65758698:/; 986+65758698:/;:/)986$9?5A57/?5:4<;/C?:<8 /#**)+#*#986 /#*#-#*#?5;=5E:<B5@F
* 45 @59?856 E/C8;5@ 7/? :45 65758698: /#?5;=/8658:/<8A/:4:45=5:<:</8;E/8:58656:49::45 @9D9;<:;://6D458:4565758698:/;986+98665758698:
/; :/ ) 986 $ 7<@56 :45<? ?5;=5E:<B5 D?<::58 ;:9:5G58: D9;
:49: :45F E/C@6 =@596 96B5?;5 =/;;5;;</8 :/ 8/8;C<: :45
- 10 -
=@9<8:<77; /D5B5? <8 B<5D /7 :45 HC6>G58: /7 :45 /8'A@5 =5I/C?:<8:45E9;5/7 !"
#$% &'9E@9<G7/? 96B5?;5=/;;5;;</8E/C@6A58/DC;569;9;D/?645?57/?5 45E/8:586;:49::4565758698:/;986+986:/)986$ D5?5 58:<:@56 :/ ;55J 7/? E/C8:5? E@9<G; 986 :4<; A5<8> 98 5IE5=:</89@ E<?ECG;:98E5 :45 ?<9@ /C?: GC;: 49B5 9@@/D56 :4565758698:/;986+98665758698:/;:/)986$:/ ;55J7/?E/C8:5?E@9<G;
5? E/8:?9 :45 @59?856 E/C8;5@ 7/? :45 =@9<8:<77 /;# :/ ?5;=/8658: /;# :/ <8 A/:4 :45 =5:<:</8; E/8:58656:49::4565758698:/;986+98665758698:/; :/)986$49B59@?596F?9<;569E@9<G/796B5?;5=/;;5;;</8 <8 :45<? ?5;=5E:<B5 D?<::58 ;:9:5G58: 5 ;CAG<:; :49: <7 :45 65758698:; 9?5 9A@5 :/ 5;:9A@<;4 :49: :45<? =/;;5;;</8 496 A5E/G596B5?;5:/:45?<>4::<:@5986<8:5?5;:/7:45=@9<8:<77; :458:49:D/C@6;C77<E5986:45?5<;8/85567/?:4565758698:; :/G9J59E/C8:5?E@9<G7/?65E@9?9:</8/7:45<?:<:@5<8?5;=5E: /7;/G5/7:45;C<:@986;AFD9F/796B5?;5=/;;5;;</8
- 11 -
# 49B5 E/8;<65?56 :45 ;CAG<;;</8; /7 :45 @59?856 E/C8;5@7/?:45=@9<8:<77/;#:/986:45@59?856E/C8;5@7/? :4565758698:/#
+ 4565758698:/;986+98665758698:/;:/ ) 986 $ <8 :45<?
?5;=5E:<B5 977<69B<: 9EE/G=98F<8> :45 9==@<E9:</8 /;) 986 , 496 E9:5>/?<E9@@F G58:</856 :49: :45 /8'A@5=5I/C?:49665E@9?56:49::45?5@<57/7E/C8:5?E@9<G E/C@6 9@;/ A5 E@9<G56 9; 9 G9<8 ?5@<57 65=9?:<8> 7?/G :45 59?@<5? B<5D :49: <: E/C@6 A5 ?9<;56 9; 9 65758E5 <8 9 ;C<: 7/? =9?:<:</8
49B5=5?C;56:45D?<::58;:9:5G58:;7<@56AF:45 65758698:/;986+98665758698:/;:/)986$D4<E4 ;4/D:49::45;9<665758698:;496<86556:9J58965758E5:49: :45F496=5?75E:56:45<?:<:@5:/;/G5/7:45;C<:@986;AFD9F /7 96B5?;5 =/;;5;;</8 ; ?<>4:@F E/8:58656 AF :45 @59?856 E/C8;5@ 7/? :45 65758698: /# <8 B<5D /7 :45 E498>5 <8 :45 =/;<:</8 /7 @9D :45 65758698: /; 986 + 986 :/ ) 986 $ D5?5 58:<:@56 :/ ;55J 7/? E/C8:5? E@9<G; :49: :45F 496 =5?75E:56:45<?:<:@5<8?5;=5E:/7;/G5/7:45;C<:@986;AFD9F /796B5?;5=/;;5;;</84<;A5<8>985IE5=:</89@E<?ECG;:98E5
- 12 -
:45?<9@/C?:GC;:49B59@@/D56:4565758698:/;986+ 98665758698:/;:/)986$:/?9<;5E/C8:5?E@9<G;9;:49: D/C@67C@@F986E/8E@C;<B5@F65:5?G<85:456<;=C:5A5:D558:45 =9?:<5;9869@;/9B/<6GC@:<=@<E<:F/7=?/E556<8>;
8 :49: B<5D /7 :45 G9::5? /#**)+#*# 986 /#*#-#*# 9?5 986 :45 <G=C>856 /?65?69:56*,#*#* =9;;56AF :45 58</? <B<@ "C6>5 986
"( 9;9B989 9>5D96< <8 /##* ?5H5E:<8> :45 9==@<E9:</8; 89G5@F /;) 986 , 7<@56 AF :45 65758698: /; 986 + =5:<:</85?; <8 /#**)+#*# 986 65758698: /; :/ ) 986 $ =5:<:</85?; <8
/#*#-#*# ?5;=5E:<B5@F 7/? 9G586G58: /7 :45<? ?5;=5E:<B5D?<::58;:9:5G58::/<8E/?=/?9:5:45E/C8:5?E@9<G; <;;5:9;<6545;9<69==@<E9:</8;9?59@@/D564565758698: /;986+98665758698:/;:/)986$9?5=5?G<::56:/ 9G586:45<??5;=5E:<B5D?<::58;:9:5G58:<8/##* 986<8E/?=/?9:5:45E/C8:5?E@9<G;:<;/=587/?:45=@9<8:<77 /;#:/:/7<@59D?<::58;:9:5G58::/:45E/C8:5?E@9<G;<7 :45F9?5;/96B<;56
- 13 -
) <8E5 :45 ;C<: <; 7<@56 <8 :45 F59? #* :45 ?<9@ /C?:<;?5KC5;:56:/6<;=/;5/77:45;C<:L/##*9; 59?@F9;=/;;<A@59:98F?9:5D<:4<89=5?</6/7/85F59?7?/G :4569:5/7?5E5<=:/79E5?:<7<56E/=F/7:4<;/?65? *(
&"'
"
<;:/@/,