- 1 - !!" # $ $ %%&' ( ) * ! "# $ $%&#!'! ( ( ( $%&#!'! () !$ !*'!' + Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ( !,! ( + ( + !','' ( $- !%#%'!% ( ( + . $ . ! /012 3/014/2 56748/3 099/01:4; <61 =>/ 099/3304=$9/=:=:64/1 042 3/014/2 56748/3 099/01:4; <61 1/89642/4=6$4871045/6?904@ /:4; 0;;1:/A/2 B@ =>/ C72;?/4= 042 0D012 20=/2 !','' 9088/2 :4 6!%#%'!% B@ =>/ 22:=:6403 :8=1:5= 042 /88:648 72;/ 042 /?B/1 $ !, :C0@09710 <61 8>61= E=>/ 1:B7403F =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 :8 B/<61/ =>:8 671= :4 099/03 8//G:4; /4>045/?/4= 6< =>/ 56?9/480=:64 - 3 - , >/ 9/=:=:64/1 564=/42/2 =>0= 64 ,!''!" D>:3/>/D08D03G:4;64=>/3/<=?01;:46<=>/16020=42: =>/ 21:A/1 6< =>/ A/>:53/ B/01:4; 6$&$,#&& 50?/ <16?=>/8:2/6< :1/17;: :330;/042208>/2=6=>/9/=:=:64/1 08 0 1/873= 9/=:=:64/1 878=0:4/2 :4C71:/8 / 178>/2 =6 6A/14?/4= 689:=03<61<:18=0:2042=>/4=66G=1/0=?/4=0= 689:=03 :C0@09710 <61 !! 20@8 4 =>/ 80:2 055:2/4==>/9/=:=:64/1>02878=0:4/2<105=71/6<=>/530A:53/ 042:4C71@=6=>/0B26?/41/873=:4;:420?0;/=6=>/893//4 042=>/1/0<=/1893//4/5=6?@D08264/64=/42:4;=>0=>/ >0887<</1/29/1?04/4=2:80B:3:=@=>/9/=:=:64/10991605>/2 =>/ 1:B7403<6102/H70=/56?9/480=:64 " >/ 9/=:=:64 D08 1/8:8=/2 B@ =>/ 4871045/ 6?904@564=/42:4;=>0==>/56?9/480=:64530:?/2:8>:;>3@ /I61B:=04=:?0;:401@042=>0==>/1/D/1/A:630=:6486<=/1?8 0425642:=:6486<=>/963:5@/89642/4=6!$6D4/16<=>/ A/>:53/2:246=564=/8= >/9/=:=:64/1/I0?:4/2>:?8/3<08 +!042065=61D>6088/88/2=>/2:80B:3:=@08+042 ?01G/2 =>/ 2657?/4=8 0= I8! =6 !, >/ 569@ 6< =>/ - 4 - 963:5@D08?01G/208I!B7=466103/A:2/45/D083/02 64B/>03<6<1/89642/4=6 % >/ 1:B7403 0<=/1 >/01:4; B6=> =>/ 901=:/8 >08 0D012/256?9/480=:64742/12:<</1/4=>/02808B/36D # >/ 3/014/2 56748/3 099/01:4; <61 =>/ 099/3304= 87B?:=8=>0==>/ 1:B7403>08<0:3/2=65648:2/1=>/2:80B:3:=@ 6< =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 =>67;> =>/ +$65=61 >02 8=0=/2 =>0= =>/1/ :8 2:80B:3:=@6< !J 64 055674= 6< =>/ <105=71/ 6< =>/ 530A:53/042!%J 64055674=6<=>/ :4C71@=6=>/0B26?/4 =:887B?:==/2=>0=2:80B:3:=@D0846=0=0335648:2/1/2B@=>/ 1:B7403 042 =>/1/<61/ =>/ 56?9/480=:64 4//28 =6 B/ 1/088/88/2 /026<530:? D012 ! (61=>/:4C71:/804290:4 04287<</1:4; 8&''''$ 6886<:456?/271:4;=>/ =1/0=?/4=0421/8=:4; 9/1:62 8!&'''$ , /2:503:338 8!*#$ " 671:8>?/4=K 1048961=0=:64 8''''$ % (612:8<:;710=:64 8''''$ +,- ."/"/0& - 5 - 3/014/2 56748/3 099/01:4; <61 1/89642/4=6$4871045/6?904@2/</428=>/C72;?/4= 564=/42:4;=>0==>/1/01/462:85/14:B3/:4C71:/8D>:5>D6732 1/873=:402:80B:3:=@ & >/9/=:=:64/1530:?:4;>:?8/3<=6B/26:4; 6=/3 78:4/88 0;/2 0B67= ! @/018 8=0=/8 =>0= >/ >08 87<</1/2 =>/ 2:80B:3:=@ 64 055674= 6< =>/ <105=71/ 6< =>/ 530A:53/ 042 36886<893//4 >/+088=0=/20B6A/>08088/88/2=>/ 2:80B:3:=@ 0= !J 042 !%J 1/89/5=:A/3@ >/ + 0386 8=0=/8 =>0= =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 <1/H7/4=3@ 87<</18 <16? </A/1 042 3668/ ?6=:64 6D/A/1 =>/ =/8=:?64@ 6< + 26/8 46= 51/0=/04@4/I78B/=D//4=>/893//4/5=6?@042=>/0B6A/ 2:856?<61=8D>:5>01/8=0=/2B@>:? * 501/<73 088/88?/4= 6< =>/ 0A650=:64 6< =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 08 0 9/1864 1744:4; =>/ >6=/3 D:=> =>/ 2:80B:3:=@ 56793/2D:=>=>/2:856?<61=8<05/2B@>:?64055674=6<3688 6< 893//4 D>:5> 1/873=8 :4 2/93/=/2 :??74:=@ := D6732 B/ C78=0429169/1=6>632=>/2:80B:3:=@0=%J - 6 - !' >/ ;7:2/3:4/8 :887/2 B@ =>/ 0140=0G0 =0=/ /;03 /1A:5/8 7=>61:=@ <61 8/==3/?/4= 6< =>/ 2:897=/8B/<61/=>/6G2030=91/851:B/=>/46=:6403:456?/ 6< 8%''$ <61 =>/ @/01 '!" 4 7?9=//4 47?B/1 6< 2/5:8:648 =>:8 671= >08 >/32 =>0= =>/ ;7:2/3:4/8 :887/2 B@ 01/>/32=6B/055/9=0B3/64=>/;16742=>0==>/@01/ :4 ;/4/103 564<61?:=@ D:=> =>/ ?:4:?7? D0;/8 <:I/2742/1 =>/:4:?7?+0;/85= >/1/<61/=>/46=:6403:456?/6< =>/9/=:=:64/1:8055/9=/2088%''$9/1?64=> !! >/1/<61/ =>/ 3688 6< :456?/ 27/=6 2:80B:3:=@ :8 5035730=/2088%''$I!I!&I%JL8&!'''$ ! 648/H7/4=3@ =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 :8 /4=:=3/2 <61 56?9/480=:64742/1=>/>/02836886<:456?/271:4;30:279 9/1:62 <61 =D6 ?64=>8 D>:5> /H7038 =6 8%''$ I 8!%'''$ 08 0;0:48= 8!&'''$ 0D012/2 B@ =>/ 1:B7403 !, >/ 1:B7403 >08 0D012/2 0 87? 6< 8&''''$ =6D0128:4C71@90:404287<</1:4;8:45/=>/9/=:=:64/1>08 - 7 - B//40D012/202/H70=/56?9/480=:64742/1=>/>/0236886< <7=71/ :456?/ =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 :8 /4=:=3/2 <61 8"''''$ =6D0128 90:4 042 87<</1:4; 08 0;0:48= 8&''''$ 0D012/2 B@=>/ 1:B74036<0108=>/36886<0?/4:=:/8:85645/14/2 =>/ 1:B7403 >08 46= 0D012/2 04@56?9/480=:64 =>/1/<61/ 5648:2/1:4;=>/<05==>0==>/1/:82:8<:;710=:6408D/33083688 6< 893//4 D>:5> >/ >08 =6 87<</1 =:33 308= B1/0=> 6< >:8 3:</ =>/1/<61/ := D6732 B/ C78= 042 9169/1 =6 0D012 0 87? 6< 8"''''$742/1=>:8>/02 !" >/ 56?9/480=:64 0D012/2 742/1 =>/ >/02 6< ?/2:503 /I9/48/8 =1048961=0=:64 4671:8>?/4= /=5 :45372:4; =>/ 0==/4204=F8 5>01;/8 26 46= 1/H7:1/ 04@ :4=/1</1/45/ !% 55612:4;3@ =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 :8 /4=:=3/2 <61 0 =6=03 56?9/480=:6408B/36D 3 6 /02 D012 B@ =>/ 1:B7403 D012B@=>:8 671= ! 688 6< <7=71/ :456?/ 27/ =6 2:80B:3:=@ $$ 8&!'''$ 0:404287<</1:4;8 8&''''$ 8"''''$ - 8 - , /2:503/I9/48/8 8!*#$ 8!*#$ " 688 6< :456?/ 271:4; 30:2 79 9/1:62 8!&'''$ 8!%'''$ % 6886<0?/4:=:/8:4 3:</ $$ 8"''''$ # :8<:;710=:64 8''''$ $$ # 671:8>?/4= 042 1048961=0=:64 8''''$ 8''''$ 8!%**#$ 8!*#$ /880D012B@=>/ 1:B7403 8!%**#$ 4>045/?/4= 8%&'''$ !# /45/=>/<6336D:4; : >/099/03:80336D/2:4901=) :: >/ :?97;4/2 C72;?/4= 042 0D012 9088/2 B@ =>/ 1:B7403 :8 >/1/B@ ?62:<:/2 >/9/=:=:64/1:8/4=:=3/2<610 87?6<8%&'''$0856?9/480=:64:4 022:=:64 =6 D>0= >08 B//4 0D012/2 B@ =>/ 1:B7403 0364; D:=> :4=/1/8= 0= =>/ 10=/6<#J90<16?=>/20=/6<9/=:=:64 =:33:=82/968:=B/<61/=>/ 1:B7403 - 9 - ::: >/ 1/8= 6< =>/ =/1?8 042 5642:=:648 1/;012:4; 2/968:= 042 /=5 612/1/2 B@ =>/ 1:B74031/?0:47403=/1/2 :A /89642/4=6M4871045/6?904@ :8 2:1/5=/2 =6 2/968:= =>/ /4>045/2 56?9/480=:64 0?674= D:=> :4=/1/8= D:=>:4 <671 D//G8 <16? =>/ 20=/ 6< =>/ 1/5/:9=6<=>/569@6<=>:8C72;?/4= 2$ ' $ ) $ :8=6!36&