Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12475 (KAR)
SHANKAR S/O BHIMARAY AGASAR v. RAMESH AND ANR
MFA/201698/2021 · 2025-02-11
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12475 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12475 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
#$ $
%
! "
# ! !"$%
"$% & ' (
%%!!!!"
!!! $ % %
#! )! ! "$% &
%! %
! %! #
* +*# ! &* (
! %! !" , &"! ! ! !#
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% !%! '- . ' ! $%! ! # ! ! ! /
! *
%
!! " $%! ! . "$%
"$% ! ! !$%! !# ! * *&
! %
! ! $%! #! "
! %!
0
$% $
$ 0
$% $
12341 516 785569 -: :;856< =29 8<7-::-2> ?-51 516 @2>:6>5 2= A251 516 B895-6: -5 -: 58C6> 3B =29 =->8; <-:B2:8;
16:1295B2->5=29@2>:-<6985-2>A6=29651-:2395 -: ?165169 516 277-::-2>69 ?8: D3:5-=-6< -> 58C->4 516 ?846:2=5168BB6;;8>585 :'&512341516>25-=-@85-2> -::36< AE 516 6>598; 2F69>76>5 3><69 6@5-2> *& B96:@9-A6:5167->-737?846:85 :&B6972>51
- 3 -
'
16B65-5-2>69@;8-76<518516?8:67B;2E6<8:8 <9-F69 2> 8 593@C A689->4 2&&/' 2?>6< AE 96:B2><6>528><->:396<AE96:B2><6>528><16?8:
689>->4 8 :8;89E 2= :*& B69 72>51 > / ?16>16?8:5E->492B68A2F6;28<2>516593@C16:;-BB6< 8><=6;;<2?>8><:3==696<592@18>569-@=98@53962==67398>< :3@1 ->D39E A6->4 :3==696< AE 1-7 <39->4 516 @239:6 2= 516 67B;2E76>5 96:B2><6>5 2: 8>< 896 ;-8A;6 52 B8E 516 @27B6>:85-2> 52 1-7 :->@6 -5 18< 2@@3996<<39->4516 3:6 2=516F61-@;6 6:B2><6>52<-<>258BB689A6=296516 ;689>6< 277-::-2>69 52 @2>56:5 516 B65-5-2> 2?6F69 96:B2><6>52@2>56:56<516:876=56959-8;516;689>6< 277-::-2>6916;<518551696A6->4>2:3==-@-6>578569-8;52 12;< 516 ->@276 2= 516 B65-5-2>69 52 A6 :*& B69 72>51168::6::6<516:87685 :'&B6972>518>< 8?89<6< 8 @27B6>:85-2> 2= :*''& AE @2>:-<69->4 516 <-:8A-;-5E85G
- 4 -
*
16 8BB6;;8>5 @2>56><: 5185 516 277-::-2>69 :123;<18F658C6>516?846:2=516B65-5-2>6985 :& ->F-6?2=516>25-=-@85-2>-::36<AE5166>598;2F69>76>5 3><696@5-2>*&2=516
7B;2E66:27B6>:85-2>@5
;689>6< @23>:6; 8BB689->4 =29 96:B2><6>5 2 & >:398>@6 27B8>E :3A7-5: 5185 ?16> 516B65-5-2>691-7:6;=18<@;8-76<516->@27685 :*& B69 72>51 >2 =83;5 @8> A6 =23>< ?-51 516 ;689>6< 277-::-2>69 -> 8::6::->4 516 ?846: 85 :'& B69 72>51
8F->4 1689< 516 ;689>6< @23>:6; 8BB689->4 =29 516B895-6:18F6B693:6<51678569-8;2>96@29<
/ 5 -: B695->6>5 52 >256 5185 516 B92F-:-2>: 2= 6@5-2>*&2=516
7B;2E66:27B6>:85-2>@5=29:1295 H516
@5.@2>567B;856:8>25-=-@85-2>52A6-::36<AE516 2F69>76>52=><-8=9275-76525-76=-I->4516?846:=29 516 B39B2:6 2= @27B35->4 516 @27B6>:85-2> 3><69 516 B92F-:-2>: 2= 516
@5 16 2AD6@5 2= :3@1 >25-=-@85-2> A6->4 -::36< 3><69 6@5-2> *& -: 52 6>:396 5185 516
- 5 -
?846: 896 52 A6 -> @2>:2>8>@6 ?-51 516 7->-737 ?846:
8BB;-@8A;6 3><69 516 B92F-:-2>:2=516 ->-737 #846: @5
16->-737#846:@5B96:@9-A6:516?846:A8:6<2>516 :C-;;;6F6;:8><-5<-==69:=9272>68968528>25169>29<69 522AF-856516@27B;-@85-2>:2=@27B35->4:3@1?846:3><69 516 ->-737 #846: @5 A8:6< 2> 516 :C-;; ;6F6;: 8>< 516 8968 2= 516 ?29C 516 6>598; 2F69>76>5 -: 67B2?696< 3><69 6@5-2> *& 52 >25-=E 516 ?846: > 25169 ?29<: 5167->-737?846:B96:@9-A6<3><696@5-2>*&-:52A6 8BB;-6<6F6>512341516@;8-72951684966<?846:A65?66> 516 B895-6:-:;6::518> 516 >25-=-6<?846: 1696=296-5 -:
>25 B92B69 =29 516 ;689>6< 277-::-2>69 52 96<3@6 516 ?846: 6F6> A6;2?
516 2>6 ?1-@1 -: 8<7-556< AE 516 B65-5-2>696>@6516;689>6<277-::-2>6918:6996<->>25 8@@6B5->4516?846:>25-=-6<3><696@5-2>*&2=516 @5>51696:3;5516@27B6>:85-2>18:52A68::6::6<AE 58C->4516?846:85 :&B6972>518:>25-=-6<AE516 6>598; 2F69>76>5 -> 516 E689 2>:6J36>5;E 516 @27B6>:85-2> -: 96@8;@3;856< 8: G 2= :& K :*&IGI*K//&
- 6 -
>8<<-5-2>5251-:@27B6>:85-2>516B65-5-2>69-:
8;:26>5-5;6<=2976<-@8;6IB6>:6:2= :/&?1-@1896 8: B69 516 76<-@8; A-;;: <65697->6< AE 516 ;689>6< 277-::-2>69 @@29<->4;E 516 B65-5-2>69 -: 6>5-5;6< =29 5258;@27B6>:85-2>2= ://&L/& ://&
16<-==696>@68723>5?-;;A6//M*'' :*'& 6>@6516=2;;2?->4 ! -
168BB68;-:8;;2?6<->B895
--
16B65-5-2>69-:6>5-5;6<=29<-==696>@6 8723>5 2= :*'& ?-51 ->5696:5 85 G B69 8>>37 =927 '51 <8E 2= 516 <856 2= 8@@-<6>5 5-;; 516B8E76>5A6=296516277-::-2>696I@;3<->4 ->5696:5 =29 '* <8E: 516 <6;8E @83:6< -> =-;->4 5168BB68;8:B6951629<69<856< -> 8<<-5-2> 52 ?185 18: A66> 8?89<6< AE 516
9-A3>8;
<& &$ ' $
-:52;2