- 1 - !"! # $ %"!& $ %"" ##' ( ! "# $ %&&% ' (& & # # # % # ( )!!! (# # )!!! # (# * ) ! & (( * ) ! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # * ## ) ! # * ) ! " # $ &+ ( , - %' ## ( ( & & # % ## # !! # . + # !! /!/! # # 0( # ( ## # 0& !!!(## # # !! ( ## # (+ * ## ( + % 1+ % 1+ + & - 3 - "% $#1+ %' 23 455366478 92: 94; 823 538<8<:73= >3?:=3 823 634=73@ <7A63 +B@A3 24; C246637A3@ 823 :=@3= @483@ /!/! 54;;3@ <7 #: !! 923=3>D C246637A3 8: 823 :=@3= 48 773EB=3F(. @483@ /!/! C4G38:>3=3H3C83@ 7 83=G; :? 773EB=3F(. 823 =3;5:7@378 B82:=<8<3;7:8<C3@8248823538<8<:73=.;?4823=24@@<3@:7 !/47@2394;=3IB<=3@8:;B>G<88234556<C48<:7 9<82<7 :73 D34= :? 4884<7<7A G4H:=<8D :93J3= 4; 823 4556<C48<:794;?<63@:76D:7!/!!!<34?83=645;3:? 4>:B8 ! D34=; 823 4556<C48<:7 C4G3 8: >3 =3H3C83@ 8 94;?B=823=236@8248<783=G;:?82337@:=;3G3788248823 3E837@3@ 53=<:@ ?:= ?<6<7A 4556<C48<:7 >3<7A 4 :73 8<G3 G34;B=394;46;:7:84556<C4>63<7823C4;3:?538<8<:73= 23 ?4C8; G4@3 :B8 4=3 8248 823 538<8<:73=.; ?4823= 94; 9:=K<7A 4; 4 C2::6 34C23= 9<82 =3;5:7@378 - 4 - :92<C2<;4G<7:=<8D 7;8<8B8<:747@;B>H3C88:4<@>D 823:J3=7G37847@23@<3@:7!/ 8<;;B>G<883@8248823538<8<:73=.;G:823=A4J3 4 =35=3;37848<:7 8: 823 =3;5:7@378 B82:=<8D 4; 48 773EB=3F. :7 /!/ ;33K<7A 455:<78G378 ?:= 23= G<7:= ;:7 9237 23 4884<7; G4H:=<8D 8 <; ?B=823= ;B>G<883@ 8248 823 538<8<:73= 4884<73@ G4H:=<8D :7 !!!!!47@A4J34=35=3;37848<:7:7!!!?:= 455:<78G378 :7 C:G54;;<:7483 A=:B7@; 8: 823 474A<7A :GG<8833 8 <; 823 C4;3 :? 823 538<8<:73= 8248 >D :8<?<C48<:7 @483@ !!!/ &4=7484K4 @BC48<:746 7;8<8B8<:7; L3C=B<8G378 47@ 3=G; 47@ :7@<8<:7; :? ;3=J<C3 :? 3G56:D33;. <7 #=<J483 <@3@ #=<G4=D 47@ 3C:7@4=D @BC48<:746 7;8<8B8<:7;M LG37@G378M B63; !! 93=3 G4@3 4556<C4>63 8: #=<J483 <@3@ :663A3; 4; =3A4=@; 455:<78G378 :7 C:G54;;<:7483 A=:B7@; 47@ >D J<=8B3 :? <78=:@BC8<:7 :? ;BC2 B63; 823 538<8<:73= 94; 36<A<>638:C64<G>373?<8:?C:7;<@3=48<:7:?2<;4556<C48<:7 - 5 - ?:= 455:<78G378 :7 C:G54;;<:7483 A=:B7@; 8 <; 46;: ;B>G<883@824882337@:=;3G37848773EB=3F(.<;7:8<7 83=G;:?B63;!!/ 23 634=73@ <7A63 +B@A3 B5:7 4 @384<63@ C:7;<@3=48<:7 24; =3H3C83@ 823 538<8<:7 92<63 :>;3=J<7A 8248 823 C64<G ?:= C:G54;;<:7483 455:<78G378 C:B6@ 7:8 24J3 >337 C:7;<@3=3@ 48 823 5:<78 :? 8<G3 9237 823 538<8<:794;?<63@4;823?4G<6D:?823@3C34;3@3G56:D33 24@ ;B=J<J3@ 9<82:B8 ;:B=C3 :? 34=7<7A ?:= 823 54;8 D34=;36<47C394;564C3@>D823634=73@ <7A63+B@A3:7 823 HB@AG378 :? 53E :B=8 <7 823 C4;3 :? =35:=83@ <7 <7;:?4= 4; C64<G ?:= 455:<78G378:7C:G54;;<:7483A=:B7@;484@364D3@5:<78 :?8<G3 23634=73@ <7A63+B@A324;46;:=3?3==3@8:823 HB@AG378<7823C4;3:?! "" # " $%& =35:=83@ <7 ' () (( 823 53E :B=824@4??<=G3@823:>;3=J48<:7<7823C4;3:?* +,-" .%=35:=83@<7(''/ - 6 - / ()0 923=3<7 823 53E :B=8 24@ :>;3=J3@ 8248 455:<78G378 :7 C:G54;;<:7483 A=:B7@ C:B6@ 7:8 >3 A=4783@ 4?83= 645;3 :? =34;:74>63 53=<:@ 4; 823 J3=D 5B=5:;3:?C:G54;;<:7483455:<78G378<7837@<7A8:G338 823 <GG3@<483 ?<747C<46 ;8=<7A37CD ;B??3=3@ >D 823 G3G>3=;:?@3C34;3@3G56:D33@<@7:8;B=J<J3 (B=823=823634=73@ <7A63+B@A324;C:7C6B@3@ <7 6<A28 :? HB@AG378; :? 53E :B=8 8248 C:7;<@3=48<:7 :? 4556<C48<:7 ?:= C:G54;;<:7483 455:<78G378 >3<7A 47 3EC358<:78:8237:=G465=:C3;;:?=3C=B<8G378823@364D 94;8:>384K377:83:?47@4CC:=@<7A6D4;8234556<C48<:7 94; ?<63@ <7 823 D34= !! >D 823 538<8<:73= 823 538<8<:7 94;=3H3C83@ 23 634=73@ C:B7;36 =< 2<J4KBG4= &466::= 45534=<7A :7 >3246? :? 823 538<8<:73= ;B>G<8; 8248 823 53=<:@:?@364D:BA288:>384K377:83:?<783=G;:?823 B63; 8248 C4G3 <78: 3??3C8 :76D :7 !!!/ 47@ 8<66 ;BC2B6394;G4@34556<C4>63823=394;7:IB3;8<:7:? C:7;<@3=48<:7 :? 4556<C48<:7 :? 823 538<8<:73= 47@ 823 - 7 - 4556<C48<:7 :? 823 538<8<:73= C4G3 8: >3 =3H3C83@ :76D :7 /!/! 9237 823 739 B63; 93=3 <7 ?:=C3 47@ ;BC2 B63; 24J37:8 >33784K37 7:83:?3<823=<7823:=@3=48 773EB=3F(.:=>D823634=73@ <7A63+B@A3 / 8GB;8>37:8<C3@8248823G:823=:?538<8<:73= 24@ G4@3 47 4556<C48<:7 9<82<7 4 ;2:=8 8<G3 :? @483 :? @3482:?823538<8<:73=.;?4823=<3:7/!/;823 538<8<:73=94;4G<7:=4?=3;24556<C48<:7C4G38:>3?<63@ >D823538<8<:73=:7!!!<783=G;:?773EB=3F&. 8 94; 74==483@ <7 823 ;4<@ =35=3;37848<:7 8248 4; 823 538<8<:73= 24; 4884<73@ G4H:=<8D 823 ;4<@ 4556<C48<:7 94; ?<63@ J37 4; 53= 823 C4;3 :? 634=73@ C:B7;36 ?:= 823 538<8<:73= 8<66 !!!/ 823=3 93=3 7: B63; A:J3=7<7A 823 C:G54;;<:7483 455:<78G378 8248 823 538<8<:73= C:B6@ 24J3<7J:K3@ 23B63;A:J3=7<7A=<A28:?C:G54;;<:7483 455:<78G378 94; :76D >D J<=8B3 :? 823 :8<?<C48<:7 @483@ !!!/ 23?4C882488237@:=;3G37894;<;;B3@4; 53=773EB=3F(.<7!9:B6@:76D=3J3468248>389337 !!!47@!823=3;5:7@378B82:=<8D@<@7:884K347D - 8 - 4C8<:7B5:78234556<C48<:7 7823G34792<63<8<;:76D :7 !/!!! 823 538<8<:73= A4J3 47 4556<C48<:7 8: C:7;<@3= 2<; C4;3 <7 83=G; :? 739 B63; 8248 94; G4@3 4556<C4>63:93J3=823?4C8=3G4<7;8248>389337!!! 47@!!823=394;7:4C8<:7>D823538<8<:73=8:5B=;B3 2<; 4556<C48<:7 ? 823 4556<C48<:7 :? 538<8<:73= ;33K<7A C:G54;;<:7483 455:<78G378 94; @<;5:;3@ :? >3?:=3 !!!/<76<A28:?4>;37C3:?47DB63;?:=A=478<7A 455:<78G378 :7 C:G54;;<:7483 A=:B7@; 823 538<8<:73=.; C4;3C:B6@7:824J3>337C:7;<@3=3@3=3645;3:?8<G3 =3;B68<7A<7C:G<7A<78:?:=C3:?739B63;G4D7:824J3 823 3??3C8 :? 823 538<8<:73= >3<7A C:7?3==3@ 9<82 47D 4@@<8<:746=<A28 ! 23 53E :B=8 <7 823 C4;3 :? 1 $," 23345=35:=83@<767) (/ 24; C:7;<@3=3@ 823 4;53C8 :? 455:<78G378 :7 C:G54;;<:7483 A=:B7@ <7 @384<6 47@ 24; :>;3=J3@ 8248 5=<G4CDGB;8>3 A<J378:823 ;37;3:?<GG3@<4CD<7823 - 9 - G4883= :? C:G54;;<:7483 455:<78G378 8 54=4 <8 <; :>;3=J3@4;?:66:9; N !""#!""$ !"! % & % ' % % % ( ) ' * 2353E:B=845534=;8:24J384K374;847@ 8248 :7C3 823 C=<;<; :? @3537@37CD 24J<7A >6:97 :J3= >D J<=8B3 :? @364D 823 @364D <7 C:7;<@3=48<:7 :? 4556<C48<:7 488=<>B83@3<823=8:823538<8<:73=:=8:823=3;5:7@378>D <8;36? 9:B6@ >3 <==363J478 47@ 823 B82:=<8D 92<63 C:7;<@3=<7A 823 4556<C48<:7 G4D 7:8 >3 <7 4 5:;<8<:7 8: - 10 - A=478455:<78G378:7C:G54;;<:7483A=:B7@484>36483@ 53=<:@:?8<G3 78235=3;378C4;34@G<883@6D823538<8<:73=.; ?4823=@<3@<7823D34=/ 23=:B7@;:?6<8<A48<:747@ @364D 488=<>B83@ 3<823= 8: 823 538<8<:73= := 8: 823 =3;5:7@378>D<8;36?24;=3;B683@<74;<8B48<:78248<7823 D34= ! @<=3C8<:7; 4=3 ;:BA28 ?:= C:7;<@3=48<:7 :? 2<; 4556<C48<:7 2<;<;7:9D34=;4?83=823@483:?@3482 :? 538<8<:73=.; ?4823= 47@ <8 9:B6@ 7:8 >3 455=:5=<483 8: <;;B3 47D ;BC2 @<=3C8<:7 48 82<; 5:<78 :? 8<G3 <3 G:=3 8247 D34=; 4?83= 823 @3482 :? 538<8<:73=.; ?4823= B=<7A ;BC2 <783==3A7BG :>J<:B;6D 823 J3=D C4B;3 47@ :>H3C8<J3:?A=478<7A=36<3?8:8<@3:J3=8233C:7:G<CC=<;<; 45534=;8:24J3>33784K374>4CK;348CC:=@<7A6D93 ?<7@ 8248 823 455=:4C2 :? 823 634=73@ <7A63 +B@A3 <; 4 564B;<>63455=:4C2 2:BA2 634=73@ C:B7;36 45534=<7A ?:= 823 538<8<:73= =36<3; :7 823 HB@AG378 :? 823 53E :B=8 <7 4& .% <7<J<655346 - 11 - : !! 823 :B=8 <; :? 823 :5<7<:7 8248 823 ;4<@ :=@3=<;54;;3@<782353CB6<4=?4C8;:?823;4<@C4;347@ C477:8 >3 G4@3 4556<C4>63 <7 823 5=3;378 C4;3 923=3 4@G<883@6D 4; :7 823 @483 :? @3482 47@ 8<66 !!!/ 823=3 94; 7: ;C23G3 <7 :53=48<:7 ?:= 455:<78G378 :7 C:G54;;<:7483A=:B7@; 3?<7@7:=34;:78:<783=?3=39<82;BC2:=@3= CC:=@<7A6D8239=<8455346<;@<;G<;;3@ )* '!&( " )* '" ( " % <;8: 6: #