- 1 - !"!# $%" !& $%" " ' ( ! " " #$$$% " ! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " && &&' " " ( " " $)$*&$&% &$#+&$&$ ! " " ! ( " " " " &$#+&$&$ " " ,- " " . . " / " / " ." / ! 01 2314156 21676785094 :115;7<1=:>601922<7?956 :1;83160137:@59<A08094?9<<1=75B@14678560183=138; 601 37:@59< 75 22<7?96785 8&$#+&$&$ A013175 601 ?09<<15C1:>6011D2<8>119431C93=46860183=13=961= %$'&$&$ 96 551E@31) A07?0 74 95 83=13 :> 601 - 3 - 74?72<7593> @608376> =731?675C ;@36013 15B@73> 094 :115 31F1?61= & 01 :371; ;9?64 931 6096 601 2167678513 A94 A83G75C 94 95 44746956 E1?@67H1 5C75113 @:=7H74785 09<G7 95= ?8D2<9756 A94 <8=C1= :1;831 601 935969G9 8G9>@G69 8<7?1 85 %$%%&$%% 9<<1C75C 6096 2167678513 09= =1D95=1= 9 4@D 8; 4%&$$$+ 68 31?8DD15=07459D168601E1?@67H15C75113;839A93= 8; ?85639?6 6 74 ;@36013 D9=1 8@6 6096 9 6392 A94 ?85=@?61=95=60131A941563@46D15675613D48;41?6785 %& !8;601935969G98G9>@G69?6%*) 5B@73>A9401<=:>601 29<8G9>@G696038@C0 955B@73> ;;7?13609674==767859<1C7463938;5B@73714 6749<489=D7661=609660115B@73>31283609=01<=601 ?093C14 68 :1 586 238H1= @:41B@156<> 76 9221934 6096 601 29<8G9>@G69 09= 31?8DD15=1= 6096 60131 511=4 68 :19;@3601315B@73>95=3175H1467C9678595=85601:9474 8; 4@?0 31?8DD15=96785 601 83=13 96 551E@31) A94 29441==731?675C;@3601315B@73>5613D48;551E@31) - 4 - 601 74?72<7593> @608376> 9??12675C 601 31?8DD15=96785 8; 601 29<8G9>@G69 09= 31D7661= 601 D96613 ;83 ;@36013 15B@73> 01 37:@59< 094 ?8547=131= 75 =1697< 601 ?8561567854 8; 601 922<7?9562167678513 95= 31F1?61= 601 922<7?96785674601;75=75C8;60137:@59<609660131A94 28A136883=13;@3601315B@73>0137:@59<0948:413H1= 60131A945875;73D76>7560183=1331D76675C601D96613;83 ;@36013 15B@73> 95= 94 5867?1= 28A13 ?85;1331= @5=13 @<1 %% 8; 601 935969G9 7H7< 13H7?14 I! @<14 %*#' ;83408360131759;61331;1331=6894,601@<14-!95= 75421?7;7?%% %!8;601@<14A07?0238H7=14;8308<=75C9 ;@3601315B@73> 19351= ?8@541< ;83 601 2167678513 094 39741= H9378@4 ?8561567854 75?<@=75C 6096 75 601 C@741 8; ;@36013 15B@73>60131?8@<=586:1915B@73>3148361=68 6 74 ;@36013 4@:D7661= 6096 601 74?72<7593> @608376> @5=13@<1%%8;601@<147431B@731=6869G19=1?74785 68 08<= ;@36013 15B@73> 95= 4@?0 =1?74785 D@46 :1 69G15 :>60174?72<7593>@608376>A013194756012314156?941 - 5 - 4@?0 =1?74785 094 :115 69G15 85 601 D131 31?8DD15=96785 8; 601 29<8G9>@G69 95= 9??83=75C<> =1?74785 69G15 ?95586 :1 46961= 68 :1 9 =1?74785 69G15 A760922<7?967858;D75= # 674;@360134@:D7661=60966011E639?67858;601 8:413H967854 8; 601 29<8G9>@G69 75 601 83=13 96 551E@31) A8@<= 75=7?961 6096 29<8G9>@G69 A94 8; 601 8275785 6096 601 92231?796785 8; 1H7=15?1 95= ?85?<@4785 9337H1=96:>601 15B@7375C9@608376>A9458623821395= 4@?0 92231?796785 A8@<= :1 7D213D7447:<1 75 ;@36013 15B@73> 6 74 4@:D7661= 6096 9 ;@36013 15B@73> ?8@<= :1 83=131= 85<> 75 ?941 8; 95> <9?@59 8; 585 <19=75C 8; 1H7=15?1 8; 9 H769< A765144 16? 95= ?95586 :1 83=131= A01316019@608376714?85?1351=931586759C311D156A760 601?85?<@47858;60115B@7375C9@608376> 19351=?8@541<92219375C;83601 6961A8@<= 4@:D76 6096 601 83=13 96 551E@31) 85<> 238H7=14 ;83 ;@36013 15B@73> 95= 4@?0 ;@36013 15B@73> 74 ?8561D2<961= @5=13 @<1 %% %! 8; 601 @<14 95= 601 37:@59< 094 - 6 - 37C06<>213D7661=C875C9019=A7604@?0;@3601315B@73>6 74 9<48 4@:D7661= 6096 601 2167678513 A8@<= 586 :1 231F@=7?1= :> ;@36013 15B@73> 95= 601 ?856156785 8; 601 2167678513 6096 60131 A94 9 =731?6785 ;83 15B@73> ?95586:1C960131=;38D6012<975A83=75C48;551E@31 )??83=75C<>76744@:D7661=6096601317458?941D9=1 8@685:109<;8;6012167678513 ' 13@41=60183=138;60137:@59< ) 6 74 68 :1 5867?1= 6096 601 85<> B@146785 6096 ;9<<4;83?8547=1396785749468601<1C9<76>8;551E@31) 75 83=1375C ;83 ;@36013 15B@73> ?<841 213@49< 8; 551E@31) A8@<= 31H19< 6096 601 312836 8; 601 5B@73> ;;7?13 094 :115 2<9?1= :1;831 601 29<8G9>@G69 @:41B@156<> :1;831 ;83A93=75C 601 312836 68 601 74?72<7593> @608376> 29<8G9>@G69 094 D9=1 ?136975 8:413H967854 ;8@5= 96 29C1 & 8; 551E@31) 01 497= 8:413H96785741E639?61=0131@5=13. ! " ! ! # $ - 7 - % & " " ' () # # * + " ! # & , & *- ()" " " .*/" # ! ! " * 0 * 0 0 ' # () ! * + ! $ " " # *1 * 8 =8@:6 76 74 ?<193 6096 601 74?72<7593> @608376> 094 =731?61= ;83 ;@36013 15B@73> 75 613D4 8; 551E@31)"8A1H13601B@14678568:15867?1=749468 A016013 601 =731?6785 8; ;@36013 15B@73> 74 4@469759:<1 @<1%% %!8;601@<14319=494;8<<8A4. 23+ , 0 !, # # " ! 0 ! , 0 0 ! , 0 ! #*1 - 8 - %$ 674?<1936096601=1?74785;83;@3601315B@73>74 68 :1 69G15 :> 601 74?72<7593> @608376> 7; 76 74 586 601 75B@7375C 9@608376> ;83 3194854 68 :1 31?83=1= 75 A37675C 95= ?8@<= 31D76 601 ?941 68 601 15B@7375C 9@608376> ;83 ;@3601315B@73>95=31283656012314156?941767468:1 4115 6096 601 74?72<7593> @608376> 608@C0 1E13?7475C 28A13 @5=13 @<1 %% %! 8; 601 @<14 094 D131<> 69G15 5861 8; 601 8:413H967854 8; 601 29<8G9>@G69 A08 094 82751= 6096 60131 8@C06 68 09H1 :115 ;@36013 15B@73> 0131408@<=:19575=1215=156922<7?967858;D75=:>601 74?72<7593>@608376>A087468?8D1689?85?<@47859;613 31?83=75C 3194854 074 A8@<= D9G1 76 ?<193 6096 :1;831 83=1375C ;83 ;@36013 15B@73> 3194854 D@46 :1 31?83=1= 131<>9=82675C60182757858;601 29<8G9>@G69A8@<=586 9D8@5668922<7?967858;D75= %% 6 D@46 :1 4115 6096 A07<1 83=1375C ;@36013 15B@73>767451?14493>60966019421?68;;@3601315B@73> 09468:1=1<751961=95=421?7;71=7560183=138;;@36013 15B@73> 7641<; 01 4?821 8; ;@36013 15B@73> 74 586 - 9 - ;8360?8D75C 85 9 319=75C 8; 551E@31) "85-:<1 21E 8@36759F@=CD1568;?854676@67859<:15?075601?9418; ! 3128361=75"#$%& '&962939C3920%&094D9=1 ?1369758:413H9678594686014?8218;;@3601315B@73>01 8:413H967854752939C3920%&9311E639?61=:1<8A * .4 0 # # # # 0 # 0 " " # 0 " ' , 5 0 *% .4 ! 0 ! 0 ! , * + , ! " " .6*1 %& 674?<1936096 ;@3601315B@73> ?8561D2<961=74 7548;9394?136975=1;1?648340836?8D75C47560115B@73> 56012314156?941601 29<8G9>@G69/48:413H9678531<961 6892231?7967858;1H7=15?195=?85?<@4785319?01=:>601 15B@7375C9@608376>5601C@7418;;@3601315B@73>60131 - 10 - ?95586:19=731?67856860115B@7375C9@608376>68?8D168 9 =7;;13156 ?85?<@4785 85 601 :9474 8; 601 49D1 D961379< 01A83=,15B@73>-31;134681H7=15?168:1<1675013174 5875=7?967858;A096;@360131H7=15?1A9468:1<167585 ;@3601315B@73>5<7C068;60149D160183=1329441=74 9D:7C@8@4 95= =814 586 D9G1 8@6 9 ?941 ;83 ;@36013 15B@73>0183=138;60137:@59<95=83=1396551E@31 )931416947=1 % 01 37:@59< 094 D131<> ?85?<@=1= 6096 @<1 %% ! %!8;601@<14238H7=14;83;@3601315B@73>6=814 586 5867?1 6096 60131 931 58 3194854 31?83=1= F@467;>75C ;@36013 15B@73> 131<> 9=82675C 601 8275785 8; 601 29<8G9>@G69 A07<1 83=1375C ;83 ;@36013 15B@73> 74 586 4@;;7?71563194850174?72<7593>@608376>7431B@731=68 922<> 764 D75= 75=1215=156<> 95= 6015 31?83= 3194854 @?0922<7?967858;D75=749:4156A07?060137:@59<094 5865867?1= % 9G75C 5861 6096 601 312836 094 9<319=> :115 2<9?1=:1;83160174?72<7593>@608376>511=<1446846961 - 11 - ?8541B@156 68 416675C 947=1 8; 551E@31) 74?72<7593> @608376>74213D7661=6869G1;@360134612485601312836 4@:D7661= 75 9??83=95?1 A760 <9A 94 213 238?1=@31 ??83=75C<>601376167678574( ( )* ' !&( " )* '" ( " 7468.%<8.&