Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12457 (KAR)
CHANDRAPPA S/O BANNEPPA BHAVANI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200177/2021 · 2025-01-21
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12457 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12457 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"! #$" % &" ! $'' ()(*'+,)( ++ &
! "
#""
$%&%'(
! " ()* +! "
"
" ,'&+'+ #
!,+'&
"" ""
Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" "
-
"$
-
! ./0 122314 56738 39:/;6 ()*+! ;< 8 /0 </437 => 1995037 1001/4/6? :.3 @57?A36: 167 ;8738 ;< 9;6B/9:/;6 167 036:3693 71:37 ,'&+'+ 210037 => :.3 ;58: ;< 8/69/214 /0:8/9:167300/;6057?3239/1457?3/@1>12581/6239/14
!103;,+'&
+ 3187:.343186379;56034<;8:.3218:/30
( .3 ;<
1=1430.C18 ;4/93 :1:/;6 .17 05=A/::37 1 9.18?3 0.33: 1?1/60: 12234416:1995037 <;8 :.3 ;<<3693 256/0.1=43 56738 39:/;6 +'=! ;< :.3 189;:/9 85?0 167
0>9.;:8;2/9 5=0:16930 9: ,&% .383/61<:38 83<38837 :; 10 D:.3 9:#<;80.;8:!1443?/6?:.1:;6'&',+'&C.36:.3 </80:/6<;8A16: (!C10/6:.30:1:/;6.38393/B3719837/=43 /6<;8A1:/;6 :.1: 1 2380;6 0:167/6? 6318 91614 =8/7?3 ;6 1E.1671E/ F ;;7/.14 ;17 C10 :81602;8:/6? 9;6:81=167 18:/943?16@1167;68393/2:;<059./6<;8A1:/;6</80:/6<;8A16:
- 3 -
14;6? C/:. ./0 0:1<< 167 2169.10 .17 9;6759:37 1 81/7 167 12283.36737 :.3 199503712234416: 167 <8;A ./0 2;00300/;6 :;:144>E?0;<9;6:81=16718:/9431443?374>?16@1C1003/G37 .3831<:38 12283.36737 1995037 C10 18830:37 167 28;75937 =3<;83 :.3 ;58: 167 83A16737 :; @57/9/14 950:;7> 6B30:/?1:/;6/6:.39103C109;A243:371679.18?30.33:C10 </437 58/6?:8/14/6;8738:;05=0:16:/1:3/:0910328;0395:/;6 .103H1A/637'C/:630030=3<;83:.38/14;58:10 :;
' 167 ?;: A18E37 +( 7;95A36:0 10 H0 :; +( 6 =3.14<;<73<36936;73<36933B/73693C1043176;8C1016> 7;95A36:0?;:A18E37.328;0395:/;6/60522;8:;</:09103 .17?;:A18E37;63A1:38/14;=@39:10 .38/14;58: 1<:38.318/6?:.318?5A36:0177830037;6=;:.0/730B/73:.3 /A25?637 @57?A36: 167 ;8738 ;< 9;6B/9:/;6 167 036:3693 .1B/6?9;6B/9:37:.312234416:<;8:.3;<<3693256/0.1=4356738 39:/;6+'1!/!I=!//! !;<:.3 9:036:36937./A :;56738?;8/?;8;50/A28/0;6A36:<;81238/;7;<</B3>3180167 :; 21> </63 ;< 0%''''$ 167 /6 73<154: :; 56738?; 0/A243 /A28/0;6A36: <;8 1 238/;7 ;< ;63 >318 <;8 :.3 ;<<3693 256/0.1=435673839:/;6+'1!/!;<:.3 9:167<58:.38 036:36937 :; 56738?; 8/?;8;50 /A28/0;6A36: <;8 1 238/;7 ;<
- 4 -
</B3 >3180 167 :; 21> </63 ;< 0%''''$ 167 /6 73<154: :; 56738?;0/A243/A28/0;6A36:<;81238/;7;<;63>318<;8:.3 ;<<3693 256/0.1=43 56738 39:/;6 +' =! //! ! ;< :.3
9:
3/6?1??8/3B37=>:.3@57?A36:167;8738;<9;6B/9:/;6 167036:3693:.312234416:/0=3<;83:./0;58:
* 318637 9;56034 <;8 :.3 12234416: 05=A/:0 :.1: 03/G37 9;6:81=16718:/943?16@19166;:=39;60/7383710?16@1C/:./6 :.3 A316/6? ;< 39:/;6 + ///!=! ;< :.3 9: .3 2;4/93 .1B39;4439:37:.301A243;<:.39;6:81=16718:/9431::.3:/A3 ;<1443?3703/G583;<9;6:81=16718:/9435673803/G583A1.1G18 H 3 05=A/:0 :.1: /0 :.3 01A243 781C6 => :.3 6B30:/?1:/;6 <</938 1: :.3 :/A3 ;< 03/G583 /:034< 3 83<380 :; H , 167 + 167 05=A/:0 :.1: 01A243 ;< :.3 9;6:81=167 18:/943781C6=3<;83:.34318637 1?/0:81:356738H C10 6;: 1: 144 <;8C18737 :; :.3 ";8360/9 9/3693 1=;81:;8> 167 :.383<;83 :.383 /0 6;6 9;A24/1693 ;< 83J5/83A36: ;< 39:/;6 %+;<:.3 9:/6:.3283036:9103305=A/:0:.1:36:/83 /6B30:/?1:/;6/6:.39103?3:0B/:/1:37167:.383<;83/6B/3C;< :.341C41/77;C6=>:.3;6#=435283A3;58:/6:.39103;<
832;8:37 /6
- 5 -
:.3@57?A36:167;8738;<9;6B/9:/;6167 036:3693/04/1=43:;=303:$10/73
%
38 9;6:81 4318637 /?.
;58: ;B386A36: 431738 .10 18?537 /6 0522;8: ;< :.3 /A25?637 @57?A36: 167 ;8738 ;< 9;6B/9:/;6167036:369316705=A/:0:.1::.;5?.:.301A2430 C383 03/G37 56738 H :.3831<:38 :.383 /0 9;A24/1693 ;< 39:/;6%+;<:.3 9:/6:.3283036:9103.383<;83/: 9166;:=301/7:.1:39:/;6%+;<:.39:/06;:1:1449;A24/37 /6 :.3 283036: 9103 383 10038:/;6 ;< :.3 12234416: :.1: 39:/;6 %+ ;< :.3 9: /0 6;: 9;A24/37 /0 6;: 05<</9/36:
167 :.3 01A3 /0 83J5/837 :; =3 28;B37 <8;A :.3 A1:38/14 1B1/41=43 ;6 839;87 6 0522;8: ;< .38 18?5A36:0 0.3 .10 241937834/1693;6:.3@57?A36:;<:.3;6#=435283A3;58: /6:.39103;<
.3 05=A/:0:.1:28;0395:/;6.10A173;5:19103<;8:.31443?37 ;<<36930 1?1/60: :.3 12234416: 167 :.3 8/14 ;58: .1B/6? 122839/1:37 ;814 167 7;95A36:18> 3B/73693 .10 8/?.:4> 9;6B/9:37 :.3 12234416: <;8 :.3 1443?37 ;<<36930 99;87/6?4> 0.3281>0:;7/0A/00:.3122314
- 6 -
.328;0395:/;6758/6?:.39;5803;<:8/14 .103H1A/637 '9.18?30.33:C/:630030/6:.3283036:9103 /0:.3317 ;60:1=43167 +167 *183:.3 ;4/93;60:1=430C.; .17199;A216/37</80:/6<;8A16: (C.;9;6759:3781/7;6 '&',+'&167.1712283.3673712234416:1995037167<8;A ./0 2;00300/;6 .17 839;B3837 9;6:81=167 18:/943 ?16@1 :;:144> C3/?./6? E?0 % /0 :.3 ;4/93 ;60:1=43 C.; .17 05=A/::37":;:.3 1?/0:81:3167 /0:.32169.C/:6300 /6C.;03283036939;6:81=16718:/943C1003/G375673803/G583 A1.1G18 H
) /0 :.3 2.;:;?812.38 167 & /0 :.3 2380;6 C.; .17 C3/?.37 :.3 9;6:81=167 18:/943 1<:38 :.3 81/7 C109;6759:37=> ( ,/0:.31G3::37<</938C.;.17 199;A216/37</80:/6<;8A16:1: :.3:/A3;<81/7 '/0:.3 6B30:/?1:/;6 <</938 C.; 9;6759:37 /6B30:/?1:/;6 167 .17 05=A/::379.18?30.33:1?1/60:1995037
) H /0:.303/G5832169.161A171:37'&',+'&1671 2385014;<:.301A3C;547?;:;0.;C:.1:9;6:81=16718:/943 ?16@103/G37<8;A:.312234416:C10<;567/61C./:3=1?167 140;/61C./:3:;C346:.3C./:3=1?(E?0%''?81A0;< 9;6:81=16718:/943C10<;567167/6:.3C./:3:;C34+E?0%'' ?81A0 ;< ?16@1 C10 <;567 .383<;83 :;:14 C3/?.: ;< :.3
- 7 -
9;6:81=16718:/94303/G3756738:.303/G583A1.1G18C;547=3 E?0 6 H /:034< /: /0 A36:/;637 :.1: :.3 6B30:/?1:/;6 <</938.179;4439:37%''?81A0319.<8;A:.3C./:3=1?167 :.3C./:3:;C34167:.301A2439;6:81=16718:/9439;4439:37=> :.36B30:/?1:/;6<</938C10219E37/61C./:394;:.167031437 =3<;83:.31G3::37<</938 /0:.301A243;<9;6:81=167 18:/943 9;4439:37 => :.3 6B30:/?1:/;6 <</938 1: :.3 :/A3 ;< 283218/6? :.3 03/G583 A1.1G18 C.; C10 1 218:> :; :.3 81/7/6? 0J517 .10 02;E36 1=;5: 167 .10 01/7 :.1:
C10 :.3 01A243 ;< 9;6:81=167 18:/943 9;4439:37 => :.3 6B30:/?1:/;6<</9381::.3:/A3;<283218/6?03/G583A1.1G18
& H ) /0 :.3 38:/</91:3 ;< 6B36:;8> 71:37 ',+'& /00537 => :.3 @58/07/9:/;614 1?/0:81:3 10 28;B/737 56738 39:/;6%+;<:.3 9:2385014;<:.301A3C;547:; ?;:;0.;C:.1:%E?0,?81A0;<9;6:81=16718:/943?16@1 1443?374> C10 28;75937 =3<;83 :.3 4318637 1?/0:81:3 C./9. C10 <;567 /6 ;63 C./:3 <38:/4/G38 =1? 167 :C; 01A2430 C383 781C6<8;A:.301A3=1?C3/?./6?%'+?81A0167%+&?81A0
319. 167 C383 219E37 /6 >344;C 167 837 9;4;58 94;:. =1?0 .;5?. :C; 032181:3 01A2430 C383 781C6 :.3 <19: 83A1/60 :.1:03/G379;6:81=16718:/943C10219E37=>:.36B30:/?1:/;6
- 8 -
<</938/6;63C./:3<38:/4/G38=1?:.;5?.H 03/G583A1.1G18 C;547?;:;0.;C:.1:03/G379;6:81=16718:/943C10<;567/6 :.3950:;7>;<:.312234416:032181:34>C./9.C383C3/?./6?( E?0%''?81A0167+E?0%''?81A0319.:1223180:.1::.3 6B30:/?1:/6?<</938.17.;A;?363;504>A/H37:.39;6:81=167 18:/9430167219E37/6;63C./:3=1?
, .3 ;6#=43 5283A3 ;58: /6 :.3 9103 ;<
! 832;8:37 /6 "#$ % %%.10;=038B3710<;44;C0$ ! " #" "
$
%" &&' #"
% %
"' (
# "% )
* %
" +, - )
"
. ( #/%/%(" )$#
/% #0
' H , /0 :.3 19E6;C437?A36: /00537 => :.3 " <;8 .1B/6? 8393/B37 :.3 9;6:81=167 18:/943 <;8 :.3 2582;03 ;< 9.3A/914 3H1A/61:/;6 <8;A ;4/93 ;60:1=43 ;0:./ 67/025:374>:.301/72;4/939;60:1=43.106;:=3363H1A/637
- 9 -
/6:.3283036:91032385014;<H ,C;547?;:;0.;C:.1:
C.1: C10 8393/B37 /6 :.3 " C10 % E?0 , ?81A0 ;< 9;6:81=167 18:/943 1443?374> ?16@1 167 :.3 01A243 C./9. C10 781C6 56738 :.3 /6B36:;8> 1: H ) =3<;83 :.3 @58/07/9:/;614 1?/0:81:3 1223180 :; .1B3 6;: =336 <;8C18737 => :.3 6B30:/?1:/;6 <</938 :; :.3 " <;8 :.3 2582;03 ;< 9.3A/914 3H1A/61:/;6 H + /0 :.3 30: 32;8: ;< :.3 9;6:81=167 18:/943 71:37 +%')+', /00537 => :.3 " 6 :.3 01/7 7;95A36: /: /0 0:1:37 :.1: :.3 41=;81:;8> .17 8393/B37 9;6:81=16718:/943;6','+'&:.8;5?. ;4/93;60:1=43 ;0:./ .383<;83 567/025:374> 83<383693 /0 A173 :; :.3 9;6:81=16718:/9438393/B37=>:.3"5673819E6;C437?A36: H ,C.383/6%E?0,?81A0;<?16@1C108393/B37=>:.3
":1223180:.1:01A243;<:.3785?C10781C61::.3" 167 C10 05=@39:37 :; 9.3A/914 3H1A/61:/;6 .3 /6B36:;8> 1: H ) C;547 943184> ?; :; 0.;C :.1: :.383 183 032181:3 01A2430 C3/?./6? %'+ ?81A0 167 %+& ?81A0 319. C./9. C10 9;4439:3716712385014;<:.37;95A36:01:H ,167H + C;547 ?; :; 0.;C :.1: 01/7 01A243 ;< :.3 9;6:81=167 18:/943 C./9. C383 781C6 =3<;83 :.3 1?/0:81:3 C10 6;: 1: 144 <;8C18737<;8:.32582;03;<9.3A/9143H1A/61:/;6.383<;83
- 10 -
:.383/0:;:146;6$9;A24/1693;<83J5/83A36:;<39:/;6%+;< :.3 9:/6:.3283036:9103
./0;58:/6:.39103;<%)
1)
!! # 2-!
-2/62181?812.;,.10;=038B3710<;44;C0$
3 " 4545
%"
% # 6"
"(
7%
(
"
""
("
"
%
8+" %
"
% 8+ "
% /%(
" " 7 ' % % ( %
( % "%
'
"
((
" (6%
" 9
#
#
7" "
"
(0
+ .3 ;6#=43 5283A3 ;58: /6 :.3 9103 ;< 9
4
%5/62181?812.;0%167.10;=038B3710<;44;C0$ &% :
"45"8+"
"
"
(
%" "" %
# /%
"%
# %
- 11 -
" 9
"" %
"( "" (' )
" "(
% ) #
" # %
"" %"
" "
(
% 6"
%
(
7 " %"
'
# # "" ( 9
#%
"
%
(" ' #
:"
" " 8+ "' # ""
") ( ('
#%
"
% (
"
% 6" ( "
"8+"
(%
" #" /%
(
"
" 9
# ( "
"( ( )
# $%"
""458+" 9
( ;" 48 <%5 % " =< !!34>5
- 12 -
- #" %
.%
%
#
""
%"?
29
5 , ( "" %
("" %
"
7 #
"::"
"
" # %
" !' "'
7 ( %"" '
(
%"
"" %
(""
%
"
.%
" ( ( 9
%
% :
" 45
" .%
"
5 9
#
" %
% :
" 4!5
" '
" " %
45
" ('
#
" 9
(
""
%
% " 8%8
" ( "
"
"(
- 13 -
# % "
": :"# @@@@@@@@@
' (
45 A%' ' "
( = A% ) ,) %
;"
45 $ "
%
%
" % 45'
;"
(
"%"
' % " (
45
;"
" # (
"
"%"'
/%
%
' (' /% (
% (
%<% -
45 %" /%
%
' (' /% (
;"
% " %
45
- 14 -
/%
%
(
"%% 2
45 8
%"
( "
"
#
% "
"
' #" " ( #
%"
" ( (
" # /% "
"%( . $
% %" " (
7
%'" +
% +
%
'
"
( ' % 8
%"
" %
" 9
8% 8
@@@@@@@@@
' '
)
)
""
%" 4
"5
"
)#( % '
#%
7'
"'
(
"
8% 8
.% ! "(
#
- 15 -
) "
(
"'%
"
7%
"
""(#
) ( 8% 8 8
%
""
%%9 (9
<
0
( 39:/;6%+*!;<:.3 9:8317010<;44;C0$
:425#
(" $>""'&-43-5
+"%' 3-! 4 3-25' (
"%("%
"'
('
B"" %
' (""
%
"
' "
%
"
"("
C (
# % % :
" 45 " ( 9
' ("
"
%""00
*
"8;A18317/6?;<:.31<;8301/728;B/0/;6;<41C/:/0B38> 94318:.1:4/0:;<01A243781C65673805=$039:/;6+!;<39:/;6 %+;<:.3 9:167938:/</37=>:.3 1?/0:81:3;64>916=3 9;60/738371028/A18>3B/736936:.3283036:910301A2430 781C6 56738 :.3 /6B36:;8> .1B3 6;: 1: 144 =336 <;8C18737 :; :.3"<;8:.32582;03;<9.3A/9143H1A/61:/;6167:.383<;83 28/A18>3B/73693C106;:1:144241937=3<;83:.3;58:
- 16 -
% 6 :.3 9103 ;< **
+ ,
-
832;8:37/6'.%/:.3;6#=43 5283A3;58:/62181?812.;++.10;=038B3710<;44;C0
('"
%" 8+ " # %) ( $
A"+,:(
"
6%
" 9
$
#' ;D 4>. +:5
% #
" "0
6 :.3 9103 ;6 .167 :.;5?.
:.3 28;9337/6?0 56738 39:/;6 %+ ;< :.3 9: C383 56738:1E36 => :.3 6B30:/?1:/;6 <</938 167 01A2430 C383 ;=:1/637 /6 :.3 28303693 ;< @58/07/9:/;614 1?/0:81:3 /: 1223180 :.1: :.3 01/7 01A2430.1B36;:=336<;8C18737<;8:.32582;03;<9.3A/914 3H1A/61:/;6167:.383<;83:.3"832;8:1:H +9166;:=3 834/3752;66;8 916 /: =3 8317 /6 3B/73693 6 177/:/;6 :; :.3 01A3 9;6:81=167 18:/943 03/G37 56738 H .1B3 6;: =336 28;75937=3<;83:.3;58:167A18E3710 :/0;64>01A243 C./9. C10 9;4439:37 => :.3 6B30:/?1:/;6 <</938 56738 H
3B3628/;8:;05=@39:/6?:.39;6:81=16718:/943<;8/6B36:;8>10
- 17 -
28;B/7375673839:/;6%+;<:.3 9:C./9./028;75937 10
) .3 ;6#=43 5283A3 ;58: /6 :.3 9103 ;< 9
4
%5.10;=038B37:.1:
"#%
7 #"% %"%
) 6" . %%"9
" %
%" "
" ( % #"
"%'
"%
( # "
% #
"
%8+"
& 6 :.3 9103 ;< 4
%5 :.3 ;6#=43 5283A3 ;58: .1B/6? 83<38837 :; /:0 3184/38 @57?A36: /6 :.3 9103 ;< 9
4
%5' .10 ;=038B37 :.1: :.;5?. /: /0 /6 9;A243:31?833A36:C/:.:.3;=038B1:/;60A173/6:.39103;< 9
4
%51A38310038:/;6=>:.31995037:.1::.383/0 6;6$9;A24/1693 ;< 39:/;6 %+ ;< :.3 9: /0 6;: 05<</9/36:167/6/:/14=58736/0;6:.31995037:;30:1=4/0.:.1: :.383/06;6$9;A24/1693;<39:/;6%+;<:.3 9:3/:.38 => 4317/6? 3B/73693 ;8 => 834>/6? 52;6 :.3 3B/73693 ;< :.3
- 18 -
28;0395:/;66:.39103;6.167;6:.3=10/0;<:.33B/73693 241937;6839;87=>:.328;0395:/;6:.3199503712234416:.10 0599300<544> 28;B37 :.1: :.383 /0 :;:14 6;6$9;A24/1693 ;< :.3 83J5/83A36:;<39:/;6%+;<:.3 9:167:.383<;83:.3 =58736;6:.312234416:1995037109;6:3A241:37/6:.39103;<
4
%5 /0 0599300<544> 7/09.18?37 => ./A /6 :.3283036:9103
, /693 :.3 03/G37 9;6:81=167 18:/943 9;4439:37 56738 :.3 /6B36:;8> 1: H ) C10 6;: 28;75937 /6 :.3 283036: 9103 1 038/;507;5=:18/030C/:.83?187:;:.303/G583.38/14;58:
.10 241937 834/1693 ;6 :.3 832;8: ;< :.3 " 1: H + C./43 :1E/6?:.33B/73693;<;<</9/14C/:63003010?;0234:85:."8;A ;B38144122839/1:/;6;<;8141677;95A36:18>3B/73693/6:.3 283036: 9103 /: /0 0336 :.1: :.383 183 A16> A1:38/14 /883?5418/:/30 C./9. 9831:3 1 038/;50 7;5=: ;6 :.3 9103 ;< :.3 28;0395:/;66177/:/;6:;:.301A303/G379;6:81=16718:/943 /6945730431B300:3A03370167;:.38218:0;<:.3C3:?16@1 2416:167:.383<;831038/;507;5=:18/030C.3:.38:.303/G37 9;6:81=167 18:/943 916 =3 9;60/73837 10 ?16@1 C/:./6 :.3 A316/6?;<39:/;6+///!=!;<:.3 9:A;830;<;8:.3 8310;6 :.3 01A243 ;< 9;6:81=167 18:/943 C./9. C383 03/G37
- 19 -
56738 :.3 /6B36:;8> C383 6;: 1: 144 036: :; :.3 " <;8 :.3 2582;03 ;< 9.3A/914 3H1A/61:/;6 6738 :.3 9/895A0:16930 1A ;< :.3 ;2/6/;6 :.1: :.3 8/14 ;58: C10 6;: @50:/</37 /6 9;6B/9:/6? :.3 12234416:1995037 <;8 :.3 1443?37 ;<<36930 99;87/6?4>:.3<;44;C/6?$
/! .3122314/0144;C37
//! .3 @57?A36: 167 ;8738 ;< 9;6B/9:/;6 167 036:3693 71:37 ,'&+'+ 210037 => :.3
8/69/214 /0:8/9: 167 300/;60 57?3239/14 57?3 /@1>12581 /6 239/14 ! 103 ;,+'&/0.383=>03:$10/73.312234416:/0 19J5/::37;<:.31443?37;<<36930
///! 1/4 =;670 /< 16> ;< :.3 12234416: 0:1670 916934437167</631A;56: /<16>732;0/:37=> :.312234416:0.144=383<56737:;./A
-,
( % &" !+
"
/0:;4;*%