Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12456 (KAR)
THE GULBARGA ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY LTD AND ORS v. HULIGEMMA AND ORS
WA/200088/2021 · 2025-02-19
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12456 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12456 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! " #$%
! &
#$%%
""' (
! " #
$% &&
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% &&
% &&
'
( & % &&
%
! " ) )
%*(#
$ )
() $ ) '
&
$(%(
"*#
+
))
) )&
,
$
) &$
- &
- &
&
- 3 -
%
$
" - &
#
./01/2/34500/56784./96751:56/;41<;<4890068 =>0538 4? "@=1 2.=14 A
+# ;5662 <3 B9/24<=3 4./ ;=11/;43/22 =@ 4./ =1?/1 =@ 4./ 6/513/? <3:6/ &9?:/ 0522/?<3$=(%(C./1/784./$1<4/4<4<=3 @<6/?784./@5><68>/>7/12=@654/ 525D515E2//F<3:@=1 B952.<3: =@ 4./ /3?=12/>/34 1/E/;4<3: 4./ 0158/1 =@ :1534<3:500=<34>/34=3;=>0522<=354/:1=93?2;5>/4= 7/ ;.566/3:/? <3 4./ $1<4 /4<4<=3 C.<;. /D/3495668 C52 566=C/? ./ $1<4 /4<4<=3 C52 566=C/? 2/44<3: 52<?/ 4./ /3?=12/>/34 =@ 4./
=10=154<=3 1/E/;4<3: 4./ ;65<> 4= ;=32<?/1 500=<34>/34 =3 ;=>0522<=354/ :1=93?2 53? @914./1?<1/;4<=3C52:1534/?784./6/513/?<3:6/&9?:/ <3 4./ 35491/ =@ C1<4 =@ >53?5>92 4= 4./
=10=154<=3 4= ;=32<?/14./5006<;54<=3@<6/?784./2=3=@654/ 525D515E
514</251/1/@/11/?4=784./<1153F2<34./C1<4 01=;//?<3:2@=14./0910=2/=@;=3D/3</3;/
- 4 -
./ @5;42 >5?/ =94 51/ 4.54 525D515E %= 5:5005 C52 53 />06=8// =@ 4./ 1/20=3?/34* C.=?</?=3?91<3:.<22/1D<;/4<24./1/5@4/1 297><44/? 4.54 <3 4/1>2 =@ 33/G91/* 4./ C<@/ =@ 654/
525D515E 4./ ?/;/52/? />06=8// .5? >5?/ =94 5 1/01/2/3454<=3 4= 4./
=10=154<=3 =3 H' 4= 4./ /@@/;4 4.54 ./1 2=3 <2 5 ><3=1 C.= C52 3=4 5445<3/? 4./ 5:/ =@ 8/512 53? 0/1><22<=3 C52 2=9:.4 4= @<6/ 53 5006<;54<=35@4/1./5445<3/?4./5:/=@>5E=1<48 ( 4 <2 @914./1 297><44/? 4.54 <3 4/1>2 =@ 33/G91/* 96<:/>>5 $%= 525D515E >5?/ 53=4./1 1/01/2/3454<=3=3HH1/<4/154<3:4./;=34/342=@ 33/G91/*
4<2562=4./;52/=@4./0/4<4<=3/14.54<34/1>2 =@ 33/G91/*
5006<;54<=3 C52 >5?/ 1/B9/24<3: @=1 500=<34>/34 =3 ;=>0522<=354/ :1=93?2 ?54/? %' 4 <2 4.<2 5006<;54<=3 C.<;. <2 <3 ?<2094/ 52 4./
=10=154<=3 .52 ;=34/3?/? 4.54 4.<2 5006<;54<=3 C52 3/D/1 >5?/ 4= <4 53? ?<? 3=4 7/51 538
- 5 -
5;F3=C6/?:/>/34 =1 /3?=12/>/34 4= 29724534<54/ 4.54 <4 C522/1D/?=34./
=10=154<=3 ' 4 <2 4./ @914./1 ;52/ =@ 4./ 0/4<4<=3/1 4.54 53 /3?=12/>/34;5>/4=7/<229/?5433/G91/*1/E/;4<3:
4./ 1/B9/24 >5?/ 53? 1/@/11<3: 4= 4./ 5006<;54<=3 ?54/? '2454/?4=.5D/7//3>5?/784./2=3=@654/
525D515E0/4<4<=3/1=( H ./ $1<4 /4<4<=3 ;5>/ 4= 7/ ./51? 53? 5@4/1 ?/45<6/? ;=32<?/154<=3 4./
=914 .52 566=C/? 4./ $1<4 /4<4<=3 C.<6/ B952.<3: 4./ /3?=12/>/34 54 33/G91/* 53? ?<1/;4<3: 4.54 24/02 7/ 45F/3 4= ;=32<?/1 4./ 5006<;54<=3 @<6/? 78 0/4<4<=3/1 =( </ 4./ 2=3 <3 5;;=1?53;/C<4.65C525006<;576/3=1>253?B956<@<;54<=32 =@0/4<4<=3/1=(
./ /3?=12/>/34 C.<;. C52 <3 ;.566/3:/ 7/@=1/4./6/513/?<3:6/&9?:/?54/?'C524= 4./ /@@/;4 4.54 4./ 5006<;54<=3 =9:.4 4= .5D/ 7//3 @<6/? C<4.<3 =3/ 8/51 =@ ?54/ =@ ?/54. 53? 25>/ .5D<3: 7//3
- 6 -
@<6/?5@4/16502/=@H8/512I>=34.2 53?( ?582?/658 ;=96? 3=4 .5D/ 7//3 ;=32<?/1/?
<3 4/1>2 =@ 4./ 96/2 <3 @=1;/ /@/1/3;/ 4= 4./ 5006<;54<=3 4.54 C52 ;=32<?/1/? C52 4./ 5006<;54<=3 2454/? 4= .5D/ 7//3 >5?/ =3 '780/4<4<=3/1=( I 0/19256 =@ 4./ =1?/1 =@ 4./ 6/513/? <3:6/ &9?:/ C=96? 1/D/56 4.54 4./ 6/513/? <3:6/ &9?:/ .52 45F/3 3=4/ =@ 4./ 96/ <3 @=1;/ </ ./ /:9654<=3 =@ 006<;54<=3@=1500=<34>/34=@513545F56/;41<;<48 =51? /;19<4>/34 "00=<34>/34 =3
=>0522<=354/ 1=93?2# /:9654<=32 IIH /:9654<=3 4.54 C52 <3 @=1;/ 52 =3 4./ ?54/ =@ 4./ ?/54. 01<=1 4= <42 5>/3?>/34 1/5?2 52 @=66=C2J
!"#$"% &% '(
)
)
$
- 7 -
*
)
&%'(
+,
"/>0.52<229006</?#
3 4/1>2 =@ 4./ 25<? 196/ 4./1/ C52 5 1/B9<1/>/3493?/14./01=D<2=4.54C./1/4./5006<;534<2 5><3=15006<;54<=32.=96?7/>5?/C<4.<350/1<=?=@=3/ 8/515@4/15445<3<3:>5E=1<48 ./ 6/513/? <3:6/ &9?:/ .52 >5?/ =72/1D54<=32 52 1/:51?2 4./ 5006<;54<=3 @<6/? C<4.<3 =3/ 8/51 5@4/1 5445<3<3: 4./ 5:/ =@ >5E=1<48 54 0515:150. =C.<;.1/5?252@=66=C2J - #
%. +
)
-/012001
)
%- -30/200
#
-/012001
)
)
) #
)
)
-3012001# 4 %
+ *
2001 ) )
#
)
- 8 -
)
%. 20-2
)
+
) ) 5
2001
20-6
)
( (
,
./ =72/1D54<=3 >5?/ <2 4= 4./ /@@/;4 4.54 0/4<4<=3/1 =( .5? 5445<3/? >5E=1<48 53? @6</? 53 5006<;54<=3 =3 ' 53? 4.=9:. 4./ 5006<;54<=3 01=?9;/? 56=3: C<4. 0/4<4<=3 54 33/G91/*
?<? 3=4 7/51 538 /3?=12/>/34 .=C/D/1 >/>= C52 @<6/? 78 0/4<4<=3/1 =3 4./ ?54/ =@ =1?/1 7/<3: 0522/? C.<;. .5? ?=;9>/34 1/@6/;4<3:4.//3?=12/>/34=@1/20=3?/344=.5D/1/;/<D/? 4./5006<;54<=3=3H 4 >924 7/ 2//3 4.54 4./ 1/20=3?/34* =10=154<=3 <3 4./ 01/2/34 500/56 .52 ;53D522/? 4./ 01<>518;=34/34<=34.54 3=5006<;54<=3C52 >5?/=D/14= 4./
=10=154<=3?54/?'53?33/G91/*
4=4./ 0/4<4<=3 ?<? 3=4 7/51 53 5;F3=C6/?:>/34 4 <2 @914./1 297><44/?4.54/D/3=4./1C<2/?/20<4/4./6/513/?<3:6/
- 9 -
&9?:/ .5D<3: 1/@/11/? 4= 5 ?=;9>/34 01=?9;<3: 53 5;F3=C6/?:>/34 .5D<3: 7//3 01=?9;/? 4./ >/>= @<6/? 56=3: C<4. $1<4 /4<4<=3 ?<? 3=4 .5D/ 538 ?=;9>/34 C<4. 53 5;F3=C6/?:>/34 52 1/:51?2 33/G91/*
4 <2 @914./1 297><44/?4.54<34./572/3;/=@5385;F3=C6/?:/>/344= 33/G91/*
4./ 6/513/? <3:6/ &9?:/ ;=96? 3=4 .5D/ 45F/3 3=4/ =@ 538 =4./1 ?=;9>/34 4= .=6? 4.54 4./ 5006<;54<=3C52@<6/?C<4.<3=3/8/51=@5445<3<3:>5E=1<48 ( 4 <2 @914./1 ;=34/3?/? 4.54 4./ 5??<4<=356 ?=;9>/342 01=?9;/?
56=3: C<4. 4./ 500/56 <3;69?/ 53 /G415;4 =@ 4./ /:<24/1 C.<;. C=96? <3?<;54/ 4.54 4./ /:<24/1 .52 7//3 45>0/1/? C<4. 53? 53 /3418 4= 4./ /@@/;44.54535006<;54<=3C52?/6<D/1/?=3H53? 52 4./ 25<? ?54/ C52 4./ 93?58 53? 4./ 1/20=3?/34* =10=154<=3 <2 5 976<; 94.=1<48 =7D<=9268 29;. /3418 C52 5 ;=3;=;4/? =3/ /34/1/? <3 4./ 1/:<24/1 <3 ;=6692<=3 C<4.4.//>06=8//2=@4./
=10=154<=3 )914./1 4./ ;=932/6 @=1 4./
=10=154<=3 C=96? 297><44.545.=C*;592/3=4<;/C52<229/?<34./35>/
- 10 -
=@ 4./ =@@<;<56 4= /G065<3 52 4= .=C 29;. /3418 <3 4./ /:<24/1.52;5>/4=7/>5?/520/19256=@4.//:<24/1 C=96?<3?<;54/4.54<4C5253<32/14/?/3418 ' /513/?/3<=1
=932/6500/51<3:=37/.56@=@ 4./0/4<4<=3/12C=96?297><44.5433/G91/*
C52<3/@@/;4 297><44/? 4= 4./
=10=154<=3 C.<;. 5006<;54<=3 <@ 45F/3 3=4/ =@ C=96? 7/ 53 5006<;54<=3 @<6/? C<4.<3 =3/ 8/51 =@ ?54/ =@ ?/54. =@ 525D515E 4 <2 297><44/? 4.54 4./ 25<? .53?<3:=D/1=@5006<;54<=3C<4.<3=3/8/51@1=>4./?54/ =@ 5445<3<3: >5E=1<48 4 <2 297><44/? 4.54 /D<?/3;/ =@ .5D<3: 297><44/? 29;. 5006<;54<=3 C52 <3 4./ /:<24/1 C.<;. 4./
=10=154<=3 .52 01=?9;/? <3 4./ 500/56 01=;//?<3:2 H 4<2@914./1297><44/?4.544./@5><68>/>7/12 =@ 525D515E <3;69?<3: 0/4<4<=3/1 =( .5D/ 3= 1=6/ <3 >5<34/353;/ =@ 4./ /:<24/1 3=1 .5D/ 538 5;;/22 4= 4./ /:<24/1C.<;.7/51253/34181/654<3:4=4./@913<2.<3:=@ 5006<;54<=35433/G91/*
- 11 -
/51?7=4.2<?/2 I ./ @5;42 C.<;. 51/ 3=4 <3 ?<2094/ 4.54
525D515E?</?=334/1>2=@/:9654<=3 =@ 4./ 513545F5 6/;41<;<48 =51? "29015# <3 ;52/ 4./ ;65<>534 <2 5 ><3=1 5006<;54<=3 >924 7/ @<6/? C<4.<3 =3/ 8/51=@?54/=@5445<3<3:>5E=1<484<23=4<3?<2094/78 7=4. 2<?/2 4.54 4./ ?54/ =@ 7<14. <2 'II @ 4.54 C/1/ 4= 7/ 2= 5006<;54<=3 =9:.4 4= .5D/ 7//3 @<6/? 78 ' .//34<1/48=@1/52=3<3:=@4./6/513/?<3:6/ &9?:/ <2 @=93? 54 0515:150. = C./1/<3 4./ 6/513/? <3:6/&9?:/.521/;=1?/?535@@<1>54<D/@<3?<3:4.544./ 5006<;54<=3 ?54/? ' 50051/3468 1/@/11<3: 4= 33/G91/*
C52297><44/?=3H53?<@4.54C/1/ 4=7/2=5006<;54<=3.5D<3:7//3@<6/?C<4.<3=3/8/51=@ 5445<3<3:>5E=1<48=9:.44=.5D/7//345F/33=4/=@ 0/19256 =@ 4./ $1<4 /4<4<=3 1/;=1?2 C=96? 1/D/564.5433/G91/*
4=4./0/4<4<=3C524./5006<;54<=3
- 12 -
?54/? %' >5?/ <3 4./ 35>/ =@ 0/4<4<=3/1=(./1/<23=5;F3=C6/?:/>/344=4./25<? 5006<;54<=3 .=9:. 4./ 6/513/? <3:6/ &9?:/ <3 4./ =72/1D54<=3540515:150.=.522454/?4.54>/>=C52 01=?9;/?<3;69?<3:;=08=@/3?=12/>/340/19256=@4./ >/>= ?=/2 3=4 <3?<;54/ 33/G91/* C<4. 5;F3=C6/?:/>/34 C.54 .52 7//3 01=?9;/? 56=3: C<4. >/>=<2=368535006<;54<=3.<2;=96?3=445F/4./ 1=6/ =@ /24576<2.<3: 4.54 33/G91/*
C52 1/;/<D/? =3 H 52 =72/1D/? 78 4./ 6/513/? <3:6/ &9?:/ $.54 <2 ;91<=92 <2 4./ 297><22<=3 =@ 6/513/? ;=932/6 @=1 4./
=10=154<=3 4.54 H C52 4./ 93?58 ./ 1/6/D534 /:<24/1 C52 ?<1/;4/?
4= 7/ 01=?9;/? ./ 6/513/? ;=932/6 @=1 4./ 0/4<4<=3/12 C52 562= 01=D<?/? 5;;/224=4./25<?/:<24/1 0/19256 =@ 4./ /:<24/1 /G415;4 =@ C.<;. <2 01=?9;/? 56=3: C<4. 4./ 5??<4<=356 ?=;9>/342 C=96? 1/D/56 4.54 /3418 =( 1/@/12 4= 4./ 566/:/? 5;F3=C6/?:/>/34 =@ 4./ 5006<;54<=3 >5?/ 78 0/4<4<=3/1
- 13 -
=(./1/<23=2<:35491/<34.//:<24/178538=@@<;<56 56=3:2<?/29;./34187=D/4./25<?/3418<34.//:<24/1 53=4./1 /3418 .52 7//3 >5?/ C.<;. 500/512 4= 7/ 0/145<3<3:4=/3418=(C.<;..527//32419;F=@@53? 2972/B9/3468/3418=(<25:5<3<32/14/?.<2<32/14<=3 <2 D<2<76/ 4= 4./ 7/51 /8/ 32=@51 52 4./ ;=34/34<=3 4.54 4./ 0/4<4<=3/12 .5D/ 3= 1=6/ <32=@51 52 29;. /341852 4./ /:<24/1 <2 <3 4./ 0=22/22<=3 =@ 4./ 1/20=3?/34* =10=154<=3 <4 ;=96? 7/ 2454/? 4.54 538 <32/14<=3 <3 4./ /:<24/1 C=96? 7/ @=1 4./ 7/3/@<4 =@ 4./ ;65<>5342 53? 5;;=1?<3:68 <@ 4./1/ <2 53 <32/14<=3 52 <2 50051/34 <3 4./ /:<24/153?4./2453?45F/3784./
=10=154<=3<4<2=368 @=14./7/3/@<4=@4./;65<>5342 4 >924 7/ 3=4<;/? 4.54 4./ ;=34/34<=3 =@ 4./ =10=154<=3 4.54 3= 5006<;54<=3 C52 >5?/ <3 4./ 8/51 <2 @914./1 241/3:4./3/? 78 4./ @5;4 4.54 4./ /3?=12/>/34 54 33/G91/* C.<;. 1/E/;4/? 4./ 5006<;54<=3 >5?/ 78 0/4<4<=3/1 =( 1/@/12 4= 5006<;54<=3 >5?/ 78 0/4<4<=3/1 =( ?54/? ' ./ 25<? - 14 -
1/01/2/3454<=3 2454/? 4= .5D/ 7//3 >5?/ 78 0/4<4<=3/1 =( <2 /D<?/3;/? 78 /G415;4 =@ 4./ /:<24/1 01=?9;/? 56=3:C<4.4./5??<4<=356?=;9>/342C.<;.>5F/253/3418 4.54 0/4<4<=3/1 =( .5? >5?/ 53 5006<;54<=3 =3 ' @ 4./ 5006<;54<=3 ?54/? ' <2 45F/3 3=4/ =@ =7D<=9268 <4 <2 7/8=3? 4./ 0/1<=? =@ =3/ 8/51 =@ 5445<3<3: >5E=1<48 53? .52 7//3 >5?/ 5@4/1 5 6502/ =@ ( 8/512 5@4/1 5445<3<3: >5E=1<48 @ 4./ =368 =@@<;<56 5006<;54<=3 52 @=93? <3 4./ /:<24/1 C52 >5?/ 78 0/4<4<=3/1=(=3'25>/;=96?3=4.5D/7//3 ;=32<?/1/? ( ./@<3?<3:=@4./6/513/?<3:6/&9?:/<2=368 =3 4./ 752<2 =@ 4./ 258 =@ 4./ 0/4<4<=3/1 4.54 5006<;54<=3 C52 @<6/? 53? ?968 5;F3=C6/?:/? 53? /3?=12/>/34 C52 >5?/<34./8/51=C/D/14./1/<23=/D<?/3;/=@ 53 5;F3=C6/?:/>/34 53? /D/3 4./ /:<24/1 01=?9;/? 78 4./
=10=154<=3 C=96? 01<>5 @5;</ <3?<;54/ 53 <32/14<=3 C52>5?/53?4./@//76/1/20=32/=@4./0/4<4<=3/12<23=4 29@@<;</344=?<20/64./50051/34<32/14<=3<34.//:<24/1
- 15 -
)914./1 <3 =1?/1 4= ;651<@8 4./ 5??<4<=356 ?=;9>/34 /D<?/3;<3:0/4<4<=3/1=(4=.5D/>5?/535006<;54<=3=3 ' 1<:<356 /:<24/1 C52 01=?9;/? 53? /3418 0/192/?.<2C=96?@914./1;651<@84.54C.54C52@<6/?78 0/4<4<=3/1=(C52535006<;54<=3=368=3' D/3 <@ 53 5006<;54<=3 C52 >5?/ <3 4./ 8/51 4./1/<23=1/52=3@=14.;=><3:524=4./?/658@1=> 4= 4./ 2/;=3?
5006<;54<=3 <3 9;. <35;4<=3 C=96? 562= ?/@/54 4./ D/18 =7E/;4<D/ =@ :1534<3: 500=<34>/34=3;=>0522<=354/:1=93?25@4/193?9/?/658 C.<;.<252/446/?0=2<4<=3=@65C ' ;;=1?<3:684./$1<400/56<2566=C/?53?4./ =1?/1=@4./6/513/?<3:6/&9?:/<22/452<?/ H 3 6<:.4 =@ 4./ D/./>/34 297><22<=3 =@ 4./ 6/513/?;=932/6@=14./
=10=154<=34.544.//:<24/1.52 7//3 564/1/? 4./
=10=154<=3 <2 1/2/1D/? 6<7/148 4= 45F/ 5001=01<54/ 5;4<=3 7=4. =3 4./ 5?><3<24154<D/ 2<?/ 53? /D/37/@=1/4./5001=01<54/0=6<;/594.=1<4</2
- 16 -
./=1<:<356/:<24/1<20/1><44/?4=7/1/4913/? 784.//:<24185@4/11/45<3<3:5?968544/24/?;=08=@4./ 1/6/D534/G415;4
)*
'
! &( %
)*
'% ( %
<24= 6= (